OH - Pike Co, 8 in Rhoden Family Murdered Over Custody Issue, 4 Members Wagner Family Arrested #70

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #461
I wonder if this was the route taken that night? if so it looks like the W's killed Chris and Gary, moved on to Frankie and Hanna then left to go to Kenny's and then circled back leaving dana's for last. I still think Kenny saw or the W's thought he saw that truck in Chris's driveway that night, so they had to kill him and fast. IMO they followed Kenny or arrived at his home shortly after he did. i think he was getting ready for bed. <modsnip - no link> I think Kenny was sitting up in bed and probably called brownie off by telling her to stay or something when Jake knocked and called out to Kenny and tell him it's me, Jake.

No other reason to kill Kenny and especially not kill him before hitting Dana's house.

JMO
JMO, that’s a very good theory, Raize. They must have been in quite a hurry to get back to UHR to finish their spree before people started waking up and driving to work. I think a lot of people out there work in the Columbus area and get up early to commute.

I’m still puzzled, though, by the AR showing Chris Sr. May have died before the others.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #462
I wonder if this was the route taken that night? if so it looks like the W's killed Chris and Gary, moved on to Frankie and Hanna then left to go to Kenny's and then circled back leaving dana's for last. I still think Kenny saw or the W's thought he saw that truck in Chris's driveway that night, so they had to kill him and fast. IMO they followed Kenny or arrived at his home shortly after he did. i think he was getting ready for bed. <modsnip- no link>I think Kenny was sitting up in bed and probably called brownie off by telling her to stay or something when Jake knocked and called out to Kenny and tell him it's me, Jake.

No other reason to kill Kenny and especially not kill him before hitting Dana's house.

JMO
I still think the single shot to Kenny's right eye was symbolic. IMO, Kenny had seen/witnessed something that could have been used as evidence as motive in these eight murders. Maybe that night, or maybe the week before when he witnessed the fight.

Completely my JMO.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #463
Just saw this pop up on twitter from another reporter. It looks like they're visiting the Peterson Rd farm that used to be the Wagners. If so, those jurors are working late tonight and must have a full day tomorrow. Very nice those people who bought the farm to make it available to LE and the court for so many searches, etc.










Considering how much the W's had, what a huge consuming amount of anger that drove them to risk everything just to get what they wanted. That poor little child would have been so much better off sharing time between both parents, happier also.

JMO
 
  • #464
I really hope she's doing well enough to attend GW4s.

Was just remembering George and the tattoo he got after the Rhoden Massacre. A skull, and eight ball and the "Dead Man's Hand" featuring eights and aces. Clever.

Wow I missed this. Was this hearing not televised? Very interesting.

His tattoo referencing the the skull and number 8? Wow. I thought that was a rumor. That was brought up on here "years" ago. Someone on here heard about it.

Done after the murders, wow again.

West Chester police captain Hagaman said George got a tattoo after the killings. It features a skull, eight ball, and the so-called "dead man's hand" of cards showing aces and eights. Wagner's defense team called that "speculative" in relation to the murders.

I thought they dyed their hair after the murders but.....

He said George and Jake dyed their hair in the week leading up to the murders, and watched a clip from the movie "The Boondock Saints" - about two brothers who killed for vigilante justice - the evening of the massacre.

Wonder how BCI learned about the Bookdock Saints?
 
Last edited:
  • #465
Jake could certainly testify to it because I can't imagine that they didn't discuss it or possibly even that Jake was there if/when this fight occurred.

Or perhaps it never even happened. MOO
 
  • #466
JW confessed to 5 of the 8 murders. Are we suggesting 1 of the 5 was KR? I guess it is possible if someone else killed 1 at DRs. I must ssay there isnt any evidence to support this but i always felt AW killed either DR or KR. Jmo
 
  • #467
JW confessed to 5 of the 8 murders. Are we suggesting 1 of the 5 was KR? I guess it is possible if someone else killed 1 at DRs. I must ssay there isnt any evidence to support this but i always felt AW killed either DR or KR. Jmo
I was always of the opinion that it was Billy who got Kenneth either on his way home to flying w farms or on his way to uhr.

I believe Kenneth was either killed first or last JMO
 
  • #468
Wow I missed this. Was this hearing not televised? Very interesting.

His tattoo referencing the the skull and number 8? Wow. I thought that was a rumor. That was brought up on here "years" ago. Someone on here heard about it.

Done after the murders, wow again.

West Chester police captain Hagaman said George got a tattoo after the killings. It features a skull, eight ball, and the so-called "dead man's hand" of cards showing aces and eights. Wagner's defense team called that "speculative" in relation to the murders.

I thought they dyed their hair after the murders but.....

He said George and Jake dyed their hair in the week leading up to the murders, and watched a clip from the movie "The Boondock Saints" - about two brothers who killed for vigilante justice - the evening of the massacre.

Wonder how BCI learned about the Bookdock Saints?
Pretty sure investigators found the Boondock Saints video in the trash/storage the W’s left behind after they moved.

But who knows on how investigators knew they actually watched it leading up to the murders.
 
  • #469
Pretty sure investigators found the Boondock Saints video in the trash/storage the W’s left behind after they moved.

