FL - Derek Rosa, 13, charged as adult in stabbing death of mother Irina Garcia in her sleep, 13 Oct 2023

[ChatteringBirds]

I wish they would have kept this juvenile, no court, plea deal, counseling, incarceration until age 22. Just seems like too much to convict a 13 year old as an adult.

But don't forget the victims or need to protect society. Some of these teens might be able to grow up and change, but what about their victims and the victims' families? What about the teens who do things like this and grow up to remain a danger to society?

Because I imagine most who do this will remain abnormal. We knew not to commit murder when we were 13 and knew what murder meant. I am really concerned about just giving a hush plea deal to teenagers (not little kids) who commit extreme violence.

He even did the whole "look how cool I am" selfie thing afterwards. No remorse.

 

[katydid23]

But don't forget the victims or need to protect society. Some of these teens might be able to grow up and change, but what about their victims and the victims' families? What about the teens who do things like this and grow up to remain a danger to society?

Because I imagine most who do this will remain abnormal. We knew not to commit murder when we were 13 and knew what murder meant. I am really concerned about just giving a hush plea deal to teenagers (not little kids) who commit extreme violence.

He even did the whole "look how cool I am" selfie thing afterwards. No remorse.

And I'm getting the feeling that his surviving family members are coddling him and minimising this crime. They seem to be taking the stance that he is innocent and misunderstood?

If he does get an early release, and moves in with family, we may have a repeat of violent behaviour, imo.

 

[Kemug]

I was just trying to find that recent photo of him, but cant. He looks 20ish now.

 

[Sarahlou]

I was just trying to find that recent photo of him, but cant. He looks 20ish now.

This one?

 

[Kemug]

Yes, that's the one. Perhaps he did have a thing for his mother?

 

[mpnola]

His e

This one?

His eyes look empty.

 

[Seattle1]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1967753351275122839

 

[Seattle1]

Judge not stepping down from case of Hialeah teen accused of murdering mother

The judge overseeing the case of a Hialeah teen accused of brutally stabbing his mother to death is staying on the case after denying a motion by the teen’s attorneys for him to remove himself.

www.nbcmiami.com

9/15/25

The judge overseeing the case of a Hialeah teen accused of brutally stabbing his mother to death is staying on the case after denying a motion by the teen's attorneys for him to remove himself.

In a ruling issued Monday, Judge Richard Hersch said the motion filed by attorneys for Derek Rosa is "legally insufficient."

Attorneys for Rosa had claimed in their motion that Hersch's conduct was "hostile and biased" and argued that the teen wouldn't receive a fair trial if he stayed on the case.

 

[Seattle1]

Attorneys of Derek Rosa, teen accused of killing mom, ask judge to step down

The Hialeah teen who allegedly confessed to stabbing and killing his mother is now asking the judge handling his case to step down.

www.nbcmiami.com

9/11/25

 

[Kemug]

The judge overseeing the case of a Hialeah teen accused of brutally stabbing his mother to death is staying on the case after denying a motion by the teen's attorneys for him to remove himself.

Attorneys for Rosa had claimed in their motion that Hersch's conduct was "hostile and biased" and argued that the teen wouldn't receive a fair trial if he stayed on the case.

RSBM
To tell the truth, my feelings for Rosa are also a teensy bit hostile and biased, given his confession and all the proof we've seen.

 

[Chimera]

And I'm getting the feeling that his surviving family members are coddling him and minimising this crime. They seem to be taking the stance that he is innocent and misunderstood?

If he does get an early release, and moves in with family, we may have a repeat of violent behaviour, imo.

Bbm.
Hoping that doesn't happen !
There needs to be justice for the victim.
Not to mention the baby and her father.
Imo.

 

[mpnola]

Judge not stepping down from case of Hialeah teen accused of murdering mother

The judge overseeing the case of a Hialeah teen accused of brutally stabbing his mother to death is staying on the case after denying a motion by the teen’s attorneys for him to remove himself.

www.nbcmiami.com

9/15/25

The judge overseeing the case of a Hialeah teen accused of brutally stabbing his mother to death is staying on the case after denying a motion by the teen's attorneys for him to remove himself.

In a ruling issued Monday, Judge Richard Hersch said the motion filed by attorneys for Derek Rosa is "legally insufficient."

Attorneys for Rosa had claimed in their motion that Hersch's conduct was "hostile and biased" and argued that the teen wouldn't receive a fair trial if he stayed on the case.

Yeeeeah it's definitely the judges fault if he's found guilty The guilty are always setting up a reason for a guilty verdict before the trial begins. Oooorr it's because he's guilty. I hope it is a no nonsense judge!!! This kid committed an absolutely horrible crime!!

 

[Seattle1]

Yeeeeah it's definitely the judges fault if he's found guilty The guilty are always setting up a reason for a guilty verdict before the trial begins. Oooorr it's because he's guilty. I hope it is a no nonsense judge!!! This kid committed an absolutely horrible crime!!

^^bbm^^

I've listened to most of the hearings publicly available, and the failed defense arguments that I think they are blaming on the Judge are motions on civil rights law, and not specific facts to this case. To be clear, a civil rights complaint isn't a fact just because the defense files the allegation. JMO

 

[Seattle1]

But don't forget the victims or need to protect society. Some of these teens might be able to grow up and change, but what about their victims and the victims' families? What about the teens who do things like this and grow up to remain a danger to society?

Because I imagine most who do this will remain abnormal. We knew not to commit murder when we were 13 and knew what murder meant. I am really concerned about just giving a hush plea deal to teenagers (not little kids) who commit extreme violence.

He even did the whole "look how cool I am" selfie thing afterwards. No remorse.

Very good points @ChatteringBirds

Also, and I think this is important -- several times, the Court denied housing DR in a juvenile holding or outside of the jail without appropriate security readily in place. Although DK is kept away from adult jailed inmates, for his protection, it's clear that youthful offenders were believed to need protection from DR. Sadly, I'm afraid this kid is a psychopath.

How to Tell a Psychopath from a Sociopath

One is much more dangerous than the other.

www.psychologytoday.com

Psychopaths: Calm, manipulative, and planned

• Calculated crimes: Psychopaths meticulously plan their crimes, taking calculated risks to avoid detection. A psychopath would be a cold, calculating killer who thinks through every detail of the crime in advance.
• Innate lack of conscience: Their profound lack of empathy is believed to have a physiological basis, possibly due to underdevelopment in parts of the brain that control emotions and impulses.
• "Mask of sanity": Many psychopaths are superficially charming, charismatic, and skilled at manipulating others. They can mimic normal emotions to blend in and gain trust, making them very effective predators.
• Absence of remorse: They are unable to form genuine emotional attachments and view others as objects for their own amusement or gain.

 

[Motoman_90]

Going off that link that @Seattle1 shared I fall near 100% into the sociopath category but saying that I've seen enough mental health people/specialists over the years I'm sure they would of picked up on it maybe