I hope everyone is listening to the complete recording which is about 2.5 minutes long. I've heard only excerpts on tv.
I did listen to the whole thing.
He clearly threatens to get on an airplane for ONE DAY to "straighten her out." What does that mean to an 11 yr old girl that's listening to that recording?? That they are going to a nice little Italian restaurant and have lunch while they discuss this over spaghetti and a coke? I don't think so!
He said he was going to explain exactly how angry he was. He never threatened her with anything more. I have certainly told my kids I was going to "straighten them out" or "set them straight." It is not a threat of physical violence. More along the lines of an attitude adjustment.
(Sherri, I totally agree with your comment at 3:21.)
If Ireland wanted to talk with her dad, she would have picked up the phone.
I have a feeling she didn't want to talk to him, so she didn't. If he's verbally abusive and negative about her mother, I wouldn't expect she wants to talk to him!
This is exactly the point. You can tell from the beginning of the message that he has gone out of his way to call her at that exact moment in time. Without knowing the backstory, I am guessing from his anger that there has been a great deal of discussion about him calling or not calling, and they have set up very specific times for him to call. He may have been accused of not calling enough, or calling at times when he knows she cannot talk or when he knows it is inconvenient or disruptive for her mother, and there may be something (in writing even!) that says exactly when he is supposed to stop whatever it is that he might be doing and call her. And she has turned the phone off. It is total passive agressive behavior.
The parent that bad-mouths the other parent in this type of situation is very often the loser. The child wants to hear nothing negative about either, as they love them both and usually want them back together. The minute you say negative things about the other parent, that child is driven to their defense almost naturally, even if what is being said is true.
That's why I wholeheartedly believe Alex Baldwin is the only problem here. If Kim were bad-mouthing (I hate that term) Alex to Ireland all the time, Ireland would naturally be driven to defend Alex and do everything in her 11 yr old power to be with
him.
This is not always the case. My cousin (mentioned in a previous post) has bent over backwards not to say anything bad about her ex, who admits he is almost exclusively to blame for the failure of the marriage. He started out nice and has gone downhill in his badmouthing of her mother, and she (the daughter) believes every word of it. The stuff she says to her mother is disgusting, and I have heard it with my own ears. It makes me sick, and some of the stuff AB said to Ireland totally applies to this child. I would hope to be able to hold my tongue, but who knows.
He is obviously an angry man with control issues, but Kim is equally to blame for playing it in the media, IMHO.
As far as Rosie goes: :razz:
ITA