GUILTY CA - Fabio Sementilli, 49, renowned hairdresser, murdered in LA, 23 Jan 2017 *Arrests, 1 guilty*

I just went back and listened to the end of day 35 and the judge told the jury that they are now taking their adjournment as far as the jury is concerned until April 1st. Then the camera cuts off so we don't get to hear why. :(
Time stamp 6:53:50


Hmmm.... wondering "why" the court site has today on it? I shall go ahead & put it on 4/1 if that is what is going on with the jury. Maybe some kind "private" hearing for defense, DA & Judge maybe?
 
Future Proceedings
Date Time Type Result Location Department
04/01/2025 08:30AM Jury Trial in Progress
Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center Dept. - 101

Past Proceedings
Date Time Type Result Location Department
03/28/2025 08:30AM Jury Trial in Progress
Held - Proceedings Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center Dept. - 101

link: LA Court
 
For anyone that has not been able to follow the trial like they would like too .. I went back and listened to Mitzi Roberts testimony and filled in a few things from Sy Ray's testimony and made a time line of the day of Fabios murder. This is just about a 2 hour window surrounding the time of the incident.

3:26pm - Monica is seen leaving Residence
3:28pm - Monica is seen passing Ralph's Supermarket
3:29:50pm - Monica enters Target parking lot
(an individual is seen walking around the front of her vehicle and possibly entering the vehicle in front of the Payless shoe store .. her car then parks at the far end of the Target parking lot)
3:34pm - Monica repositions her car and parks closer to the Target entrance
3:36pm - Monica sends Viber message to Baker
3:37pm - Rental car that Baker is driving exits Target parking lot
3:37:56pm - Monica makes an outgoing call to Gessica
3:39pm - Monica enters Target
3:40pm - Monica sends IM to Gessica (do not be late)
3:41pm - Gessica sends IM to Monica ( I won't lol)
3:47pm - Gessica leaves the residence
3:53:57pm - Monica accesses the IDMSS (connects to her home ip address to access the home security)
4:00pm - 4:15 pm - Monica connects to her home ip address 8 times to view home security
4:18pm - Joggers (Baker & Austin) are captured on camera heading to Sementilli residence
4:22pm - Incoming call from Isabella to Monica
4:24pm - Monica makes outgoing call to Isabella
4:27pm - Incoming call from eye doctor to Monica (unanswered)
4:28pm - Monica makes outgoing call to eye doctor
4:32pm - Monica exits Target
4:37pm - Outgoing call Monica to Isabella
4:38pm - Monica exits Target parking lot
4:41:55pm - Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket lot
4:42:30pm -Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket
4:46:11pm - Monica sends viber message to Baker
4:50pm - Monica deletes Lifestyle lounge app from her phone
4:52:40pm - Monica exits Ralphs Supermarket
4:53pm - Baker & Austin leave residence in Porsche
4:54pm - Isabella returns home
4:56pm - Porsche passes Ralphs Supermarket
5:03pm - Monica returns home
5:12pm - Bakers phone registers back on
5:14:30pm -Baker sends viber message to Monica
 
For anyone that has not been able to follow the trial like they would like too .. I went back and listened to Mitzi Roberts testimony and filled in a few things from Sy Ray's testimony and made a time line of the day of Fabios murder. This is just about a 2 hour window surrounding the time of the incident.

