Identified! PA - White Haven, 'Beth Doe' & Unborn Baby 169UFPA, 16-22, Dec'76 - #2 - Evelyn Colon

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
I came across this guy, its just a fragment of the whole story, http://murderpedia.org/male.E/e/einhorn-ira.htm well known person, killed his former girlfriend in 1977, when she returned after leaving him, to pick up her belongings, was violent against her and other girlfriends before and what about the trunk story....foam, newspapers....hmmm. He was from German descent and fled to France and married again. I didn't have time to dig out, the complete time line...could Beth Doe have run into him...while his girlfriend (for 5 years) had left him and stayed in New York. Maybe we could investigate the name Ben Moore, or his real name.....or his French name...and find any connection with Beth? Just a brainwave.... Still no explanation for cutting of nose, ears and breasts...

Peace, Love and Murder: The Ira EinhornStory
By Juan Hann Ng -CrimeandInvestigation.co.uk
For two decades, guru Ira Einhorn was onthe run as a fugitive. Nicknamed 'The Unicorn', he brutally murdered his loverHolly Maddux.
Ira Samuel Einhorn, nicknamed the‘Unicorn’ as his surname translates to ‘one horn’ in German, spent 16 years onthe run after murdering his girlfriend Helen ‘Holly’ Maddux in 1977 inPhiladelphia, America. Einhorn’s case is unique in that while his crime was agrisly one, it is often overshadowed by the events leading up to hisimprisonment, and is regularly cited as an example of the conceptualdifferences between the American and continental European legal systems. TheAmerican murderer became a cause celebre for human rights in France where hewas initially arrested.
Profile
Einhorn was born into a middle-classJewish family but developed into a bona fide left wing radical by thetime he was in his twenties. He was a symbol and a prominent figurehead of theyouth-driven movement in the sixties that stood in opposition to America’sinvolvement in the Vietnam War. Instantly recognisable as ‘Philadelphia’s headhippie’, he was a large burly man with electric blue eyes and an unkempt beard,and he seldom washed or bathed.
However, he was a master of rhetoric andhe had networking skills that drew many important and famous people to thecause of freedom and peace that he preached. The self-styled ‘Prince of FlowerPower’ and ‘Guru of Peace and Love’ was revered and admired by many of theleading intellectuals of Philadelphia and America. A brilliant student at theUniversity of Pennsylvania, he counted as friends many of the authors of theBeat generation, such as Allen Ginsberg and Jack Kerouac; he hobnobbed withcelebrities including Isaac Asimov, Peter Gabriel and Uri Geller; and hung outwith the Yippie (Youth International Party) crowd, including their foundersAbbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin. Pot-smoking, LSD-popping, free-loving Einhornwas the toast of Philadelphia.
Strangely, he also endeared himself to thecorporate set, who were entranced by his convincing predictions of futuretrends of anything from computer science to quantum physics to New Agemanagement. He was intelligent, a voracious reader and his ability to influencepeople was magnetic. He sold blueprints of the future to Fortune 500 companyCEOs, convincing them that their money could save the world through ecologicalawareness. He was a speaker at the inaugural 1970 Earth Day rally in Philadelphiaand was reportedly its creator, although its organisers disputed this claim. In1977, he even held a fellowship at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government.
Einhorn had been going out with HollyMaddux, his beautiful and gracefully delicate girlfriend, for five years whenshe disappeared in 1977. Originally from Tyler, Texas, Maddux was a blue-eyedformer cheerleader, had been a brilliant student at Bryn Mawr College and hadthen turned her energies to the women’s liberation movement. She was drawn to Einhornas one of the political icons of their day. However, although an advocate of peace andnon-violence, the hulking Einhorn treated her poorly, as he had with previousgirlfriends. His behaviour extended to physical abuse, smashing a soft drinkbottle on one girlfriend’s head and even attempting to strangle another.
Tiring of his violence, Maddux moved toNew York where she began a relationship with a kind and gentle man named SaulLapidus. She called Einhorn from New York to sever their relationship. He flewinto a temper and commanded her to return to Philadelphia to collect herbelongings, which he threatened to throw out into the street. Maddux left forPhiladelphia on 9th September 1977 and was never seen alive again.
The crimes
