OH - Pike County: 8 People From One Family Dead As Police Hunt For Killer(s) #36 *Arrests*

[CIA Team Member]

I am certain in my heart that JW fired the shots into HHG. That is why she was shot five times in the face. Those bullets were meant for her brother CG. All that rage, hate and jealousy of CG for being with HR went into those five shots. None of the others BW, GW or AW would have had that kind of rage and hate toward HHG because of her brothers affair with HR. Just JW. He was the one who was wronged by HHG's brother CG.

I am also certain that JW fired the shots into HR. Only two shots, almost lovingly done in relation to all the others.

After all that face twitching every time CR2 was mentioned leads me to think he also killed CR and regrets having to do it.

JMO

IMO, you'll see the "sniffling" (face twitching ??) in those who have snorted drugs, etc. Great deal of damage done to ones nose/nasal system.

 

[CIA Team Member]

I am certain in my heart that JW fired the shots into HHG. That is why she was shot five times in the face. Those bullets were meant for her brother CG. All that rage, hate and jealousy of CG for being with HR went into those five shots. None of the others BW, GW or AW would have had that kind of rage and hate toward HHG because of her brothers affair with HR. Just JW. He was the one who was wronged by HHG's brother CG.

I am also certain that JW fired the shots into HR. Only two shots, almost lovingly done in relation to all the others.

After all that face twitching every time CR2 was mentioned leads me to think he also killed CR and regrets having to do it.

JMO

IMO, I believe we'll learn this was entirely AW's idea, either egged on by FW or in tangent with each other. GWIV will be the one to cooperate/plead. Again, JMO

 

[rsd1200]

I put this on LE. They were the ones throwing out. Cartels, major grow operations, cockfighting etc. Which apparently made people look down on victims. Still the media should do a little research. This AM when I was looking for live feed. I ran across a Kentucky station that changed Jake W name to Luke halfway in article and had a picture of his brother as Jake.

Those things, except for the weed, and cousin DS reported that to the DM in short order, were all found on very public FB's, within hours after hearing of the murders. I read their FBs. Screenshotted them even. Their neighbors had to know too. The chickens were there for years, the traffic to and from CR1's had to be telling, the security and the dogs... There were people on the street who even made comments about the Rs and their lifestyle, to reporters. I'm not the most trusting of LE, at all, but I can't lay it all at their feet. The Rs and Ms were a family who were very close, and would defend one another's rep, they sold weed to enjoy their hobbies, and lived their lives out loud. I've no issue with weed, I use it myself, but they were rough around the edges, like myself, and folks I know. They stopped giving interviews because of the way, as GR's daddy said, that the media "mishandled" things. The media took this to extreme proportions, and there was DS in his rebel flag hat, in the Dally Mail, don't you think they didn't know what they were doing when they put him front and center, in that hat? And the backlash was brutal. The media bears the brunt, but it appears their family, friends and neighbors are hanging with them, and in the end, that is all that matters.

 

[Gracie55]

I had trouble hearing what was being said so I appreciate those who contributed the information I missed. During the hearing I had to stay busy observing other things. I noticed that Jake's hair tells a tale on him... he's either burned it using a hot comb too many times (no) or else ... he's been doing some of that very potent "speedy" stuff up until very recently (yes) imo. Nothing like speed to turn the hair into hay, imo.
I had the irrational thought for just a moment that I wished the murdered family members could be there, too, to see the love and support and justice for their murders being done... but then, of course, just wishing none of it... not one moment of it had ever happened so there would be no arrests and hearings or trials at all. The Rhodens would be at their jobs working today... and wouldn't Chris Jr have just graduated from high school last June?

I noticed the hair as well, frizzy at the roots. Head lice treatments in jail? It looks burned.
JW sure looks little like his family IMO.
LM looked stoic but sad. There were many supporters, I'd guess friends or family, but somehow he touched me, maybe his self control.
Poor Geneva. I'm glad she's able to be there. I try and fail to imagine losing all she did.
I'm afraid I couldn't have pulled it off with their class. I might have been firing off too many bolts of lightening with my eyes.

