AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[LRinCA]

It just mentions exactly what I posted from the article

No mention of a neighbor.

IMO it was because of the SAFE (formerly Silver) alert for NG and it was requested because of that, neighbor, LE, doesn't matter. It was after she was reported missing and has no part of this investigation. Other than the fact that the employee of APS was even able to leave the card at the front door, where we all clearly saw blood and was part of a crime scene that LE released WAY too early, again IMO.

Thanks again for posting it!

 

[tbgo]

You know, if Harvey Levin would stop giving these alleged ransom notes attention the person may crawl out of their hole and expose themselves in other ways (by letter with fingerprints). TMZ is just giving this person or people the attention they crave. I really wish they’d stop reporting on it. The more they do the more emails they’re going to receive. If they, the writer, stops getting a reaction, they’ll stop - if they’re pulling a hoax. If they’re the real deal they’ll have to switch to other means of communication which might trip them up.

Also, if they’re fake, they’re inadvertently helping the real perp by causing a distraction. TMZ keeping this going publicly is not helping matters. Not that HL actually cares.

TMZ should keep the emails between themselves and the FBI.

 

[SMK777]

 

[warp3dwing]

The SHERIFF said it was a neighbor who called. The article was posted yesterday evening.

If you go to the Arizona APS site, you can submit an anonymous tip online. In theory, it would be possible that someone anonymously requested an APS checkup on Nancy without providing any personal information outside of saying they're a "neighbor."

 

[stmichael]

Earlier I was talking about the marks seen in the driveway.

Picture source: Page Six

View attachment 646699

“She couldn’t walk 50 yards by herself,” Nanos said at the news conference, noting that while Nancy Guthrie had mobility issues because of her age, she had no cognitive issues.

https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona-breaking/2026/02/02/savannah-guthrie-mom-missing-tucson/88470747007/

On the website Calc maps I put in a travel of Nancy that line up with the marks and go to where the marks stop.

It is exactly 50 yards.

View attachment 646700

Map Distance calculator, Google Maps Distance Calculator

Use the distance calculator map to find the distance between multiple points along a line. Map distance calculator is a simple tool that allows you to draw a line on a map and measure the distance.

www.calcmaps.com

I am not claiming that this is what happened, or that the drag marks are from Nancy, only that it is a possibility.

When was this picture taken? The foot traffic must have been significant since the scene was released the first time (3x total) and pizza guys and pool cleaners were walking and driving since then. The night of the SWAT raids Tucson had some decent rain as well.

I initially wondered if they tested tire tracks/soil samples seeing the type of driveway it was and assuming he'd pull the car up out of sight, but at some point after the scene was released and there was so much foot traffic that scene was cooked.

 

[shonyakay]

FYI, this isn't how Google Trends works at all and Google themselves dismissed the Fox News claims about the Nancy Guthrie search claims. Ashleigh Banfield talks about it at around the 24:30 min mark. News Nation reached out to Google to inquire about the claims and Google responded.

Here is the transcript from the video below:

Nation reached out to Google to try to get, you know, flesh this out a little bit and say, "Hey, you know, uh, what do you know about this?" And Google had some really interesting things to say. It's a little complicated. So, I am going to read their words exactly, so follow along.


Okay. Google said, "We are actively trying to get corrections in the Fox piece as there are some fundamental misunderstandings and inaccuracies in what was reported. Key facts for you to know." Again, this is Google to News Nation.


Google Trends does not — underlined in bold — show actual volume of queries. So, the suggestion that an individual person did a given search is not something you can claim via the Google Trends tool.


That's interesting.


Then underlined — very important — they say for queries with very low or even no search volume at all, Google Trends charts will show statistical noise as a privacy protection measure. Because of this, Google Trends charts are not — bold and underlined — definitive evidence of a specific search having occurred.


And then they say, if you're still planning to publish something, we can provide a statement, but would encourage you to scrutinize the claims given this information about how Trends works.


So that's super interesting because it sort of tamps down the shock value of that report.

