Should Cindy and George be charged? Do They Need An Attorney?

[Americka]

During the depositions(cindy's I believe) Did Bruce C. Claim the A's are still being brought up on charges?

It seemed wishy washy...started with Yes they are...ok they were, no they are no longer...I couldn't get a straight answer, listening to them go at it back and forth.

Pages 34-35 of George's deposition:
And what reports did you get back as to
13 their efforts to find --
14 A You'll have to ask sheriff's department about
15 that.
16 Q No, your investigators, what reports did you
17 get back?
18 MR. CONWAY: That's privileged information.
19 It's privileged information.
20 MR. MORGAN: Why is it privileged?
21 MR. CONWAY: Because he hired them. They
22 worked for him. Everything that was given to them
23 is work product.
24 MR. MORGAN: That isn't work.
25 MR. CONWAY: It had everything to do with the
>Rough Draft - 41
1 fact they were being investigated by the sheriff's
2 office. They were obstructions of --
3 MR. MORGAN: You're taking the privilege based
4 on no pending lawsuit.
5 MR. CONWAY: I'm talking about the lawsuit
6 based on pending criminal charges at the time.
7 MR. MORGAN: Against the Anthonys?
8 MR. CONWAY: Yes, sir.
9 MR. MORGAN: George and Cindy?
Page 34
GAnthony-rough.txt
10 MR. CONWAY: According to the sheriff's
11 office, they're being investigated and could be
12 charged with obstruction charges.
13 MR. MORGAN: Not now or still?
14 MR. CONWAY: At this point, no, absolutely
15 not.
16 MR. MORGAN: Then you have no privilege.
17 MR. CONWAY: We'll certify it to the judge and
18 deal with the judge on it.


According to BC ("could be charged with obstruction charges"), the possibility is there. However, no charges have currently been filed...

 

[sumbunny]

Pages 34-35 of George's deposition:
And what reports did you get back as to
13 their efforts to find --
14 A You'll have to ask sheriff's department about
15 that.
16 Q No, your investigators, what reports did you
17 get back?
18 MR. CONWAY: That's privileged information.
19 It's privileged information.
20 MR. MORGAN: Why is it privileged?
21 MR. CONWAY: Because he hired them. They
22 worked for him. Everything that was given to them
23 is work product.
24 MR. MORGAN: That isn't work.
25 MR. CONWAY: It had everything to do with the
>Rough Draft - 41
1 fact they were being investigated by the sheriff's
2 office. They were obstructions of --
3 MR. MORGAN: You're taking the privilege based
4 on no pending lawsuit.
5 MR. CONWAY: I'm talking about the lawsuit
6 based on pending criminal charges at the time.
7 MR. MORGAN: Against the Anthonys?
8 MR. CONWAY: Yes, sir.
9 MR. MORGAN: George and Cindy?
Page 34
GAnthony-rough.txt
10 MR. CONWAY: According to the sheriff's
11 office, they're being investigated and could be
12 charged with obstruction charges.
13 MR. MORGAN: Not now or still?
14 MR. CONWAY: At this point, no, absolutely
15 not.
16 MR. MORGAN: Then you have no privilege.
17 MR. CONWAY: We'll certify it to the judge and
18 deal with the judge on it.


According to BC, the possibility is there. However, no charges have currently been filed.

Still wishy washy...."pending charges ((at the time))"
Then "at this time NO absolutely not"

So what is it in your opinion..yes or no??

Oh and THANKS btw

oh darn just saw your "purple response" so there is a possibility...Argh...

 

[Americka]

Still wishy washy...."pending charges ((at the time))"
Then "at this time NO absolutely not"

So what is it in your opinion..yes or no??

Oh and THANKS btw

oh darn just saw your "purple response" so there is a possibility...Argh...

Yes, there is a possibility. And if the Anthonys continue to behave in the same manner, then that possibility grows exponentially every day.:woohoo:

 

[MIbarb]

I'ld like to see a new poll now after their depositions. I would like to see them charged myself, don't people have no respect for police anymore? I don't believe this to be the case, but what if their had been a babysitter and she did take Caylee, how could the police find her with the lies and mistruths, and the not giving them all the items they needed and ask for. If there had been a babysitter-they were the reason their daughter ended up dead. They didn't help like they should have, to get her daughter/granddaughter back.

 

[Duckley]

I would love to see them charged with obstruction, accessory after the fact, purjury etc. I am not sure they are going to be helpful witnesses for the prosecution, so I wonder if it is better to have them as defense witnesses where they can be cross-examined. The only problem with their being charged is by them taking the 5th. This might hurt the prosecution case.

I would love to see them injected with "truth serum"! I wonder if the threat of jail time would help them speak the truth. I cant help but feel if they could get G alone for a period of time, he might spill. C is like KC - I am not sure we will ever get the truth or at least the whole truth.

I agree with the poster who indicated that he/she would love to feel compassion for G and C. I would too. I have no problem with them trying to defend their daughter. I have no problem with them trying to support their daughter. I have a problem with them seemingly to be actively obscuring the truth. I just wish they would come out and say that they love and support their daughter, that they cannot imagine that she is responsible for the death of Caylee and that they will do whatever it takes to find out who is responsible. Scott Peterson's parents believed him. They went on TV to actively support him. But I do not believe they actively lied, obscured, spun, omitted, covered up, etc.
By being honest and forthright they will contribute to finding Caylees's killer and will bring justice to Caylee.

 

[sharpar]

They need to wait until after the murder trial, they arent going anywhere - any residual sympathy for the Ant Farm should pretty much disappear by then and Ant Farm will continue to lie racking up more charges.

 

[flyonsweetangel]

During the depositions(cindy's I believe) Did Bruce C. Claim the A's are still being brought up on charges?

