OH - Pike County: 8 people from one family dead as police hunt for killer(s) #5

[pisces51]

BJM say drug in the 911 call, blood in the living room but found in bedroom.

Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk

I assumed one of them was sleeping in the living room and was shot there, explaining all the blood. But maybe they were beaten in the living room? I just don't think a well-planned execution should include beatings and moving the bodies...too much risk of dna left behind.

 

[EyesofTheSouth]

I believe with shotguns it varies; some eject and some do not. Revolvers do not eject their casings.

This is correct. There are Ejectors and Extractors. An Ejector will 'fling' the spent shell out of the shotgun. An Extractor will raise the spent shell up so that you can grab it with your hand and manually remove it. The plus of the Extractor is that you don't have to pick up shells. The minus is it takes longer to pull the spent shell out by hand and reload. In a mass shooting situation like this, an Extractor would not be efficient.

 

[JanetElaine]

I'm going to have to stop following this case, I'm so far behind... I hate doing this but - did I miss anything breaking since this morning?

 

[cujenn81]

Another thing I'll add about the 911 call is that it does seem strange that she never once requests an ambulance or asks her to send someone down there right away. She clearly sounds very upset but... I don't hear a real sense of urgency. No pleas to hurry. No nothin'.

 

[Damarna]

She is talking to someone else also and I'm still not sure I don't hear kids in the background.

Yes!! Young voices are what I thought I had heard.

 

[Babyfacemagee]

I was JUST about to say the same thing. And someone is definitely there with her (talking to them when call starts) and I hear background talking. It sounds like child babble but a TV could have also been on in the house, I guess.

Am I imagining things or did I remember reading somewhere that Bobby wasn't alone in the morning when she went to feed the animals, that she had a friend named Tammy or something that was with her. That could be who she's talking to in the audio and who we hear in the background.

 

[KKearns]

I'm thinking she was thinking out loud while on the phone. She may have been in fear for her own life after finding them dead and said please don't hurt me to the killers in her mind and out loud. I would imagine a lot of things were going through her mind at that moment.

I've thought that a possibility also when I first heard about her saying that. That audio was the best one and I could hear it much clearer.

 

[EyesofTheSouth]

This time listening to the audio, I can see where it sounds like "Please don't hurt me". I didn't really notice background voices, but I've got a thunderstorm raging outside, so I'll throw on my headphones and give it another listen.

 

[KKearns]

@CARIIS Oh I don't know about all that. I'm a cat person that had a racoon momma climb a tree, chew a hole on my house and birth babies in my attic lol.

 

[smc1225]

http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slat...11_audio_from_ohio_rhoden_family_murders.html

Audio version!

I transcribed what was on this call. There's a couple of parts I couldn't get - I noted that.

911: 911

BJM: Yes I need a sheriff's deputy at 40...?...hold on...umm

911: I need you to tell me the address. What's the address?

BJM: Gimme just a second. Let me walk to the mailbox. I think my brother-in-law's dead.

911: Ok. What is the address?

BJM: Gimme just a second. 4077 Union Hill Road.

911: 4077....

BJM: 4077

911: Ok four-zero-seven-seven Union Hill correct?

BJM: Yes 4077 Union Hill Road (crying)

911: Ma'am. You got to tell me what's going on.

BJM: There's blood all over the house.

911: Ok.

BJM: My brother-in-law's in the bedroom. It looks like someone has beat the hell out of him.

911: Ok. (unintelligble)

BJM: There's blood all over the carpets (note: could be covers?)

911: Ma'am can you tell me what county that's in?

BJM: Pike's County

911: It's Pike County?

BJM: Yes and they drug him in the bedroom (or backroom)

911: Ok. I need you to get out of the house. Did you drive over there?

BJM: Yes I did.

911: What's your brother-in-law's name?

BJM: Huh?

911: What's your brother-in-law's name?

BJM: (unintelligble)

911: Ma'am?

BJM: Yeah

911: What's his name?

BJM: Chris Rhoden and Gary Rhoden

911: Chris and Gary Rhoden?

BJM: From the signs in there it looks like they're dead

911: You think they're both dead?

BJM: I think they're both dead. It looks like someone beat the f--k out of them.

911: Ok. Is there anybody else in the house?

BJM: Not that I know of.

911: Ok.

BJM: The door was locked when we got here. But I know where the key was at. So I went in and they were laying on the floor. I'm down out. I'm staying outside right now.

911: Ok. Just stay out of the house. Don't let anybody go in there. Ok?

BJM: Yeah.

911: We have somebody on the way, ok?

