Found Deceased CO - Suzanne Morphew, 49, did not return from bike ride, Chaffee County, 10 May 2020 #37

Status
Not open for further replies.
The mountain lion isn’t the lesser of two evils though. If a lion took her, she’s dead. If she’s been kidnapped, there is still hope.

Very quickly, BM grabbed hold of this mountain lion theory, and he hasn’t let go since.

This is incredibly damning, as he knows better. He knows a mountain lion didn’t kidnap Suzanne, leave no trace, and throw her bike in a ravine.

But he pushes it anyway, because it’s a scenario that points away from him.

“Anything but me.”
Respectfully, my focus was on simply this, mountain lion theory DID originate with LE per AM, and that BM would rather SM be taken by a lion, as that could be a more of merciful death, as awful as it sounds.
He continues to list it more as a check list of which scenarios have been eliminated. JMO
And even I, probably one of the last holdouts for hope, believes she is dead, now.
 
This could be the bombshell we’ve waited for, we just have to question the msgr?
IMO, we have had an incredible amount of speculation about character, but from those who know him best, truthfulness has never been a factor. IMO
WHY would he lie about this?



TIA, there’s a disconnect, you can’t have a disorganized person plan this out to the degree that this seems to have been planned, ie, he can’t even handle last minute scheduled job, yet he can time this disappearance to the minute?

He can’t organize search, flyers, etc, but he can figure out how to elude gps, phone/ texts, etc?

JMHO, if BM did this, he would already have been charged. Because chances are we would already have her body.
It occurs to me that the Morphew's oldest daughter looks strikingly like her mother.

I don't know when the Morphew daughters actually arrived back home, but if early Sunday evening, maybe the two witnesses (if such actually exist) saw that daughter riding in a car driven by BM on Sunday evening and assumed she was SM.
 
Respectfully, my focus was on simply this, mountain lion theory DID originate with LE per AM, and that BM would rather SM be taken by a lion, as that could be a more of merciful death, as awful as it sounds.
He continues to list it more as a check list of which scenarios have been eliminated. JMO
And even I, probably one of the last holdouts for hope, believes she is dead, now.

Law enforcement may have mentioned that one of their own saw a mountain lion, but that theory was shot down by Sheriff Speeze at that press conference.

It looks like Barry heard “mountain lion,” and then ran with it. That’s how I’ve always believed that went down.

Most loved ones hold out hope, even when the circumstances are all but hopeless. Instead of behaving like these people, Barry thought it better that his wife was deceased, mauled to death by a mountain lion?

That’s a new one.
 
In my opinion, BM’s biggest fear is having his daughters and his mother acknowledge him as a proven liar and hypocrite.
JMO

I think BM's greatest fear is having his persona as some big, successful, important, powerful man being completely stripped away, and of being exposed to the whole world as a total fraud.

His greatest fear is being exposed as being a failure as a human being, and the resulting collapse of all of the status and stature he believes he's achieved in life.

Hubris and Greed.

JMO.
 
Last edited:
Respectfully, my focus was on simply this, mountain lion theory DID originate with LE per AM, and that BM would rather SM be taken by a lion, as that could be a more of merciful death, as awful as it sounds.
He continues to list it more as a check list of which scenarios have been eliminated. JMO
And even I, probably one of the last holdouts for hope, believes she is dead, now.
IIRC the Mountain lion "theory" didn't originate with LE, nor did AM say so. They apparently saw one, drawn to the bloody antlers left near the BM house, but I never heard of LE supporting the theory that the Mt. Lion was responsible for her death or disappearance, where did you see that?

Getting mauled, dragged off and eaten, probably partly while very alive, by a cougar would be more merciful than what other kind of death? Did BM really say that? I've seen ppl mauled by grizzlies and it ain't pretty, & they weren't even killed or dragged off.
 
Last edited:
not so sure= in the Fotis Dulos case, LE found enough blood in her garage that the ME said
she could not have survived the assault, and yet there was no arrest for several months.
I'm guessing for AM to use the word "murder"
now, that LE DID find significant cleaned up
blood, maybe only visible under luminol or such.
Something found led them to believe a "murder" took place, IMO.
One good thing about AM, he's sharing some good details with us. Hope he continues to help us fill in the blanks.

I’m not sure LE used the term “murder” when referring to SM, that’s AM speaking, not LE. AM is determined to find his little sister and I hope and pray he’s successful! I hope AM keeps sharing these nuggets of info as well. This case seemed it was reaching a standstill until AM got actively involved thanks to assistance from @ProfilingEvil
 
Re: 3.5 time frame

It seems the three things that could track and verify BM’s whereabouts are:

-Cell GPS
-Truck GPS
-Cameras

For a phone, the logical conclusion would be that it’s off for 3.5 hours then turned back on.

For the truck, the only scenario I can think of is BM using a different vehicle than his truck. But even that seems like it would have to be tipped off by cell GPs.

And for cameras, it would be that to go from point A to point B, it took 3.5 hours longer than it should have.

The cell phone pinging at home and then being turned off for 3.5 hours and then turned on back at home again would be my guess.