 

[almond]

i agree his attorney has told him to show no emotion.

Myland I owe you an apology for questioning who you are, and why you are here. My sincerest apology.

 

[Normrock]

Ok lets guess.
Hair- That man is using jail hand soap to wash hair.
Circles under eyes little sleep.
The look in eyes. He is gobsmacked to be here.

 

[KentuckyMama]

JMO but I heard or saw nothing today to prove guilt or innocence, I still have to wait for evidence. I do feel extremely sorry for families of Rhodens, Gilley, and Manleys. I can’t imagine their pain.

You wouldn't. Today was just an arraignment hearing. No evidence was shown for or against on either side. Hopefully we will get to see the trials but I wouldn't be surprised if cameras were not allowed in during the proceedings.
I agree about the families. I wonder how many of them felt the Ws were the murderers all along. I don't think the arrests shocked LM. He called it from the very start.

 

[Jennifer17]

Ok lets guess.
Hair- That man is using jail hand soap to wash hair.
Circles under eyes little sleep.
The look in eyes. He is gobsmacked to be here.

He could be a girl without the facial hair.

 

[Normrock]

Those things, except for the weed, and cousin DS reported that to the DM in short order, were all found on very public FB's, within hours after hearing of the murders. I read their FBs. Screenshotted them even. Their neighbors had to know too. The chickens were there for years, the traffic to and from CR1's had to be telling, the security and the dogs... There were people on the street who even made comments about the Rs and their lifestyle, to reporters. I'm not the most trusting of LE, at all, but I can't lay it all at their feet. The Rs and Ms were a family who were very close, and would defend one another's rep, they sold weed to enjoy their hobbies, and lived their lives out loud. I've no issue with weed, I use it myself, but they were rough around the edges, like myself, and folks I know. They stopped giving interviews because of the way, as GR's daddy said, that the media "mishandled" things. The media took this to extreme proportions, and there was DS in his rebel flag hat, in the Dally Mail, don't you think they didn't know what they were doing when they put him front and center, in that hat? And the backlash was brutal. The media bears the brunt, but it appears their family, friends and neighbors are hanging with them, and in the end, that is all that matters.[/QUOTE

I didn't know any of that since I'm not anywhere near that area. I only get what media sends out and what I saw at first was cartels, major grows etc. which went worldwide. Thanks for heads up.

 

[Betty P]

JMO but I heard or saw nothing today to prove guilt or innocence, I still have to wait for evidence. I do feel extremely sorry for families of Rhodens, Gilley, and Manleys. I can’t imagine their pain.

Well, today consisted mostly of reading the indictment charges against JW and his plea of "not guilty". Nothing new was expected, other than his plea. There isn't enough information revealed at this point for anyone to form an opinion. The evidence will come later.

 

[pepper 34]

I think that he is inferring that GW3 would not have the skills to plan such an elaborate crime. I don't think GW3 was the main planner, but, with that said, I know several folks who never graduated h.s., but who have thriving businesses, and are quite comfortable, financially.

No doubt you're correct. At least it makes sense that the attorney is thinking that way. But, it would get nowhere with me if the prosecution reminded me that planning the murders takes no more talent than all the planning that goes into a good hunting trip in the woods. They had months to study every last detail of the Rhoden's lives. They observed and stalked and had an inside "mole" named Jake. If they filmed one or more of the Rhodens by camera... well, trail cams are used in hunting, too. Where does the animal eat, sleep, drink water, when does it eat, sleep... where are it's trails and when does it travel them and what do it's tracks look like? (special shoes) That's what the hunter does. He knows his prey completely and he knows when it's at it's most vulnerable... when it has no idea it's being stalked. Nothing could be more vulnerable than people sleeping at night. None of this information is anything a hunter doesn't know.

