GUILTY UK - Det. Leanne McKie, 39, found dead in Cheshire lake, 28 Sept 2017

  • #61
12:56

Could have taken 'from 30 seconds to a few minutes' for Leanne McKie to die

The pathologist said it was virtually impossible to say how long it took for Leanne McKie to die but he said it could have taken from 30 seconds to a few minutes.

Dr Rodgers said it was difficult to time the death but he said he had been told by the police they believed the death occurred at ‘around about mid-day’ on September 28 and he agreed this timing was ‘consistent’ with the pattern of rigour mortis he had discovered from witnesses who found found the body and his own examination.

The pathologist concluded the main cause of death was ‘asphyxia’ caused by ‘external compression’ which was likely to have been ‘manual strangulation’.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #62
13:44

Police officer tells how he found body in lake

A police officer has described how he found Leanne McKie’s body at Poynton Lake and then pulled her onto the bank.

Jack Nelson, based in Macclesfield, was working a nightshift when he responded to a call of a body being found, the court heard.

He arrived at Poynton Lake, a fishing pond, at 3.59am on September 29 last year and saw a man ‘distressed, shaking and crying’, the officer said in a statement read to the jury.

The officer climbed through a dense section of trees to a ‘jetty section’ at the water’s edge, the court is told.

“I could see there was a body face down in the water,” said the officer, who noted there were no shoes on the body and that the arms and hands were above the water line.

He described how he and another police officer who arrived at the scene pulled the body onto the bank.


13:44

Body had no shoes on

The body was of a white female with blonde hair wearing dark trousers and a black and white top, PC Nelson said in is statement.

He noted there were rings on the fingers, that rigour mortis had set in and that there was blood around the nose, the court hears.

The body had no shoes on, according to the PC.

“After I removed the body from the water, I checked to see if there was a pulse. There was none,” said the officer,


13:45

Drag marks 'roughly 140 metres from car park'

PC Nelson said he noticed ‘drag marks’ in the mud.

“These marks were close together and started from where the body had been found in the water and there has been roughly 140 metres to the car park area of the lake,” according to the officer.

A paramedic, in another statement read to the jury, confirmed he had seen ‘drag marks coming from the car park’ when he arrived at the scene.

The court heard that earlier someone flagged down a passing motorist to raise the alarm.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #63
15:14

Pc Tom Spowage tells court how he twice encountered Darren McKie

Pc Tom Spowage tells the jury how he twice encountered Darren McKie during the early hours of September 29 while on patrol with another officer in an unmarked police vehicle.

The first occasion he saw him walking along Adlington Road in Wilmslow at 1.30am when he was walking along the pavement with his hood up, the court heard.

He was wearing black trainers and a black jacket, according to the officer who revealed there had been a number of burglaries in the area.

The officers asked him where he was going and he pointed to the nearby Bletchley Park Way and said he lived there.


15:16

Insp McKie seemed ‘very vacant’, officer tells court

PC Spowage said the officers saw Darren McKie for the second time on Moor Lane in Wilmslow at 2.15am.

He said he recognised him from the first encounter but this time noticed he wasn’t wearing shoes, the court is told.

Insp McKie said he was on his way home which he said was just around the corner, according to the PC.

The witness said Insp McKie seemed ‘very vacant’ and added: “There’s just no sort of emotion or anything there.”

He got out of the patrol car and asked Insp McKie his name but he only identified himself as ‘Darren’, the jurors are told.

Insp McKie is said to have told the officer he didn’t have to give further details.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #64
15:27

'Very strange that Insp McKie wasn’t wearing shoes'

PC Spowage said he noticed that Insp McKie was wearing what appeared to be police issued combat pants and top, at which point he announced he was an off-duty officer for Greater Manchester Police.

The witness said he found it ‘very strange’ that Insp McKie wasn’t wearing shoes and that he was ‘a little bit concerned for his wellbeing’.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #65
15:51

PC Spowage tells court McKie had thrown shoes in bin

Insp McKie said he had thrown his trainers into a black bin as his feet had been ‘rubbing’.

He also then revealed his wife was also a GMP officer, the court is told.

The witness said they drove the short distance to the family home in Burford Close.

PC Spowage told the court: “He said he believed she may have crashed on the way home and had gone out looking for her and he had drunk some wine and was unable to drive.”

Insp McKie revealed he had only texted his wife rather than call her and, urged by the police officer, he called his wife and left a message, the jurors are told.

