You and Shelley sound much more gracious about him than I think I could be in regards to how he acts. I guess maybe there's just something gnawing at me about him I just can't shake. Of course, this is an observation from a distance as obviously I've never met him!
I think what bothers me is that he seems to have injected himself into this story, almost to a point where it seems like he's toying with people. His 'assistance' doesn't seem to be for good will or authentic, more like it's a game and he seems confrontational almost, but who am I to say. I swear I saw him today, looked back twice, but maybe because this was on my mind not even sure he's still in Victoria.
I think that the conversation you women are having right now is the truth of what happened to Emma, regretfully said. As a man who considers himself to have the ability to "read" people, I must say that I'm willing to bet JH may know exactly where Emma is. Shelley, I'm sure you don't want to comment much on what the Investigator is looking into but i really hope JH is picked apart.