But who knows on how investigators knew they actually watched it leading up to the murders.
I'm completely going off memory here. I could be way off. For some reason I thought that the video was found partially burned. Does anyone else remember? TIA
 
  • #470
I really hope she's doing well enough to attend GW4s.

Was just remembering George and the tattoo he got after the Rhoden Massacre. A skull, and eight ball and the "Dead Man's Hand" featuring eights and aces. Clever.

I hope I can say this without violating any TOS. The Wags are a real special kind of stupid, what hubris!!! What's the old saying? Arrogance and ignorance, or in this case, stupidity are a deadly combination. I still cannot wrap my mind around that not only did these 4 continue to live life as if nothing had happened, at least 2 of the 4 permanently memorialized their atrocities by inking it on their person.
 
  • #471
It turned out well, though? I haven’t decided about lenses. I wear bifocals (glasses) now.
MOD NOTE:

Hi Everybody,

There is no way on earth that we can give you an acceptable list of media sources for this trial - have you SEEN how many there are? Acceptable media sources are the same as always . . . mainstream media. Top-level posts from journalists are also acceptable, but comments on those posts are not. All of this is detailed in the links in my signature.

As for documents, digital documents provided by mainstream media is fine. "The Docket" twitter account is also an acceptable source for documents.

Law & Crime and Court TV are mainstream media.
@Betty P. Yes, All was good.

Thanks @Knitty Appreciate having official clarification on acceptable news sources before we go into the trial.
 
  • #472
I think the only reason Wagners killed Kenny was he knew too much. They couldn't leave him as lone survivor to testify against them.
 
  • #473
  • #474
I think the only reason Wagners killed Kenny was he knew too much. They couldn't leave him as lone survivor to testify against them.
i agree. even in a big family, issues and knowledge of situations can be highly compartmentalized. if kr was closest to crsr especially considering the grows he would know about this "meeting" with billy and intricate details about the custody battle and general insanity of the wagner cult. maybe tony and brady werent read into the more private issues. wagners plan needed to erase the custody battle and point fingers inside at the manleys and outside to the "cartel" or "isis" kr would have blown that to bits
 
  • #475
  • #476
^^rsbm

The prosecution has the burden of proof so it's no wonder that they have a witness list exceeding 250! To be clear, the length of this list itself does not mean that every witness on the list will be called to testify (the trial would go on for 2 years). However, it's a matter of law that a witness cannot be called and "surprise the court" if they never made the witness list admitted into evidence. The point here about EW is that the defense doesn't know nor has any guarantee that they can question EW on the stand.

In this case, the prosecution has relied on an exception to Discovery Rule 16 that provides for non-disclosure of a witness's identity/address (for good cause). In other words, this means that as of 8/31/22 when Defense filed Motion to Compel #109, they still had no knowledge or guarantee from the Court whether or not EW has been subpoenaed as a prosecution witness and will in fact appear in court.

Although the prosecution has rightfully used the discovery exception for non-disclosure to protect EW for several years, Rule 16 also provides that the non-disclosure exception ends 7 days prior to the trial commencing.

Not only would it be a violation of the defendant's Sixth Amendment Right not to be able to subpoena EW, but It would also be ineffective assistance of counsel for the defense to fail to subpoena a witness to rebut testimony against their client. Seriously, how tragic it would be if GW4 won on appeal over the prosecution withholding EW's address on the heels of his trial?



8/29/22

Potential jurors heard about a possible witness list as well: More than 250 people could be called as witnesses in this case, including dozens of state Bureau of Criminal Investigation agents and members of two county dive teams. Not all people on the list will be called during the course of the trial.

[..]

George is the first of the Wagner family members charged in the eight murders to face trial. His brother, Edward "Jake" Wagner, is believed to be at the center of the motive for the murder; He and one of the victims, Hanna Rhoden, had a child together over which there were vicious custody disputes. Jake took a plea deal in April 2021.

Also charged in the murders were George's parents, Angela and George "Billy" Wagner. Angela took a plea deal in September 2021. Billy has maintained a plea of not guilty, though a trial date has not yet been set for him.
About EW. If anyone knows, is her fear because she knows what the Ws did to the Rhodens or just because of her experiences living or being around the Ws?? I missed how she was able to leave them, anyone know??
 
  • #477
Considering how much the W's had, what a huge consuming amount of anger that drove them to risk everything just to get what they wanted. That poor little child would have been so much better off sharing time between both parents, happier also.

JMO
They didn't think they would get caught!!!
 
  • #478
Two questions for you. After opening statements ...If you were the prosecutor who is your first witness?...Who do you think will be the first witness?
 
  • #479
Just a thought, but it's possible the major news stations in Ohio could live stream the trial online or on their Facebook page. There have been 3 major trials on my local news stations since 2010. What major city in Ohio is close to where the trial is at?
 
  • #480
About EW. If anyone knows, is her fear because she knows what the Ws did to the Rhodens or just because of her experiences living or being around the Ws?? I missed how she was able to leave them, anyone know??
Sorry, wrong quote.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
122
Guests online
2,716
Total visitors
2,838

Forum statistics

Threads
632,083
Messages
18,621,804
Members
243,017
Latest member
thaines
Back
Top