CO- Dylan Redwine, 13, Vallecito, 19 November 2012 - #27

[Psychic Sleuth]

All I can say is I'm so happy for my websleuth's community! Even those I may not agree with. At least we are all sane and semi cordial to each other Whew!! And now I see why the Mods are so tough. Could you imagine the chaos if they weren't?

 

[cluciano63]

I so agree with this. I wanted to use the "vigilante" word earlier but didn't.



Yes, you are correct. I figured my post would be deleted, but I'm glad it hasn't. If I didn't have FB, I would want to know that others were discussing us here and calling out by name. Going back to the V word and having experienced first hand the vicious nature of some, I would absolutely want to know if I was being called out.



I go by my gut when I don't have all the facts. It's how I roll.



I don't think LE is showing anything other than how they can win the silent game.

How on earth does a silent game help find a missing child? Why would LE want to make a point in that way? If they do not have a suspect, they are harming Dylan, IMO.

 

[Psychic Sleuth]

Hi guys, I really think we should get off the FB subject. And think of areas where Dylan may be. Hugs everyone I know this is hard case on us all

Thanks Raine. You are right of course! I don't know what else we can possibly come up with?

 

[Psychic Sleuth]

How on earth does a silent game help find a missing child? Why would LE want to make a point in that way? If they do not have a suspect, they are harming Dylan, IMO.

Well if they have a potential suspect but not enough evidence I could see them laying low just waiting for that break. Of course it's always possible they are working on things behind the scenes that we are totally unaware of. Otherwise I have no clue!

 

[Dixie811]

All I can say is I'm so happy for my websleuth's community! Even those I may not agree with. At least we are all sane and semi cordial to each other Whew!! And now I see why the Mods are so tough. Could you imagine the chaos if they weren't?

Thanks, Mods!! :rocker:

 

[raine1212]

Thanks Raine. You are right of course! I don't know what else we can possibly come up with?

Until we receive news from LE there is not much to discuss. Discussing rumors from other sites are never good and are not allowed. I am afraid we may not hear more until LE has all the evidence in place and has much as I hate to say this a body has been found. If they have a suspect we will not know till an arrest is made, they will not want to tip the ice berg.

 

[mijamawi]

How on earth does a silent game help find a missing child? Why would LE want to make a point in that way? If they do not have a suspect, they are harming Dylan, IMO.

I don't have a clue. I was responding to someone who said they were being led by LE. I was just saying that LE is doing nothing to lead anyone by playing the silent game.

 

[PaulR]

That is the first question LE would ask MR, any enemies, etc. So no, I do not see it. Any such people would have been run down by the FBI long ago.

You mean, like someone who has publicly accused MR of harming Dylan?

Nope, nobody like that at all! :moo:

 

[azgrandma]

I ask myself everyday, what if the original statements about MR had not been made, would we be looking at him as having done something bad to DR. If the suggestion had not been made that he had removed DR from the situation what would my feelings be right now. I have to say for me the seed was planted and I never originally had the thought that DR's father had harmed him. jmo

I understand a seed being planted, however, I have to very respectfully disagree that it somehow set the thinking in motion, (not your words, mine).
I have read through 27 threads, I have laughed, cried, yelled, screamed, agreed, disagreed, sometimes I wanted to use that little brick :banghead: on the computer and sometimes I wanted to ullhair:

What I mostly wanted to do is read, think, look at different angles, different possibilities. You (everyone here) has a valued and different opinion. It's amazing to see so many minds think alike and differently at the same moment. I find it highly unlikely that any of you would be so easily swayed by a seed, I give you all more credit than that and hope you give yourselves that as well. I don't know any of you and other than introducing yourself by your ws name, I wouldn't know you from Adam. But................I respect each of you, even the ones I don't agree with, because you provide a valued point of view.

I'm remaining on my opinion, that hasn't changed from day one. Yes, I know a bit more than others here and that's because of the dynamics of life. I'm not asking anyone to agree with me. I'm suggesting that you value your opinion and I hope I never ever (yes used the "n" word there) read that any of you believe that a seed dictated the opinion you hold. I think you all are brighter than that.

I don't drink wine, but I've had half a beer so I get chatty too :great:

 

[Allusonz]

I guess the way I follow cases is not about a gut feeling so much is what makes the most sense based on what is known. Even then I never say never, but I do form opinions if I follow a case closely and there is enough information. Sometimes I am wrong, sometimes I am right...most of the cases I have followed aren't solved yet. Does it matter if my opinion is right or wrong? No, only to me and I understand everyone has different views on how they look at things.

