FL - Nubia Barahona, 10, slain, twin injured, West Palm Beach, 11 Feb 2011 *Arrest*

  • #861
  • #862
  • #863
At this point, what is there to say that I haven't already said. Just. What is the point any longer? Nubia was killed in 2011? Over 14 years ago. What has been the reason for the fact that her murderer has not gone to trial? 14 years?!
 
  • #864
Monday, June 30th:
*Status Hearing (@ 9am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County, (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Jorge L. Barahona (43/now 58) “adopted father” arrested (2/12/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (4/13/11) with 8 felony counts of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, 8 felon/counts of child neglect & attempted murder (Victor) & charged (3/7/11) with 1st degree murder. Plead not guilty (1/7/21). $1M bond. DA will seek DP. Miami-Dade
Trial was set to begin on 4/6/20 reset for 6/15/20 & cancelled due to guilty plea on 9/20/20 & now has new attorneys, plead not guilty on 1/7/21.
Trial was set to begin on 3/16/23 continued with no further dates available.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson presiding. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorneys Carmen Vizcaino & Richard Houlihan.

Court info from 8/30/18 thru 5/22/25 reference post #860 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-43

6/10/25 Update: Report re evaluation hearing on 6/24/25 @ 9am & competency report hearing on 6/30/25 @ 9am. Docket update: Order to appoint & pay expert for competency evaluation of defendant for mental illness by Dr. Sandra Klein, Dr. Bodan & Dr. Haui.
6/24/25 Docket update: Psychological evaluation by Dr. Lina Haji & Dr. Sandra Klein. Next status hearing on 6/30/25 @ 9am.
*Carmen V. Barahona (60/now 64) (adopted mom) – 2/21/20: Plead guilty. 3/4/20: Sentenced to life in prison.
 
  • #865
Jorge:

Hearing
Hearing Date: 07/22/2025 Hearing Time: 10:30 Hearing Type: R
Court Room: REGJB - JUSTICE BUILDING, ROOM No.: 4-1
Address: 1351 N.W. 12 ST


Dockets:
DIN Date Docket
1357 06/30/2025 PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION DR. DAYRA BODAN

1354 06/30/2025 REPORT RE: COMPETENCY HEARING SET FOR 07/23/2025 AT 11:00

1353 06/30/2025 REPORT RE: COMPETENCY HEARING SET FOR 07/22/2025 AT 10:30


Carmen:

Hearing
Hearing Date: 07/22/2025 Hearing Time: 10:30 Hearing Type: R
Court Room: REGJB - JUSTICE BUILDING, ROOM No.: 4-1
Address: 1351 N.W. 12 ST

Dockets:
DIN Date Docket
958 06/30/2025 REPORT RE: STATUS SET FOR 07/23/2025 AT 11:00

957 06/30/2025 REPORT RE: STATUS SET FOR 07/22/2025 AT 10:30

955 06/24/2025 EEPORT RE: STATUS SET FOR 06/30/2025 AT 09:00


link: https://www2.miamidadeclerk.gov/cjis/CaseSearch.aspx?AspxAutoDetectCookieSupport=1
 
  • #866
Tuesday, July 22nd:
*Competency Hearing (Day 1 of 2) (@ 10:30am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County, (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Jorge L. Barahona (43/now 58) “adopted father” arrested (2/12/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (4/13/11) with 8 felony counts of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, 8 felon/counts of child neglect & attempted murder (Victor) & charged (3/7/11) with 1st degree murder. Plead not guilty (1/7/21). $1M bond. DA will seek DP. Miami-Dade
Trial was set to begin on 4/6/20 reset for 6/15/20 & cancelled due to guilty plea on 9/20/20 & now has new attorneys, plead not guilty on 1/7/21.
Trial was set to begin on 3/16/23 continued with no further dates available.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson presiding. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorneys Carmen Vizcaino & Richard Houlihan.

Court info from 8/30/18 thru 6/10/25 reference post #864 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-44

6/24/25 Docket update: Psychological evaluation by Dr. Lina Haji & Dr. Sandra Klein. Next status hearing on 6/30/25 @ 9am.
6/30/25 Update: Next competency hearing on 7/22/25 @ 10:30am & on 7/23/25 @ 11am. Psychological evaluation by Dr. Dayra Bodan.

ALSO:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 10:30am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) (missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County), (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Carmen V. Barahona (60/now 74) “adopted mom” arrested (3/5/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (3/24/11) with 1st degree murder & 14 counts of aggravated child neglect/abuse. Plead not guilty (3/8/11). $1M bond. Miami-Dade
Plead guilty to 1st degree murder & aggravated child abuse on 3/4/20. Plea deal gives her a life prison sentence in exchange for testimony against her husband. Sentencing will be after she testifies against her husband as agreed.
Trial was set to begin vacated. 2/21/20: Defendant found competent to stand trial.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorney Kellie Peterson Marcellus.