The defendant, according to the witness, left a message saying words to the effect: “Hi Leanne. It’s Darren. Just ringing to see where you are if you get this message. I’m worried. Ring back.”

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #66
15:58

Witness asked Insp McKie if he had done his wife ‘harm’

PC Spowage said: “Due to Darren’s demeanour and the circumstances, that I have seen him at 1.30am and 2.15am, and that he had no shoes and the circumstances of him trying to contact Leanne we asked ‘have you done anything stupid?’

“Darren replied ‘what do you mean by that response?’”

The witness said he asked Insp McKie if he had done his wife ‘harm’.

PC Spowage said: “He replied with words similar to ‘no nothing like that, why would you ask?’”

The defendant was told these were just routine questions, the court is told.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #67
16:22

PC and colleague left house and discussed their concerns in patrol car, court told

Insp McKie showed the officers his police warrant card when they were inside his home and he also said his wife had a red Mini although he could not recall the registration, the court is told.

PC Spowage said Insp McKie apologised to the officers and said he was probably just over-reacting.

The PC and his colleague left the house and discussed their concerns in their patrol car, the jurors are told.

They made checks on the police national computer and then decided to retrace the route Insp McKie had taken to find Leanne’s car to no avail, the court hears.

The two officers are then said to have returned to Burford Close to see if the Mini was there but it wasn’t.

The officers went back to Wilmslow police station and found out just before 4am that a body had been found at Poynton Lake.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #68
16:39

Concern as children had been left ‘home alone’, witness tells court

PC Spowage said he was concerned when he arrived Insp McKie’s home on Burford Close as the children had been left ‘home alone’.

As Insp McKie opened the front door and walked into the home with the officers, they saw a child crying, the court is told.

The child was ‘quite visibly upset’, said the officer, who continued: “There was no interaction between Darren and the child. He was very cold, very emotionless and unmoved by anything.”

He said he told Insp what he had done was ‘wrong’.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #69
16:47

Officers returned to house after body found at lake

The two police officers returned to Burford Close after they learned of the discovery of a body at Poynton Lake just before 4am, the jurors are told.

PC Spowage said he went to the rear of the property while his colleague was ‘banging on the front door’.

Insp McKie answered the door in his dressing gown and was ‘very calm and collected’, said PC Spowage, who added: “Again, no emotion.”

His PC colleague noticed washing spinning in the machine in the utility room but was able to stop the cycle, the court hears.

The registration of Leanne McKie’s Mini Countryman was obtained from insurance documents and checks later revealed the car had activated number plate recognition cameras towards Poynton Lake, the jurors are told.


16:51

Officers considered sectioning Insp McKie, court hears

During cross-examination of PC Spowage, it emerged the officers considered sectioning Insp McKie under the Mental Health Act because of his behaviour.

Trevor Burke QC, defending the inspector, said his client had not been wearing shoes and suggested that the defendant had been ‘difficult and stroppy’ when the officers had dealt with him on the second occasion.

“We were concerned for his well-being, yes,” said PC Spowage.


16:57

'He had a vacant look on his face, no expression what-so-ever'

PC Spowage’s colleague, PC Phillip Reeves, confirmed to the court that officers considered sectioning Insp McKie.

Describing the defendant’s behaviour, PC Reeves told the court: “He had a vacant look on his face, no expression what-so-ever.

“The whole time we stopped it was as though he wasn’t a person.”


16:57

Trial will resume tomorrow

The jury has been sent home and trial resumes in the morning.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #70
DAY FIVE

Darren McKie is sitting in dock taking notes

Day five of the trial is underway here at Chester Crown Court.

Darren McKie, wearing a suit, is sitting in the glass fronted dock, taking notes of the proceedings as he has done throughout the trial.

The public gallery here in court two is about two thirds full, with some members of the family also present.

The first witness this morning is Professor Lorna Dawson, who the jurors are told is an expert in soil.

In his opening address to the jury earlier this week, prosecutor Nigel Power QC told the court that soil found on the defendant’s trainers, which were found in a bin near the family home, had come from the ‘deposition site’ at Poynton Lake and not the garden of his home.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #71
11:02

Expert compares soil on trainers and at lake

Prof Dawson, wearing gloves, is given the pair of trainers which the prosecution say was dumped in a bin close to the McKie house in Wilmslow.

She tells the jury she found ‘fairly homogenous’ soil adhering deeply to the tread of both trainers.

