Deceased/Not Found Italy - Li Yinglei, 36, vanished from Mediterranean cruise, 10 Feb 2017 *husband guilty*

  • #101
This probably won't fit your format, Niner. You'll be excused.... ;)

One would expect him to be there, even more so for the verdict and the sentencing. But who knows, perhaps they'll send him a whatsapp....

Very, very strange. Most of the evidence is highly circumstantial, part of it is based on the absence of evidence, so the strategy of the prosecution should be to bring it all together in a compelling way, and not spread it like they do. Maybe it's a matter of planning and there are no other options, but still.

The Irish Independent was following the case and posting on twitter, but even they seem to have given up.

No, it will not fit into my format! LOL! And thanks for excusing me.... :)

Laughing at - that they will send him a whatsapp! :D

I'll just keep looking for articles to see if there will be any updates. Maybe the middle of next week.

We will probably get tired as the Irish Independent....
 
  • #102
@ZaZara - was wondering if you could find any current articles as I am just coming up with May ones on what is going on with his trial?

TIA! :)
 
  • #103
@ZaZara - was wondering if you could find any current articles as I am just coming up with May ones on what is going on with his trial?

TIA! :)

Come what May, not June!

Even the Irish Independent lets us down.
 
  • #104
  • #105
This came up on my alerts - but nothing about the trial...


July 16, 2022
A man who claimed his missing wife was behind a scheme to falsify documents to get a mortgage has avoided jail.

Daniel Belling, 49, pleaded guilty on his trial date to one count of dishonestly inducing the Bank of Ireland to providing a mortgage loan of €112,500 in March 2014.
[.....]
Passing sentence yesterday, Judge Martin Nolan said this offence was a 'classic whitecollar crime'. The judge said that while Belling said his wife, who has been missing since 2017, was the driver of the scheme, he would take that explanation 'with a pinch of salt'.
[.....]
Judge Nolan said he had reluctantly decided not to jail Belling, of Kilkee House Coolock, Dublin 17. He sentenced him to three-and-a-half years but suspended it fully.
 
  • #106
I guess the trial is ongoing, but nothing to update about it.

Received this article in my alerts though.

 
  • #107
Not getting any recent articles on this case -

@ZaZara - how about you - anything NEW on this? :)

Last update I have is from Monday, May 2, 2022...
 
  • #108
Not getting any recent articles on this case -

@ZaZara - how about you - anything NEW on this? :)

Last update I have is from Monday, May 2, 2022...

The trial in Italy is mentioned in the Irish press in July in an article about DB being convicted of fraud in Ireland. He was given a suspended sentence of 3.5 years.

The interesting bit is this - IMO it might also apply to the Missing Person's Case in Italy:

Man accused of killing wife on cruise ship claims she was behind scheme to falsify mortgage documents

Det Gda Seberry told Róisín Lacey SC, defending, that Belling is the primary carer for his two sons, aged nine and 10, both born in Ireland. The court heard Belling was born in Germany and lived there for much of his life.


Ms Lacey told the court that Belling had an exceptional worth ethic and had worked in technical support for companies including Xerox, Canada Life, Hewlett Packard, Microsoft and most recently Apple, where he worked from 2012 to 2017.


The court heard Belling had a degree in computer science from DIT and had also done some training to be a nurse.


Ms Lacey said her client has been unemployed since 2017 and home-schools both his children.


He is not on social welfare in Ireland but claims welfare allowances from Germany.


A psychiatric report handed to the court showed that Belling had been an inpatient for depressive illnesses in Berlin as a result of suicide ideation and that although treatment had been successful, he still suffers from long-term depressive disorders and passivity.


Ms Lacey said the report showed that Belling had been subjected to “conditioning” from both a domineering mother and a domineering wife. His father died when he was two years old, and his mother remarried an alcoholic.


She said Belling’s wife had been listed as a missing person since 2017 and that both Belling and his wife had obtained safety orders against each other during the course of their 17-year marriage.


“Their relationship was tempestuous,” said Ms Lacey.

She said although Belling has taken full responsibility, the plan to dishonestly gain mortgages had emanated from his wife, who knew Chinese people involved in forgery and liaised with them to forge the fake documents, payslips and ID card.


BBM
 
  • #109
Thank you @ZaZara for that update!
 
  • #110
A man accused of murdering his missing wife on a cruise ship says she could be being held captive by a Josef Fritzl-type monster.

German national Daniel Belling (49), who is living in Coolock, Dublin, is on trial in absentia in Italy — accused of murdering his missing wife Xing-Li (38) while they were on a Mediterranean cruise in February 2017

But now her husband says that even if she does turn up alive, he doesn’t want to live with her.

“It would be great, yeah, but only if you could live in two different locations. So not together in the same apartment because that would be too oppressive for me,” he told us in an exclusive interview.

