Meredith Kercher murdered in Perugia, Amanda Knox convicted #3

[Tizzle]

Isabella, don't get it twisted. I didn't say the cases were similar, at all. I said that Mignini's tactics are similar in the two cases. Not the same thing and I'm not wrong.

Also, I don't care what charges were dropped against Mignini. All that matters to me is the abuse of office charge that he was CONVICTED of. It proves how crookedly he conducts business. It speaks to his character, or lack thereof. You think he's only abused the power of his office once???? DOUBTFUL!

Also, I don't need to be reminded that Amanda AND RAF were convicted of Meredith's murder anymore than you need me to remind you that I don't think they actually ARE guilty of Meredith's murder. I wonder how people would feel about Mignini if it were somebody they love being wrongly accused and subsequently convicted by him. He still wouldn't be so bad then? Think about it.

 

[Isabella]

Isabella, don't get it twisted. I didn't say the cases were similar, at all. I said that Mignini's tactics are similar in the two cases. Not the same thing and I'm not wrong.

Also, I don't care what charges were dropped against Mignini. All that matters to me is the abuse of office charge that he was CONVICTED of. It proves how crookedly he conducts business. It speaks to his character, or lack thereof. You think he's only abused the power of his office once???? DOUBTFUL!

Also, I don't need to be reminded that Amanda AND RAF were convicted of Meredith's murder anymore than you need me to remind you that I don't think they actually ARE guilty of Meredith's murder. I wonder how people would feel about Mignini if it were somebody they love being wrongly accused and subsequently convicted by him. He still wouldn't be so bad then? Think about it.

Oh I have thought about it. And if my son/daughter/sibling committed this vile murder i would tell them they had done wrong..that i would love them and support them but they had to be punished for there crime. I wouldnt go around doing a media blitz of my country trying to trash the country or slandering them. I would simply be there for them. And i dont believe for one moment that her parents dont know she is guilty. There is a case on this board where a boy killed his brother and the parents support him being tried as adult. The difference in the way those parents behave and Amandas is just so different.

 

[missyjane77]

So he was in fact CLEARED of the main charges against him

It seems to me he was trying to get justice for a guy who had been murdered after it had been stated he wasnt murdered. All in all his "conviction" seems far less severe than Amandas

Of course his conviction seems far less severe....they weren't even charged with the same things. It's apples and oranges.

 

[missyjane77]

Oh I have thought about it. And if my son/daughter/sibling committed this vile murder i would tell them they had done wrong..that i would love them and support them but they had to be punished for there crime. I wouldnt go around doing a media blitz of my country trying to trash the country or slandering them. I would simply be there for them. And i dont believe for one moment that her parents dont know she is guilty. There is a case on this board where a boy killed his brother and the parents support him being tried as adult. The difference in the way those parents behave and Amandas is just so different.

I bet if you thought your children were INNOCENT, you'd feel a lot differently. It's obvious that Amanda's family thinks she's innocent. Why would they support a conviction if they feel it's wrong? Think about that.

 

[Isabella]

I bet if you thought your children were INNOCENT, you'd feel a lot differently. It's obvious that Amanda's family thinks she's innocent. Why would they support a conviction if they feel it's wrong? Think about that.

NO its not obvious to me they think shes innocent at all. At times i wonder just how well her family even knew her and personally i would love to know what time Amanda phoned them the day Meredith was found.

Because they "say" shes innocent doesnt mean they believe this. The Entwhistles said Neil was innocent. The Anthonys say Casey is innocent etc. And the same in many other cases the parents have publically claimed there children are innocent. Its all about trying to influence the public and help get there little darlings off the charges.

JMO

 

[missyjane77]

NO its not obvious to me they think shes innocent at all. At times i wonder just how well her family even knew her and personally i would love to know what time Amanda phoned them the day Meredith was found.

Because they "say" shes innocent doesnt mean they believe this. The Entwhistles said Neil was innocent. The Anthonys say Casey is innocent etc. And the same in many other cases the parents have publically claimed there children are innocent. Its all about trying to influence the public and help get there little darlings off the charges.

JMO

Well, I guess we won't ever know, now will we....since no one can read minds.

 

[Isabella]

Well, I guess we won't ever know, now will we....since no one can read minds.

As i said..it would be interesting to know the timing of the call to her parents and whether it was BEFORE the police turned up.

 

[missyjane77]

As i said..it would be interesting to know the timing of the call to her parents and whether it was BEFORE the police turned up.

Why is the timing important? Is it one of those things where it doesn't really matter because she "damned" either way? Call too soon, wrong; call too late, also wrong.

