Missouri - The Springfield Three--missing since June 1992 - #8

[MooseMeMuch]

We have proved it, their actions are not normal and if it needs repeating time and time again I am happy to do so.


At least Janis McCall has had the balls to
admit that they shouldn’t of been in that house that day and she was extremely uncomfortable being there from the get go.

Janelle from reports I have read oddly has never shown such remorse about her actions that day.

You confirmed yourself that Mike Hensen knew the grave robbers so that’s one of my theory’s.


ETA - also for all Janelle claiming they were friends it’s funny how in the 3 months Suzie lived at that new address that Janelle had never been inside that house.

I don't believe Janelle is a cold blooded killer. But something smells concerning the behavior exhibited by her, Mike and various classmates that dropped by Sherrill and Suzie's home off/on that Sunday.

What bugs me the most.....after finding the broken globe, open/unlocked door, purses, keys, cigs, dog locked in the bathroom, cars in the driveway but no people at the residence......Janelle did not use the phone to call Janis.

Janelle answered the phone.....2 x's but no effort to call her friend's mom. The 2 girls had known each other since they were 4 years old.
That's what gives me.....pause.

What if Stacy had been your daughter?

 

[MooseMeMuch]

If you think that’s how a friend refers to another close friend then nothing I can say will change your mind.

I find it distasteful that in one breath Janelle claims they are close friends but in a video does not even have the common curtesy to refer to her friend by name which is Suzie. The friend that has been kidnapped and more than likely killed by this stage.

I have never claimed she killed them but I think she knows something.

IMO

'
Broke my heart for Suzie too.
'the other girl'...

 

[Alexsea]

Did Nigel go to school with Suzie and Stacy?

I believe Nigel worked with Suzie at the movie theater, but I’d have to hunt to validate that. Not sure about school, my impression is that Nigel was older.

 

[Missouri Mule]

If you think that’s how a friend refers to another close friend then nothing I can say will change your mind.

I find it distasteful that in one breath Janelle claims they are close friends but in a video does not even have the common curtesy to refer to her friend by name which is Suzie. The friend that has been kidnapped and more than likely killed by this stage.

I have never claimed she killed them but I think she knows something.

IMO

Just so I completely understand this, what exactly did she say? There was a third close friend named Nigel. Could she had been the “other girl?”

Nigel, I believe, was the closest friend that Suzie had.

I don’t even know that Nigel or Janelle knew one another. That might explain this “other girl” controversy. I doubt that Janelle knew who Nigel was, hence, the offhand “other girl’ business.

I’m thinking she was the one who said that Suzie always parked in the carport, Suzie’s bedroom was an original garage converted into a bedroom which explains why the bedroom was a step down to floor level.

That begs the question why Sherrill’s car was parked there. The obvious answer (to me at least) is she did not expect Suzie to return from Branson until late Saturday or sometime Sunday.

 

[HmmWhoKnows]

For those with the Mike/Janelle theory, let me get this straight: you don’t think Janelle or Mike killed anyone but you think they were the cleanup crew for some other people?

And so then who is the real killer/abductor?

Let’s hear it.

 

[Alexsea]

For those with the Mike/Janelle theory, let me get this straight: you don’t think Janelle or Mike killed anyone but you think they were the cleanup crew for some other people?

And so then who is the real killer/abductor?

Let’s hear it.

I’m not gonna be popular for this, and I do think Mike and Janelle acted strangely. But I think we’re attributing adult thought processes to a couple teen-agers. I don’t know how mature they were, and therefore, im not sure how much we can credibly judge their behavior. Just another thought...on the other hand, teens can be easily manipulated, and that’s worth considering as well.

 

[Talullah]

I think Janelle dreaded telling Janis where Stacy stayed and answering a bunch of questions-so I understand if she wasn’t in a hurry to speak with her. I don’t understand how she didn’t realize something was wrong. It’s hard to reference my teenage mind but I think seeing their cars and their things inside would’ve freaked me out.

 

[HmmWhoKnows]

The Janelle angle is a red herring.

Just like the green van, the bearded suspect, etc.

And that’s why they lead nowhere. If those kids did this, the crime would have solved a long time ago. They wouldn’t be able to contain themselves with all that guilt. While a cop is friends with them. While Janis is over at their family functions. I don’t believe it. Someone would roll.

I think someone with lots of power took an interest in Sherrill.

Find out who Sherrill dated or had over in those two months and you will find out what happened.

 

[MooseMeMuch]

I believe Nigel worked with Suzie at the movie theater, but I’d have to hunt to validate that. Not sure about school, my impression is that Nigel was older.

yes, they worked together at the movie theater
yes, Nigel is older.

 

[MooseMeMuch]

Just so I completely understand this, what exactly did she say? There was a third close friend named Nigel. Could she had been the “other girl?”