Thanks for sharing. I was already told by another poster that it may not be accurate. I just was sharing what the Data states. Take it or leave it. I just found it interesting that there is only searches listed for Savannah for very specific dates right before the crime when there was not any activity for months before. Same with the searches for Nancy. Where the Data was pointing for the majority of them having occured was just South of Nancy's home Tubac / Sierra Vista. South is where LE detained the first individual. Now it seems like you are saying that there is an innocent explanation for these searches and dates correct?

 

[cherryleaf]

You know, if Harvey Levin would stop giving these alleged ransom notes attention the person may crawl out of their hole and expose themselves in other ways (by letter with fingerprints). TMZ is just giving this person or people the attention they crave. I really wish they’d stop reporting on it. The more they do the more emails they’re going to receive. If they, the writer, stops getting a reaction, they’ll stop - if they’re pulling a hoax. If they’re the real deal they’ll have to switch to other means of communication which might trip them up.

Also, if they’re fake, they’re inadvertently helping the real perp by causing a distraction. TMZ keeping this going publicly is not helping matters. Not that HL actually cares.

My hope is that TMZ is baiting and a trap has been set

 

[SaraSmile]

https://twitter.com/x/status/2024546185026187333

All in my opinion.

Yes, Mexicans near the border hear about, follow AZ border news. Maybe they want the reward! Also, many American News stations, such as Telemundo and local AZ TV stations are in Spanish, so no problem getting USA News to “ nearby” across the border Mexicans. A lot know English, too.

In addition, the Mexican border patrol works closely with USA border patrol to send USA criminals back to the USA, very common, in my opinion.
I highly doubt the perp would risk taking NG across the border. Maybe on day one, lying down in back, covered? I just don’t see a benefit really.

Yes, maybe the perps went somewhere outside of AZ to hide( NG left in AZ, sorry). That is possible.

All JMO

 

[RatFace]

I see what you're saying, but you just stereotyped

I don't think you understood what I said if you thought that was stereotyping.

 

[connie9030]

Apparently, Tucson homicides are on the rise. Is it time to let residents turn the lights back on at night?

IN-DEPTH: Tucson homicides on the rise, how police plan to react amid public pressure

Homicides are on the rise in Tucson, leaving many residents feeling unsafe and demanding action. According to data from Tucson Police, the city is currently dealing with more homicide cases

www.kvoa.com

 

[submarine7]

My hope is that TMZ is baiting and a trap has been set

I think so, or, at the very least TMZ is encouraging communication which may lead to discovery of physical location.

 

[Mistermagoo]

I do not claim to be any sort of forensics expert, and I certainly think that LE and the FBI have their reasons, but wouldn't you think that the front porch Mat would be in some sort of evidence? I mean, like everything else, it is too late, but the perp was obviously standing on it. Like someone else mentioned, he could have drooled while using the flashlight. Couldn't his shoes have fibers or something from his house/car that may have possibly been left behind? That is stuff that can be compared to a potential perps actual home/car after they've been caught. Not to mention that there is a good chance there was blood on it. Maybe they just did a luminol test on site and figured that it wasn't important.

 

[Napoli]

If you go to the Arizona APS site, you can submit an anonymous tip online. In theory, it would be possible that someone anonymously requested an APS checkup on Nancy without providing any personal information outside of saying they're a "neighbor."View attachment 646703

YIKES! Pretty generic, huh? Thanks for posting that.

 

[Katrinepa]

Apparently, Tucson homicides are on the rise. Is it time to let residents turn the lights back on at night?

IN-DEPTH: Tucson homicides on the rise, how police plan to react amid public pressure

Homicides are on the rise in Tucson, leaving many residents feeling unsafe and demanding action. According to data from Tucson Police, the city is currently dealing with more homicide cases

www.kvoa.com

Not for us to decide, and the reason they don't have lights all over is they confuse wildlife, especially birds. Very sad, but in somewhat isolated, overall calm areas, crime will eventually rear its ugly head. Certainly, all this attention will bring all kinds to the neighborhood. Hoping for the best outcome for all, especially the family.

 

[stmichael]

SNIPPED-

In addition, the Mexican border patrol works closely with USA border patrol to send USA criminals back to the USA, very common, in my opinion.
I highly doubt the perp would risk taking NG across the border. Maybe on day one, lying down in back, covered? I just don’t see a benefit really.