The electronic stuff is all on the internet for sale and with companies and customers more than happy to tell people exactly what each item does, how to set it up and how to get top performance from the product.

 

[rsd1200]

Ok lets guess.
Hair- That man is using jail hand soap to wash hair.
Circles under eyes little sleep.
The look in eyes. He is gobsmacked to be here.

That is the look of a terrified young man, too terrified to got to sleep, but cries himself to sleep, very quietly, when he does finally grab a few Zsss.

 

[Myland]

You wouldn't. Today was just an arraignment hearing. No evidence was shown for or against on either side. Hopefully we will get to see the trials but I wouldn't be surprised if cameras were not allowed in during the proceedings.
I agree about the families. I wonder how many of them felt the Ws were the murderers all along. I don't think the arrests shocked LM. He called it from the very start.

I know LM said custody in first few days, but did he say the custody of Sw? Truly looking for the answer not asking for another reason in case some may wonder.

 

[GordianKnot]

He could be a girl without the facial hair.

Jen17, great observation...here's hoping his prison cellmate reaches the same conclusion (crossing fingers).

 

[KentuckyMama]

I know LM said custody in first few days, but did he say the custody of Sw? Truly looking for the answer not asking for another reason in case some may wonder.

Yes. He said it during an interview very early on and during another interview on the day of the arrests. There was no other custody issues than I'm aware of in that family at the time of the murders.
Here is the recent interview.
Child custody battle was factor in Rhoden family massacre

 

[KentuckyMama]

Delete please

 

[rsd1200]

No doubt you're correct. At least it makes sense that the attorney is thinking that way. But, it would get nowhere with me if the prosecution reminded me that planning the murders takes no more talent than all the planning that goes into a good hunting trip in the woods. They had months to study every last detail of the Rhoden's lives. They observed and stalked and had an inside "mole" named Jake. If they filmed one or more of the Rhodens by camera... well, trail cams are used in hunting, too. Where does the animal eat, sleep, drink water, when does it eat, sleep... where are it's trails and when does it travel them and what do it's tracks look like? (special shoes) That's what the hunter does. He knows his prey completely and he knows when it's at it's most vulnerable... when it has no idea it's being stalked. Nothing could be more vulnerable than people sleeping at night. None of this information is anything a hunter doesn't know.

The electronic stuff is all on the internet for sale and with companies and customers more than happy to tell people exactly what each item does, how to set it up and how to get top performance from the product.

Oh, we can see by the Peterson Rd place that they are excellent hunters. I agree, it takes a lot of skill. They bagged wild boar and they are not an easy take. Earlier on, I'd theorized that this could have been done by avid hunters. Just change up the prey. I knew they had to know this family inside and out. That, was one thing, that I was right about.

 

[rsd1200]

I know LM said custody in first few days, but did he say the custody of Sw? Truly looking for the answer not asking for another reason in case some may wonder.

I'd say the infant was included if it had turned out to be JW's, just by the comment JW made about hoping the two were sisters. Fwiw, he was also very upset that LE was not taking him seriously over another matter, that he'd made them aware of. I don't think that he truly knew, for sure, until AK, and after the GJ w/ JM.

 

[Myland]

I'd say the infant was included if it had turned out to be JW's, just by the comment JW made about hoping the two were sisters. Fwiw, he was also very upset that LE was not taking him seriously over another matter, that he'd made them aware of. I don't think that he truly knew, for sure, until AK, and after the GJ w/ JM.

Jmo but I had recently seen there was fighting between HR and FR over not letting CG see the newborn on the day she was born. I was wondering then was LM referring to SW or the newborn and we all just assumed he meant SW on the first interview LM did.

 

[Myland]

Jmo but I had recently seen there was fighting between HR and FR over not letting CG see the newborn on the day she was born. I was wondering then was LM referring to SW or the newborn and we all just assumed he meant SW on the first interview LM did.

But to make it clear I don’t think CG did the murders at all