3:26pm - Monica is seen leaving Residence
3:28pm - Monica is seen passing Ralph's Supermarket
3:29:50pm - Monica enters Target parking lot
(an individual is seen walking around the front of her vehicle and possibly entering the vehicle in front of the Payless shoe store .. her car then parks at the far end of the Target parking lot)
3:34pm - Monica repositions her car and parks closer to the Target entrance
3:36pm - Monica sends Viber message to Baker
3:37pm - Rental car that Baker is driving exits Target parking lot
3:37:56pm - Monica makes an outgoing call to Gessica
3:39pm - Monica enters Target
3:40pm - Monica sends IM to Gessica (do not be late)
3:41pm - Gessica sends IM to Monica ( I won't lol)
3:47pm - Gessica leaves the residence
3:53:57pm - Monica accesses the IDMSS (connects to her home ip address to access the home security)
4:00pm - 4:15 pm - Monica connects to her home ip address 8 times to view home security
4:18pm - Joggers (Baker & Austin) are captured on camera heading to Sementilli residence
4:22pm - Incoming call from Isabella to Monica
4:24pm - Monica makes outgoing call to Isabella
4:27pm - Incoming call from eye doctor to Monica (unanswered)
4:28pm - Monica makes outgoing call to eye doctor
4:32pm - Monica exits Target
4:37pm - Outgoing call Monica to Isabella
4:38pm - Monica exits Target parking lot
4:41:55pm - Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket lot
4:42:30pm -Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket
4:46:11pm - Monica sends viber message to Baker
4:50pm - Monica deletes Lifestyle lounge app from her phone
4:52:40pm - Monica exits Ralphs Supermarket
4:53pm - Baker & Austin leave residence in Porsche
4:54pm - Isabella returns home
4:56pm - Porsche passes Ralphs Supermarket
5:03pm - Monica returns home
5:12pm - Bakers phone registers back on
5:14:30pm -Baker sends viber message to Monica
Wow! Thank you for that timeline breakdown @rebelchild. That paints such a clear image; it’s like watching a slow motion movie, minute by minute. I can easily see all this activity going on between two (imo) definitely involved co-conspirators, with (again, imo) one hapless underling. Mr Sementilli’s daughters were almost caught up in this web - one daughter missed seeing them leave by one minute. What a mother.

Does anyone recall why they wanted it done that day, in broad daylight? They were almost caught in the act.
 
Tuesday, April 1st:
*Trial continues (Day 37) (@ 8:30am PT) – CA – Fabio Sementilli (49) (Jan. 23, 2017, Los Angeles) – *Monica Sonia Crescentini Sementilli (45/now 53) (wife) arrested (8/18/17), indicted (8/31/17), charged (8/18/17) & arraigned (8/31/17) with capital murder with special circumstances of murder for financial gain & conspiracy to commit murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. DA will not seek DP. LA County
Jury Selection began on 1/21/25 & ended 1/22/25. No info on jurors. Juror #2 was replaced by an alternate on 3/19/25. Juror #2 [new one] was replaced by an alternate on 3/20/25.
Trial began on 1/24/25 & on 3/12/25 Prosecutors rested their case. Defense began their case on 3/12/25. Dark on Fridays (sometimes).
Superior Court Judge Ronald S. Coen. Deputy DA Heather Steggell & Deputy DA Beth Silverman. Defense attorneys Leonard Levine & Blair Berk.

Court hearings from 6/5/18 thru 1/28/25 & Jury Selection Days 1-2 (1/21-1/22/25) & Trial Day 1-36 (1/24 & 1/29-3/21/25) reference post #753 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...a-23-jan-2017-arrests-1-guilty.327994/page-38

3/28/25 Friday, Trial Day – No trial on Firday. Trial continues on Tuesday, 4/1/25.
*Christopher Austin (38/now 39) – Plead guilty on 1/17/25. Sentencing hearing on 4/30/25.
*Robert Louis Baker (55/now 62) (wife’s BF) plead no contest/guilty on 7/7/23 & sentenced to life without parole.
 
For anyone that has not been able to follow the trial like they would like too .. I went back and listened to Mitzi Roberts testimony and filled in a few things from Sy Ray's testimony and made a time line of the day of Fabios murder. This is just about a 2 hour window surrounding the time of the incident.

