LadyL
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 29, 2009
- Messages
- 27,879
- Reaction score
- 73,700
I had never heard of Pastor Martin Niemoller until two weeks ago when my daughter had a weekly History test andWhen Hitler annexed Austria WWII began, even though there was no shooting because the soon-to-be Allies appeased and rationalized and did nothing.
When Hitler took over the Sudetenland it was the same.
Not until 1939 did the shooting start.
Just my opinion, WWIII has already begun. Putin’s goal is his fantasy of a new Russian/USSR empire. There are only two ways to stop him 1) the Russian people rebel or 2) the West militarily puts a stop to it, a scary thought for sure.
“First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”
Martin Niemoller
Pastor
Nazi Germany
I question your first link, it appears to have been spread by Tass, the Russian news agency. <modsnip - link to Tass not permitted>This is one lay what led Russia to invade:
West made mistake in promising Ukraine NATO membership: Borrell
This professor called it and blamed the West in 2015 after Russia invaded Crimea:
He explains the situation very clearly. I’m not sure I agree with all he says. But at this point I’m thinking the best bet is if Ukraine agreed not to join NATO/EU with conditions. Maybe Putin will leave.
When Hitler annexed Austria WWII began, even though there was no shooting because the soon-to-be Allies appeased and rationalized and did nothing.
When Hitler took over the Sudetenland it was the same.
Not until 1939 did the shooting start.
Just my opinion, WWIII has already begun. Putin’s goal is his fantasy of a new Russian/USSR empire. There are only two ways to stop him 1) the Russian people rebel or 2) the West militarily puts a stop to it, a scary thought for sure.
“First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”
Martin Niemoller
Pastor
Nazi Germany
I question your first link, it appears to have been spread by Tass, the Russian news agency. <modnsip -link to TASS not permitted>
The interview with Borrell was on French TV, in French. Ukraine : "Poutine mérite d’être jugé", déclare sur LCI le chef de la diplomatie européenne, Josep Borrell
There's no indication in the summary of the interview that he talked about 'mistakes'
(I can read French but not willing to listen to an 8 min interview).
But really, why would the head of the EU foreign policy, who is working extemely closely with the US and NATO during this crisis, make wild comments on live TV about past "mistakes", exactly what Putin wants to hear?
JMO
@Reevellp
Grim development from one of the southern Ukrainian cities under Russian occupation. Ukraine says the mayor of Melitopol, Ivan Fedorov, who had insisted the city remained Ukrainian, was kidnapped by Russian forces today- CCTV shows him led away. He has been charged with terrorism
https://twitter.com/Reevellp/status/1502427476194123779?s=20&t=Qs7I2yhvXoDgPTUwnKKXsg
I listened to the beginning...of course, he's an academic, it's his job to talk about the world in terms of abstract ideas.Thank you for vetting that. I certainly don’t want to spread Russian propaganda.
I know it’s long, but could you maybe watch some of the YouTube video I posted? Or respond to the comments I made about it in my last post?
Maybe. But maybe it’s not about imperialism. I know it’s long but the YouTube video I posted above gives a different take on the causes of this. And thus the ways to end it. I’m not sure. But it does match what I learned in history class a couple decades ago about the balance of power before each past world war. When the balance between differing factions becomes weighted one direction, or appears to be, it causes aggression.
What that professor said in the video I posted that made some sense is he talked about the Monroe Doctrine and what would happen if China forged an alliance with Canada and Mexico and thus began installing military sites in those nations, what would our response be?
Inviting Ukraine and Georgia to join NATO was that sort of threat to Russia, he says.
Of course there’s a huge difference- Russia isn’t a democracy. But we did nothing when he invaded and took Crimea. We did nothing when he aided the maniac in Syria in order to prevent democracy from spreading there. He invaded Georgia and committed gross human rights against the people there just as he did in Crimea and Syria We did nothing.
So why would the West step in now?
I don’t know. It seems hopeless to me. We are just sitting here watching a nation and it’s people be destroyed.
I understand your point, I’m not so sure I agree with the professor. It seems he’s drawn it a little too black and white. I totally agree we have allowed Putin to get away with way too much.
I do think the West has always had a hard time understanding Russia and their obsession with their security. If you look at their open geography and history of being invaded by hoards from east and west over the centuries you kinda get it. We certainly don’t have that problem being secured by large oceans etc.
At some point though, countries need to let their histories be history and move forward. A lot of atrocities have been committed trying to settle old scores from hundreds of years ago.
Russia, in my opinion, is ready to do that, but…they are ruled by a man who is looking backward and not forward. Ukraine poses no threat to Russia except in his head. Unfortunately he’s calling the shots.