He also told us that he believes it’s possible she is being held captive — citing infamous Austrian kidnappers Wolfgang Priklopil and Josef Fritzl as examples.

“Do you know the story of this crazy guy in Austria? I think his name was Priklopil. Josef Fritzl was another one.

“It was crazy. It could have happened to her, something like that,” Mr Belling told us.

Mr Belling, who denies murdering his wife, also revealed that his relationship with her was strained before she vanished.

Asked if he’d like to get answers as to what happened to her and get her back, Mr Belling said: “Definitely I would really appreciate it if she would come back and then two separate locations where we live.”

Mr Belling also claimed that she might have returned to China and is living there today.

Asked if he misses his wife, Mr Belling responded by saying it was “complicated.”
 
  • #111
Trial scheduled to resume mid-month (April!)

Moglie sparita in crociera, il marito accusato di averla gettata in mare chiusa in una valigia: “Ci ha abbandonati lei” - Il Riformista

Wife disappeared on a cruise, husband accused of throwing her overboard in a suitcase: 'She abandoned us'

They had set off together with the whole family on a peace-building cruise from Genoa in February 2017 along the coast of the Mediterranean Sea. But when the ship arrived at the last stop, the mother of that little family was gone. It sounds like the plot of a mystery novel, but instead it is an actual event that happened between 10 and 13 February 2017. The woman's name is Li Yingley, 37 years old of Chinese origin. On trial for that mysterious disappearance is her husband, the German former computer scientist Daniel Belling, 49, who is accused of murder and destruction of a corpse. He allegedly killed his wife and then disposed of her body at sea. But the man, who ended up in prison and was then sent to Dublin under house arrest, where he lived with his young children with his wife and, strangely enough, his mother-in-law, has always rejected all charges, claiming that it was his wife who had decided to abandon her family by taking advantage of one of the stops on that cruise.

According to a report in Il Secolo XIX, the public prosecutor's office recently imposed an obligation for residence on Daniel Belling, who is accused of murder and flew to Ireland after prison. The trial is scheduled to resume mid-month. The defence meanwhile confirms its hypothesis: 'She went back to China.'

RomaToday has reconstructed the mysterious affair. The family boarded the cruise ship in Genoa on 9 February 2017. On the 10th Li was seen in the ship's restaurant at dinnertime with her husband and children. From 8pm onwards, there is no trace of her. However, her absence is only made official upon the ship's arrival in Civitavecchia on 22 February when the ship's staff realise that the woman is no longer on board thanks to the passenger counting system on board.

According to the prosecution, it was the husband who killed the woman and then disposed of the body by putting it in a suitcase, which was then thrown from the ship into the open sea. Suspicion immediately fell on the man because of some of his peculiar behaviours, such as the fact that he did not report his wife's disappearance immediately and on arrival in Civitavecchia he immediately went to the airport to catch the first flight home, without bothering to find out what had happened to his wife or give any explanation. The man always admitted, however, that there had been disagreements between them for some time. That family cruise was supposed to serve as a means of reconciliation. Belling has always rejected the accusations, claiming that his wife took advantage of the cruise to leave him and the children during a stopover and disappear.

But among the dark points of the story is the moment when the man allegedly killed his wife and then disposed of the body in the open sea. Is it possible that the ship's sophisticated video surveillance systems did not record anything? Just as possible that the same video surveillance systems never even caught the woman again on a date after 10 February? Where did Li end up?

Another knot concerns the cabin. When the ship docked in Civitavecchia on 22 February, the investigators requested to search the couple's cabin for clues. To their amazement, they found that the room had already been re-assigned and then cleaned from top to bottom, effectively wiping out any hypothetical evidence or clues that might still be at the hypothetical crime scene.


Added to this is the fact that, according to the investigators, if Belling had killed and put his wife in a suitcase and then disposed of her by throwing her off the cabin balcony, she would have ended up on the 12-metre-wide deck below and not in the sea. Belling, on the other hand, could have walked out of the cabin with the suitcase to one of the corridor doors which, if opened, would have allowed something to be thrown overboard unimpeded, but no camera recorded such a scene. The investigation also revealed a recording of the use of a card in Li Yinglei's name along an Irish motorway on 23 March, i.e. almost two weeks after Belling had been arrested and transferred to Regine Coeli prison. Hence the speculation that the woman may indeed have fled to perhaps return to China. A mystery still unsolved for the time being.

BBM



This report is dated April 4, 2023. Cannot find any confirmation that the trial did resume.
 
  • #112
Trial scheduled to resume mid-month (April!)