3:26pm - Monica is seen leaving Residence
3:28pm - Monica is seen passing Ralph's Supermarket
3:29:50pm - Monica enters Target parking lot
(an individual is seen walking around the front of her vehicle and possibly entering the vehicle in front of the Payless shoe store .. her car then parks at the far end of the Target parking lot)
3:34pm - Monica repositions her car and parks closer to the Target entrance
3:36pm - Monica sends Viber message to Baker
3:37pm - Rental car that Baker is driving exits Target parking lot
3:37:56pm - Monica makes an outgoing call to Gessica
3:39pm - Monica enters Target
3:40pm - Monica sends IM to Gessica (do not be late)
3:41pm - Gessica sends IM to Monica ( I won't lol)
3:47pm - Gessica leaves the residence
3:53:57pm - Monica accesses the IDMSS (connects to her home ip address to access the home security)
4:00pm - 4:15 pm - Monica connects to her home ip address 8 times to view home security
4:18pm - Joggers (Baker & Austin) are captured on camera heading to Sementilli residence
4:22pm - Incoming call from Isabella to Monica
4:24pm - Monica makes outgoing call to Isabella
4:27pm - Incoming call from eye doctor to Monica (unanswered)
4:28pm - Monica makes outgoing call to eye doctor
4:32pm - Monica exits Target
4:37pm - Outgoing call Monica to Isabella
4:38pm - Monica exits Target parking lot
4:41:55pm - Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket lot
4:42:30pm -Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket
4:46:11pm - Monica sends viber message to Baker
4:50pm - Monica deletes Lifestyle lounge app from her phone
4:52:40pm - Monica exits Ralphs Supermarket
4:53pm - Baker & Austin leave residence in Porsche
4:54pm - Isabella returns home
4:56pm - Porsche passes Ralphs Supermarket
5:03pm - Monica returns home
5:12pm - Bakers phone registers back on
5:14:30pm -Baker sends viber message to Monica

I also want to Thank You @rebelchild. I don't know how you were able to put together such a mind-blowing timeline, I'm in awe of your tenacity. It's totally convincing & precise that the actions of Monica were part of an orchestrated plan of hers. Makes her look like the actual ringleader doing the directing of actions & timing. IMO, there's no doubt after reading through your timeline that she was aware of what was going down. She's despicable. @rebelchild, I wish your timeline would be handed out to each juror, and a computer enactment shown in the courtroom.
 

I also want to Thank You @rebelchild. I don't know how you were able to put together such a mind-blowing timeline, I'm in awe of your tenacity. It's totally convincing & precise that the actions of Monica were part of an orchestrated plan of hers. Makes her look like the actual ringleader doing the directing of actions & timing. IMO, there's no doubt after reading through your timeline that she was aware of what was going down. She's despicable. @rebelchild, I wish your timeline would be handed out to each juror, and a computer enactment shown in the courtroom.
Thank you @Curious Me but I hate to take any credit for this. They showed a couple of great power point displays that show the timeline while Mitzi Roberts and Sy Ray were on the stand. I just went back and re-listened to the testimony and took notes. It has helped me wrap my head around what was going on during that time so I wanted to share with all of you. Hopefully the jury has access to the power points they showed during court .. or at least took good notes.
 
Started streaming 2 hours ago
Monica Sementilli is accused of murdering her husband, Fabio Sementilli, because she allegedly wanted to continue her affair with a new man and collect a $1.6 million life insurance policy. Fabio Sementilli was found stabbed to death inside their Woodland Hills home back in January of 2017. Monica Sementilli and her lover, Robert Baker, were arrested six months after the crime. Monica Sementilli is charged with murder and conspiracy. Baker pleaded no contest to the charges against him and was sentenced to life in prison.
 
Wow! Thank you for that timeline breakdown @rebelchild. That paints such a clear image; it’s like watching a slow motion movie, minute by minute. I can easily see all this activity going on between two (imo) definitely involved co-conspirators, with (again, imo) one hapless underling. Mr Sementilli’s daughters were almost caught up in this web - one daughter missed seeing them leave by one minute. What a mother.

