First time responding to this thread but longtime reader....
A few questions/thoughts....
I'm still unsure of how I feel after reading every single thread about DD/GB...
For those that think she should be set free.... Obviously she has no education how will she support herself? In some way or another she has learned the art of manipulation from DD who is to say she will not carry on manipulating others as I'm sure plenty feel bad for her for what she has been through rightfully so but at what point can it not be used as an excuse and she be held accountable as an adult? MOO she needs mental help extensively.
If she was sheltered and not allowed to do anything where would the dark sexual side come from? She obviously had plenty of time on the Internet and chatted frequently with strangers and had friends. How do we know for sure DD sheltered her so much. Maybe DD let her have her own time in return for GB keeping the ruse up? I will let you do this if you keep doing that mentality.....
Last, for those who think it is all DD's fault she was murdered? What do we really know about her? What was her childhood like? Was these learned traits from her mother that she carried on to her daughter? What was their relationship like in that house when it was just them?
I don't think there's one person here who thinks Gypsy should simply be set free. She is likely damaged beyond repair. Years in a mental institution would probably be best. She's ruined.
Also medical torture in the guise of "love" is enough to cause any child to develop a dark sexual side over time.
As as far as their relationship in the house, and whether Gypsy was "in on it" as many have suggested, I really urge everyone who hasn't to delve into the sick world of medical abuse, if you think you can handle it. IMO it explains a lot.
The relationships are complex. I think it is very rare that a child in this situstion, even as an adult, is "in on it". Having been raised in a world of domination, control, and love given only in the context of the attention or gifts the mother can glean from the medical abuse, the kids grow to become twisted and incapable often of breaking free. They may know internally that they can walk, for example, but having been told forever that they can't and having doctors agree, they
may have trouble determining reality.
And this is even so when they have evidence that they can move their legs, for example. It is more so because the mother will control them- punishing them for walking, or for moving their legs, either physically or by withholding love and then rewarding them for conforming to the "expectations". But this is not done in the way people keep repeating here: "You'll get in trouble for fraud if you don't play along." Or "We won't get gifts if you tell the truth." That's not what happens in these situations.
An example I recall was a 10 year old boy whose mother kept exaggerating his medical condition. He had a contentious relationship with his mother, and would snap to, just like Gypsy, acting "sick" whenever his mother was in the room, complaining of symptoms and agreeing with her when she was there. When removed from her care, he refused at first to believe he was okay. Eventually his symptoms cleared.
A better example of what happens is a kid, let's say like Gypsy, in the doctors office waiting for the doctor to come in. She moves her legs a bit. Mother grabs her hard looms in and pinches her somewhere while saying in a menacing and sinister tone, "You know you're not well. Your legs can't move. Try that again and you'll face the consequences."
Juxtapose that with what happens when the doctor comes in and Gypsy "confirms" the diagnosis- The mother fawns over her, pets her, buys her a treat after.
These kids typically know subconsciously that they aren't as sick as their mother says but they are psychologically incapable of admitting the truth to themselves or others for fear of losing their mother's love or being harmed by their parent. These are very, very scary parents and their hildren typically live a life desperately seeking their love, and with it the hope that mommy won't hurt them, while feeling quiet feelings of terror, sensing what mommy can do to them.
It is complex and quite evil and what Gypsy was raised in since early childhood. To expect her to be able to suddenly and magically figure it all out and extricate herself from the situation at age 18, is unreasonable.
There are a lot of case studies out there and books and two threads of such cases right here on websleuths. To understand Gypsy I think it's necessary to know something about these cases.