Moglie sparita in crociera, il marito accusato di averla gettata in mare chiusa in una valigia: “Ci ha abbandonati lei” - Il Riformista

Wife disappeared on a cruise, husband accused of throwing her overboard in a suitcase: 'She abandoned us'

They had set off together with the whole family on a peace-building cruise from Genoa in February 2017 along the coast of the Mediterranean Sea. But when the ship arrived at the last stop, the mother of that little family was gone. It sounds like the plot of a mystery novel, but instead it is an actual event that happened between 10 and 13 February 2017. The woman's name is Li Yingley, 37 years old of Chinese origin. On trial for that mysterious disappearance is her husband, the German former computer scientist Daniel Belling, 49, who is accused of murder and destruction of a corpse. He allegedly killed his wife and then disposed of her body at sea. But the man, who ended up in prison and was then sent to Dublin under house arrest, where he lived with his young children with his wife and, strangely enough, his mother-in-law, has always rejected all charges, claiming that it was his wife who had decided to abandon her family by taking advantage of one of the stops on that cruise.

According to a report in Il Secolo XIX, the public prosecutor's office recently imposed an obligation for residence on Daniel Belling, who is accused of murder and flew to Ireland after prison. The trial is scheduled to resume mid-month. The defence meanwhile confirms its hypothesis: 'She went back to China.'

RomaToday has reconstructed the mysterious affair. The family boarded the cruise ship in Genoa on 9 February 2017. On the 10th Li was seen in the ship's restaurant at dinnertime with her husband and children. From 8pm onwards, there is no trace of her. However, her absence is only made official upon the ship's arrival in Civitavecchia on 22 February when the ship's staff realise that the woman is no longer on board thanks to the passenger counting system on board.

According to the prosecution, it was the husband who killed the woman and then disposed of the body by putting it in a suitcase, which was then thrown from the ship into the open sea. Suspicion immediately fell on the man because of some of his peculiar behaviours, such as the fact that he did not report his wife's disappearance immediately and on arrival in Civitavecchia he immediately went to the airport to catch the first flight home, without bothering to find out what had happened to his wife or give any explanation. The man always admitted, however, that there had been disagreements between them for some time. That family cruise was supposed to serve as a means of reconciliation. Belling has always rejected the accusations, claiming that his wife took advantage of the cruise to leave him and the children during a stopover and disappear.

But among the dark points of the story is the moment when the man allegedly killed his wife and then disposed of the body in the open sea. Is it possible that the ship's sophisticated video surveillance systems did not record anything? Just as possible that the same video surveillance systems never even caught the woman again on a date after 10 February? Where did Li end up?

Another knot concerns the cabin. When the ship docked in Civitavecchia on 22 February, the investigators requested to search the couple's cabin for clues. To their amazement, they found that the room had already been re-assigned and then cleaned from top to bottom, effectively wiping out any hypothetical evidence or clues that might still be at the hypothetical crime scene.


Added to this is the fact that, according to the investigators, if Belling had killed and put his wife in a suitcase and then disposed of her by throwing her off the cabin balcony, she would have ended up on the 12-metre-wide deck below and not in the sea. Belling, on the other hand, could have walked out of the cabin with the suitcase to one of the corridor doors which, if opened, would have allowed something to be thrown overboard unimpeded, but no camera recorded such a scene. The investigation also revealed a recording of the use of a card in Li Yinglei's name along an Irish motorway on 23 March, i.e. almost two weeks after Belling had been arrested and transferred to Regine Coeli prison. Hence the speculation that the woman may indeed have fled to perhaps return to China. A mystery still unsolved for the time being.

BBM



This report is dated April 4, 2023. Cannot find any confirmation that the trial did resume.

Not sure I've ever followed a case that has been more difficult to find details than this one. I get other country's laws are different (he doesn't need to be present for trial) but even finding even the most basic info has been weird in this case.
 
  • #113
Tell me about it - re following this case & not finding anything for details on ongoing trial. Seems they do not have trial everyday - they like to spread it out! LOL! :D

This quote from the article that @ZaZara posted:

The investigation also revealed a recording of the use of a card in Li Yinglei's name along an Irish motorway on 23 March, i.e. almost two weeks after Belling had been arrested and transferred to Regine Coeli prison. Hence the speculation that the woman may indeed have fled to perhaps return to China. A mystery still unsolved for the time being.

Sounds like she DID get off by herself - if he was in jail at the time - then there is no way he could have used her card....

I too think she is in China.
 
  • #114
I shall move my notes to April - too bad they do not give us a date. I had this in May of 2022!! That is how long this has been going on....
 
  • #115
I shall move my notes to April - too bad they do not give us a date. I had this in May of 2022!! That is how long this has been going on....

It's April 30 today! How many days do you think there are left for a trial to resume this month?

:oops:
 
  • #116
It's April 30 today! How many days do you think there are left for a trial to resume this month?

:oops:

LOL!

A BIG ZERO!! :D

I think I have given up on this case... Same with the old lady re Nazi camp. I don't think I have a resolution on that case either. Or did she get a probated sentence - no time to serve?
 