Does anyone recall why they wanted it done that day, in broad daylight? They were almost caught in the act.
Thank you @TwinkieDefense .. I was trying to figure out if Monica had enough time to possibly help Baker get away from the area he dumped the Porsche.
She did not arrive back home until 10 minutes after being seen walking out of the Ralph's Supermarket and it's only a 2 minute drive.
She did not arrive back home until 7 minutes after the Porsche was seen passing by the Ralph's Supermarket.
And in one of Rob Bakers interviews with the defense he said that he dumped the Porsche close to Ralph's.
IMO .. she picked him up and took him somewhere .. maybe to where he left the rental car.

moo
 
Prosecutor having a field day with defense private eye (P.I.) re his discussions with Baker, especially re gps. For example, the only reference to Baker talking about gps devices, which were not mentioned in the P.I.’s raw (hand written) notes. (The P.I. had previously testified he used his hand written notes to refresh his memory, then they were discarded). The only reference to the gps in his finished report were the words Ford F150 Porsche on the very last page of his notes for that days visit at the prison. That was the very first time Baker had ever mentioned the gps during their twelve or so visits.

There was also some disagreement regarding the date of that visit, whether it was March 10 as on his hand written notes, or March 11, 2025 as on his finished notes.

Baker was interviewed twice by the P.I. that day, once in the morning, and once after court ended that same day. He said it was because their visit didn’t get finished in the morning.

His notes indicate Baker said he removed the gps from the Porsche the night of the murder. He went on to say he removed the device from the Ford F150 sometime thereafter. None of which were in his hand written notes.

This fellow says he knew about the gps purchase earlier and Baker volunteered he had two gps units, had to buy them, cash. That indicated to the P.I. that the gps he had bought six months earlier was not the one he put on the car because it had been purchased on a credit card.

So now we have three gps.

Then they jump to the night before the murder - prosecutor says Monica told Baker Fabio was going to pick up Chinese food, Baker said he knew from past experience that there were only two Chinese/Asian restaurants the family went to, the Pho/Chinese restaurant, and Jasmine Thai, both on Ventura Blvd., but that was not in the P.I.’s notes either.

Hmmm. My head hurts. So all this is my interpretation of the witness testimony.
 
Last edited:
Prosecutor having a field day with defense private eye (P.I.) re his discussions with Baker, especially re gps. For example, the only reference to Baker talking about gps devices, which were not mentioned in the P.I.’s raw (hand written) notes. (The P.I. had previously testified he used his hand written notes to refresh his memory, then they were discarded). The only reference to the gps in his finished report were the words Ford F150 Porsche on the very last page of his notes for that days visit at the prison. That was the very first time Baker had ever mentioned the gps during their twelve or so visits.

There was also some disagreement regarding the date of that visit, whether it was March 10 as on his hand written notes, or March 11, 2025 as on his finished notes.

Baker was interviewed twice by the P.I. that day, once in the morning, and once after court ended that same day. He said it was because their visit didn’t get finished in the morning.

His notes indicate Baker said he removed the gps from the Porsche the night of the murder. He went on to say he removed the device from the Ford F150 sometime thereafter. None of which were in his hand written notes.

This fellow says he knew about the gps purchase earlier and Baker volunteered he had two gps units, had to buy them, cash. That indicated to the P.I. that the gps he had bought six months earlier was not the one he put on the car because it had been purchased on a credit card.

So now we have three gps.

Then they jump to the night before the murder - prosecutor says Monica told Baker Fabio was going to pick up Chinese food, Baker said he knew from past experience that there were only two Chinese/Asian restaurants the family went to, the Pho/Chinese restaurant, and Jasmine Thai, both on Ventura Blvd., but that was not in the P.I.’s notes either.

Hmmm. My head hurts. So all this is my interpretation of the witness testimony.
Thank you for the quick update! I'm trying to get caught up on today's testimony and work keeps getting in my way. lol I knew there was something up with the gps units .. so glad to see it all coming out now!
 
