Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023 #4

[Inthedetails]

I am anxious to know if Rex was at the sex party that ShannonGilbert was hired for. I am curious if you all believe all 11 victims are his. I don’t believe it for a second.

I don't think Rex got invited to parties. People don't like him.

If he had any connection with other johns, I think it was all online chatter. Once you met the guy, you wouldn't want to party with him, imo

jmo

 

[Inthedetails]

Thats exactly where my mind went. Said to my partner "bet he put his feet on the seat or had the sound on playing candy crush and the big man said something." People treat the LIRR like it's their living room and much worse.

Turn your video games down! I hate the sound of them, but you'd never know looking at me across the aisle. LOL!

 

[Friday13]

The cop said RH was mad about something he did. It is not specified, but my guess, being a NYC transit rider myself, is the cop put his feet on the seat, put his bag on an empty seat or something along those lines. Maybe he played music or talked too loud on his phone. If any of that is done on a crowded train, others can get irritated...but not to the point of follow-up afterwards! Most people shrug it off as inconsiderate and certainly don't care about it once they leave the train.

I don't know that's the correct scenario, but I picture something like that.

jmo

They aren’t saying much and IMHO, I wonder if RH knew the walls were closing in on him, that he was being watched and this guy got a little too close to him or his personal belongings and he freaked. RH took the train daily, he should be used to the circus that comes along for the ride.

You raise an excellent point, I just see it a different way.

 

[kittythehare]

A serial killer is defined by several things, among them is a “cooling off” or dormancy period and this what separates a serial killer from simply being a mass murderer.

Let’s say RH is responsible for EVERY victim associated with this case, here is a breakdown of his “dormant” periods:

Fire Island Jane Doe April 1996

*14 Months cool off

Peaches Doe June 1997
*toddler found 2011

*3 Years cool off

Valerie Mack (last seen spring/summer 2000)

*3 years cool off

Andre Isaac “Sugar Bear” November 2002 (discovered Dec 2002) many don’t believe this to be connected but at one point SCPD had him on their website as potential victim so putting him here)

*8 month cool off

Jessica Taylor July 2003

*4 Years cool off

Cherries Doe March 2007

*4 months cool off

Maureen Brainard Barnes - July 2007

*2 Years cool off

Melissa Barthelemy- July 2009

*11 months cool off

Megan Waterman - June 2010

*3 months cool off

Amber Costello - September 2010

**The only potential victim we don’t have an accurate date of death for is Asian Doe, found in 2011 is given a 5-10 postmortem interval**. They could have been killed anywhere from 2001-2006 (estimated)

could be lots of others in between?

Serial Murder | Federal Bureau of Investigation

www.fbi.gov

 

[indicolite22]

Would SW’s or Escorts readily agree to accompanying a new customer (or any customer) to his home?

SBM. His last known victim Amber Costello, whose pimp remembered his car, was involved in a ruse to take RH's money without providing service, so she likely would not go to his house voluntarily a day later.

 

[Ursamajr]

I am anxious to know if Rex was at the sex party that ShannonGilbert was hired for. I am curious if you all believe all 11 victims are his. I don’t believe it for a second.

There has been extensive discussion in here over the years about this. I don't think there is a collective yes or no on that. IMO and many others do not believe that SG came across RH that night. It might be the biggest coincidence of them all in this case. I suggest you look up the thread "Hawkshaws Grudge Report" and settle in. Knowing/thinking that SCPD might be involved in SGs case both before and after death and knowing/thinking RH only benefitted from that coverup... sounds like a real live conspiracy and thats because it absolutely is.

 

[Ann99]

SBM. His last known victim Amber Costello, whose pimp remembered his car, was involved in a ruse to take RH's money without providing service, so she likely would not go to his house voluntarily a day later.

I am mystified that she agreed to meet up with him at all…
After the encounter the day before with her “ boyfriend” crashing into the house…
Maybe RH insisted that his house was the only place he felt safe. And that she “ owed” him.

 

[Ursamajr]

Turn your video games down! I hate the sound of them, but you'd never know looking at me across the aisle. LOL!

haha! I have perfected the judgmental death glare.

 

[Friday13]

SBM. His last known victim Amber Costello, whose pimp remembered his car, was involved in a ruse to take RH's money without providing service, so she likely would not go to his house voluntarily a day later.

IMHO, he contacted her (via text) from another phone number the next day and didn’t give any indication it was the same person. I couldn’t imagine why shy would go off alone with him after what transpired the day before.