The witness agreed with the prosecutor when he suggested she had found similarities between the soil on the trainers and the soil found at the ‘deposition site’, the spot where Leanne McKie’s body was found at Poynton Lake.

The soils were of a ‘very similar profile’, said Prof Dawson.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #72
11:46

Soil on trainers is 'very unlikely' not to have come from lake site

Prof Dawson described the soil on the trainers as a ‘very unusual profile’.

The jury has been told by the witness that soil is made up of organic and inorganic material. Man-made material such as fertilizer can make up inorganic material, the court is told.

The inorganic material found on the trainers were ‘similar’ to that found at ‘deposition site’, Prof Dawson tells the jurors.

She said she could exclude the garden at Burford Close as the source of that inorganic material.

She said both the organic and inorganic soil profiles were different on the trainers and in the family garden.

There was ‘strong support’ for the proposition that the soil on the trainers was from where the body had been dumped at Poynton Lake, she said.

Adding a caveat, the professor tells the jurors soil analysis could not provide a ‘100 per cent match’ but that there was a ‘high degree of comparability’.

She said it was ‘very unlikely’ somewhere else would have the same characteristics as the soil she examined on the trainers and at the deposition site.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #73
13:35
‘Obviously visible’ areas of blood staining found on left trainer

The jury is now hearing from forensic scientist Lisa Johnston, who said DNA matching Leanne McKie was found in blood staining discovered on the defendant’s left trainer.

The jury has previously heard how Darren McKie’s New Balance trainers were found in a bin about a 100 yards from the family home.

Ms Johnston told the court ‘obviously visible’ areas of blood staining were found on the left trainer.

The trainer showed ‘contact’ blood staining and also ‘air-borne’ blood staining, the jury was told.

Asked how blood could become air-borne, Ms Johnston said: “Through force applied to it. It could be a very forceful punch or a kick or it could also be moving an item.”

She said DNA found in the blood matched DNA taken from Leanne McKie.

A DNA profile taken from the heel of the trainer matched that of the defendant, the court heard.

The jurors were told that no blood was found on the right trainer.


13:39
Darren McKie's DNA in wife's Mini 'which was used to dump body'

The court heard Darren McKie’s DNA was found on the hand-brake of his wife’s Mini Countryman, which the prosecution say he used to dump her body.

Ms Johnston said Leanne McKie’s DNA was also found on the hand-brake but that the defendant’s DNA was ‘a more significant contributor than Leanne McKie’.

The defendant’s DNA is also said to have contributed to samples taken from the car’s steering wheel where his wife’s DNA was also found.

The jury was told that Insp McKie was an ‘infrequent driver’ of her car.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #74
14:55
DNA could have been 'washed away'

The jurors hear that none of the defendant’s DNA was found on Leanne McKie’s body but Ms Johnston agreed that this may have been ‘washed away’ while her body was in Poynton Lake.

The witness tells the jury:

The absence of DNA does not refute that he had contact with her. The DNA could have been removed in the water or it could have been at a very low level which we have not detected.

When asked by Nigel Power QC, for the prosecution, she agreed that Darren McKie had been a ‘significant contributor’ to the DNA found on the steering wheel and hand-break of his wife’s Mini Countryman.

She said her findings ‘did not really fit’ the suggestion from Insp McKie that he had not driven the car for four or five days before her death.


15:09
Witness cross-examined on whether DNA profile suggests Darren McKie is major driver of the car

Under-cross examination from Trevor Burke QC, defending, Ms Johnston was asked whether the fact that the major DNA profile found on the steering wheel suggested that Darren McKie was the major driver of the car.

The witness agreed but added ‘in isolation’.

Ms Johnston confirmed she was unable to identify a third DNA trace found on the steering wheel and hand-break.

Asked about swabs taken from seat adjustor handle inside the car, the witness said she had found ‘low level partial DNA’ which she said ‘could be or could not be Darren McKie’.

Ms Johnston said:

There were low-level DNA results present but it wasn’t suitable for comparison and therefore no comparison was made.


15:10
Trial adjourned for the weekend

The jury has been sent home and the trial resumes on Monday.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #75
Interesting but disturbing case, thanks for the updates. I have added interest as I live a mile away from the police station he worked at.

I'm interested in the financial context at the time.

The accused DM arrived home to his wife LM after she discovered the fact that DM applied for a secret loan that would take them from £400k to £450k of debt. Around £58k of that debt occurred in the last 7 months.