I'm getting here rather late today. I know, I haven't given this trial my full attention. Wish I got all her testimony. This witness, a neighbor, Deborah Obad, seemed to have noticed what was going on. Said she was close friends and warning Fabio about the racquetball new friends. She was there right after, helping console the girls, observing Monica. Please, if you can fill me in, I know I missed a lot of spilled tea.​

1743547428505.webp
1743547499866.webp Deborah Obad said, "I told Fabio to watch out for those racquetball friends."


1743547612486.webp

1743548065342.webp
 


Thank You, @dotr. Done for the day on Court TV, and on to another case. Fortunately, now I can watch more of the neighbor, Deborah Obad's testimony from your video link.

Deborah Obad is being asked about talking to the son, Luigi Sementilli, in some quick convo, and if Stock Options were mentioned. She said no. I'll have to go back further to watch and hear what else she had to say.

1743549772179.webp
1743549714215.webp
 
Since CourtTV has not updated their 4/1 - I have no name for the P.I.

Wednesday, April 2nd:
*Trial continues (Day 38) (@ 8:30am PT) – CA – Fabio Sementilli (49) (Jan. 23, 2017, Los Angeles) – *Monica Sonia Crescentini Sementilli (45/now 53) (wife) arrested (8/18/17), indicted (8/31/17), charged (8/18/17) & arraigned (8/31/17) with capital murder with special circumstances of murder for financial gain & conspiracy to commit murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. DA will not seek DP. LA County
Jury Selection began on 1/21/25 & ended 1/22/25. No info on jurors. Juror #2 was replaced by an alternate on 3/19/25. Juror #2 [new one] was replaced by an alternate on 3/20/25.
Trial began on 1/24/25 & on 3/12/25 Prosecutors rested their case. Defense began their case on 3/12/25. Dark on Fridays (sometimes).
Superior Court Judge Ronald S. Coen. Deputy DA Heather Steggell & Deputy DA Beth Silverman. Defense attorneys Leonard Levine & Blair Berk.

Court hearings from 6/5/18 thru 1/28/25 & Jury Selection Days 1-2 (1/21-1/22/25) & Trial Day 1-36 (1/24 & 1/29-3/28/25) reference post #768 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...a-23-jan-2017-arrests-1-guilty.327994/page-39

4/1/25 Tuesday, Trial Day 37: Defense witnesses: Deborah Obad, Sementilli's neighbor. Defense's P.I. (no name given). No other info yet. Trial continues on Wednesday, 4/2/25.
*Christopher Austin (38/now 39) – Plead guilty on 1/17/25. Sentencing hearing on 4/30/25.
*Robert Louis Baker (55/now 62) (wife’s BF) plead no contest/guilty on 7/7/23 & sentenced to life without parole.
 
^^^ Day 36 – April 1, 2025Deborah Obad finally takes the stand, surprisingly as a defense witness. Monica’s attorney asks her a number of questions regarding her and her husband’s relationship with the Sementilli's, to which she states they were very close. She is also asked about her suspicions of having an affair, the day Fabio was killed, Monica’s demeanor during that time, and about Robert Baker himself.

Notes in somewhat my own wording.
She was suppose to be a Prosecution witness, but surprisingly she turned into a witness for Monica's defense?
Deborah Obad had a 2 hr. mtg. once, but then there was a short appt. with Ms. Silvermen, then they walked across the street together to the Grand Jury.

She has been a Literary Agent for 30 yrs. Lives in Tarzana since 2011, then Fabio & Monica moved, but she remained close friends with them. They, then, lived about 2 miles apart after the move. Deborah & her husband saw Monica & Fabio on a regular weekly basis. Very close, they gave her a baby shower, etc., The couples socialized and even traveled together once.

Spring 2016 through January 2017 at least once a week, unless he was gone for extended time. Sometimes they sit outside with Fabio, while Monica stayed inside being into their baby which Deborah didn't want outside. Gessica babysat too.