 

[Barbie619]

And digging in his yard late at night. If I did ONE of those things, the entire police force would be at my house. And my neighbors aren’t even that nosey. That is beyond odd behavior for most of Long Island. I can see that behavior out east, where homes are on acres+, but, not in this area.

Where I lived and on LI it should be illegal, it's just too densely populated, homes are too close together, etc. I moved from Northern New Jersey after 9/11 and moved to my summer home at the Jersey Shore. I owned nearly 1 acre there and it wasn't allowed there either. It is weird that he was doing it and getting away with it like he did.

 

[minazoe]

I am anxious to know if Rex was at the sex party that ShannonGilbert was hired for. I am curious if you all believe all 11 victims are his. I don’t believe it for a second.

I believe it..still PH is hinky as H! mOO

 

[citizen_sleuth]

Gilgo Beach Murders: Investigators say killings may have happened in Rex Heuermann's home

Detectives are now looking into whether any of the Gilgo Beach murders may have been carried out at the family home of suspect Rex Heuermann.

abc7ny.com

<snipped & BBM>
Detectives are now looking into whether any of the Gilgo Beach murders may have been carried out at the family home of suspect Rex Heuermann.

Evidence technicians will be scouring Heuermann's Massapequa Park home for an eighth consecutive day on Friday. The search of the house is expected to last at least another two days, a law enforcement official familiar with the search told ABC News.

[...]

Two of Heuermann's Chevy Avalanches are also being examined for evidence.

The first, a newer black Avalanche, was towed from his Massapequa Park property Friday. The second, an older green Avalanche, was recovered on his property in South Carolina and towed by a New York State Police flatbed to New York, where it arrived at the Suffolk County Crime Lab at 4 a.m. Wednesday.

Harrison says Heuermann gave the green Avalanche to his brother, who lives in South Carolina, around 2015. Harrison says Heuermann owned the vehicle at the time of the murders of three women whose bodies were dumped along Gilgo Beach.

 

[Inthedetails]

I am mystified that she agreed to meet up with him at all…
After the encounter the day before with her “ boyfriend” crashing into the house…
Maybe RH insisted that his house was the only place he felt safe. And that she “ owed” him.

Yes, that's how I can picture it. "This could've been nice, but you weren't nice to me. You owe me and now it's not going to be so nice."

jmo

 

[Kikalina]

Yes, that's how I can picture it. "This could've been nice, but you weren't nice to me. You owe me and now it's not going to be so nice."

jmo

I believe he offered her a decent amount of money, more than she typically required. That is why she decided to go. Let me see if I can find the news source.

Edited to add msm source:

Wife, 2 Children of Long Island Serial Killer Suspect Rex Heuermann Were Out of State When Women Were Killed

Rex Heuermann is accused of murdering Amber Costello, Megan Waterman and Melissa Barthelemy

people.com

 

[Inthedetails]

I believe he offered her a decent amount of money. That is why she decided to go. Let me see if I can find the news source.

That would do it too! He could certainly offer more money, knowing he never intended to give her any.

I thought he told her he should get a "credit" after the angry-boyfriend ruse.

jmo

 

[minazoe]

I believe he offered her a decent amount of money. That is why she decided to go. Let me see if I can find the news source.

Edited to add msm source:

Wife, 2 Children of Long Island Serial Killer Suspect Rex Heuermann Were Out of State When Women Were Killed

Rex Heuermann is accused of murdering Amber Costello, Megan Waterman and Melissa Barthelemy

people.com

yes! didn't she say this was going to pay big $$$? I remember that, from the interview with her roommate. mOO

 

[Kikalina]

yes! didn't she say this was going to pay big $$$? I remember that, from the interview with her roommate. mOO

Yes. It was more than she usually “charged” which is what enticed her

 

[Not a Belle]

I wish the media would ignore Rader. That would be worse than imprisonment for him.

 

[Nocturnal 911]

I wonder if he was burning evidence. I personally have a paper shredder, but with him he probably had much more than paper to get rid of. Creepy.

Probably getting rid of garbage with DNA. To keep it off the curb. Researching the murders & true crime in general would educate him on genetic genealogy & DNA catching up.

 

[minazoe]

these poor girls..I feel like he is the type where everything seems like nice chit chat everything seems fairly happy and then out of the blue he punches you in the face..I also can see him tricking these girls into bondage situations...ala Gacy..I think he is way more Gacy than a Rader type..mOO