At 10% interest, that is their whole income for the next 25 years. The reality is that they would only be able to give say half their income, taking the repayments beyond their life expectancy.

On the day of the murder a survey of the house had been arranged to value to house to support a loan application, Do the lenders have any culpability in this crime for lending their lifetime expected income?

One motive for murder in this situation is life insurance, however this murder appears to be totally unplanned. Clearly this situation triggered a difficult conversation, but what could lead to DM strangling LM?

The timeline is quick from murder to arrest - about 4-5 hours:

11:20 - LM recieves parcel giving evidence of the secret loan.
11:30 - DM leaves work to go home
11:40 - Phone call between DM and surveyor. Survey wants 1pm appt, DK asks for for 2pm but settles on 1:30pm
12:00 - Approx DM arrives home
12:00 - 13:00 LM strangled by DM, both cars and body moved from the house
13:00 - Surveyor arrives and waits
13:00 - 13:30 approx DM seen walking into his own house, neither car is seen outside from 13:00
15:00 - 16:00 seen at school picking kids up
00:00 - 01:00 approx - DM disposing of LM's body in lake using LM's car, dumping car nearby and walking home (about 1 hr walk)
01:30 - DM spoken to by police whilst walking towards home
02:15 - DM spoken to second time by police. Now without shoes that have been put in a bin nearby. Police take him home and ask if he has harmed his missing wife. Police notice 3 young children had been left unattended.
03:47 - Body of LM discovered by angler
04:00 - Original police made aware of body and return to DM house to arrest DM.
 
  • #76
Thank you @legallybland for posting the updates and @tallmansix for compiling a helpful timeline. Given their financial difficulties had been ongoing for some time and LM had no life insurance (if I read the reports correctly), I wonder what triggered DM to strangle her (if he did, although it seems likely). I'm not familiar with the different police roles - was she more senior than him i.e. did she earn more? Maybe she said she was leaving him? I feel awful for the three innocent children, losing both parents and reading about all this in years to come.
 
  • #77
DAY SIX - START
Hearing to recommence shortly

Today’s proceedings in the trial are due to start at 10.30am.

We’ll bring you live updates from Chester Crown Court here.


10:17
Court to hear mobile phone 'cell site' evidence

The court is hearing from cell site expert Gregory Robinson this morning.

He has more than 30 years experience in telecoms. He has compiled a report for the court.

Cell site analysis uses historic data records of a particular mobile phone to discover its whereabouts.
He is explaining the process to the jury.


10:29
Focus on use of three phones

His evidence will focus on the use of three mobile phones, all of which were on the Vodafone network. All capable of 4G technology.

Most of the time, a mobile phone will use the nearest available ‘cell site’ to transmit. If this is blocked it can use a cell site that is further away, he explains.


10:42
Cell site ranges differ in cities and in rural areas

Typical cell site ranges tend to be smaller in cities. In suburban areas cell site ranges are about two to three kilometres. They get bigger, and the distance between the cells become greater, the more rural an area becomes, Mr Robinson explains to the jury. There can also be areas with no signal in rural areas.

Now the court moves on to his evidence. This will focus on one phone used by Leanne McKie and two phones used by Darren McKie - his personal and work phones.


11:27
Analysis of 'data events' on mobiles phone

Asked by Nigel Power QC for the Crown if two phones on the same network, if used in the same place would use the same cell, Mr Robinson replies that this is something ‘you would expect, by and large’.

The court is now looking at data records from the three phones. Mr Robinson attended several key locations and measured which cells would provide service to phones. This includes the couple’s home and Paddock Hill Farm.

The court is now looking at a ‘data connection’ made by Leanne McKie’s phone. These can happen for many reasons, not because the user has interacted with it, Mr Robinson explains.

At 1.08am there is a ‘data event’ lasting 5hrs 45mins. This means the ‘data session’ has been running for more than five hours.

Manchester Road was the cell site to begin with. This later moved to land off the A538. Mr Robinson says this could be because the phone found a better cell site.

The court is now looking at a map which includes Stretford Police Station and the home address. A call was made at 11.36, from Leanne McKie’s phone lasting 16 seconds.

Mr Robinson is being asked to look at the records from Mrs McKie’s phone from 11.37am onwards.

The data activity on it did not require anyone to have used it. When asked by the prosecution if the cell it used was one serving the home address he agrees.


11:43
Cell-site records on Darren McKie's phones examined

The court continues to look at maps correspond to which cells the three phones were using at points throughout the day on the 28th September.

