Early on, I thought maybe they went downstream in a canoe, or possibly walked up Bridge Creek to I25 where a car was waiting, or, there was a 4 wheeler in waiting, or a van on that private drive that squirrel'd 'em away out of there.
I thought maybe they were at a local house, then a barn, then a shed, then over at the Indiana packers, then bicycle bridge road, then up and out of there through the cemetery, then up the hill and through the woods and back to the parking lot.
I thought maybe the searchers were in on it, then I thought maybe the searchers just didn't go over the creek that night, why would they? Then I considered, after that billboard campaign, the probability of a serial killer, most likely in fact. Then no, had to be someone local.
Then, they came out with the video of the dude on the bridge. The man that said 'guys, down the hill'. I guess there coulda been a car down on that driveway, waiting for 'em...to take 'em away from the bridge, out that driveway. I guess they could have returned somehow, maybe through the cemetery, or back up Deer Creek some how, in a 4 wheeler, or on foot.
But nowadays, I think it's real simple. "Guys, down the hill"....over the driveway, through the bottom ground there, across that creek, and back up to the CS. I bet either Abby, or Libby's pants, and/or shoes were wet.
Moo folks!