Yes, maybe the perps went somewhere outside of AZ to hide( NG left in AZ, sorry). That is possible.

All JMO

There are benefits, if one is being realistic. A poster laid out a compelling overview many many pages ago.

You have cheap and accessible medical care and medicine (many Americans go over the border to buy drugs and steroids at unregulated pharmacies). Easy to find a female older caretaker for an elderly medically compromised woman. You have a cultural concept of no snitching and minding your business much more so, local police and political corruption, bribes, far less regulation and surveillance state. You have far less heat and investigation on you and jurisdictional and resource complications. Much easier to lay low and disappear overall.

As I said, 1,000s of Americans cross over and back every day. Border towns have many dual nationals and it's much more casual and in some areas less monitored than most think.

When they pulled over and detained Carlos, the delivery driver, he was minutes from Nogales Border and driving South. The proximity alone kicks in border protocols.

 

[SaraSmile]

According to this video, BE says most local people in Nogales have not heard of the case. A few people who read or look at social media did know about it. All it takes is one keen observer, who has heard of the case, to turn in the perp.

I personally don’t think NG is in Mexico.

JMO

 

[Bluewing3102]

Thanks for sharing. I was already told by another poster that it may not be accurate. I just was sharing what the Data states. Take it or leave it. I just found it interesting that there is only searches listed for Savannah for very specific dates right before the crime when there was not any activity for months before. Same with the searches for Nancy. Where the Data was pointing for the majority of them having occured was just South of Nancy's home Tubac / Sierra Vista. South is where LE detained the first individual. Now it seems like you are saying that there is an innocent explanation for these searches and dates correct?

The biggest problem with google trends is that they normalize their data. To normalize data means that the numbers on the graph don't represent absolute search volume numbers. It's presented on a scale from 0-100, where each point on the graph is divided by the highest point, or 100. This also means that searches with low volume are essentially erased to maintain normalcy.

Google themselves state :

"Hovering your mouse over the graph reveals a number, which reflects how many searches have been done for the particular term relative to the total number of searches done on Google.

Trends excludes certain data from your searches:

• Searches made by very few people: Trends only analyses data for popular terms, so search terms with low volume appear as 0 for a given time period
• Duplicate searches: Trends eliminates repeated searches from the same user over a short period of time for better overall accuracy."

Essentially if you see 1 on a random date it doesn't mean that one person searched that specific term. It could've been 500 people in that region searched that term but because people googled a million other things that day it's considered a relatively low "trending" term on a scale from 0-100

 

[Charlot123]

.

Celebrity stalker. Captivated by SG. Thinks she is his fantasy girlfriend. Lives in a make believe world of movies and TV. Socially shy, awkward in normal male/female relationships. Puts HIS WOMAN (SG) on a pedestal. Might be a poetic or well read, literary type, bookish or nerdy guy. OCD. Anxiety is high. Can no longer contain his love for SG. Gets to her through her mother, NG. Receives the attention he craves. Feels, SG has spurned him by not responding to little compliments he may have said to her on a fan page that are simple like "Loved you on the show today". Basically, he's a tortured soul. MOO JMO

No offense, but is she a typical stalker's type? She's neither a singer nor a star. People can get obsessed with anyone, but i imagine her audience being of a different type. Am I missing something?
Are we sure it's her and not money?

 

[Katrinepa]

Good You tube podcast I just watched, with a world crime profiler. Interesting things to observe, and when

 

[K9Enzo]

I do not claim to be any sort of forensics expert, and I certainly think that LE and the FBI have their reasons, but wouldn't you think that the front porch Mat would be in some sort of evidence? I mean, like everything else, it is too late, but the perp was obviously standing on it. Like someone else mentioned, he could have drooled while using the flashlight. Couldn't his shoes have fibers or something from his house/car that may have possibly been left behind? That is stuff that can be compared to a potential perps actual home/car after they've been caught. Not to mention that there is a good chance there was blood on it. Maybe they just did a luminol test on site and figured that it wasn't important.

I am surprised they left the mat. That mat was not a random object. It's a primary contact surface. To counter my comment, they probably fully documented the mat with photos and swabs. IMO