Court info from 2/21/20 thru 12/17/24 reference post #825 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-42

12/18/24 Docket updates: Motion to compel production of jail records including psychological & medical records. Order-Granting State's Motion to compel production of all recording including psychological & medical. Next status report hearing on 1/31/25 @ 9am.
6/30/25 Update: Next status hearing on 7/22/25 @ 10:30am & on 7/23/25 @ 11am.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nao
  • #867
Wednesday, July 23rd:
*Competency Hearing (Day 2 of 2) (@ 11am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County, (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Jorge L. Barahona (43/now 58) “adopted father” arrested (2/12/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (4/13/11) with 8 felony counts of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, 8 felon/counts of child neglect & attempted murder (Victor) & charged (3/7/11) with 1st degree murder. Plead not guilty (1/7/21). $1M bond. DA will seek DP. Miami-Dade
Trial was set to begin on 4/6/20 reset for 6/15/20 & cancelled due to guilty plea on 9/20/20 & now has new attorneys, plead not guilty on 1/7/21.
Trial was set to begin on 3/16/23 continued with no further dates available.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson presiding. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorneys Carmen Vizcaino & Richard Houlihan.

Court info from 8/30/18 thru 6/24/25 reference post #866 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-44

6/30/25 Update: Next competency hearing on 7/22/25 @ 10:30am & on 7/23/25 @ 11am. Psychological evaluation by Dr. Dayra Bodan.
7/22/25 Update: No info yet on competency hearing which continues on 7/23/25 @ 11am.

ALSO:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 10:30am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) (missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County), (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Carmen V. Barahona (60/now 74) “adopted mom” arrested (3/5/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (3/24/11) with 1st degree murder & 14 counts of aggravated child neglect/abuse. Plead not guilty (3/8/11). $1M bond. Miami-Dade
Plead guilty to 1st degree murder & aggravated child abuse on 3/4/20. Plea deal gives her a life prison sentence in exchange for testimony against her husband. Sentencing will be after she testifies against her husband as agreed.
Trial was set to begin vacated. 2/21/20: Defendant found competent to stand trial.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorney Kellie Peterson Marcellus.

Court info from 2/21/20 thru 12/18/24 reference post #866 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-44

6/30/25 Update: Next status hearing on 7/22/25 @ 10:30am & on 7/23/25 @ 11am. 7/22/25 Update: Status hearing continues on 7/23/25 @ 11am.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nao
  • #868

July 23, 2025
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, Fla. — It has been more than 14 years since a Florida Department of Environmental Protection contractor found a 10-year-old girl dead in Palm Beach County.
[.....]
On Tuesday, after years of delays in the murder case, Jorge Barahona, Nubia’s adoptive father and alleged killer, was in Miami-Dade County court when he smiled at his defense attorney before a competency hearing.
[.....]
Jeniffer Rohrer, a psychologist, testified via Zoom before Miami-Dade County Circuit Judge Andrea Wolfson, who will have to decide if Barahona is competent for trial.

Rohrer, a defense witness, testified that she had examined Barahona in August and September of 2023 and concluded that he suffered from a psychotic disorder, but she did not arrive at a specific diagnosis.
[.....]
[Judge] Wolfson, who declared Barahona incompetent for trial last year, will also have to consider three other evaluations.

Lina Haji, a psychologist, is among the two experts who evaluated Barahona and believe he is competent to stand trial this time.

“He has never displayed any indication that he is out of touch with reality ... Mr. Barahona has always been able to articulate and verbalize that he is charged with murder, that he is facing the death penalty,” Haji said.
[.....]
Miami-Dade County inmate records show corrections booked Jorge Barahona, then 53, on March 23, 2011.

County court records also show that the case that County Circuit Judge David Young had presided in closed on March 23, 2011, and the charges were transferred to the case that remains open with five additional charges.

County corrections records show Jorge Barahona, now 58, was a Metrowest Detention Center inmate.

The 20 charges he faces: First-degree murder, eight counts of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, eight counts of child neglect, abuse of a corpse, attempted first-degree murder with a deadly weapon, and aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm.



an another article


July 2, 2025
.....
Judge Andrea Wolfson made the determination after he was evaluated by three doctors, and two found him incompetent.

Barahona was transferred from the county jail to the Treasure Coast Forensic Treatment Center, a state mental health hospital, where he has since been evaluated multiple times, including by Dr. Jennifer Rohrer, a forensic psychologist hired by his attorneys.