At approx 2:41-2:42:28 Deborah remembers it was at the end of the summer, so around September of 2016. She'd confirmed she see Fabio and Monica once a week then. Did not see any conflict between them.

5:43:22 Did you ever bring up the subject to Monica again about an affair with Monica? "Never."

5:43:35 How about bringing up with Fabio Monica having an affair to Fabio? "Sort of." Deborah says she told Fabio, "You need to watch those racquetball friends. I don't trust them." Then, Fabio says, "Ah, Deb, you think?" Deb then said, "I think." That was in September of 2016.

The entire 2016 holidays they couples spent together.

5:45:00 Needs to ask Ms. Obad some questions about the day of the murder.​
 
I'm tired and not able to listen to the whole testimony, but I'm most interested in Deborah Obad's testimony and want to know what she really thought went on. If anyone has insight about Monica turning on her husband, I think this woman observed important details. They were all such close friends. In essence, she actually warned Fabio. She had some kind of gut feeling. Why is she now a Defense witness?

Here's another video with transcription on the side. Easier. In case you need to find it-- go to the youtube site and after the more statement there's 1743579521604.webp a way to turn on the transcript on the side.

I time-marked video to start at approx the 11:58 mark when she's asked and goes into receiving additional information about Rob getting drunk and spending the night. I'll have to continue listening to this tomorrow. Tired.

 
Last edited:
For anyone that has not been able to follow the trial like they would like too .. I went back and listened to Mitzi Roberts testimony and filled in a few things from Sy Ray's testimony and made a time line of the day of Fabios murder. This is just about a 2 hour window surrounding the time of the incident.

3:26pm - Monica is seen leaving Residence
3:28pm - Monica is seen passing Ralph's Supermarket
3:29:50pm - Monica enters Target parking lot
(an individual is seen walking around the front of her vehicle and possibly entering the vehicle in front of the Payless shoe store .. her car then parks at the far end of the Target parking lot)
3:34pm - Monica repositions her car and parks closer to the Target entrance
3:36pm - Monica sends Viber message to Baker
3:37pm - Rental car that Baker is driving exits Target parking lot
3:37:56pm - Monica makes an outgoing call to Gessica
3:39pm - Monica enters Target
3:40pm - Monica sends IM to Gessica (do not be late)
3:41pm - Gessica sends IM to Monica ( I won't lol)
3:47pm - Gessica leaves the residence
3:53:57pm - Monica accesses the IDMSS (connects to her home ip address to access the home security)
4:00pm - 4:15 pm - Monica connects to her home ip address 8 times to view home security
4:18pm - Joggers (Baker & Austin) are captured on camera heading to Sementilli residence
4:22pm - Incoming call from Isabella to Monica
4:24pm - Monica makes outgoing call to Isabella
4:27pm - Incoming call from eye doctor to Monica (unanswered)
4:28pm - Monica makes outgoing call to eye doctor
4:32pm - Monica exits Target
4:37pm - Outgoing call Monica to Isabella
4:38pm - Monica exits Target parking lot
4:41:55pm - Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket lot
4:42:30pm -Monica enters Ralphs Supermarket
4:46:11pm - Monica sends viber message to Baker
4:50pm - Monica deletes Lifestyle lounge app from her phone
4:52:40pm - Monica exits Ralphs Supermarket
4:53pm - Baker & Austin leave residence in Porsche
4:54pm - Isabella returns home
4:56pm - Porsche passes Ralphs Supermarket
5:03pm - Monica returns home
5:12pm - Bakers phone registers back on
5:14:30pm -Baker sends viber message to Monica

Thank you for this Rebel! It helps to see it in linear context.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
118
Guests online
5,701
Total visitors
5,819

Forum statistics

Threads
621,282
Messages
18,430,030
Members
239,528
Latest member
VincentKun
Back
Top