This was an ESSAY contest, not a fiction contest. Essays are assumed to be non-fiction.
Girl wins contest with false essay about soldier dad...
- Thread starter Texana
- Start date
-
-
***GUILTY*** Mark Sievers - APPEALS HIS DEATH SENTENCE Oct 13 2025- Latest: nhmemorymaker
-
This was an ESSAY contest, not a fiction contest. Essays are assumed to be non-fiction.
Amraann I feel sorry for the little girl too. However, she doesn't deserve to win. What she said she was going to do to "make someone's holiday special" was a lie. Therefore, she doesn't deserve to win. Read what the essay is supposed to be about.
"We want to hear how you're going to ROCK someone else's holiday."
If it is a deed you are doing to make someone have a better "holiday" then that implies that you are GOING TO DO IT. She couldn't do it because the whole story is a farce. No, she clearly doesn't deserve to win. I am glad that they are going to give it to some other "deserving" child. I pray this child doesn't turn out like her lying, cheating, mother.
"We want to hear how you're going to ROCK someone else's holiday."
If it is a deed you are doing to make someone have a better "holiday" then that implies that you are GOING TO DO IT. She couldn't do it because the whole story is a farce. No, she clearly doesn't deserve to win. I am glad that they are going to give it to some other "deserving" child. I pray this child doesn't turn out like her lying, cheating, mother.
Some things we teach our children are just common sense Amraan.
Read the first sentence. The idea was to reward a child for doing something for someone else.
If it had to be spelled out that it had to be truthful, it would be an embarrassment,IMO.
LionRun
Former Member
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2006
- Messages
- 5,592
- Reaction score
- 60
A dishonest, amoral woman who is teaching her currently innocent daughter all of her ugliness was booted, and unfortunately her daughter is paying for the lousy mother's wrongdoings. Had the fraudulent mother not done what she did, her daughter would not be now paying the price. It is solely the mother's fault that this happened and that the daughter may now feel sad.
Shame on her if her daughter sheds a tear over this. But, it would not be right to allow the daughter (and even more so the sleazy mother) to go at this point, IMO. The prize should and will be awarded to the rightful winner--who would not have had this chance if the fraud mom were not found out. Now that would have been wrong.
Lion
Shame on her if her daughter sheds a tear over this. But, it would not be right to allow the daughter (and even more so the sleazy mother) to go at this point, IMO. The prize should and will be awarded to the rightful winner--who would not have had this chance if the fraud mom were not found out. Now that would have been wrong.
Lion
LionRun
Former Member
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2006
- Messages
- 5,592
- Reaction score
- 60
Jelly, I couldn't agree with you more. And, if the mother had nothing to hide why on earth would she not use her daughter's real name? And, by stating that they would do anything to win doesn't make her look so good, either.
Lion
Also, notice the mother said "We wrote whatever we could to win." I don't think that little girl wrote the essay in the first place.
JanetElaine
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2007
- Messages
- 5,966
- Reaction score
- 4,060
From wiki:
An essay is a piece of writing, usually from an author's personal point of view. Essays are non-fictional but often subjective; while expository, they can also include narrative. Essays can be literary criticism, political manifestos, learned arguments, observations of daily life, recollections, and reflections of the author.
Apologies for not cleaning it up, I'm waiting for dinner to be done lol.
We don't know what the rules are until we ask: For complete details including entry information and judging criteria, send a self addressed stamped envelope to Club Libby Lu Attn: Hannah Montana Official Rules, 2700 West Grand Avenue, Chicago, IL 60612."
Is it worth the time to anyone??
Amraann: Great job as loyal opposition. A job in British politics awaits.
I agree the rules should be simple and available easily (on the net), not by snail from some cubicle in Chicago. Also, I think the mother is a crappy role model and preventing her from twisting and violating the spirit of the contest and the season is what the company needed to do.
Crypto6
LionRun
Former Member
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2006
- Messages
- 5,592
- Reaction score
- 60
Texana
Overreaching
Perfectly said!
Will Amraan have to wear one of those fluffy white wigs to argue the opposition, though? :laugh:
LionRun
Former Member
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2006
- Messages
- 5,592
- Reaction score
- 60
. 
southcitymom
Well-Known Member
I bet she'd look HOT in one of those!
Spazkat9696
Former Member
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2007
- Messages
- 1,468
- Reaction score
- 29
:furious: Still makes me mad.:furious: I feel she should have understood the essay needed to be true. What you are going to do to make someones holiday special. Not pretend you father is dead to get a prize. I hate how people think they can pull on the heart strings by saying their loved one died in Iraq/Afghanistan, and get something. People like that just make it harder for the people/families who were really killed/injured over there. I am sticking with my previous post. :furious:
Beyond Belief
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- May 25, 2005
- Messages
- 14,496
- Reaction score
- 118
My husband said he heard the woman got a lawyer. is there any truth in that?
pixies
Former Member
- Joined
- Dec 5, 2007
- Messages
- 1,306
- Reaction score
- 38
She is one of the most hated women in America right now. I don't blame her. I bet she and her family is in hiding right now too. This touched a nerve with most people who have heard the story.
You dont ever say "Daddy was killed in Iraq" just to win something. Lots of Daddies died in this war, Mommies too. Can you imagine being a little kid whose parent did die in the war and is hearing this??
She is a cruel heartless woman. Her daughter (and son) is being raised with a mother who feels winning is worth lying and in my op. CHEATING.
Her husband has a myspace also and boy is he still alive and obviously shares the same values his wife does. If you seen his pictures on myspace, you will understand.
She will sue the company. No doubt. But I cannot imagine any jury giving this
anything. I hope the company does NOT bow down and offer her a dime. :furious:She closed down her my space. Could you link me to his my space? What is he saying about it?She is one of the most hated women in America right now. I don't blame her. I bet she and her family is in hiding right now too. This touched a nerve with most people who have heard the story.
You dont ever say "Daddy was killed in Iraq" just to win something. Lots of Daddies died in this war, Mommies too. Can you imagine being a little kid whose parent did die in the war and is hearing this??
She is a cruel heartless woman. Her daughter (and son) is being raised with a mother who feels winning is worth lying and in my op. CHEATING.
Her husband has a myspace also and boy is he still alive and obviously shares the same values his wife does. If you seen his pictures on myspace, you will understand.
She will sue the company. No doubt. But I cannot imagine any jury giving this
ljwf22
Reality continues to ruin my life.
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2004
- Messages
- 3,052
- Reaction score
- 5
I saw her MySpace yesterday before it was pulled. She was married, has three kids: the 6-year old girl, a boy who looked to be about 4 and a baby girl. Mom was a fan of 'ChicanoRap or LatinaRap (I don't remember the term she used, sorry.)' and said about her favorite rapper that he was the "only that could come between me and my husband."
that could come between me and my husband."
