People being detained and "exported" by ICE

[BeginnerSleuther]

are those the "civilian" clothes he was taken away in? just curious because he looks normal FWIW, not injured or starving.

In that particular photo, there's no evidence of physical injury. There is zero chance he isn't psychologically harmed.

MOO.

 

[Lilibet]

People inside the USA don't seem to understand consequences, so they do nothing until it makes a difference to their lives.

We saw that with recent protests. No one in the USA cares when Canada and Greenland are threatened, trade agreements are violated, or unjust tariffs are imposed. They only care when their personal investments are hit by the global response to tariffs. Then they have something to say - but only when it impacts them personally.

As I pointed out on the “Tariff” thread @otto, I don’t think you’re seeing the extent and variety of the protests in the US almost daily. Only Rachel Maddow on MSNBC is showing these and she zeroes in on the signs people carry. They vary, but I have definitely seen Canada and Greenland mentioned. It kind of depends on what the latest news is about. But thinking Americans (and there are many, contrary to popular opinion ) are very well aware of the impact of Trump on the world, not just on themselves, and are sick about it. I’m begging you not to generalize in such a negative way. It’s disheartening in your otherwise excellent posts, which are much appreciated.

Nationwide tomorrow April 19, the 200th anniversary of the start of the American Revolution.

No King/ Anti Trump protest · Mobilize

The "NO KING/ ANTI TRUMP NATION - WIDE PROTEST WILL BE: SATURDAY April 19th, 2025 1:00-2:30 500 SW Dorian sidewalk Pendleton, Oregon 97801 No marching just a standing protest... Bring your chairs if need be, Signs noise makers and anything else you would like to bring. Good time to bring...

www.mobilize.us

List of cities hosting nationwide anti-Trump protests on Saturday, April 19

Another nationwide protest sponsored by the 50501 movement is scheduled for Saturday, April 19. Here are some of the cities hosting demonstrations.

www.newsweek.com

JMO

 

[Leilei]

On the official White House Twitter page today. Absolutely vile human beings.
View attachment 580020

Appalling.

 

[keek]

Appalling.

Saying when is this going to be blasted out of this country is so wearying. All of it.

 

[TheTeach]

Emphasis: "The panel said he might succeed, but warned his anti-judiciary campaign may backfire if the public begins to doubt [Trump] is following the law."

It's a bit late for that, isn't it? The anti-judiciary campaign has not backfired. There is a clear difference of opinion between USA citizens, and the rest of the world. Everyone outside the USA can see what's happening - perhaps because we are not bombarded with daily propaganda. People inside the USA don't seem to understand consequences, so they do nothing until it makes a difference to their lives.

We saw that with recent protests. No one in the USA cares when Canada and Greenland are threatened, trade agreements are violated, or unjust tariffs are imposed. They only care when their personal investments are hit by the global response to tariffs. Then they have something to say - but only when it impacts them personally.

Similarly, they will sit silent and idle until the following quoted consequence happens to someone they know, and then it will be too late. All the pieces for deporting USA citizens to foreign prisons will be in place, and the justice system will be powerless.

"What assurance will there be tomorrow that it will not deport American citizens and then disclaim responsibility to bring them home?"

US citizen who cares! I've contacted my representatives weekly since January on various aspects of this mayhem that Trump has caused: education, social security, human rights, tariffs, Ukraine, immigration. Ive peacefully taken a stand with others across the country. That's the scary part, our voice seems loud, but no one is hearing us.

 

[Leilei]

Saying when is this going to be blasted out of this country is so wearying. All of it.

Sweetie, my husband and I are exhausted. It just gets worse and worse and louder and louder.
IMO.

 

[TheTeach]

What's strange is that the USA government says they have no reason to request his return to the USA, El Salvador said it has no reason to send him back to the USA. At the same time, it seems that everyone agrees there's no reason for him to be in prison.

Why isn't he released from prison. No government needs to do anything for him beyond releasing him safely from prison. Why hasn't that happened?

Because Trump is paying El Salvador to keep him in that prison. Trump wants the US to see that he is taking care of business, and it will be a bruise to his ego/image, if Abrego Garcia does not stay there. The statement Trump is making with our tax dollars. MOO it's crazy how it doesn't make sense, yet....people are still buying it.

 

[erratum]

People inside the USA don't seem to understand consequences, so they do nothing until it makes a difference to their lives.

I think there is a lot of that, actually.



First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist

Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist

Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist

Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew

Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me

 

[NuttMegg]

And those are valid reasons to deport someone, as long as it's done the right way.

There's been other cases where it doesn't seem to be as justified.

"Currently facing charges" doesn't get it with me. Anyone can point the finger at anyone. We have dozens if not hundreds of threads here. Cases discussed in exquisite detail until the accused gets their due process.