It seemed wishy washy...started with Yes they are...ok they were, no they are no longer...I couldn't get a straight answer, listening to them go at it back and forth.

Nor could I understand this. As far as obstruction of justice, perjury, AND parents enabling a daughter to continue being an evil, immoral, self-center ..... individual they are guilty on all counts! JMO of course

 

[SoCalGal]

I'd like to vote, but would like Cindy and George to be a seperate choice.

Ditto.........

 

[flyonsweetangel]

I wish someone would start a thread asking if they think KC will fire JB before her trial or during it

 

[tfrohning]

I think Cindy should be charge she lied and her answers was different from what was said in beginning to LE. I used to feel sorry for her , not after this despostion I think she should sit right next to her daughter. I really believe George was the oonly one that loved Caylee. Also think that lee should be arrest too.

 

[ThoughtElf]

Part of the issue that bothers me the most is that they are so firmly anchored in orbit around Planet SODDI.

I lean more towards obstruction charges than perjury. I expected them to perjure themselves. I think everyone in LE/Courts expected them to perjure themselves.

I think obstruction charges would be more meaningful. We all know that they've verbally pointed accusing fingers at many other people, but if it can be proven that they've taken specific actions to cast doubt or suspicion through their actions on another person (i.e. JG), then I believe that warrants the charges.

That is the root of all of the lies, the possible cover-ups, their rage. It is their die-hard insistence that SODDI and they'll obstruct and tell all the lies necessary to get to that goal.

The thing is, Planet SODDI will have two less satellites orbiting it when the Asteroid called 'Criminal Justice' slams directly into their flight-path.

 

[Searchfortruth]

This is actually a very legitimate question because their actions, attitudes and disgusting behavior resulted in their depositions being public stonings of their daughter. Serious...the prosecution couldn't have scripted this better if they tried.

Thats the irony, IMO, of this whole drama, Cindy and George are trying their hardest to protect princess Casey, but in reality they couldn't harm her more if they tried. Yes they should be charged, YESTERDAY ! :furious:

 

[Pink Panther]

They should both be charged for obstruction in a murder investigation. I have the utmost respect for LE but the fact that these two are still out and about spewing their CARP really disgusts me and makes me wonder a bit about Law Enforcement and what exactly they're doing!

MOO

 

[WholeLottaRosie]

This is what I don't get. Wasn't there a case, in Florida, where the family or at least one or two members, helped a killer (of a small girl abducted from a car wash, the abduction being caught on tape, I can't recall the name right now) and at that time what they did wasn't against any existing FL law, so laws covering family members helping cover up crimes/obstruction/etc. were passed? Did I dream this? If true, the Anthony's seem to be the poster people to be charged on this, because as I recall, no one has yet been charged under the new law. If it is against the law, they must be charged and if I lived in Orlando and or Florida I would be calling my elected officials constantly demanding charges be brought.

 

[Searchfortruth]

This is what I don't get. Wasn't there a case, in Florida, where the family or at least one or two members, helped a killer (of a small girl abducted from a car wash, the abduction being caught on tape, I can't recall the name right now) and at that time what they did wasn't against any existing FL law, so laws covering family members helping cover up crimes/obstruction/etc. were passed? Did I dream this? If true, the Anthony's seem to be the poster people to be charged on this, because as I recall, no one has yet been charged under the new law. If it is against the law, they must be charged and if I lived in Orlando and or Florida I would be calling my elected officials constantly demanding charges be brought.

I don't think you are dreaming this, I don't know the circumstances surrounding the change in laws, but do remember a FL prosecutor talking about the change and saying that the A's could be charged under the new law. Before this law change the state didn't include family members in the obstruction laws because it was understood they would lie to protect their own, this is how the prosecutor explained it on TV. I am so glad they changed the laws and I hope the A's ARE made an example of, for others to see. To let family members lie without punishment, especially when it concerns the murder of a child, is insane. If the A's get away with it there will surely be a long line of others to follow.

 

[shgrbkr]

I stand by what I said from the beginning that Cindy, in particular, should be charged with obstruction. I have no doubt in my mind that she KNEW what she was doing when she washed those pants! We watch as CAGA try in vain to come up with some answers to questions where they are obviously lying.

 

[snow_walker]

When did she wash those pants? Did that happen right away, that night the fit hit the shan, and CA called 911? Or was it a few days later, or what? I could sort of see someone in a haze trying to 'fix' things that first night, trying to normalize things.. taking a dirty pair of pants and washing them, sort of instinctively.

 

[shgrbkr]

When did she wash those pants? Did that happen right away, that night the fit hit the shan, and CA called 911? Or was it a few days later, or what? I could sort of see someone in a haze trying to 'fix' things that first night, trying to normalize things.. taking a dirty pair of pants and washing them, sort of instinctively.

Yeah, it was the same day they got the car back, IIRC. CA found the pants in the car and washed them, sending the most likely smoking gun literally down the drain.

 

[EclecticArtist]

yes! Both lied and lied and lied again throughout the deposition! how dare they?? They both showed total disrespect. Don't cha know LE is having a fine time analyzing these actions and planning their strategy? They showed their cards!

Now, how long will it be before BC gets enough and walks. His reputation is on the line, although it might be too late!

 

[MADJGNLAW]

This is what I don't understand. Casey was bonded out - said if out she could help, and in the home with the Anthony's. So, what information did they get out of her? Did they share with LE? And if not why? I would think that Cindy would of grilled Casey to no end and that is why Casey kept going to spend the day at Baez's office. My point is, Cindy now has shared that she does have the information for the right ZFG. Why did she not state that early on if true? I don't buy it, but for some reason I feel Cindy knew what happen and she orchestrated this whole missing person's case to save Casey since that is all she had left. I think she found out soon after the incident. JMO.