It is speculated that Maddux was murdered on or around the9th or 10th of September 1977, when she returned to the apartment sheshared with Einhorn on Race Street. No one except her family noticed Maddux’sabsence and they became apprehensive at her continued silence. Her mother’sbirthday had come and gone without a call from Maddux, who was normally aconsiderate and attentive daughter.
The family notified the police. Einhornwas cursorily questioned but upon his claims of ignorance, was left alone.Dissatisfied with the police’s efforts, the Maddux family hired two privatedetectives to investigate the girl’s disappearance. In the meantime, Einhorncontinued with his life, embarking on speaking tours and taking a semester-longfellowship at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government.
However by 1979, the private investigatorshad pieced together enough circumstantial evidence to give the police enoughprobable cause to obtain a search warrant for Einhorn’s apartment. The evidenceincluded the fact that Einhorn had requested help from friends to dispose of atrunk containing what he said were “secret documents”; there had been Einhorn’snon-cooperation with police investigators; and a putrid and rancid brown liquidhad been leaking through Einhorn’s floorboards into the kitchen of theneighbours below.
The arrest
Detective Mike Chitwood led the search ofEinhorn’s apartment on 28th March 1979, almost 20 months after Maddux had gonemissing. In a wardrobe, Chitwood found Maddux’s suitcase, handbag, driver’slicence and social security card. In the same wardrobe, he also found Maddux’s body in a trunk, packedin styrofoam, air fresheners and newspapers. Her decomposing body waspartially mummified and the remains weighed only 37 pounds.
A post-mortem revealed that Maddux hadsuffered trauma to the head and her skull was smashed in several places as aresult. However, the position of the body and size of the trunk meant that shehad actually been alive and semi-conscious when placed in the trunk and haddied trying to claw her way out. Upon his arrest, Einhorn reportedly shruggedindifferently and said, “You found what you found”. He was charged with murder,as Pennsylvania has no degrees of murder
Einhorn was represented by the notoriousdefence attorney Arlen Specter. Later a Senator, he served on the infamousWarren Commission and was the author of the ‘single assassin/crazy bullettheory’ used to explain the assassination of John F Kennedy. Specter arguedsuccessfully at the bail hearing on 3rd April 1979 for bail to be set at the strangelylow sum of $40 000, of which only 10% had to be paid in cash to secure therelease of the bailor.
The bail hearing in itself was abnormal,as it was unheard of for bail to be granted in murder cases. While Einhorn’sfriends in high places might not have influenced the bail hearing or the amountof bail itself, they certainly did put up the money for his release. BarbaraBronfman, a Montreal socialite who had married into a wealthy distilleryfamily, paid Einhorn’s bail.
Still vociferously protesting hisinnocence, Einhorn was released onto the streets. He told anyone and everyonethat he would clear his name, claiming it was a conspiracy by the CIA or FBI,who wanted to discredit him and halt his political activities. Then, on 21stJanuary 1981, Einhorn skipped bail on the eve of the pre-trial hearing anddisappeared, probably to Europe. Thus began the most determined internationalpursuit of a fugitive since the Israeli Mossad’s hunt, capture and cross-borderkidnapping of Nazi war criminal Adolf Eichmann.
Conducting the manhunt was AssistantDistrict Attorney Richard DiBenedetto, who, through Einhorn’s 60 handwrittenjournals, knew his prey better than anyone else. In 1985, Einhorn was traced toDublin, Ireland, where he was living under the name of Ben Moore. However,there were no extradition papers in effect and Einhorn fled Dublin after thealert. From there, he probably travelled throughout the United Kingdom,crossing the English Channel at some point, to enter continental Europe. In1993, the unprecedented step, in Philadelphia at least, was taken to tryEinhorn in absentia, a hugely significant development that would laterbe exploited by Einhorn. He was convicted of murder and sentenced to lifeimprisonment.
Circa 1994, DiBenedetto learned thatEinhorn’s benefactor, Barbara Bronfman, had been financing his flight from hishunters. However she had a change of heart, to one in the belief in Einhorn’sguilt, and she provided DiBenedetto with the Stockholm address where Einhornwas residing. The address turned up one Annika Flodin, who disclaimed allknowledge of Einhorn, saying that she knew him as Ben Moore, and that she hadno idea where he was. When Flodin subsequently disappeared, investigators ranher name through Interpol and found that she had relocated to France andmarried Einhorn, who was then known under the moniker of Eugene Mallon.
On 13th June 1997, DiBenedetto and his menarrested Einhorn in a converted millhouse outside Champagne-Mouton, a beautifulvillage in the French countryside near Cognac.
 
