Family wants to keep life support for girl brain dead after tonsil surgery #8

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #561
I'm on a Mac and the photos had the time I saved on my desktop, not the time the picture was taken on my iPhone.

So are you using a tool to look at the Exif data/Metadata? Are you using Lightroom? Did you enable the setting on your iPhone to not record personal data?

I guess I can't help you without seeing what you are seeing. I did quickly find out that there is an iTunes app that enables a person to remove metadata from your photos. https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/metadata-cut-view-remove-metadata/id568689108?mt=8
 
  • #562
  • #563
  • #564
The same reason, even the faithful, look both ways before crossing the street and don't simply leave it up to god.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

My following comment is not meant to be blasphemous, I am not Christian but American Indian who practices Traditional ceremony. While I believe that there is a purpose for everything, I think that it is Jahi's family who has the right to determine what they choose to do at this time. Personally, I wish they would call in a Yuwipi man but that is just me.

I am reminded of the Saturday Night Live skit with Sally Fields and Phil Hartman, she was a housewife named Mary and Hartman played Jesus. She was exhorting Jesus for everything, right down to her biscuits coming out right. Hartman's line which was really funny, as he walked out dressed as Jesus was, 'Mary, Mary Mary, I am a busy man.'
 
  • #565
So are you using a tool to look at the Exif data/Metadata? Are you using Lightroom? Did you enable the setting on your iPhone to not record personal data?

I guess I can't help you without seeing what you are seeing. I did quickly find out that there is an iTunes app that enables a person to remove metadata from your photos. https://itunes.apple.com/gb/app/metadata-cut-view-remove-metadata/id568689108?mt=8

I use Lightroom, yes. My imports from my SD card show the capture date and time, lens used, shutter speed, ISO ... everything.

The stuff I e-mailed to myself from my phone and imported into Lightroom show no data except the "created" time (time I downloaded it to my computer). When I look up the info in "Finder" I can see the same created time, and the modified time.

I don't use any apps to modify metadata. Perhaps it might also have something to do with my method of getting it from phone to computer (emailing to myself). Also that wouldn't explain a timestamp that is totally off. The only other option would be that they are using antiquated equipment that you have to set the date and time on your own.
 
  • #566
I have a few questions regarding Jahi and hopefully you all understand I'm not being morbid - I have never watched a person pass away so I truly don't know what happens.

When Jahi does pass - which, in this case is a relative term since she's already dead, but you know what I mean - is her passing (given her condition) going to be something that appears as a quiet calm passing or is there potential to be a "not peaceful" passing involved lack of brain activity?

I just can't help but wonder what kind of chaos would ensue if this new medical facility doesn't have the capabilities to take extreme measures to keep her heart beating. When the brain has no activity, is it assumed that there wouldn't be gasping for air (since that would be a brain regulated "reflex" right?) or any signs of a "struggle" per se...??? Is this correct?

I'm trying to ask as PC as possible...I just wonder if when she passes the family would possibly see things that her body does in a response to death that could falsely lead them to think that those final moments were all the signs of her "coming back to them" culminating immediately to her passing.
 
  • #567
No. Her feet move in a video. She's dead and has been for some time.


Yes she is indeed dead. Just for thought... when I was a little girl I watched my grandmother cut off a chickens head and that chicken (without head) was able to run around the yard! I knew it was it wasn't alive anymore. That what it was like on my grandma's farm!
 
  • #568
Yes she is indeed dead. Just for thought... when I was a little girl I watched my grandmother cut off a chickens head and that chicken (without head) was able to run around the yard! I knew it was it wasn't alive anymore. That what it was like on my grandma's farm!

Same. Yikes, I'd forgotten all about that. My gp's had a tree stump out in the backyard.
 
  • #569
I have a few questions regarding Jahi and hopefully you all understand I'm not being morbid - I have never watched a person pass away so I truly don't know what happens.

When Jahi does pass - which, in this case is a relative term since she's already dead, but you know what I mean - is her passing (given her condition) going to be something that appears as a quiet calm passing or is there potential to be a "not peaceful" passing involved lack of brain activity?

I just can't help but wonder what kind of chaos would ensue if this new medical facility doesn't have the capabilities to take extreme measures to keep her heart beating. When the brain has no activity, is it assumed that there wouldn't be gasping for air (since that would be a brain regulated "reflex" right?) or any signs of a "struggle" per se...??? Is this correct?

