AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[shonyakay]

Agreed. Very off. This site is very empathetic towards the family, but based on what I've read on other platforms, the goodwill towards them is waning. It just seems like in other cases, the families fight hard for their missing loved one, and quite frankly, I don't see that here. MOO.

The goodwill toward the family was interrupted on like day 3 when AB announced to her over 300,000 subscribers (at that time) what her source leaked to her.

 

[cathathorse]

This is going around social media at the moment and people are tying it to the report date on the Pima County Sheriff Evidence Submission Portal. If you go to the portal it says report filed 1/31/2026 6:00 PM
I'm thinking that it was a mistake for the last seen date. ??

Missing Endangered Adult

The Pima County Sheriff's Department is urgently requesting your assistance in locating Nancy Guthrie, 84, who last seen on the evening of January 31, 2026, at her residence near East Skyline Drive and North Campbell Avenue. If you have any information, please contact the Pima County Sheriff's...

pimasheriff.evidence.com

I don't think there's anything to this other than someone inputting the wrong date/time. The ex-FBI agent linked in the post you quoted can lose sight of reality quickly with one random piece of information. Sometimes she is very insightful, especially when talking about general FBI procedures... other times I feel she has lost her mind (example: Delphi case).

 

[SUNchips]

This is really difficult for me to tell, but the implications are so insane if true...

Could the weeds he is holding in his hand be the same weeds left lying on the ground and not collected as evidence??

I don’t think it’s “could it be”, without a doubt in my opinion those are the same weeds. This case was botched from the beginning. Even before the porch video came out (on Feb 10) it was obvious that those weeds were out of place, the doormat and Nest camera mount should have been taken in to be examined for evidence, and the house should have remained a crime scene and not released nearly immediately.

I hope if I ever go missing (since I live near Nancy) that sheriff Nanos is no longer employed here. How embarrassed he should feel at his handling of this case, IMO.

 

[SMK777]

Thanks for clarifying. I have been intrigued with LD as a potential suspect and if he truly has the alibi that he claims (and likely is true because it can easily be checked), I'm disappointed that he can prove that he wasn't in the area. If he, indeed, can absolutely prove with a strong alibi that he wasn't in the area that night.

I have known of a case where the perp could prove they were 200 miles away and in another state the night of a murder. But, it turned out that he checked into a hotel that was 200+ miles away from their home, then immediately went back to murder his wife, and then returned to the hotel by early morning hours. This was years ago and the perp didn't take into account cell phone pings, so that was problematic for him. And, the hotel had footage of him leaving and returning in a side door of the hotel and digital evidence of him leaving and returning to his hotel room with his key being recorded at the times of entry and exit.

FBI had enough evidence linking him to NG's disappearance that a federal judge approved a federal warrant to search his house. A federal warrant has a fairly high bar so while he may not be the actual perp, I'm still curious about his possible involvement. Maybe there will be evidence in his Road Runner that the FBI took in for testing.

JMO

*I recall the case you are referring to.

*I also recall another, where the suspect seemingly had an airtight alibi: Until the person whose house he was at far away admitted to lying for him.

 

[gin2]

Agreed. Very off. This site is very empathetic towards the family, but based on what I've read on other platforms, the goodwill towards them is waning. It just seems like in other cases, the families fight hard for their missing loved one, and quite frankly, I don't see that here. MOO.

The family are victims. I'm not judging how they are behaving. I think it's sad and cruel if there are places that are commenting about waning "goodwill."

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

Investigation IMO has been problematic.

Cessna aircraft is outfitted with high-resolution thermal imaging cameras capable of detecting heat signatures in rugged terrain. After argument, sheriff had re-assigned pilot to ground duty. No one else could fly plane. Valuable time lost.
NG home area searched, then left. Neighbor alerted missed roof cameras.
Home area not off limits yet revisited by investigators.
Pizza delivery guy walked right into investigation.
Rio Rico man detained because of Door Dash/door broken down. Nothing.
Nearby mother/son home searched. Why? Nothing.
Man/home searched wth no evidence except he was previously in prison.
Found glove revealed no results.
Backpack currently no evidence.
APS left card left in door.
No requests for "people" organized searches for NG.
No ground searches of desert near Tucson.
Reward has not yet worked.
NG not found. Criminal(s) not found. Bitcoin continual demanders not found.
What has a search with no results cost so far?

