AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[Data Sleuth]

Not satisfied by the Sheriff’s explanation of the elder abuse business card. I think that’s a clear investigative angle. Nancy appears to be alone and unprotected in that secluded home. I don’t buy it.

In my opinion it seems that you have a personal vendetta with the sheriff, and we get that because you repeatedly post negative views. No certain that anything will change until election time. JMO

 

[VeronicaVaughn]

Not late , check the due dates

Thanks! I deleted the posts.

 

[ilgirl]

dbm

 

[Data Sleuth]

Is this a cold case?

Definitely not. The Sheriff and FBI certainly have lots of information that we are not privy to. My opinion only.

 

[IceIce9]

Plenty homeowners pay late. I don't see how this would be connected.

2025 property taxes are due in 2026. Not late at all.

 

[VeronicaVaughn]

2025 property taxes are due in 2026. Not late at all.

This was my bad. I deleted the original posts.

 

[Katrinepa]

In my opinion it seems that you have a personal vendetta with the sheriff, and we get that because you repeatedly post negative views. No certain that anything will change until election time. JMO

Not every LE is an experienced public relations speaker/communicator, and this area is not used to dealing with this type of horrid crime, as NY would be. It's easy to criticize, and I have done some as well, but most of us are not there, and not experts in how LE is dealing with all this, including all the national/international attention. Local LE are also residents of this seemingly quite area, and are probably overwhelmed themselves, while trying to focus on getting the job done.
While the public is hungry for information, the Press can be too aggressive, and LE needs the space and time to do their job, without reporting to the public at large. I'm sure, I hope they have lots of information and are working hard. For me, while I want to know, I live in PA and do not have the need, or right to know what any LE agencies have. Send strength and positive Karma to everyone involved. Just MOO.

 

[rebel123]

This was my bad. I deleted the original posts.

It's o.k. Can't think of a 'poster' whose not posted something by mistake.

 

[rebel123]

I think we all need to remember that 'law enforcement' will be way ahead of where we think they are. They won't be giving a 'running commentary', they won't want to warn the 'individual'.

 

[H73]

Not late , check the due dat

This was my bad. I deleted the original posts.

Someone elses are late though

 

[maskedwoman]

LE has stated this is not a burglary gone wrong. It's amazing to me that people accept what LE has said and links are posted for sources but when they say something that goes against someone's personal narrative, what LE has said has no merit. Not personal to you bigcityaccountant AT ALL, I like your posts but LE (NANOS) said it was a targeted kidnapping. NOT a burglary gone wrong. This came out this week. We have no idea if she even had a safe. Maybe she fell and fainted. Maybe the perp stopped long enough to make a ham sandwich for the road! He may have knocked her out, drugged her, then tied her up and while disabled, taken her away in a space ship. WE KNOW NOTHING, really! We can go by what has been stated and even that may be said by LE in an effort to keep the perp confused. It's all about motive, imo. MOO

EDITED TO ADD THE LINK ABOUT THE BURGLARY GONE WRONG

Nancy Guthrie update: Sheriff reacts to "robbery gone wrong" theory

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nano explains why he believes the case is a kidnapping rather than a burglary gone bad.

www.newsweek.com

I never thought this was a burglary gone wrong because moving the body too far to be found made no sense to me. Unfortunately, LE has contradicted themselves so often on this case that I find it difficult to say "aha, I knew it!" when they do occasionally say something that supports any view that makes sense to me.

A targeted kidnapping does make the most sense, because of SG's videos speaking directly to the kidnapper. Unless the motive was as simple as cashing in on SG's heavy bank account, it may turn out that the motive will be a plot twist only a few of us will see coming.

 

[SMK777]

I think we all need to remember that 'law enforcement' will be way ahead of where we think they are. They won't be giving a 'running commentary', they won't want to warn the 'individual'.

In some cases, yes.
Let's hope this is one of them.

 

[Laura Avery]

Should imagine U.S mirror is as trashy as the U.k one but still I haven't heard this one especially the reason behind the Bitcoin ransom. Nancy Guthrie search receives huge update as blood stained item found

 

[SMK777]

Should imagine U.S mirror is as trashy as the U.k one but still I haven't heard this one especially the reason behind the Bitcoin ransom. Nancy Guthrie search receives huge update as blood stained item found

According to reports, the items were uncovered in the desert approximately a mile from Nancy Guthrie's home, just days after she was reported missing. The couple, who wished to remain anonymous, came across the suspicious black gloves lying on the ground 10 feet apart off Campbell Avenue in the Catalina Foothills of Tucson on February 11, KVOA reported on Friday.

Would love for this to be a huge breakthrough!

I just wonder how these items were missed in the prior searches?

 

[Gunther Toody]

I was reading an off-site article about the sheriff shutting down the investigation and stating that only he and two of his senior people will make decisions on this case.

I think that same information has been posted here.

What is problematic if I am reading it correctly, is the two people he is referring to are command staff and not investigators or detectives.

Chief Jesus Lopez leads the Administration Bureau of the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, and Captain Juan Carlos Navarro oversees the Criminal Investigation Division.

Not to criticize their qualifications but these roles are administrative rather than investigative.

Of course, MOO

 

[SMK777]

Not to criticize their qualifications but these roles are administrative rather than investigative.

That's worrisome as it indicates that they've reached the end point of their own investigation. MOO

 

[aamillaa]

So many weird inconsistencies in this case. I think that’s what’s bothering me. We all expect LE to be tight lipped and only share info when something is needed from the public. We all expect LE to have more than they let on.

I think this case is bothering me because there seems to be no info and too much info at the same time.

For example:
*PCSD stating no press conferences bc there’s no significant updates. Make sense. But then why is Nanos doing all these one on ones?
*As been discussed, the lack of community searches, family appeals to public, etc. On one hand, this could have something to do with LE feeling that may not be the right move based on what they know about the crime. BUT SG’s one video to the public was pleading for info from the public.
*The whole “this scene has been processed” while we’ve all seen so many searches with crime scene tape going up and down
*Not releasing info we’d expect to have - like what NG may have been wearing, etc but daily updates on the gloves/dna testing


It’s just all so odd. Idk what to think. the confusion/ego match between FBI and Nanos, as reported? Investigation strategy based on spooking the perp? Something left at the scene initially (maybe a note) that led them to realize they needed to have this specific strategy?

I don’t know what to make of any of it. I’m out of theories because I can’t even figure out what info is factual and what isn’t.

MOO

 

[SMK777]

Viewer questions about Nancy Guthrie case answered

Viewer questions about Nancy Guthrie case answered

NewsNation has been collecting a number of questions from viewers about the case ahead of our special report this Saturday.

www.newsnationnow.com

 

[heli]

no additional video recovered

Nancy Guthrie kidnapping probe may see resources scaled back as leads come up empty: Sources

Investigators looking into the kidnapping of Nancy Guthry believe the case would soon have to move into a new phase with fewer dedicated resources, sources told ABC News.

www.goodmorningamerica.com

 

[FaviousM]

no additional video recovered

Nancy Guthrie kidnapping probe may see resources scaled back as leads come up empty: Sources

Investigators looking into the kidnapping of Nancy Guthry believe the case would soon have to move into a new phase with fewer dedicated resources, sources told ABC News.

www.goodmorningamerica.com

I wonder if that's something LE confirmed to them or that the outlet is just assuming there isn't any additional footage as it's not been released to the public

Edit: Re-reading it, yeah it's very discouraging assuming their LE sources are legit, which I've no reason to doubt