UK UK - Claudia Lawrence, 35, Chef, York University, 18 March 2009 #6

[MajorLang]

Why should she feel shame..shes done nothing wrong. If anything shes a victim too.
Its comments like that, that stop people coming forward with any evidence of a personal nature they may have.

Well if the DVD does exist she has had 11 years to come forward so you don't need to worry about me putting her off. But the reality is whilst I agree there should be no shame she will not want to be associated with it.

 

[MummyRatcliffe]

Why should she feel shame..shes done nothing wrong. If anything shes a victim too.
Its comments like that, that stop people coming forward with any evidence of a personal nature they may have.

I agree she shouldn't be ashamed, and she is also a victim. I don't think Major meant that the wife should be ashamed, but knowing your hubby was participating in extra curricular activities and recorded them for God knows who to see, the average woman would be embarrassed and ashamed of him. MOO

 

[keep-it-real]

Absolutely .. If it is true there is just one question I would like to know..
Is the policeman boyfriend on there!

 

[MummyRatcliffe]

Absolutely .. If it is true there is just one question I would like to know..
Is the policeman boyfriend on there!

Imagine if he was!!! If the DVD does exist and police are aware of it, then they'd have tracked down the Bobby by now wouldn't they?...

 

[keep-it-real]

Well if the DVD does exist she has had 11 years to come forward so you don't need to worry about me putting her off. But the reality is whilst I agree there should be no shame she will not want to be associated with it.

Why wouldnt she?
A woman has gone missing in one of the most high profile cases of the century and the alledged dvd is said to have her on it alongside a number of men.
How do you know that the police didnt know about this from very early on and held it back if this dv does exist it could a vital part of evidence in any prosectution.

 

[keep-it-real]

Imagine if he was!!! If the DVD does exist and police are aware of it, then they'd have tracked down the Bobby by now wouldn't they?...

You would hope so... The Plot thickens .. dont you think

 

[keep-it-real]

I agree she shouldn't be ashamed, and she is also a victim. I don't think Major meant that the wife should be ashamed, but knowing your hubby was participating in extra curricular activities and recorded them for God knows who to see, the average woman would be embarrassed and ashamed of him. MOO

Correct me if Im wrong but didnt the woman contact the police to inform them that her husband had had an affair with CL resulting in the marriage ending.

 

[MajorLang]

Why should she feel shame..shes done nothing wrong. If anything shes a victim too.
Its comments like that, that stop people coming forward with any evidence of a personal nature they may have.

Well if the DVD does exist she has had 11 years to come forward so you don't need to worry about me putting her off. But the reality is whilst I agree there should be no shame she will not want to be associated with it.

Imagine if he was!!! If the DVD does exist and police are aware of it, then they'd have tracked down the Bobby by now wouldn't they?...

Possibly not

 

[MajorLang]

Why wouldnt she?
A woman has gone missing in one of the most high profile cases of the century and the alledged dvd is said to have her on it alongside a number of men.
How do you know that the police did know about this from very early on and held it back if this dv does exist it could a vital part of evidence in any prosectution.

Where have I commented that the police knew about this from very early on?

 

[keep-it-real]

Where have I commented that the police knew about this from very early on?

Sorry typo error it meant to read didnt

 

[MummyRatcliffe]

Correct me if Im wrong but didnt the woman contact the police to inform them that her husband had had an affair with CL resulting in the marriage ending.

I'm not sure how it all came out. I know BH went to the press after lots of speculation to tell her truth. MOO

 

[Popejohn3]

I'm not sure how it all came out. I know BH went to the press after lots of speculation to tell her truth. MOO

Yes and if you believe the dvd exits you should also believe the police have a copy because the same source said so !

 

[MajorLang]

Yes and if you believe the dvd exits you should also believe the police have a copy because the same source said so !

Was she posting a DVD that day-One with her in it ???

 

[Popejohn3]

Was she posting a DVD that day-One with her in it ???

I wouldn’t think so would you ?
If you believe the dvd dvd chanting in the pub you would think they were teasing her probably because she was embarrassed .

 

[HongKongPhooey]

I wouldn’t think so would you ?
If you believe the dvd dvd chanting in the pub you would think they were teasing her probably because she was embarrassed .

Dont think I heard about this before. Is that what they say, that people used to chant it at her?

 

[Andyboy]

If dvd exists which I'm not at all sure about, then any men featured in it who have wives or girlfriends must be incredibly dense to want, let alone keep a copy of it

 

[Andyboy]

And even if the police had a copy, what does it prove, just because they took part in some sort of orgy, it might make there morals somewhat dubious, but you couldn't charge them with murder, bit of a severe step up that I'd say

 

[MummyRatcliffe]

And even if the police had a copy, what does it prove, just because they took part in some sort of orgy, it might make there morals somewhat dubious, but you couldn't charge them with murder, bit of a severe step up that I'd say

I agree, it must be known in the nags exactly who took part in the DVD (If true) and it proves nothing.

I hope NYP throw us a bone this March as we're going round in circles with the info we have up to now

 

[keep-it-real]

If dvd exists which I'm not at all sure about, then any men featured in it who have wives or girlfriends must be incredibly dense to want, let alone keep a copy of it

Andy do you think its a possiblity that the dvd was mailed to a male that appeared on the alledged dvd and the wife found it accidentally. A woman would not be being dense by holding on it but could merely use it as proof of a cheating husband if family or friends found it difficult to believe of the man

 

[Andyboy]

Andy do you think its a possiblity that the dvd was mailed to a male that appeared on the alledged dvd and the wife found it accidentally. A woman would not be being dense by holding on it but could merely use it as proof of a cheating husband if family or friends found it difficult to believe of the man

Possible, but more likely to use it to push through a divorce, or as a reason to punch him in the face I reckon