I'm trying to ask as PC as possible...I just wonder if when she passes the family would possibly see things that her body does in a response to death that could falsely lead them to think that those final moments were all the signs of her "coming back to them" culminating immediately to her passing.

Once this poor child is removed from the ventilator, she will simply cease to breathe. No gasp, no agonal respirations. IF she is on a heart monitor, her heart rate will slow. After a couple of minutes, her pulse will stop. Often, there will be what is termed PEA (pulseless electrical activity) on the monitor. No blood is being pumped, and the QRS complexes (the sharp up-and-down EKG spikes) will be come widened and blunted. Eventually (and it sometimes takes 10-15 minutes) even the PEA will stop.
 
  • #570
Well, if you look on the Muñoz case from Texas the husband said his wife's bones cracked when moved, and the smell of his wife had been replaced wit the smell of death. She was pronounced brain dead about 2 weeks before Jahi McMath, so I wouldn't doubt that the same conditions have or will be setting in for Jahi's body. Also the report from Heidi Flori on January 3rd about her respiratory secretions being malodorous. I don't imagine that is pleasant. :scared:




I'm on a Mac and the photos had the time I saved on my desktop, not the time the picture was taken on my iPhone.

I worked as a RN in an adult ICU for years. The smelly respiratory secretions thing for a patient on a vent was my one GAG trigger. I could do blood, vomit, diarrhea, etc., but those infected lung secretions would get me every time. Just looking at it in the suction cannister could trigger a gag in the back of my throat when I had to chart it. And suctioning...God help me. It was all I could do not to hurl. Some of the other ICU nurses referred to it as "lung butter" and I can't say I saw all that many patients survive conditions which had progressed to that point.

I know that doesn't sound very compassionate, but I think every nurse has a gag trigger, and sometimes nurses will have a bit of black humor to keep from going nuts...if you had empathy 100% of the time, you'd burn out in a big way I think.

Gallows humor in the trauma ICU of our county hospital was another animal all together. What a house of horrors. I had to leave when I started crying about various patients in my off time, had terrible insomnia, and my hair started falling out in handfuls.:hills:
 
  • #571
I have a few questions regarding Jahi and hopefully you all understand I'm not being morbid - I have never watched a person pass away so I truly don't know what happens.

When Jahi does pass - which, in this case is a relative term since she's already dead, but you know what I mean - is her passing (given her condition) going to be something that appears as a quiet calm passing or is there potential to be a "not peaceful" passing involved lack of brain activity?

I just can't help but wonder what kind of chaos would ensue if this new medical facility doesn't have the capabilities to take extreme measures to keep her heart beating. When the brain has no activity, is it assumed that there wouldn't be gasping for air (since that would be a brain regulated "reflex" right?) or any signs of a "struggle" per se...??? Is this correct?

I'm trying to ask as PC as possible...I just wonder if when she passes the family would possibly see things that her body does in a response to death that could falsely lead them to think that those final moments were all the signs of her "coming back to them" culminating immediately to her passing.

Once this poor child is removed from the ventilator, she will simply cease to breathe. No gasp, no agonal respirations. IF she is on a heart monitor, her heart rate will slow. After a couple of minutes, her pulse will stop. Often, there will be what is termed PEA (pulseless electrical activity) on the monitor. No blood is being pumped, and the QRS complexes (the sharp up-and-down EKG spikes) will be come widened and blunted. Eventually (and it sometimes takes 10-15 minutes) even the PEA will stop.

If Jahi's heart stops while she is on the ventilator, it depends on "how closely" she is being monitored, how quickly this is detected, and whether or not they have decided to try to do anything about it.

It is "possible" that her heart and other functions (like pulse oximetry) are not being monitored continuously, if she is in a long term care facility. We have no idea what they are monitoring, and the capabilities of the staff and the facility. Particularly if Mrs. Winkfield had decided not to try to do anything medically if her heart enters an abnormal rhythm-- for instance, if she is on palliative care, she may not be on typical ICU monitoring, but just have the ventilator cycling.

If she is receiving heart monitoring and pulse oximetry, and if appropriate alarm limits are enabled and audible, then if her heart enters an abnormal rate or rhythm, the alarms will sound as the limits are violated. Then the staff would have to decide if they are going to attempt to treat whatever is going on (with drugs, and intravenous fluids, and/ or electricity), or "let her go", or call 911, etc. I have no idea what they have decided to do.