So... I guess this case is on hold.... :rolleyes:
 
  • #869
OR - am I mis reading that article. Did Judge find him incompetent??
 
  • #870
Oops- I DID mis-read that article!! Good!


July 25, 2025
A South Florida judge ruled Wednesday that the defendant in one of the most notorious child abuse cases in Florida history is mentally competent to stand trial. The ruling clears the way for trial proceedings to resume after years of delays.

Found competent to stand trial​

Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson said Jorge Barahona, 58, can stand trial for the 2011 murder of his 10-year-old daughter, Nubia Barahona.

"At this point in time, it's the court's opinion that Mr. Barahona is competent to proceed, and all parties should continue trial proceedings," said Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson, who made the ruling after hearing expert testimony from doctors and mental health evaluators.
[.....]
The latest ruling follows over a year of ongoing assessments. A status hearing is scheduled for Sept. 19 at 9 a.m.
 
  • #871
  • #872
  • #873
  • #874
I am on Holiday in California thru Sept. 18th - I am going to be flying out on the 18th - and home late on the 19th.
So - posting this now - so I can keep my notes straight - even though the hearing is in a couple of days! :)

Friday, Sept. 19th:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 9am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County, (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Jorge L. Barahona (43/now 58) “adopted father” arrested (2/12/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (4/13/11) with 8 felony counts of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, 8 felon/counts of child neglect & attempted murder (Victor) & charged (3/7/11) with 1st degree murder. Plead not guilty (1/7/21). $1M bond. DA will seek DP. Miami-Dade
Trial was set to begin on 4/6/20 reset for 6/15/20 & cancelled due to guilty plea on 9/20/20 & now has new attorneys, plead not guilty on 1/7/21.
Trial was set to begin on 3/16/23 continued with no further dates available. Found competent to stand trial 7/23/25.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson presiding. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorneys Carmen Vizcaino & Richard Houlihan.

Court info from 8/30/18 thru 6/30/25 reference post #867 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-44

7/22/25 Update: No info yet on competency hearing which continues on 7/23/25 @ 11am. 7/23/25 Update: On Tuesday, after years of delays in the murder case, Jorge Barahona, Nubia’s adoptive father & alleged killer, was in Miami-Dade County court when he smiled at his defense attorney before a competency hearing. Jeniffer Rohrer, a psychologist, testified via Zoom before Miami-Dade County Circuit Judge Andrea Wolfson, who will have to decide if Barahona is competent for trial. Rohrer, a defense witness, testified that she had examined Barahona in August & September of 2023 & concluded that he suffered from a psychotic disorder, but she did not arrive at a specific diagnosis. Judge Wolfson, who declared Barahona incompetent for trial last year, will also have to consider three other evaluations. Lina Haji, a psychologist, is among the two experts who evaluated Barahona & believe he is competent to stand trial this time. “He has never displayed any indication that he is out of touch with reality ... Mr. Barahona has always been able to articulate & verbalize that he is charged with murder, that he is facing the death penalty,” Haji said. Miami-Dade County inmate records show corrections booked Barahona, then 53, on March 23, 2011. County court records also show that the case that County Circuit Judge David Young had presided in closed on March 23, 2011 & the charges were transferred to the case that remains open with five additional charges. County corrections records show Barahona, now 58, was a Metrowest Detention Center inmate. The 20 charges he faces: First-degree murder, eight counts of aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm, eight counts of child neglect, abuse of a corpse, attempted first-degree murder with a deadly weapon & aggravated child abuse with great bodily harm. Judge Andrea Wolfson made the determination after he was evaluated by three doctors, & two found him incompetent. Barahona was transferred from the county jail to the Treasure Coast Forensic Treatment Center, a state mental health hospital, where he has since been evaluated multiple times, including by Dr. Jennifer Rohrer, a forensic psychologist hired by his attorneys.
7/23/25 Update: Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson said Barahona can stand trial for the 2011 murder of his 10-year-old daughter, Nubia Barahona. The defendant in one of the most notorious child abuse cases in Florida history is mentally competent to stand trial. The ruling clears the way for trial proceedings to resume after years of delays. "At this point in time, it's the court's opinion that Mr. Barahona is competent to proceed & all parties should continue trial proceedings," said Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson, who made the ruling after hearing expert testimony from doctors & mental health evaluators. The latest ruling follows over a year of ongoing assessments. 7/25/25 Docket update: Order-Adjuging the defendant competent. 7/29/25 Docket updates: Sealed Order. Letter re defendant. A status hearing is scheduled for 9/19/25 @ 9am.

