I agree with you. the gas can thing has bothered me since the beginning.
http://blogs.discovery.com/criminal_report/files/george_anthony_burglary.pdf
here he reported 2 gas can at $20 and $50 worth of gas in the cans. That is $70 total not the $50 that everyone seems to be stuck on. He then later tells Greta that one was 2.5 gallons and one was about 1/5 gallons. The gas cans could possibly have costs that much but he bought them at the most expensive store he could find. I have 5 gallon ones from home depot and they only cost me about $7 each.
Next we have the gas. 2.5 gallons of gas @ 4.00 per gallons is $10. 1.5 gallons of gas @ 4.00 per gallon is $6. This comes to $16 not $50.
5 gallon gas cans would be about $20 per can. or about $40. If you fill them all the way to the top you might, might get $50 in gas in the 2 of them.
You don't use the most expensive gas in an old clunker or in your lawn mover but I figured using a fairly high gas price.
He either lied about the value or he lied about the size of the gas cans and the amount of gas in them.
The report does not say what size the cans were and he obviously didn't think it was important enough to give them the size but I can bet you money that they were a 2.5 gallon and a 1.5 gallon.
Weren't the gas cans found by the searchers 5 gallon cans. There might be your $50 worth of gas and $20 worth of gas cans.
He either lied to the police when he made the report or he lied to Greta. I wonder which it was and I wonder why.
Also if the cans came back to him on 6/24, why did he not call the police and cancel the report. It didn't have anything to do with the fact that it was Casey that took them because he could have just reported that they were found and cancel the report or if the police pressed the issue he could have refused to press charges.