Nigel, I believe, was the closest friend that Suzie had.

I don’t even know that Nigel or Janelle knew one another. That might explain this “other girl” controversy. I doubt that Janelle knew who Nigel was, hence, the offhand “other girl’ business.

I’m thinking she was the one who said that Suzie always parked in the carport, Suzie’s bedroom was an original garage converted into a bedroom which explains why the bedroom was a step down to floor level.

That begs the question why Sherrill’s car was parked there. The obvious answer (to me at least) is she did not expect Suzie to return from Branson until late Saturday or sometime Sunday.

hmmm, I thought it was something about Stacy spending the night with 'the other girl'.

Nigel seemed like a very sweet, sincerely grief stricken, person.

 

[Talullah]

The only indication of something going on in Sherrill’s life that I’m aware of is Stacy saying to someone at the gym where she worked that she was scared for Sherrill. Why Stacy discussed Sherrill with someone at her job is another can of worms.

 

[MooseMeMuch]

I think Janelle dreaded telling Janis where Stacy stayed and answering a bunch of questions-so I understand if she wasn’t in a hurry to speak with her. I don’t understand how she didn’t realize something was wrong. It’s hard to reference my teenage mind but I think seeing their cars and their things inside would’ve freaked me out.

Most likely you're right on not wanting to answer a bunch of questions and the dread.
Janelle said it was creepy but that's as far as it went.
If only she had called Janis...this case may have been solved by now.

 

[k-mac]

Just so I completely understand this, what exactly did she say? There was a third close friend named Nigel. Could she had been the “other girl?”

Nigel, I believe, was the closest friend that Suzie had.

I don’t even know that Nigel or Janelle knew one another. That might explain this “other girl” controversy. I doubt that Janelle knew who Nigel was, hence, the offhand “other girl’ business.

I’m thinking she was the one who said that Suzie always parked in the carport, Suzie’s bedroom was an original garage converted into a bedroom which explains why the bedroom was a step down to floor level.

That begs the question why Sherrill’s car was parked there. The obvious answer (to me at least) is she did not expect Suzie to return from Branson until late Saturday or sometime Sunday.

there is no confusion so no need to muddy the waters here.

Janelle stated in a video interview that her friend stacy stayed at the other girls house.
that girl she was referring to is suzie.

if you are confused maybe you should take a look at the video.

 

[Missouri Mule]

I believe Nigel worked with Suzie at the movie theater, but I’d have to hunt to validate that. Not sure about school, my impression is that Nigel was older.

yes, they worked together at the movie theater
yes, Nigel is older.

I believe you are correct.

 

[Missouri Mule]

there is no confusion so no need to muddy the waters here.

Janelle stated in a video interview that her friend stacy stayed at the other girls house.
that girl she was referring to is suzie.

if you are confused maybe you should take a look at the video.

Does it really matter?

 

[Alexsea]

Delete. Silly moment. Sorry.

 

[MooseMeMuch]

The only indication of something going on in Sherrill’s life that I’m aware of is Stacy saying to someone at the gym where she worked that she was scared for Sherrill. Why Stacy discussed Sherrill with someone at her job is another can of worms.

And if Stacy mentioned being scared for Sherrill...the recipient would surely ask 'why' but so far I haven't heard any reason.

 

[MooseMeMuch]

Does it really matter?

"The girl" is an acquaintance.
Calling her "Suzie" would be a friend.

Does that 'slip' have anything to do with the abduction? no
But it makes me distrust her.
It's just......complicated.

 

[Talullah]

And if Stacy mentioned being scared for Sherrill...the recipient would surely ask 'why' but so far I haven't heard any reason.

I haven’t seen any follow up on that but it makes me doubt Janelle’s claim that Stacy being with Suzie that night was a freak situation. Why would anyone be concerned for the safety of a “sort of” friend’s mom? I believe Stacy and Suzie and possibly Sherrill spent more time together than people, especially Janelle, wanted to admit. Stacy might’ve admired Sherrill and Suzie’s relationship. Janelle could’ve easily felt left out and jealous, and though I don’t think anyone would kill over that, it could’ve made a teenage girl easier to manipulate.

 

[MooseMeMuch]

The Janelle angle is a red herring.

Just like the green van, the bearded suspect, etc.

And that’s why they lead nowhere. If those kids did this, the crime would have solved a long time ago. They wouldn’t be able to contain themselves with all that guilt. While a cop is friends with them. While Janis is over at their family functions. I don’t believe it. Someone would roll.

I think someone with lots of power took an interest in Sherrill.

Find out who Sherrill dated or had over in those two months and you will find out what happened.

You could be right. Someone in a political position?
Sherrill posed a threat to their career? But why take all 3? Perhaps it was all planned out to abduct Sherrill but then there were 2 unexpected people that would be witnesses so they had to go too.