The court is now looking at records from between 11.52am and 12.11pm on the 28th.

Both Darren McKie’s work and personal phones were using cells serving the home address.

Between 11.52am and 13.39 that work phone was using cells in and around Wilmslow.

Between 11.59 and 14.28 the personal phone was using the same cells.

Between 14.00 and 14.28, Darren McKie’s personal phone was using cells covering the home address.

The court is now taking a short break.


12:29
'Similar movement' shown by Leanne and Darren's phones

To recap, the prosecution is currently taking the expert witness, cell site analysis expert Gregory Robinson, through a series of maps which track the location of Leanne McKie’s phone, and Darren McKie’s work and personal phone, on September 28.

At 14.38 on Leanne McKie’s phone and at 14.42 on Darren McKie’s phone, there was a ‘data event’ on both phones at Walton Farm.

Asked by the prosecution if this suggests that both phones were together, Mr Robinson said: “It would certainly support similar movement by both of these phones”.


12:58
Movements of phones described

The data suggests that Darren McKie’s phone was in ‘the Wilmslow area’ from 14.50 to 22.42.

During the afternoon and evening of the same day, data connection suggests that Leanne McKie’s mobile phone was switched on. There was a long data connection that started at Walton Farm. There were ‘incoming events’ such as text messages being received, during this time.

The majority of the cells which were used during this time served Burford Close. Between 22.43 and 12am, Darren McKie’s phone was using cells consistent with the phone being around Burford Close.

The data of Leanne McKie’s phone suggests it was ‘not static’ between 22.43 and 22.47 and was moving away from Burford Close.

Between 22.48 and 22.50 Leanne McKie’s phone used three different cell sites within a few minutes, in an area to the west of Wilmslow.


13:08
Data suggests Leanne's phone remained at Paddock Hill Farm

When asked by the prosecution if that data suggested Leanne McKie’s phone had remained at Paddock Hill Farm, Mr Robinson agreed it did.

Mr Robinson said the data supported Darren McKie’s personal phone being at Burford Close from 12am to 5am.

The court proceedings are now breaking for lunch.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #78
Thank you @legallybland for posting the updates and @tallmansix for compiling a helpful timeline. Given their financial difficulties had been ongoing for some time and LM had no life insurance (if I read the reports correctly), I wonder what triggered DM to strangle her (if he did, although it seems likely). I'm not familiar with the different police roles - was she more senior than him i.e. did she earn more? Maybe she said she was leaving him? I feel awful for the three innocent children, losing both parents and reading about all this in years to come.
There was a link earlier in the thread which showed approx. hourly rates of pay for different grades of police officer, I'm pretty sure he was the higher earner, plus LM was working 16 hours p/w.

As for timing, I think things probably just came to a head when the £50k loan agreement came through the post on the day of the murder.

I can't work out what his defence will be other than deny, deny, deny. But this makes me think there's a possibility he'll try to introduce a third party:


[Day 2]12:50KEY EVENT
'I did not kill my wife'

The jurors are told that Insp McKie was charged with murder on October 2 last year and that he is said to responded: “I did not kill my wife.”

Nigel Power QC, coming to an end of his opening statement for the prosecution, told the jurors: “That’s the issue you will have to decide in this case, whether Mr McKie killed his wife or whether it was some other person.”

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526

BBM.
 
  • #79
14:37
Defence questions how precise cell site data is

Court has resumed following lunch.

Witness Mr Robinson is now talking about the iCloud account shared by Darren and Leanne McKie’s phones. They shared the same AppleID.

The cell site data is still independent to each phone as the access to the network of each phone is independent.

The defence is now beginning its cross-examination.

Trevor Burke QC puts it to the witness that the nature of cell site data is imprecise.


15:07
Defence pitches football analogy on cell site evidence

Mr Burke, defending, puts a hypothetical scenario of a football match to the witness in order to query the reliability of cell site data, in which two people making calls next to each other might have their calls picked up by different cell sites because many people are using their phones at the same time, and therefore appear to be miles apart.

The judge has now granted the jury a break so they can privately study the data which the witness has been discussing this morning.

The case is expected to resume in around 30 minutes.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.c...-news/darren-mckie-murder-wife-trial-14368526
 
  • #80

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
93
Guests online
1,803
Total visitors
1,896

Forum statistics

Threads
632,760
Messages
18,631,340
Members
243,282
Latest member
true-crime_fan
Back
Top