But then it seems like a non-gps vehicle would have been used. I’ve speculated about the Range Rover but the car of a third party could be an option too.

Eithrr way, based on what AM is saying it appears the 3.5 he time frame originated from the house.
 
It may interest everyone to know that the remains of Mitchell Dale Stehling, who disappeared after a quarter-mile hike in Mesa Verde National Park 7 years ago, were found a few days ago.
See the Websleuth page for the full story, but what I want to emphasize is that he was only 4.2 miles away from where he was last seen, in an area that had been searched during the weeks after his disappearance. This is how rugged and inhospitable Colorado can be. We may never find Suzanne. :(
 
I feel if something like that did happen, it wasn't at the house.

Still thinking about the call out to the evidence recovery team from Monday. PE talked about it in the Monday episode - a searcher named Mike found something that DLR, took some pics and sent to either PE or LE. The ERT came out and picked up whatever it was. No way of knowing if it's relevant to Suzanne or not, but it highlights how a single person out there searching is an invaluable resource. Hoping an ARMY of well organized, targeted, searchers will be successful!

I am worried, that this massive search, and the effort by so many, will not find Suzanne's body.
These folk will be devastated.:(:(:(.
Thinking of AM after the search.
He will need wonderful friends surrounding him, for a long time.

But BM will be overjoyed, knowing how smart he really is, and an entire army cannot solve the case.
BM will carry on, with more 'money making' efforts, knowing he is safe.
MOO.
 
I'm skeptical that a mountain lion actually took Suzanne because such attacks are very rare. That being said, @TxGidget posted that -- during a video interview -- AM said "that one thing he knows 'for a fact' was that LE saw a large male mountain lion at the Morphew home." From a legal perspective, it doesn't matter if a mountain lion actually harmed Suzanne or not. If an officer actually testifies for the defense as to seeing a mountain lion at the Morphew home, then it provides a great basis for arguing reasonable doubt.

Of course, the defense will have to identify this officer & subpoena him/her for trial. There's also the possibility that AM misunderstood the remark about the mountain lion, though his statement appears to be fairly emphatic.

Does that mean any vehicle seen on County Road 225 and Puma Path that evening could have been the cause of an accident with SUZANNE and her bike?

Or I’m sure there were several LEOs with holstered pistols, maybe one of those guns caused her death?

I mean, several possible means of harming SUZANNE were later in the vicinity of where it is supposed she went missing, will they all be a basis for (un)reasonable doubt?

Sorry, lamlawindy, I know you are just speaking to us from your experience as an attorney, and I appreciate you and your point of view.

But, I’m hoping common sense will prevail, as other evidence would have to support any proposed theory?

My heart is heavy for SUZANNE and her daughters.
 
Re: 3.5 time frame

It seems the three things that could track and verify BM’s whereabouts are:

-Cell GPS
-Truck GPS
-Cameras

For a phone, the logical conclusion would be that it’s off for 3.5 hours then turned back on.

For the truck, the only scenario I can think of is BM using a different vehicle than his truck. But even that seems like it would have to be tipped off by cell GPs.

And for cameras, it would be that to go from point A to point B, it took 3.5 hours longer than it should have.

The cell phone pinging at home and then being turned off for 3.5 hours and then turned on back at home again would be my guess.

But then it seems like a non-gps vehicle would have been used. I’ve speculated about the Range Rover but the car of a third party could be an option too.

Eithrr way, based on what AM is saying it appears the 3.5 he time frame originated from the house.

It's also possible that he used an ATV to drive off up the trails around Monarch Pass. I'd be surprised if he did not own one. And if he did, he may have driven it all over the area near his home and been familiar with the terrain. Does anyone know if ATVs are allowed on the bike trails?
 
Last edited:
Law enforcement may have mentioned that one of their own saw a mountain lion, but that theory was shot down by Sheriff Speeze at that press conference.

It looks like Barry heard “mountain lion,” and then ran with it. That’s how I’ve always believed that went down.

Most loved ones hold out hope, even when the circumstances are all but hopeless. Instead of behaving like these people, Barry thought it better that his wife was deceased, mauled to death by a mountain lion?

That’s a new one

Apparently I read too many mystery/thriller/ suspense novels. Currently serial killers are main themes. Writers seem to be competing for the most gruesome, grotesque methods of sadistic torture they can dream up. Many claim to be based on true stories. Some actually are.
So yes, I think a lion is not likely to prolong the agony.
It also is probably the only way BM could exact revenge, of a sort. He could track the lion and kill her.

JMO, we’ve gotten a little too cavalier with our speculation on BM being guilty. It is still possible he is guilty of being lousy husband, but not a murderer.
 
BBM:

That's not where my brain is tracking right now.
I don't see disposal of SM's body happening during daylight.

Here's what I'm currently pondering:

What if the digital evidence shows BM's phone being either turned off or stationary at the house, at the exact time his vehicle gps shows his truck traveling at an inexplicably strange time, like, say, the middle of the night, for 3.5 hours?

If BM's phone and vehicle were separated in the middle of the night, that would be an indicator to LE that it was the likely critical window of time during which SM was moved from the house to another location.