Facing charges is no excuse to ship someone in chains to a foreign country for the rest of their life. Here under the constitution we can't imprison anyone for life. Until proven guilty.

 

[BeginnerSleuther]

Emphasis: "The panel said he might succeed, but warned his anti-judiciary campaign may backfire if the public begins to doubt [Trump] is following the law."

It's a bit late for that, isn't it? The anti-judiciary campaign has not backfired. There is a clear difference of opinion between USA citizens, and the rest of the world. Everyone outside the USA can see what's happening - perhaps because we are not bombarded with daily propaganda. People inside the USA don't seem to understand consequences, so they do nothing until it makes a difference to their lives.

We saw that with recent protests. No one in the USA cares when Canada and Greenland are threatened, trade agreements are violated, or unjust tariffs are imposed. They only care when their personal investments are hit by the global response to tariffs. Then they have something to say - but only when it impacts them personally.

Similarly, they will sit silent and idle until the following quoted consequence happens to someone they know, and then it will be too late. All the pieces for deporting USA citizens to foreign prisons will be in place, and the justice system will be powerless.

"What assurance will there be tomorrow that it will not deport American citizens and then disclaim responsibility to bring them home?"

BBMFF.

I don't think that's fair. There was actually quite a bit of protest by residents, citizens, and politicians about Greenland/Canada, tariffs, and all the other absurdities. But also, this is how MAGA operates -- throwing everything including the kitchen sink at the wall so people's heads are spinning and they have to pick and choose the topic they'll fight back on. It's incredibly manipulative and psychologically abusive. My point is, just because you don't see the disgust of the US for what he's threatening and doing internationally, don't assume it doesn't exist or that we're not up in arms about it. We are.

MOO.

 

[fred&edna]

As I pointed out on the “Tariff” thread @otto, I don’t think you’re seeing the extent and variety of the protests in the US almost daily. Only Rachel Maddow on MSNBC is showing these and she zeroes in on the signs people carry. They vary, but I have definitely seen Canada and Greenland mentioned. It kind of depends on what the latest news is about. But thinking Americans (and there are many, contrary to popular opinion ) are very well aware of the impact of Trump on the world, not just on themselves, and are sick about it. I’m begging you not to generalize in such a negative way. It’s disheartening in your otherwise excellent posts, which are much appreciated.

i guess this is the rachel maddow/msnbc you speak of... the ones who just settled a lawsuit for falsely accusing a physician.

settled when the physician sued for $10 million in compensatory damages and $20 million in punitive damages.

Maddow quoted a detainee's account in the complaint: "When I met all these women who had the surgeries I thought this was, like, an experimental concentration camp[,] it was like they're experimenting with our bodies."

the judge found "there were no mass hysterectomies or high numbers of hysterectomies at the facility," contrary to the allegations from a whistleblower; that Dr. Mahendra Amin, the plaintiff in the case, had performed only two hysterectomies on female detainees; and that he was not a "uterus collector,"

Amin received death threats and bomb threats, lost patients, lost the ability to provide medical service to the ICE facility as a result of MSNBC's broadcasts, his lawyers say. They also say he's withdrawn from social and community activities he previously enjoyed.

NBC settles defamation lawsuit with doctor falsely labeled "uterus collector"

MSNBC had aired stories falsely claiming the doctor performed mass hysterectomies on female detainees at an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Georgia.

www.whro.org

https://www.npr.org/2025/02/21/nx-s1-5305268/nbc-settles-lawsuit-ice-doctor-msnbc-maddow-georgia-detainee

jmo - but we should all be careful of our news sources and reporters - whether approved by ws or not o
i do believe maddow's producers have been fired but no link to share. just google. she and her friends destroyed a physician's life and livelihood with lies.

 

[SouthAussie]

"A U.S. judge barred the Trump administration from rapidly deporting hundreds if not thousands of migrants to countries other than their own without giving them a chance to show they fear being persecuted, tortured or killed there.

U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy's preliminary injunction on Friday was the latest setback to an immigration crackdown launched by President Donald Trump when he took office on January 20.

Many of the people deported to third countries are refugees who have been granted protections against returning to their home countries, where they would face persecution or torture, according to Anwen Hughes of Human Rights First, a lawyer for the plaintiffs.

Judge Murphy voiced concern that without a court order, the administration might carry out deportations in violation of the Convention Against Torture."

US judge halts Trump plan for rapid deportations to third countries

 

[SouthAussie]

"Lawyers for Venezuelan men detained in Texas asked the U.S. Supreme Court on Friday to block what the lawyers said were the men's imminent deportation by the Trump administration without the judicial review previously mandated by the justices.

The case raises questions about President Donald Trump's administration's adherence to limits set by the Supreme Court. It carries the risk of a significant clash between the two coequal branches of government and possibly even a full-blown constitutional crisis.