 

[miley]

As i said..it would be interesting to know the timing of the call to her parents and whether it was BEFORE the police turned up.

If you are that interested, Isabella, why don't you look it up -


(let us know what you find)

 

[LinasK]

Oh I have thought about it. And if my son/daughter/sibling committed this vile murder i would tell them they had done wrong..that i would love them and support them but they had to be punished for there crime. I wouldnt go around doing a media blitz of my country trying to trash the country or slandering them. I would simply be there for them. And i dont believe for one moment that her parents dont know she is guilty. There is a case on this board where a boy killed his brother and the parents support him being tried as adult. The difference in the way those parents behave and Amandas is just so different.

Exactly!:clap::clap::clap: I'd behave like Mark Hacking's family or Jeffrey Dahmer's father, NOT like the Knox's, the Anthony's, or Scott Peterson's family- deny, deny,deny!

 

[Isabella]

Why is the timing important? Is it one of those things where it doesn't really matter because she "damned" either way? Call too soon, wrong; call too late, also wrong.

I think its OBVIOUS why its important to be honest. I read she phoned them BEFORE Merediths body was found telling them. Now i dont know if this is true or not and thats why i said i would love to know the time of her ringing them. IF she did phone them before the police got there..then personally i think theres no chance at all they dont know shes guilty.

JMO

 

[missyjane77]

I think its OBVIOUS why its important to be honest. I read she phoned them BEFORE Merediths body was found telling them. Now i dont know if this is true or not and thats why i said i would love to know the time of her ringing them. IF she did phone them before the police got there..then personally i think theres no chance at all they dont know shes guilty.

JMO

Do you have a link?

 

[missyjane77]

Exactly!:clap::clap::clap: I'd behave like Mark Hacking's family or Jeffrey Dahmer's father, NOT like the Knox's, the Anthony's, or Scott Peterson's family- deny, deny,deny!

If you truly thought your daughter was innocent, you wouldn't. We don't know what these families are thinking. Maybe they are in denial. Maybe they honestly and truly believe in the innocence.

 

[Isabella]

If you truly thought your daughter was innocent, you wouldn't. We don't know what these families are thinking. Maybe they are in denial. Maybe they honestly and truly believe in the innocence.

And maybe they dont! We will never know unless firm proof comes out one way or another.

 

[Isabella]

Do you have a link?

No I dont. I also said it was just what i read and was why i would love to know the timing of the call to her parents to prove it one way or another.

 

[missyjane77]

No I dont. I also said it was just what i read and was why i would love to know the timing of the call to her parents to prove it one way or another.

No source (link) means it's a moot point, IMO.

 

[Isabella]

No source (link) means it's a moot point, IMO.

Its not a moot point to me at all. I was explaining why I wanted to know the timing of the call. Weirdly..if it could help to prove anything either way..i would have thought ALL would be interested in the timing...unless of course some really arent interested in the truth.

JMO

 

[kemo]

Amanda called her mother at 12:47 while she was with Raffaelle in her room and the Postal Police were in the house. At 12:55, Raffaele called the police to report the break-in. Niether Raffaele nor Amanda mentioned anything about the Postal Police being there. This same information is confirmed by the FOA web site except that it claims the Posal Police had not yet arrived. From what I can tell, unless there is a conspiracy amoung police agencies to LIE, the police were there before 12:47. I have no idea what the defense or FOA are currently claiming about these times, but they are obviously very critical. The cell phone records are extremely accurate and pretty much impossible to deny yet it is very damming to the defense that Amanda and Raffaele would make such calls without mentioning the fact that the police were already there. The only reasonable conclusion is they were covering up the fact that had not called to report the break-in promptly and to cover the lie that they had told to the Postal Police (that they had already called in the report). While it is possible that they were only covering up their poor handling of the situation, the time to fess up to that has long passed.

Obviously parents are going to be the last to recognize that their children have commited a crime but Amanda's parents have an added incentive to be in denial. They must raise funds for her defense and their best, pehaps only hope, is to argue for the absolute innocence and victimhood of their daughter. Who would give money to help free a murderer?

 

[missyjane77]

Do you have a link Kemo?

 

[kemo]

Check the "True Justice for Merideth" site under "Cell phone Activity". #5 covers it pretty well.

This site is obviously "anti-Amanda" but I think the information it provides is accurate.

Check friendsofamanda.org site under "Case summery" They acknowledge that Raffaele made his call to report the break-in when he did, They just try to argue the Postal Police actually arived latter. I find they arguemnt weak.

At the trial, The Postal Police stood by their claim to have arrived at 12:25. I do not know if the defense team tried to challenge this.