I agree the investigation has been problematic in so many of the areas that you've mentioned.

At the same time, though, I'm hopeful that FBI and LE have a great deal going on behind-the-scene that puts them much closer to finding the perp and NG than we are aware.

Hopefully LE and FBI may find a:
--helpful match from a forensic generalogist with the glove found that wasn't in COIS
--backowner purchaser who may already be on their radar or from whom they can get DNA (Walmart provided a list of people throughout AZ who purchased that particular backpack)
--a DNA match with the partial DNA found in the house
--a DNA match with the comingled blood that FBI is believes has DNA from both NG and the suspect

JMOO

 

[mpnola]

They almost certainly are and I wish they would have been collected. Even though they may have not contained any evidence as the perp had gloves on, and i doubt saliva/sweat etc would be very viable to extract from organic material.

With that said you have to remember the significance of them likely wasn’t known until video footage was recieved.

I agree. Except!!!! They knew he was at the front door to remove the camera. So at minimum, why not take the mat? There are so many cases where they can get a footprint. Or find dirt, flora or fauna that leads them to a particular area. So many things could be potential leads on that doormat. And certainly the flowers at the door were odd. I would have collected, as they didn't look like something that would naturally blow in that long and broken state.

 

[turaj]

My apologies if this has already been asked/answered as it's impossible to keep up with this fast-paced discussion.

Has the Guthrie family hired their own private investigator/s? After nearly three weeks with seemingly little or no progress in the case, I would want to get a second opinion, so to speak, and engage my own team of investigators.

good question. Others will chime in but I sure have not heard about any being hired. Brian Entin had a retired investigator that said that can often lead to confusion and chaos in the investigation with too many involved. But don't know in this case.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

*I recall the case you are referring to.

*I also recall another, where the suspect seemingly had an airtight alibi: Until the person whose house he was at far away admitted to lying for him.

And that's a real possibility, too. If a suspect has a close friend who has lied for him in providing an alibi, the friend may have remorse and guilt about lying in a major criminal investigation and end up later telling the truth.

JMHO

 

[Love Never Fails]

From the ABC NEWS article posted by @RedHaus :

Maybe a ray of hope:


Jason Pack, a former FBI agent and current chief executive of Media Rep Global Strategies, said the gap between what a case looks like publicly at day 20 and what is happening inside the investigation can be enormous.

"The things most likely to break a case open are almost never the things being discussed in one-on-one press interviews. They are happening in labs, in Walmart security offices, in gun shops, in backend server logs, and in conversations between investigators who have been staring at the same timeline long enough that it might be time for a fresh set of eyes," Pack said.

I hope so. The sad part is day 20.
For someone 84, or for a child, it’s devastating. While it might be just routine for authorities, it is devastating to the victim.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

good question. Others will chime in but I sure have not heard about any being hired. Brian Entin had a retired investigator that said that can often lead to confusion and chaos in the investigation with too many involved. But don't know in this case.

They hired a private security person to guard the house, and some news media mistakenly thought the family had hired a private investigator. If they hired a private investigator, the public hasn't been told and we don't know.

JMO

 

[Love Never Fails]

The goodwill toward the family was interrupted on like day 3 when AB announced to her over 300,000 subscribers (at that time) what her source leaked to her.

Well, not all the family. We will know in the end what really happened.

 

[RaspberryMama]

Yes absolutely. When i first saw the picture i wondered what they were doing there

And the doormat that he was literally standing on (possibly dripping a little saliva with that bite light in his mouth right onto it) is still there too.