If, for example, they have decided to "let her go", hopefully they will silence alarms, allow family to sit quietly with her body, hold her hands, etc, and at some point an appropriate staff member will quietly turn off the ventilator.

Very seldom does a heart go from a normal rhythm to complete stand still (asystole) abruptly-- it's more likely her heart would experience rate and rhythm abnormalities as a prelude to the final pings of electricity that precede asystole (standstill). That could be minutes, or hours. Often, the final bits of electricity can kick out for 15-20 min or more, once a rhythm has ceased. The other situation, as MMJ explained above, is that the heart continues to put out electricity, but there is no "squeeze" to produce a pulse that can be felt. That is a common ending, too, with that rhythm deteriorating to remnants of electricity that eventually stop.

There is no suffering for someone with brain death. Their color will become pale (most noticeable in the lips and inner mouth, and the palms, in someone with darker complexion), and the skin takes on an ashy, pale color as circulation ceases.

She wouldn't gasp or convulse, if that is what you're asking.

In fact, if she is not on a heart monitor or a pulse oximeter, the staff might not notice that her heart isn't beating well for some time. The vent will continue to cycle, even if her heart isn't beating well enough to circulate blood effectively, or if her blood pressure is very, very low.

I want to add that if she is in a home care, or long term care facility, that the monitors themselves are not as sophisticated as an ICU setting. They may not have any central telemetry monitoring-, but may have a type of transport bedside monitor- meaning, only when someone is in the room looking at her monitor would they be evaluating what is going on. We cannot assume what kind of monitoring her body is receiving, or not receiving, since there is really no "standard of care" for the level of care her body is receiving. Basically, they are free to do whatever monitoring they want, or are capable of doing. I doubt she has continuous arterial blood pressure monitoring, for example-- so may be on intermittent blood pressure cycling using an external cuff (such as a dynamap). They might set that to go off every one minute, or set it to go off every 15 min, or longer, etc. Or just manually cycle the automatic BP when they are in the room.I doubt they have noninvasive cardiac output capability (which uses the ventilator circuit to calculate cardiac output). All of this monitoring is dependent on having staff who understand how to do it, and how to interpret it. We just have no idea what the capabilities are where she is.
 
  • #572
I'm now getting an 'access denied' message when I click on the video link. Anyone else?

Yes, I've been playing catch up from the past few days & every time I click the link I get a page with code on it stating the same.


ETA: Thank you, Minou for the other link. That one worked :)
 
  • #573
In fact, if she is not on a heart monitor or a pulse oximeter, the staff might not notice that her heart isn't beating well for some time. The vent will continue to cycle, even if her heart isn't beating well enough to circulate blood effectively, or if her blood pressure is very, very low.

A friend of mine went to visit her mother in some kind of Christian Scientist "nursing home" where she had gone because she wasn't feeling well, did not want to go to a hospital, but needed a lot of care. My friend walked into the room and noted that her mother was sound asleep. She sat for awhile, read a magazine, reconciled her checkbook, etc. Mom never woke, so she went out to the "nurse's station" and told the woman there that her Mom had not had such a wonderful sleep in so long that she couldn't bear to wake her and could they let her mother know that she had come by? The woman said "no problem." By the time my friend got to her car and was putting the key in the lock, the woman ran up to my friend, breathless, and said, "Oh sweetheart, I just checked on your Mom and she must have passed while you were in the room." The nurse said that my friend's statement about her Mom being so peaceful suddenly got her attention, as she had been quite restless before that (congestive heart failure w/accompanying lung congestion).

Sans monitors and constant vigilance, it happened without my friend even realizing it. And she wasn't even brain dead at the outset.
 
  • #574
i need to find the link (on my iphone now) but experiments were done in the XVIII century applying electricity to the decapitated heads of guillotined criminals and having eyes open and close...so there might still be nerve activity but it does not mean the person is still alive


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
  • #575
I worked as a RN in an adult ICU for years. The smelly respiratory secretions thing for a patient on a vent was my one GAG trigger. I could do blood, vomit, diarrhea, etc., but those infected lung secretions would get me every time. Just looking at it in the suction cannister could trigger a gag in the back of my throat when I had to chart it. And suctioning...God help me. It was all I could do not to hurl. Some of the other ICU nurses referred to it as "lung butter" and I can't say I saw all that many patients survive conditions which had progressed to that point.

