Screams NOT a local.
Contradictions
The place where her body was found might not be somewhere an Orangeville local would be familiar with. It was all the way at the end of the road, almost at Airport Rd in Caledon. And it was on the side of the road that a car travelling westbound back towards Orangeville would pull over on. So it appears that the car may have turned around at the end of the sideroad instead of turning onto a busier road and continuing on and headed back westbound before disposing of the body. And that was done in a hurry IMO. At that point I think they just wanted to be done and get back home before daylight. Before the chances increased that someone would see them and their blood splattered clothing. A young perp who perhaps doesn't have their own car or hasn't done much driving between Orangeville and Caledon might not be familiar with that road. The normal route would be Hwy 9 to Airport, not an unpaved narrow sideroad. Why would someone local travel that road?
MOO