Overall I think Jb did a good job today. He established that these records could hold the key to the truth or the pathway to the truth. At any rate the records are very important to the fair trial system. I was surprized to see the SA siding with Tes. If they say there is nothing in the records, then why object to the defense seeing them?
You cannot be serious that you felt JB did a good job today. Even other defense counsel i saw interviewed thought he bumbled and was incoherent. I must ask - Did YOU go search? Is YOUR name on any of the TES records? If so, I guess you wouldn't mind your privacy being invaded and tossing your name in the BIG hat when that caravan of buses rolls toward you.
I think the Judge understood to just look at 4000 records with your eyes and not be able to record them is pretty much useless. The Judge should have known this when he made the first order. Now it comes back to haunt him.
Sorry, NTS, but you have no clue about this. This is done all the time. You tab them and then if you find anything that you believe is relevant, you make another motion explaining to the Judge WHY those docs are relevant and should be released.
I believe he will side with the defense on this issue, otherwise the defense will go to Mn office and flag every single record for review by the judge. Time to quit trying to hide things and put the evidence on the table. It is the state that is causing all these delays. The defense has a right to investigate and the Judge should support them in anyway he can.
You seem to really like law. I suggest you study up on litigation and get a copy of the FRCP
Mn did not make a good argument at all for keeping the records secret and keeping the records from the court. I was under the understanding that he was a really good Lawyer. Not impressed at all. The truth shall prevail, Mn, Tm, and Sa do not have a monopoly on the truth. IMO
MN NEVER ONCE said they were 'secret' to the defense. Not once. Judge Strickland ruled on this LONG AGO....Baez just doesn't like the ruling and is challenging it. He will lose again.