BJM: I, thank you.

911: You're welcome.

BJM: (crying) Oh my God...please come hurry

 

[KKearns]

I'm going to have to stop following this case, I'm so far behind... I hate doing this but - did I miss anything breaking since this morning?

That is the good thing.. They aren't telling us much, so you really aren't behind lol.

 

[JaimeInLA]

That is a better audio and I swear at the end when she is crying, it did sound like "please don't hurt me".

Holy crap. She DOES say that. That is the first time I have been able to hear that clearly, and I have listened to that call like 50 times. WTH?! Who would she be saying that to?!?!

No wonder the cops busted in at 3am and accused her of knowing more than she told them! That is WEIRD.

 

[Tillicum]

It sounds like "Please don't hurt me" to me.

 

[Damarna]

I transcribed what was on this call. There's a couple of parts I couldn't get - I noted that.

911: 911

BJM: Yes I need a sheriff's deputy at 40...?...hold on...umm

911: I need you to tell me the address. What's the address?

BJM: Gimme just a second. Let me walk to the mailbox. I think my brother-in-law's dead.

911: Ok. What is the address?

BJM: Gimme just a second. 4077 Union Hill Road.

911: 4077....

BJM: 4077

911: Ok four-zero-seven-seven Union Hill correct?

BJM: Yes 4077 Union Hill Road (crying)

911: Ma'am. You got to tell me what's going on.

BJM: There's blood all over the house.

911: Ok.

BJM: My brother-in-law's in the bedroom. It looks like someone has beat the hell out of him.

911: Ok. (unintelligble)

BJM: There's blood all over the carpets (note: could be covers?)

911: Ma'am can you tell me what county that's in?

BJM: Pike's County

911: It's Pike County?

BJM: Yes and they drug him in the bedroom (or backroom)

911: Ok. I need you to get out of the house. Did you drive over there?

BJM: Yes I did.

911: What's your brother-in-law's name?

BJM: Huh?

911: What's your brother-in-law's name?

BJM: (unintelligble)

911: Ma'am?

BJM: Yeah

911: What's his name?

BJM: Chris Rhoden and Gary Rhoden

911: Chris and Gary Rhoden?

BJM: From the signs in there it looks like they're dead

911: You think they're both dead?

BJM: I think they're both dead. It looks like someone beat the f--k out of them.

911: Ok. Is there anybody else in the house?

BJM: Not that I know of.

911: Ok.

BJM: The door was locked when we got here. But I know where the key was at. So I went in and they were laying on the floor. I'm down out. I'm staying outside right now.

911: Ok. Just stay out of the house. Don't let anybody go in there. Ok?

BJM: Yeah.

911: We have somebody on the way, ok?

BJM: I, thank you.

911: You're welcome.

BJM: (crying) Oh my God...please come hurry

Please come hurry is what I am hearing. I could hear don't hurt me after it was mentioned. Power of suggestion? Nice job!

 

[KKearns]

Another thing I'll add about the 911 call is that it does seem strange that she never once requests an ambulance or asks her to send someone down there right away. She clearly sounds very upset but... I don't hear a real sense of urgency. No pleas to hurry. No nothin'.

Well according to the FBI, not sure where the link is now.. That fact of not asking for help and the fact that she offered up the key info and the "huh" when asked his name.. Makes this a call that would be flagged as a. suspicious call.

Let me see if I can find the link.

 

[JaimeInLA]

Was that the same video where he kept saying "well let me just put it to you this way"?

YES! LOL! We need to all place the link to that video in our signatures because we talk about it all the time!

 

[Adt1984]

I'm going to have to stop following this case, I'm so far behind... I hate doing this but - did I miss anything breaking since this morning?

A dive team from Franklin county was called in today. Of course the information about it is vague and they are trying to downplay the significance of bringing them in.

 

[Pearline]

I think because of her dialect it sounds like please don't hurt me, but I am hearing please hurry. (I was raised in southern WV so I understand the drawl.)

 

[KKearns]

Another thing I'll add about the 911 call is that it does seem strange that she never once requests an ambulance or asks her to send someone down there right away. She clearly sounds very upset but... I don't hear a real sense of urgency. No pleas to hurry. No nothin'.

Here is the link..

http://www.thefreelibrary.com/911+h...alysis:+is+the+caller+the+killer?-a0180406725

 

[smc1225]

https://youtu.be/ZoMRgNwUtug

This version is slightly different than one posted on slate. This one leaves out where they asked her name and she gave it and then it censors the swear words. Other than that I hear the same exact things.