 

[shonyakay]

EXACTLY!!! I can’t wrap my head around running DNA evidence outside of the FBI at this point. I don’t care how friendly your relationship is with the Florida lab. Direct to the FBI lab is the only thing that makes sense. It’s arrogance at best and deliberate interference at worst.

He explained that it takes an extra step out of the process. All of the evidence they collected from the home was sent to the Florida lab.
Also all of the buccal swabs that were taken from family, friends, aquantiances were all sent there as well.

 

[Sakura2Sophia4Lucia]

From the ABC NEWS article posted by @RedHaus :

Maybe a ray of hope:


Jason Pack, a former FBI agent and current chief executive of Media Rep Global Strategies, said the gap between what a case looks like publicly at day 20 and what is happening inside the investigation can be enormous.

"The things most likely to break a case open are almost never the things being discussed in one-on-one press interviews. They are happening in labs, in Walmart security offices, in gun shops, in backend server logs, and in conversations between investigators who have been staring at the same timeline long enough that it might be time for a fresh set of eyes," Pack said.

It's good for us to keep reminding ourselves of what Pack, the former FBI agent, said in that ABC interview. I'm hopeful that some of the things that are happening behind-the-scenes are going to result in matching DNA and other evidence (such as the backback, gun, cell phone pings, vehicles) with the suspect or suspects.

JMO

 

[Napoli]

Savannah Guthrie’s ‘Today’ Absence Amid Mom’s Disappearance Spurs Questions Over Next Steps at Morning Show

Savannah Guthrie’s ‘Today’ Absence Amid Mom’s Disappearance Spurs Questions Over Next Steps at Morning Show

Savannah Guthrie's Absence From 'Today' Spurs Questions Over Next Steps at NBC's Morning Franchise

variety.com

I really think we are all going to be surprised. SG, imo, will be back soon. Again, imo, if for no other reason to try and tease out the perp and keep LE focused and the public engaged.. JMO

 

[SlimPickens]

There was a possible exit ramp. Pay the RANSOM. NOT DONE. THE FRENZY WILL SUBSIDE. Unless a DNA suspect is identified and arrested and is convicted, this case is in the freezer. JMO

Indeed. If law enforcement never finds her and they advised family not to pay the ransom, I can't imagine the self-doubt/guilt/anger/torment family will be experiencing.

JMO.

 

[SaraSmile]

I could not agree with you more. Something does feel "off". I wish at least they would make an appearance to support the LE efforts, thank them and the public who are so concerned about their mother.

Perhaps, both SG and FBI prefer “Scripted” statements, just what they think is best, and will work to appeal to the abductor.
I wish someone would do a video discussing the movie lines, why important?

JMO

 

[Love Never Fails]

I could not agree with you more. Something does feel "off". I wish at least they would make an appearance to support the LE efforts, thank them and the public who are so concerned about their mother.

From the scripted notes, what I observed is CG holding back his emotions and being stoic because he was told to. I saw him as a bull in a china cabinet and rightfully so!

I saw SG as a professional news reader, staying calm because she is in front of the camera.

I saw AG as a mess not wanting to be there.

We have no idea of the dynamics there. They all live in different cities from each other. They all love “mom” and want her back and this has to be difficult at the least.

I do wish they would come forward, especially since Nancy, if she is well, has to be worried about them also. That would be a mother’s greatest concern. I would be thinking if someone did this to me, they might do it to one of my children.

 

[Jade]

Although not tresspasing, someone left an APS card in the front door. No one stopped or saw this. Who is to say there weren't tresspassers if this can happen?

Why would APS be stopped?

APS staff are government employees carrying out their duties so ultimately lumping them as a comparison to assert there is trespassing fails, imo.

The card had identifying information nothing being hidden.

The representative has every right to leave a card for the benefit of families albeit most with less resources.

Mrs. Guthrie as a taxpayer is entitled to an offer of support from APS, imo.

Its' not true that this government employee's participation in the crisis response was unknown to anyone.

The SO knew:

https://twitter.com/x/status/2023909355750650040

All imo