Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[rebel123]

Yes. But the phone needs to be on. Often they're smart enough to turn it off.

I 'caveated' the post with 'if'. Also, it seems that the 'person' isn't skilled i.e. using twigs to cover doorbell camera etc. So who knows where he's also 'stumbled'.

 

[sdmike1974]

Ashleigh Banfield's source's name for the "person of interest" (from a week and a half ago) in the disappearance of NG remains the same. (The son-in-law?)
https://youtu.be/cp1bRgdtHU8?t=1054

IMO, then at some earlier point the masked man in the video (Carlos?) was hired to remove 'mom' from her house.

Such a sad & cruel saga.

 

[SUNchips]

The thing is that those features aren't 'unique'. If you took the male population of Tucson, Arizona, then there will no doubt be other males who share the same physical characteristics .

Sure, but other men who look similar are not the last person to see Nancy and their homes/neighborhoods haven’t been searched nonstop by LE for the past two weeks.

I just can’t shake the feeling that he’s involved somehow. With all the public scrutiny he’s getting you’d think they’d want to clear his name, but for some reason they haven’t. All my opinion.

 

[shonyakay]

(I'm sorry if this already has been posted)

Look at this neighbour ring video, the man fits the description very well!

He walks the same, bends over the same and has the eyes and facial hair exactly like in the Nancy cctv vid!! - IMO

https://twitter.com/x/status/2022166579614826908

They both have a soul patch too.

 

[shonyakay]

View attachment 644471I think it’s SIL. The outline around the eyes on the mask is covering the top portion of the eyebrows. But you can see that the brows are nearly a unibrow. You can also see the shape of the head is very similar. The eyes are spaced apart the same. And the gray beard hairs are sticking out of the mask, indicating this is a long, full beard. You can also see the wrinkles under the eye indicating this is not a young man.

The chins don't appear to be the same. SiL has a noticeably longer chin imo.

 

[Sessiebo]

They both have a soul patch too.

IMO - yeah to me the resemblance is incredibly uncanny, this could really be the guy

 

[britinsussex]

We need to remember that NG's home has minimal street lighting by law. Pima County has strict outdoor lighting ordinances to protect astronomical observations. ****STATUTES TITLE 49, CHAPTER SEVEN IS THE "DARK SKY ORDINANCE.” Passed in 1987, the law states that all nonconforming yard or porch lights must be off from midnight until dawn to give amateur astronomers and stargazers a chance to enjoy the beauty of nighttime Arizona skies. http://www.mca-az.com/DARK_SKY_ORDINANCE.pdf

 

[mrjitty]

I would not react to the supposed FBI vs State Law Enforcement media panic. This comes up in a lot of long running cases. There are good reasons why local forces like help from the FBI which has some specialist resources, but don't want to hand over the whole case - which after all, is in their jurisdiction.

As far as we know, there is a decent chance this was a rando - e,g burglary gone wrong, home invader etc, in which case tracking him down could take some time. Keep in mind it took 6 weeks to identify and arrest Kohberger.

Other types of cases with staging etc can take even longer. Indeed one can find numerous cases where it can take months or years to find the victim. Many times, simply because the perp got lucky despite heavy resource investment at state and federal level.

My opinion, based on a few major cases, where the victim is missing.

 

[shonyakay]

DBM

 

[SUNchips]

The chins don't appear to be the same. SiL has a noticeably longer chin imo.

Because his beard makes it appear longer, if he scrunched down his beard into the mask his chin would then look shorter than usual, as it does imo.

I’m not saying it’s definitely him, but it sure could be. If AB outed it before LE was ready to that could botch their investigation though.

 

[shonyakay]

Ashleigh Banfield's source for the name of the "person of interest" (from a week and a half ago) in the disappearance of NG remains the same. (The son-in-law?)
https://youtu.be/cp1bRgdtHU8?t=1054

IMO, then the masked man in the video (Carlos?) was hired to remove 'mom' from her house.

Such a sad & cruel saga.

Cringe.

Everytime AB mentions her "source" take a drink.

Why is she still publicly stating this when this investigation is already a hot mess?

Edited: That is just my take from the outside looking in.

 

[42wallabyhenway]

Are you sure it wasn't in the day? UTC would be around noon local time.
This is a private helicopter. However, it could be searching for Nancy.

Ope, you’re right, I’ll adjust my wording for the time! Thank you

 

[Tortoise]

(I'm sorry if this already has been posted)

Look at this neighbour ring video, the man fits the description very well!

He walks the same, bends over the same and has the eyes and facial hair exactly like in the Nancy cctv vid!! - IMO

https://twitter.com/x/status/2022166579614826908

I think that could be a phone in his back pocket.

 

[su5ie]

I took screenshots from the January 23rd doorbell cam in Tucson that was linked to a few posts ago. Who knows if it’s related, but the guy really could match the NG abductor images quite well. I hope he’s being ruled in or out.

Thank you , eyes are very similar imo

 

[ArabianLover]

The chins don't appear to be the same. SiL has a noticeably longer chin imo.

In the known photo of him he’s got a full beard hanging down. Difficult to see exactly where the chin line actually is. Wearing a ski mask, that tightens up that beard showing the true outline of the chin.

So yes, I agree with you. But there’s an explanation why the don’t look the same.

 

[CrimeDawg123]

Sure, but other men who look similar are not the last person to see Nancy and their homes/neighborhoods haven’t been searched nonstop by LE for the past two weeks.

I just can’t shake the feeling that he’s involved somehow. With all the public scrutiny he’s getting you’d think they’d want to clear his name, but for some reason they haven’t. All my opinion.

They haven't cleared other family either, they haven't cleared the church friend who "supposedly" said she was missing from the service, they haven't cleared neighbours who live - right there. They haven't cleared anyone.

 

[Laura Avery]

In regards to the eyes, to me it looks like eyeliner is applied or maybe false lashes, this might give the dark colour over the lid but next to the eye..

 

[shonyakay]

Harvey has a point. I think the holster is more unique and could narrow the suspect pool more than the backpack.

 

[annpats]

Regarding potentially the same intruder being seen at another property, at 3.30am and 5.00am, I'd just like to say, I can understand an intruder at 3.30am, but 5.00am is risking it! People are up and about by that time, going to work, going jogging or to the gym before work, or walking the dog etc. especially in a warm area of the country.

Either the intruder is stupid.....or fearless!
MOO.

 

[annpats]

In regards to the eyes, to me it looks like eyeliner is applied or maybe false lashes, this might give the dark colour over the lid but next to the eye..

Don't forget night vision cameras show images in a different way, contrast and/or highlights can appear more pronounced.