The problem with that line of thought is that if BM's truck showed him going to a location in the middle of the night and stopping there for any period of time, LE would have been all over that area.

So, I'm hitting a wall there, too.

JMO.

I agree it was likely an evening move of her body after dark Saturday night.

Maybe it went sort of like this. Just speculating because I am pretty stumped as to the actual movements and timeframes so just taking a shot at it. Sorry such a long post here.

Just speculating....
Around noon Saturday, BM tells MG the work day is done at the Salida site and he needs to go home to make the wife happy. He arrives home around 12:30pm, and the texts with the friend abruptly stop. Assuming SM is no longer with us shortly after this 12:30pm time on Saturday. Her phone is also disabled at this time. He may also have turned off his phone at this point.

BM then realizes he needs to run back to Salida to pickup some cleaning and other supplies. Store receipts will be important if this part is true.
MG sees BM back in Salida and assumes he never went home but he actually did for a little bit just prior to that.

BM eventually leaves Salida and goes back home to do the best house cleaning he has ever done. He also gets all ready to transport a body and plant the bicycle. Nightfall has arrived by then.

It is close to 11PM before he realizes he needs a piece of equipment that is back at the Salida work site location. He makes a call to one of his workmates and they meet him at the Salida site to pickup and load up whatever equipment he needed.

The neighbor at the Salida site hears all the commotion and is woken up by all the noise.

He gets loaded up in Salida and ends up back at his house around midnight or shortly after that.

By 1 or 2 AM, he is ready to go.
He loads up a vehicle and maybe even the bobcat onto the trailer. This part is somewhat of a mystery whose vehicle this is and whether the trailer and bobcat were ever moved.

For example, he may have been able to borrow a vehicle by trading it with a friend's non-GPS vehicle with some kind of excuse about his hitch ball not being right or something off the wall like that where the friend may have not even known what was going down. Or it may have been his own vehicle and the automatic vehicle location system may have only intermittently transmitted GPS coordinates like every hour instead of a more frequent occurrence.

From what I have read about these automatic vehicle location systems, they vary quite a bit in how they function. Some are activated only when the engine is turned on or off and others are motion activated for theft reasons. And even when they are activated, the frequency of when they transmit GPS locations can also vary according to my understanding.

Below is some of the explanations of some of these systems and from reading about them, there seems to be enough variance and differences that they may not always transmit GPS coordinates 100 percent of the time.

So if it was his vehicle, then maybe the system only transmitted information like once every 1/2 hour or once every hour and it may have added enough confusion that LE has not been able to narrow down to a precise location but they have gotten close.

Enter this new search group. We can be certain a group of these searchers will be in the general vicinity of wherever LE thinks is the best chance of finding Suzanne. So that is comforting and we all wish them safety and success.
All JMO of course

Sorry such a long post. Below is a link that describes some of the vehicle location systems and the differences that some of them have.

"It might be helpful to draw a distinction between vehicle location systems which track automatically and event activated tracking systems which track when triggered by an event. There is increasingly crossover between the different systems and those with experience of this sector will be able to draw on a number of examples which break the rule.

A.V.L (Automatic Vehicle Location) This type of vehicle tracking is normally used in the fleet or driver management sector. The unit is configured to automatically transmit its location at a set time interval, e.g. every 5 minutes. The unit is activated when the ignition is switched on/off.

E.A.T.S (Events Activated Tracking system) This type of system is primarily used in connection with vehicle or driver security solutions. If, for example a thief breaks into your car and attempts to steal it, the tracking system can be triggered by the immobiliser unit or motion sensor being activated. A monitoring bureau, will then be automatically notified that the unit has been activated and begin tracking the vehicle."

Automatic vehicle location - Wikipedia
 
Last edited:
I think her life has been taken, and that hunting skills and knowledge were used to dismember the body, human flesh/muscle can look like animal meat/carcass (according to Dr Richard Shepherd - Forensic Pathologist) this was transported in the cooler - as to the pieces of flesh/muscle - I believe this may have been scattered into the wild as there are carnivorous animals around and would soon be devoured, and right now I feel disgusting and an awful human being for sharing my speculation - I am truly sorry for how horrible this theory is.

SPECULATION ONLY again I am so sorry

After the cooler was emptied, it was broken into pieces, and placed into bins: not near BM's home.
What about the market bins, and that area, where BM was reported to be searching for the blue helmet?
All speculation, but explains missing cooler/coolers.
 
I am worried, that this massive search, and the effort by so many, will not find Suzanne's body.
These folk will be devastated.:(:(:(.
Thinking of AM after the search.
He will need wonderful friends surrounding him, for a long time.

But BM will be overjoyed, knowing how smart he really is, and an entire army cannot solve the case.
BM will carry on, with more 'money making' efforts, knowing he is safe.
MOO.
I've thought about Andy too and what may happen. I think he will continue to search if she's not found in this first round. He's very determined and I think the PE guys will help him hold onto hope in order to push on in the future.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
135
Guests online
891
Total visitors
1,026

Forum statistics

Threads
626,191
Messages
18,522,111
Members
240,964
Latest member
JiJi
Back
Top