rbbm.
Removing the ears and nose to prevent identification seems like something someone would do if the victim's identity would lead right to the perp. but the mutilation of her chest area , does not make sense unless Beth had a tattooed chest or other anomaly, imo.
Or the perp was really, really angry and jealous.
If this was a sexually motivated crime by a stranger, the removal of chest area might be part of the nastiness.
imo, speculation.

http://www.doenetwork.org/cases/169ufpa.html

Some serial killers take body parts as souvenirs :sick: So it might not even be for identification.
 
I noticed a post above said nj was 12 hours from white haven. It was only a few hours. I lived near there in 1976 and just recently took my mom there to visit the areas she grew up in. Not far from the poconos. Lots of young people made their way there to work at the ski resorts. Also, lots of truck stops up that way. I believe nj plates did have 6 numbers. Plates were an off white with black.numbers I'll try to find a pic of a PA plate from that time. I believe they were navy blue with orange and said keystone state.
 
The newspaper found in one of the suitcases was from new york..which neighbors PA. Maybe she was from there.
I wonder if the WSR has any significance to NY?
 
Re: the possible connection to Bethlehem

In the 1970's Bethlehem wasn't the somewhat sleepy academic town it is today. It was a busy bustling steel town with a large immigrant population working in the mills.
 
The killer went to great lengths to hide her identity which leads me to believe she is easy to identify. Im just wondering without her actual ears and nose, how easy it is to reconstruct what she actually looked like.
 
The killer went to great lengths to hide her identity which leads me to believe she is easy to identify. Im just wondering without her actual ears and nose, how easy it is to reconstruct what she actually looked like.

I wonder if she had multiple ear piercings? A nose ring?

I know this has been brought up before, but what about a rhinoplasty? Would her killer cut off her nose to hide the fact that she had had a nose job done?

I also wonder if she had a birthmark and/or scar on her ears/nose.
 
Strange quest..but does anyone know if the wsr and series of numbers were ever photographed? I would be curious to see it. I think its a valuable piece of the puzzle, esp since the estimated time was hrs prior to death.
 
Strange quest..but does anyone know if the wsr and series of numbers were ever photographed? I would be curious to see it. I think its a valuable piece of the puzzle, esp since the estimated time was hrs prior to death.

This question was addressed in the first Beth Doe thread. (October 2005) I am very sure that photos were taken of the notations but when I first approached PSP about them years ago, there were no such photos in her file. I have my own thoughts on where they went, based on the research I've done but to state my thoughts really would be only speculation.

Here's the link to the subject in the first thread but I'll copy and paste my response here. To answer the unasked question - yes, I do have a photo of her hand.

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-amp-Unborn-Baby-169UFPA-16-22-Dec-76-1/page4

LButler
user-offline.png
Registered User

Wow, a response already!! But, not great news. As follows:


Dear Lisa:

Unfortunately, there is no photo of Carbon County Jane Doe's hand (with the writing intact) in her case file. The one photo of her hand that exists is of very good quality, excellent resolution, to the point where the grooves and whorls of her palm are clearly evident. The fingers are smudged with black from where they took her fingerprints, which tells me that the photo was taken after her arm/hand were cleaned, erasing all traces of the notations. I haven't posted the photo on my web site since there just isn't anything there that would help in trying to identify her.

I wish there were, since I also think that the writing could be key. I also think that they are some kind of shorthand for a destination. Route 437 is just west of White Haven. Travel 11 miles north and you get to PA-309 N / WILKES BARRE-HAZELTON HWY. Could WSR actually be WSB? Short for Wilkes-Barre?

I've been reading the thread on Websleuths. With the 29th Anniversary of Jane Doe's murder quickly approaching, I'm truly grateful for the renewed interest in her case. While so many are caught up in the Christmas rush, there will be a lot of us remembering the young mother and her child that most of the world has forgotten.