ALSO:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 9am ET) – FL – Nubia Barahona (10) (missing Feb. 11, 2011, W. Palm Beach, found Feb. 14, 2011 soaked with chemicals in the back of her father’s truck alongside Interstate 95 in Palm Beach County), (Victor (10) injured; had acid thrown on him; he was released from hospital 3/2/11) – *Carmen V. Barahona (60/now 74) “adopted mom” arrested (3/5/11), charged (3/7/11), indicted (3/23/11) & arraigned (3/24/11) with 1st degree murder & 14 counts of aggravated child neglect/abuse. Plead not guilty (3/8/11). $1M bond. Miami-Dade
Plead guilty to 1st degree murder & aggravated child abuse on 3/4/20. Plea deal gives her a life prison sentence in exchange for testimony against her husband. Sentencing will be after she testifies against her husband as agreed.
Trial was set to begin vacated. 2/21/20: Defendant found competent to stand trial.
Judge Andrea Ricker Wolfson. Prosecutor Laura Adams. Defense attorney Kellie Peterson Marcellus.

Court info from 2/21/20 thru 6/30/25 reference post #867 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-palm-beach-11-feb-2011-arrest.128691/page-44

7/22/25 Update: Status hearing continues on 7/23/25 @ 11am. 7/23/25 Update: Status hearing on 9/19/25 @ 9am.
 
  • #875
Enjoy the holiday. @Niner . We have followed this case, for how many years? 14 years? Longer than Nubia was alive. I don't believe this will go to trial, who would even remember things from that long ago? Where are the witnesses now? I have moved three times since Nubia's murder. Changed phone numbers twice.

This entire mess has been a joke.
 
  • #876
FOURTEEN YEARS! :mad:
 
  • #877
Docket for Jorge:
Din Date Docket
1398 09/19/2025 REPORT RE: STATUS SET FOR 12/19/2025 AT 09:00

1397 09/19/2025 REPORT RE: HEARING SET FOR 10/31/2025 AT 09:00

1396 09/19/2025 REPORT RE: MOTIONS SET FOR 10/31/2025 AT 09:00

1395 09/17/2025 AGREED ORDER GRANTING PERPETUATION OF TESTIMONY

1394 09/09/2025 SEALED ORDER

1392 09/04/2025 REPORT RE: PRO SE CORRESPONDENCE SET FOR 09/19/2025 AT 09:00

1391 09/02/2025 MOTION FOR ATTORNEY'S FEES I CAN'T CONTINUE TO PAY THESE ATTORNEYS REPRESENTING ME. MY REASONS AR

1390 08/27/2025 ORDER GRANTING PAYMENT TO EXPERTS FOR TESTIMONY

1388 08/20/2025 DEFENSE WITNESS LIST SENTENCING PHASE


for Carmen:
Din Date Docket
967 09/19/2025 REPORT RE: STATUS SET FOR 12/19/2025 AT 09:00

966 09/19/2025 REPORT RE: STATUS SET FOR 10/31/2025 AT 09:00

for both:
Hearings
Court Room: JUSTICE BUILDING 2-5
Address: 1351 N.W. 12 ST
Hearing Date: 10/31/2025 Hearing Time: 09:00
Hearing Type: Report

link: https://www2.miamidadeclerk.gov/cji...Hd66BcngaWK6lp%2BrktNN6zZ0c%2B43eUCGX9sFvXaZ4
 
  • #878
I wonder how much this entire fiasco has cost the State of Florida? How many hours in attorney fees? Specialists to examine Barahona for "Competency"?
There was even one Barahona attorney who went to South America for "hearings".
 
  • #879
Has he been held in the County Jail all this time?? The same one the whole time?

I know I read of one incident where he was beaten up by about 5 other inmates (doesn't sound like they tried too hard, no broken bones, not even a broken nose!), but is that the only time in 14 years that his fellow inmates tried to exact justice on him that the state has so far proved incapable of doing themselves? Have there been any suicide attempts?

And his wife, has she been in the same jail all this time too? If so, I bet they catch at least glimpses of each other every now and then in the halls or where ever as they are moved about. How strange.

So where does it stand now? Is he really finally going to trial? And I know about her plea deal and its conditions.

You all are amazing to stick with this for so long! All for Nubia's sake.
 
  • #880
And his wife, has she been in the same jail all this time too?

Per my notes:
Carmen V. Barahona (60/now 74) (adopted mom) – 2/21/20: Plead guilty. 3/4/20: Sentenced to life in prison.
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
114
Guests online
2,401
Total visitors
2,515

Forum statistics

Threads
632,712
Messages
18,630,830
Members
243,269
Latest member
Silent_Observer
Back
Top