Most cases do not make sense based on what is known.

The Mickey Shunick case did not make sense. It turned out to be a RSO, who was responsible for another murder, and maybe more, thus a probably serial killer.

The Samantha Koenig case did not make sense. I certainly did not expect at the end of the day, for it to be a serial killer, by the name of Keyes, who travelled the US robbing and killing people in multiple jurisdictions.

This case as well does not make sense. It is not about how we look at things. It is about what evidence LE has.

 

[PaulR]

I am most being led, if that is the word, by LE. THEY are not behaving as though they believe Dylan is the victim of a stranger abduction, IMO.

They are also not behaving as if MR did it either. Have there been any searches of MR's property in the last month and a half? Or his workplace? Have they asked the public to report if they saw MR behaving suspiciously? Have they named him a POI?

 

[PaulR]

Am I the only one who thinks we should just lock the thread until more actual information comes out? As many have pointed out, there's nothing to discuss right now that hasn't been discussed in the previous 26 threads. MOO of course.

 

[Dixie811]

It's been discussed previously on here that family and friends of Dylan who believe him to still be alive (being held/hidden away) are suffering from wishful thinking.

I tend to agree. But today I caught myself wondering whether those close to Dylan feel this way because they are thinking wishfully, or if it is because they actually know MR.

I just don't see how it would be possible for so long.

JMO.

 

[jjenny]

They are also not behaving as if MR did it either. Have there been any searches of MR's property in the last month and a half? Or his workplace? Have they asked the public to report if they saw MR behaving suspiciously? Have they named him a POI?

How many times are they supposed to search his house?

 

[cluciano63]

I don't have a clue. I was responding to someone who said they were being led by LE. I was just saying that LE is doing nothing to lead anyone by playing the silent game.

That was me you were responding to. My point is that if LE does not have a suspect to hand, then their silence is hurting Dylan and seems unfair to the community.

 

[mijamawi]

Am I the only one who thinks we should just lock the thread until more actual information comes out? As many have pointed out, there's nothing to discuss right now that hasn't been discussed in the previous 26 threads. MOO of course.

NOOOO. I would have DT's if this thread were locked. I sat in a fetal position sucking my thumb when it was locked for longer than 15 minutes last time.

 

[Psychic Sleuth]

Most cases do not make sense based on what is known.

The Mickey Shunick case did not make sense. It turned out to be a RSO, who was responsible for another murder, and maybe more, thus a probably serial killer.

The Samantha Koenig case did not make sense. I certainly did not expect at the end of the day, for it to be a serial killer, by the name of Keyes, who travelled the US robbing and killing people in multiple jurisdictions.

This case as well does not make sense. It is not about how we look at things. It is about what evidence LE has.

You make a good point. The Koenig case was way out there. But I never felt anyone closely connected to her had anything to do with it.

The Schunick case. Well we were all very focused on that truck from the time the photo's came out. Just because we didn't know who that belonged to, we were focused in the right direction. Many thought maybe he accidentally hit her bike and something happened from there. Of course this was his story...although I'm still not buying it.

Dylan Redwine. There are a lot of people on here and elsewhere focusing on one person. Could we all be wrong? Absolutely...but I will be shocked if that turns out to be the case. Whatever happened, I just hope Dylan is found and whomever did something to him pays.

 

[PaulR]

I just don't see how it would be possible for so long.

I don't see how it could be possible at all.

Usually when parents kidnap their kids due to custodial issues, they are gone. Take the kid, over the border first chance they get. Obviously this works better if the kid is very young but it's happened with older kids, and of course they run far away to evade the law.

I don't see the end game in this. Eventually DR is going to come and point out who his kidnappers were, because he can't be held captive forever. Most states don't have any statute of limitations on felonies. I guess it's one way of getting three hots and a cot for an extended period of time but unlike the typical parental kidnapping, it doesn't make a lot of sense.

 

[Dixie811]

NOOOO. I would have DT's if this thread were locked. I sat in a fetal position sucking my thumb when it was locked for longer than 15 minutes last time.

Me too. *refresh* *refresh* *refresh* LOL

 

[cluciano63]

Am I the only one who thinks we should just lock the thread until more actual information comes out? As many have pointed out, there's nothing to discuss right now that hasn't been discussed in the previous 26 threads. MOO of course.

Should all threads with no news be locked? How does that help anything? No one has to come here and read the same old stuff, if they do not want to, but with Dylan on so many minds, it would be very hard not to be able to discuss him and the case.