Sorry I couldn't be more helpful. But keep trying. The more eyes looking, the better chance we have of finding out who she is.

Best wishes for a happy and safe Holiday Season.

Nancy Monahan
Pennsylvania Missing Persons
www.pennsylvaniamissing.com
 
Thank you ccjd!
I would be interested in seeing that photo...
 
I've driven over the bridge that Beth Doe was dropped from several times between yesterday and today, and it reminds me of her each time I pass over.

Hoping that she is identified soon.
 
9 Rule-OutS :: Aerial View, & Grave Coordinates

https://identifyus.org/en/cases/8913:

Rule-Out/ExclusionS:

Annastaes Banitskas - Born 1959
Iris Brown - 1948 - Vermont
Valarie Cuccia - 1953 - New York
Teresa Fittin - 1957 - Florida
Trenny Gibson - 1960 - Tennessee
Anna Leatherwood - 1921 - Tennessee
Georgia Nolan - 1943 - Kentucky
Patricia Seelbaugh - 1956 - Pennsylvania
Denise Sheehy - 1954 - New York


https://identifyus.org/en/cases/full_report/8913

Map, Aerial View, and Grave Coordinates:

https://listsofjohn.com/mapf?lat=40.9861&lon=-75.7463&z=20&t=h&d=y

2370 Laurytown Rd., Weatherly, PA, 18255

Graves are on the NorthWest side of the road.

PA State Route 4012, Segment 170

Look For:

170
SR4012

For GPS Users & GeoCachers:

N 40 59.155 -- W-075 44.804, or,
N 40 59 09.3 -- W-075 44 48.2, or
N 40.98591 -- W-075.74673, or

UTM 18T --- 0437184 E -- 4537461 N

All Datums - WGS-84

Her for-now Grave is in the
Eastern Corner of the Cemetery, in the 2nd Row.

A Tranquil, Country Setting,
On The Site Of The Former County Home.
 
Not sure if this mp has been suggested yet..
http://www.nampn.org/cases/green_helen.html
green_helen.jpeg
Above Images: Green


[TABLE="align: center"]
[/TABLE]
Vital Statistics at Time of Disappearance


Missing Since: January 1, 1971 from Chicago, Cook County, Illinois

Classification: Endangered Missing

Date Of Birth: January 20, 1958

Age: 13

Height: 5'0"

Weight: 100 lbs.

Hair Color: Brown

Eye Color: Brown

Race: White

Gender: Female

Distinguishing Characteristics: Helen is of Greek Ancestry.


Details of Disappearance
Helen Green was last seen in Southside Chicago in 1971. She ran away from home and was never seen again.

 
Roselvr knows Helen Greens family and her story...maybe it is good thing to talk to Roselvr
 
I noticed her Wiki page says she was sexually assaulted, did I miss that info?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beth_Doe

Personally, I don't think her killer kept her body parts as a trophy. I don't think he was a serial killer, or would do that. I kind of think he did have another suitcase with her nose, breasts, and ears in it, and that one actually did land in the river. Although that wouldn't explain why he'd bother to cut off those parts if they'd ID her, so I could very well be wrong. Not sure.

I wonder if she and her killer were living in Tennessee, and he got a job in northern New Jersey and he was there checking the area out a couple months before, explaining the newspaper. Either she didn't want to leave Tennessee and that angered him, or he saw New Jersey as the perfect opportunity to get rid of her. Although, it seems more likely that they had gone to vacation/visited family in New Jersey, kept the newspaper for some reason, and went back south, where she might've been murdered. Then he drove to Pennsylvania to drop off her remains? Kind of reminds me of Bradford Bishop Jr. killing his family in Bethesda, Maryland and driving them remains six hours to North Carolina.

Sorry, my thoughts are all over the place :blushing:
 
There are some uid cases where they found human material in freezers....I can't recall that immediately...sorry....I could look into that..
 
Yes, there are killers who keep body parts as trophies. And whatever you do, don't google cannibal killers.

Sent from my SM-T560NU using Tapatalk
 
Does anyone know why they call this particular doe "Beth"? I have a reason for asking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
250
Guests online
334
Total visitors
584

Forum statistics

Threads
608,670
Messages
18,243,715
Members
234,418
Latest member
May4th to Feb13th Blessed
Back
Top