TRIAL OF CHAD DAYBELL CHARGED WITH MURDER OF JJ VALLOW, TYLEE RYAN AND TAMMY DAYBELL

[ReadySet]

Oh, they're going to play the phone call Lori to Chad on day bodies were found, I think.

 

[indicolite22]

It's about what he wants, when he wants it. He wanted them all there dancing attendance, until he wanted to be somewhere else more than he wanted his court of children around him. Presumably, when he took off, they just patiently waited for further instructions. Now he's got them stalwartly backing him in a trial where he's charged with murdering their own mother. He'll always feel a little bit godlike while they choose him over her. Which means he'll probably feel that way for the rest of his life, since Lori's trial didn't seem to disillusion them.

MOO

Why don't they read his texts about how he felt like Harry Potter living with his family?

 

[wnk]

Prior is tripping ALL over himself with this cross-exam. He can't seem to keep his facts straight about who was where when. I can't for the life of me figure out if this is some sort of strategy to confuse the jury, or if he's just in way over his head.

 

[aafromaa]

Snipped by me

IF the State obtained a transcript without filing a Motion, and IF that does not follow the Idaho Rules,

I’m not sure that the rules you cited actually say that they have to file a motion to get a transcript…technically it seems to me to be addressing the court’s responsibility to provide a copy IF a motion is made and/or the court issues an order for a transcript. In other words, it doesn’t appear to me to exclude a request for a transcript without a motion or court order or to make such a request inappropriate.

I think the reason the state didn’t respond at all to JP’s statement about this is that it is much ado about nothing - more of what I call JP’s crybaby tactics - trying to make himself appear as David facing Goliath and it’s all so unfair and if I don’t get my way at least I’ll try to make you look bad in the process by whining about everything.

Not only did the state not respond but neither did the Judge and I think that’s the best way for them to handle his whining. MOO

 

[MySharoanah]

Didn't G move back home long before Chad met Lori?

I’m not sure on when his move actually happened.

 

[lightofmine99]

Didn't G move back home long before Chad met Lori?

I don't think we have an official date for when Garth moved to Rexburg. But, Chad was preaching doomsday fanfiction long before he met Lori as well. He was fancying himself a visionary prophet for a long time.

 

[skochers75]

Where are we in this trial? Has the prosecution rested and we are hearing from the defense? I know its a simple question but have been gone for about a week

 

[wnk]

Where are we in this trial? Has the prosecution rested and we are hearing from the defense? I know its a simple question but have been gone for about a week

Not even close. We're on the 3rd State witness. For reference, the State called 61 witnesses in LVD's trial.

 

[ReadySet]

Chad had $90,000 in cash in his house; he tells Emma as he is sitting in the back of officer's car.

 

[MTW2011]

I’m not sure that the rules you cited actually say that they have to file a motion to get a transcript…technically it seems to me to be addressing the court’s responsibility to provide a copy IF a motion is made and/or the court issues an order for a transcript. In other words, it doesn’t appear to me to exclude a request for a transcript without a motion or court order or to make such a request inappropriate.

I think the reason the state didn’t respond at all to JP’s statement about this is that it is much ado about nothing - more of what I call JP’s crybaby tactics - trying to make himself appear as David facing Goliath and it’s all so unfair and if I don’t get my way at least I’ll try to make you look bad in the process by whining about everything.

Not only did the state not respond but neither did the Judge and I think that’s the best way for them to handle his whining. MOO

FWIW, the State filed a Motion right after that….today…..

EDITING TO ADD: after posting and refreshing the TylerTechnologies docket page for the case the Motion is no longer listed and instead I see now an signed Order based on the State’s Motion; again dated today several minutes ago. Not sure what any of that means, IMOO if the transcript without a Motion comment was “much ado about nothing”, why did State file anything shortly after?

I’m not sure if a Motion is not necessary, why they would then seemingly be doing it retroactively (as defense had said they were provided a copy already).

 

[TigerLou]

Chad had $90,000 in cash in his house; he tells Emma as he is sitting in the back of officer's car.

I heard $9,000

 

[skochers75]

Not even close. We're on the 3rd State witness. For reference, the State called 61 witnesses in LVD's trial.

Thank you so much. We are in for a long trial again. Maybe I havent really missed a lot then

 

[lightofmine99]

We are currently listening to a call between Chad and a very emotional Emma. Chad was sitting in the back of a cop car during the call but had not been officially arrested.

Emma is his biggest outspoken defender.

 

[Ruminations]

Holy moly, Chad totally planned to be incarcerated long enough to delegate car payments, etc.

Prior's argument that he had something else in mind when he hightailed it to the county line?

*flush!* it's poopie.

MOO

 

[TigerLou]

We are currently listening to a call between Chad and a very emotional Emma. Chad was sitting in the back of a cop car during the call but had not been officially arrested.

Emma is his biggest outspoken defender.

I have not listened to this before.

I am surprised (though I don't know why) that Emma was talking to Lori and took over filling her commissary balance every week. I wonder if she is still doing that.

 

[ReadySet]

$9,000 is probably right.

But why aren't they upset that the children's bodies were found on the property? Why aren't they shocked? I don't hear any of that.

 

[ReadySet]

I heard $9,000

Probably was $9,000 not $90,000

 

[lightofmine99]

So did Emma cease giving Lori commissary money the second they decided she must have framed pops?

 

[nodamselindistress]

Does Chad EVER get animated? He still has that same monotone voice as he is talking to Emma through the cop car window.

 

[TigerLou]

$9,000 is probably right.

But why aren't they upset that the children's bodies were found on the property? Why aren't they shocked? I don't hear any of that.

I didn't see any emotion with that discovery as well.
They seemed like it was expected--they weren't upset.