I know that doesn't sound very compassionate, but I think every nurse has a gag trigger, and sometimes nurses will have a bit of black humor to keep from going nuts...if you had empathy 100% of the time, you'd burn out in a big way I think.

Gallows humor in the trauma ICU of our county hospital was another animal all together. What a house of horrors. I had to leave when I started crying about various patients in my off time, had terrible insomnia, and my hair started falling out in handfuls.:hills:

I come from a family with quite a range of medical backgrounds, and I've considered over the years going into nursing. I was just discussing it with my husband tonight and said "I'd do it, but boogers and lung butter is my limit. Also I hate math." ... he rolled his eyes at the math part. :floorlaugh:

Reading all the things that have been posted here over the last 8 threads have led to a lot of researching and reading on my part, and put that "well... maaaaybe" notion back into my mind.
 
  • #576
i need to find the link (on my iphone now) but experiments were done in the XVIII century applying electricity to the decapitated heads of guillotined criminals and having eyes open and close...so there might still be nerve activity but it does not mean the person is still alive


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I posted this earlier in the thread, but if one were to apply a peripheral nerve stimulator to Jahi's body-- the hand and wrist area, for example, it would be quite easy to induce muscle twitching in response to electrical impulses. If you put the stimulator in certain positions, you can even induce a whole joint to flex or contract (like a wrist). This type of stimulation and response is independent of brain function. It would not be a "reaction" to pain, even though someone who isn't knowledgeable might be tempted to interpret it as "withdrawal to painful stimuli".

Here is a quick example.

[video=youtube;rnQDiDUuI3U]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnQDiDUuI3U[/video]
 
  • #577
Yes she is indeed dead. Just for thought... when I was a little girl I watched my grandmother cut off a chickens head and that chicken (without head) was able to run around the yard! I knew it was it wasn't alive anymore. That what it was like on my grandma's farm!

Nowdays, usually an animal is restrained before butchering, but they still do a lot of movements without the head, and if it is a human restraining them, you can feel how many movements just happen.
 
  • #578
Once this poor child is removed from the ventilator, she will simply cease to breathe. No gasp, no agonal respirations. IF she is on a heart monitor, her heart rate will slow. After a couple of minutes, her pulse will stop. Often, there will be what is termed PEA (pulseless electrical activity) on the monitor. No blood is being pumped, and the QRS complexes (the sharp up-and-down EKG spikes) will be come widened and blunted. Eventually (and it sometimes takes 10-15 minutes) even the PEA will stop.

MMJ, could you make any kind of an estimate about what Jahi's pulse ox numbers would be? thanks
 
  • #579

Someone's feet and toes move in the video but whose feet are they? There is no full scan from face to feet to demonstrate that it is Jahi after the operation whose feet are being shown in the video.

To me it looks like a reflex not a controlled movement, therefore, I wouldn't say someone necessarily moves her feet. I'd say someone's feet and toes move in a reflexive involuntary response to the stimuli. JMO, but I'd say it's inadequate to serve as evidence of anything. However, that will not stop people who believe Jahi is alive from thinking those are Jahi's feet and that Jahi is controlling the movements of her feet.

For me, I'd want to see a shot of Jahi's entire body, and for the stimulation to be NW's voice asking Jahi to move her feet, and for the feet to then move before I'd say that Jahi moves her feet.

There have been a few discussions of this video upthread and in previous threads by people who explain it very clearly.
 
  • #580
i need to find the link (on my iphone now) but experiments were done in the XVIII century applying electricity to the decapitated heads of guillotined criminals and having eyes open and close...so there might still be nerve activity but it does not mean the person is still alive


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Here are some other experiments with heads following decapitations, sort of historical urban legends too.

ttp://thechirurgeonsapprentice.com/2012/08/13/losing-ones-head-a-frustrating-search-for-the-truth-about-decapitation/

http://science.howstuffworks.com/science-vs-myth/extrasensory-perceptions/lucid-decapitation2.htm

http://www.lateralscience.co.uk/reanim/galvreanim2.html

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3884824
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
125
Guests online
2,840
Total visitors
2,965

Forum statistics

Threads
632,673
Messages
18,630,232
Members
243,245
Latest member
St33l
Back
Top