At issue is whether the Trump administration has fulfilled the Supreme Court's standard for providing the detainees due process before sending them to another country - possibly to the notorious prison in El Salvador where others are jailed."

Venezuelan migrants ask US Supreme Court to halt 'imminent' deportations

 

[SouthAussie]

As I pointed out on the “Tariff” thread @otto, I don’t think you’re seeing the extent and variety of the protests in the US almost daily. Only Rachel Maddow on MSNBC is showing these and she zeroes in on the signs people carry. They vary, but I have definitely seen Canada and Greenland mentioned. It kind of depends on what the latest news is about. But thinking Americans (and there are many, contrary to popular opinion ) are very well aware of the impact of Trump on the world, not just on themselves, and are sick about it. I’m begging you not to generalize in such a negative way. It’s disheartening in your otherwise excellent posts, which are much appreciated.

Nationwide tomorrow April 19, the 200th anniversary of the start of the American Revolution.

No King/ Anti Trump protest · Mobilize

The "NO KING/ ANTI TRUMP NATION - WIDE PROTEST WILL BE: SATURDAY April 19th, 2025 1:00-2:30 500 SW Dorian sidewalk Pendleton, Oregon 97801 No marching just a standing protest... Bring your chairs if need be, Signs noise makers and anything else you would like to bring. Good time to bring...

www.mobilize.us

List of cities hosting nationwide anti-Trump protests on Saturday, April 19

Another nationwide protest sponsored by the 50501 movement is scheduled for Saturday, April 19. Here are some of the cities hosting demonstrations.

www.newsweek.com

JMO

Thank goodness for Rachel Maddow's up-to-date and lauded reporting!


Maddow has received multiple Emmy Awards for her broadcasting work; in 2021, she also received a Grammy Award for the audiobook version of Blowout (2019).

Rachel Maddow - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[Anance]

are those the "civilian" clothes he was taken away in? just curious because he looks normal FWIW, not injured or starving.

A few weeks ago, Abrego Garcia was transferred from CETOM to a more conventional jail in Santa Ana. Before he met with the Senator, he was taken from that jail, given new clothes, and cleaned up. They met in the restaurant of a nearby hotel, which had been cleared of all other patrons. The Salvadoran authorities served two margaritas to them. Neither touched any drinks placed in front of them.

Trump news at a glance: Maryland senator says Ábrego García moved from notorious El Salvador prison

 

[Anance]

On the official White House Twitter page today. Absolutely vile human beings.
View attachment 580020

The VP of El Salvador told Senator Van Hollen of Maryland that El Salvador had no evidence that Abrego Garcia was an MS-13 gang member. That allegation comes from a disgraced policeman and his secret informant.

 

[IzzyBlanche]

The VP of El Salvador told Senator Van Hollen of Maryland that El Salvador had no evidence that Abrego Garcia was an MS-13 gang member. That allegation comes from a disgraced policeman and his secret informant.

Do you have a link? Thank you.

 

[Anance]

What's strange is that the USA government says they have no reason to request his return to the USA, El Salvador said it has no reason to send him back to the USA. At the same time, it seems that everyone agrees there's no reason for him to be in prison.

Why isn't he released from prison. No government needs to do anything for him beyond releasing him safely from prison. Why hasn't that happened?

The VP of El Salvador answered that question: he said that the US govt is paying the Bukele, president of El Salvador, to keep him in prison. Bukele is notoriously corrupt.

From the respected Spanish newspaper El País

Bukele clan fumes over investigation exposing their new wealth

 

[Anance]

Do you have a link? Thank you.

I read that specific quote a few days ago, but now I can't find it. In retrospect, I find it odd that the VP would admit such a thing.

EDIT: I checked an AI that provided sources of that specific quote. When I checked the sources, the quote was omitted and simply said El Salvador has not provided evidence of MS -13 membership.

 

[Anance]

Do you have a link? Thank you.

Disgraced police officer and secret informant. Never disclosed.
Disgraced Maryland police officer tied to 2019 Abrego Garcia gang report

A now-fired Maryland police officer authored the 2019 gang report that the government referenced when it mistakenly sent a Maryland father to a notorious prison in El Salvador, documents obtained by USA TODAY show.

In 2021, Mendez' name appeared on the "Do not call" list Braveboy released. Those are police deemed unreliable because of their disciplinary records, crimes or other alleged misconduct. If those officers are called to testify, prosecutors disclose the officer's history to the defense.

Speaking on CNN April 16, Braveboy said the 2019 report was based partly on a confidential informant, as well as the controversial GangNet database, which has since been disbanded. Operators of the system warned at the time that it was intended for intelligence only and should not be used as the basis for arrests or charges.