  • #117
LOL!

A BIG ZERO!! :D

I think I have given up on this case... Same with the old lady re Nazi camp. I don't think I have a resolution on that case either. Or did she get a probated sentence - no time to serve?

The old lady in de nazi camp got a suspended sentence with 5 years probation, if I remember well, and she has appealed her conviction. IMO it makes sense to let that case go.

This case however, about the missing mother, could be so interesting. Very frustrating that there is hardly any news, and whatever there is, is mostly repetition. But at least there is a trial. Italian LE moved in and started an investigation.
And that is quite something, given that this happened on a cruise. IMO there are many cases where disappearances from cruise ships aren't even investigated because the jurisdiction is unclear, or the ship is registered in the Philipines (for instance), the alleged crime or disappearance took place in international waters .... etc. Do a little googling on cruise and crime and you will find many stories.
 
  • #118
I am going to go ahead & post this - who knows what is going on with this case... These are my notes, so might not be all that happened! At least I can shorten it up a bit! :)


Sometime in April:
*Trial continues (@ am CET) - Rome, Italy – Li Yinglei “Angie” (Xing Lei Li) (36) (Feb. 10, 2017, vanished from Mediterranean cruise, Rome; still missing) – Daniel Belling (45/now 50), DH arrested (2/11/17) on suspicion of murder; vanished off Med cruise, plead not guilty. A German citizen working in Ireland, where he has been accused of fraud. Released from prison (4/24/18). Charged (7/16/20) with 1 count of homicide & 1 count of alleged destruction of wife’s body while on cruise.
Trial began on May 10, 2022.
Faces another year in prison, while pros investigate case; Judge will decide Jan. 26, 2018, postponed. Judge gave him 6 more months of detention. April 24, 2018 was released from prison.

Court info from Feb. 11, 2017 thru Sept. 30, 2021 & Trial days Nov. 29 to Dec. 24 reference post #89 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...se-10-feb-2017-husband-arrested.330422/page-5

May 9, 2022: Monday, Belling told an Italian judge that he & his wife had fought & that she wanted to “quit the trip”. He went on to claim that his wife left the ship when he & the children joined a shore excursion. Mr. Belling described her as a “cruel person” for allowing him to spend 14 months in jail for a crime “she knows I did not commit”. “I think my wife is most probably in China. There is a small probability something happened her in Greece, but I believe she is in China. I think she knows I have been in jail.” Mr. Belling's lawyer Luigi Conti said that the trial has started to hear evidence from witnesses. "Next month we will hear from the captain of the ship [MSC Magnifica]," he said. "Things have been proceeding well. Mr. Belling has not been in attendance. In Italy you can choose whether or not to attend your own trial." It is understood that while in jail, Mr. Belling made a number of phone calls to his nephew in Germany as well as his mother in law, You Xiangzhen. These were recorded & an application has been made to have them transcribed & produced as evidence. At the same hearing, Ms. You filed a civil action against Mr. Belling, seeking damages if he is convicted of killing her daughter. Mr. Conti said he has submitted the defence witness list to court, which includes "personnel from Tusla". Mr. Belling is currently in Ireland.
Will start posting this only weekly on Mondays since no news outlets are giving updates on trial unless there are some developments in case.

4/4/23 Update: The trial is scheduled to resume mid-month in April (no date given).
 
Last edited:
  • #119
got this article in my goog alerts.


Aug. 30, 2023
A man who is accused of murdering his wife on a cruise ship says he’s considering changing his name — as he can’t get a job in Ireland.

Daniel Belling, 49, who is living in Coolock, is accused in Italy of murdering his missing wife Xing-Li, 38, while they were on a Mediterranean cruise in February 2017. But Belling, who has refused to travel to Italy to face trial, says he still has no intention of handing himself over to the authorities — and now he’s struggling to find any work here in Ireland because of the case.
[.....]
He then said: “Maybe I need to change my name or something.” Belling is technically already on trial in Italy — despite not being present there himself.

He now believes the trial is set to resume in the coming weeks, where hundreds of witnesses have in the meantime given statements which are being gathered by prosecutors. But Belling believes there is “no evidence” against him.



and that is about it. Looks like the trial is set to resume - but does not say when...

I think I will give up on this one.
 
  • #120
A rose by any name .....

This is so silly you would almost forget that a woman and mother has never been heard of again.
Not even her own mother is demanding justice for her daughter. Money for herself ... yes. And that is about it.
Didn't Li Yinglei have any friends to stand up for her?

Very strange case. Just leave your alerts open, Niner. Maybe one day we'll catch the big prize.
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
114
Guests online
2,988
Total visitors
3,102

Forum statistics

Threads
632,556
Messages
18,628,381
Members
243,195
Latest member
CaseyClosed
Back
Top