Search results

Quite a fight, yet JA suffered no injury? The blood spatter around the sink could not have simply been caused by JA hacking and slashing away at a severely wounded TA?

But it is indisputable that TA did just that (sit in the shower for a minute or more with the shower door open). He didn't move between the last two shower photos, which were 70 seconds apart. You don't think it is likely he remained in that position until JA struck the initial blow? He was...

Yes, I'm assuming JA left the bathroom to retrieve the knife after delivering the gunshot wound. Where she got the knife is a mystery, but I'm guessing she found it nearby. JA could not have been holding two weapons at any time before the bathroom ceiling photo. This real-time video shows...

But the photographic evidence (e.g., the bathroom ceiling photo) shows that JA was still holding the camera in her right hand just 62 seconds before TA was bleeding at the end of the hallway. How could she have been wielding a knife in her right hand? Of course it's not impossible that she...

Under my theory, the explanation is that JA left the bathroom to retrieve the knife. During this brief moment, JA was not standing between TA and the sink area. It's really hard to leave out that last photo as it is partly the fact that TA had been holding that position for 70 seconds that...

Those are all good points and I don't deny that TA's ultimate path to the sink and eventually down the hallway can be explained in a knife-first scenario. I just believe they are better explained by a gun-first scenario in which JA left the bathroom and returned with a knife. Also, I cannot...

It's possible that she wasn't smart enough, but I just don't think anyone who wanted to contain the evidence to the shower area would use a knife instead of a gun.

If JA started slashing at TA in the shower, why would she stop at any point? Why would TA try to push by JA toward the sink area if she was standing between him and the sink as she clearly was when the bathroom ceiling photo was taken? In my opinion, the only reason TA would've moved toward...

I think I agree with most of your analysis except this part about the amount of bleeding associated with the gunshot wound that would have been evident. The autopsy report states that "[t]he wound track perforates the anterior frontal skull near the superior orbital bone and traverses the...

This diagram shows JA was standing between TA and the sink when the bathroom ceiling photo was taken: http://i922.photobucket.com/albums/ad64/SoulShynz9293/shower_travis_murder_pics_xtralarge.jpg Note that the first bleeding photo is taken 62 seconds after the bathroom ceiling photo. That...

Although I can't envision, based on the photographic evidence (especially the last shower photo that immediately preceded the attack), how or why JA would've struck her initial blow with a knife instead of a gun, I'm willing to concede that it is possible that JA did use the knife first. You...

Let's assume hypothetically that the Dr. Michael Baden that Mark Fuhrman referred to in his interview is actually the renowned forensic pathologist discussed on wikipedia here: Michael Baden - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Let's also assume hypothetically that Dr. Baden reviewed the autopsy...

The point is I think JA was smart enough to know that a knife attack in the shower would not play out as depicted in the movie Psycho. She wanted to contain all of the evidence in the shower. So she used a gun. The ME concludes differently, but his opinion is not infallible.

Knife first theorists: Is this how you believe JA thought the sequence of events would play out if she used the knife first? Shower scene from the movie Psycho

Again, another knife first theorist appears to concede that the knife first theory makes more sense if TA got out of the shower before the initial blow was struck. The idea that JA let TA get up from the vulnerable position she had so carefully choreographed, and that TA had been holding for at...

If JA delivered the first blow with the knife, she would've had to get much closer to TA without him noticing that she had the weapon. So she draws the knife from her left pocket with her left hand and attempts to stab at his neck in a downward motion. I'm not sure exactly which wound this...

But how does TA physically get there if JA is standing between TA and the sink, continuously stabbing and slashing at him with the knife? And, if that's what happened, why didn't TA sustain more knife wounds on the front of his body?

You say you don't want to speculate, but you seem to admit that the knife first theory makes more sense if TA got out of the shower before JA struck the initial blows with the knife. To me, it makes absolutely no sense that JA would let TA get up from the vulnerable position she had so...

And she was holding the camera in her right hand when she moved in for the kill.

LOL! I'm seriously thinking about doing that!