writer7
New Member
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2010
- Messages
- 1,023
- Reaction score
- 28
Lurker here! I have been reading this forum forever and wanted to address something that keeps running me around in circles. I hope it makes sense. I firmly believe JA is guilty. I look at Travis's picture and I get so mad and sad. (That's putting it mildly) I believe in the DP for killers such as these but I don't like the endless appeals process. With that said, since there was so much left out of the thousands of emails, texts, IM's, etc, how do we know for sure that some of what JA said about Travis is true? Everyone on this board is so absolutely sure about her lying and I do to; that is why I am so confused. How can she so emphatically state that the stuff is true without providing evidence? I am not one of those people that can watch JA in that courtroom and know that she is lying, seething, happy, sad. I am not made that way. How can you people read that about her? It is fascinating to read but I cannot see what you see.
So my question to anyone that wants to answer, how do you know? Give an example of something that has gone on that gives you that 100% feeling that she is lying. I have watched this trial for most of it, causing my mind to spin in every direction and that is why this post is so messed up. In one of her interviews, she says something about if you don't abuse me why should you be afraid....(paraphrasing), she says it with such conviction, how do we know that it is a lie what she has said about TA?
If you think I am approaching insanity, well, you are right. But I do wish someone could understand what I am asking and answer me.
Thank you to all WS people. You are absolutely the best. Travis and the Alexander family are so blessed to have you.
She tells more than one version of a story during the same trial, and the versions are in conflict with each other. That's the biggest sign that she's a liar
So the rest of it comes down to: did someone else say something different than her story? Believe the other person for a better probability of getting the truth. Does she have a motive to lie in whatever she is answering? Then she may be lying. Sometimes she 'probably is' lying (a lot of factors coming together on the same point).
A lot of her stories just ring false, too. Nobody gets "spun around" that much by men