Possible Victim: Shannan Gilbert, 24, missing May 2010, found Oak Beach Dec 2011 #3

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
We will probably never know exactly what happened to Shannan. If it was an accident, she was alone in her final minutes and isn't here to tell us about it. If it was foul play if was most likely committed by one of the sketchy characters she was with that night and they are not going to tell us the truth. Unfortunately the state of her body, location and passage of time makes it so we can't get a definitive result from that either.

Personally, I suspect she was not murdered. I think she was high and drunk and that led to her demise. It's possible that Brewer gave her something, either with her permission or not, which led her to get to the state she was in. She could have realized she was drugged or way more inebriated than she intended, suspected Brewer of causing it, and that's why she called 911. Pak may not have understood and that's why he was acting as though she just drank too much. It's also possible she was just drunk and high intentionally and Brewer pulled something. Maybe he tried to initiate something he didn't pay for or something that she put off limits. In her state she was fearful and called 911, also suspecting Pak of being in on it.

After that, she may have just been out of her mind and running from house to house, not knowing what to do and ended up drowning in the swamp. That is most likely what happened IMO. If she did actually encounter that sketchy doctor (name is escaping me right now) and he did give her some type of sedative, that could have reacted badly with what was in her system and then she took off and died due to it. Although I am skeptical that encounter ever happened.

None of this is to say she wasn't murdered or OD'ed at the hands of one of these men and they dumped her body. But to me, she sounded intoxicated or high on the call and paranoid. And there is no conclusive physical evidence she was murdered. So sadly, we may never know.
It makes no sense that she, while drunk and high no less, could manage to go into bramble the police said was too diffeicult for their stone-cold sober dogs. In bear feet and nothing but hosiery on her legs.

MOO

I'm not going to correct the spelling above. I'm just going to note that bear feet would be much more functional that bare feet, lol. Spelling is d-i-f-f-i-c-u-l-t.
 
Last edited:
Due to my lack of expertise and limited insight, I don’t think I am in no place to judge if Shannan Gilbert was or was not a victim of the Long Island Serial Killer but I wonder sometimes too if Shannan had ingested cocaine that night is it possible that she unfortunately suffered from cocaine toxicity. According to the NIH, some of the symptoms of cocaine toxicity include headache, confusion, anxiety, delirium, agitation, rambling, paranoia, high blood pressure, ectopic beats, restlessness, seizures, hyperthermia and also cardiac arrest.

Addiction.co.uk also mentioned that the paranoia not only feels very real to sufferers but the belief that they are being targeted and that people are out to get them becomes all-encompassing and overwhelming.

I sometimes wonder if Shannan Gilbert was victim of cocaine toxicity that could have led to feel filled with fear and distrust and also led to a tragic and fatal cardiac arrest or seizure in the marsh, a place maybe she thought she could hide, lay low or cut across to the main road and its streetlights. I in no way am blaming Shannan and think a swifter and more caring police response could have saved her life or at least quickly connected her to the medical services that would have had the ability to do so if this was the case. According to the article I read, cocaine toxicity could happen to anyone who ingests the substance, even long term users and those who are unaware if their products have been mixed with other illicit drugs.

This is just a thought and could absolutely be wrong or irrelevant.

It's relevant, and on topic. It's also a persistently offered theory.

It's not my theory. Cocaine was not found in the autopsy. I wouldn't doubt she had coke, if only enough to be sporting and if Brewer partied. She was in the service industry, and the customer is always right, lol. But I do not think she had that much coke, if any, nor do I think it explains how she got so far into a marsh.

I did learn something from your post: cocaine toxicity causes hyperthermia? Is that accurate? Because the usually explanation for the pants being removed by people (not me!) who lean towards accidental death is hypothermia.

I do think it's possible she was given what she thought was coke and it was really a sedative. For some reason, the only drug they tested for was coke.

MOO
 
I am reading 12 plus depositions. I have never read she was diagnosed as bipolar. I have read zero to suggest that she wasn’t taking medication at the time of her death.
I think she was diagnosed bipolar. As are several friends an a family member of mine.

And: my friends and family member are not crazy. Nor was Shannan.

MOO
 
I did learn something from your post: cocaine toxicity causes hyperthermia? Is that accurate? Because the usually explanation for the pants being removed by people (not me!) who lean towards accidental death is hypothermia.
Another “party” drug that can cause hyperthermia (and death) is MDMA, aka Ecstasy aka Molly. It was a real problem at raves in the 90s because kids were taking it, dancing for hours in hot clubs, and not hydrating enough (and there were quite a few deaths). I think Pak or someone mentions Ecstasy in some interview or another, so it got me thinking about it.

 
It's relevant, and on topic. It's also a persistently offered theory.

It's not my theory. Cocaine was not found in the autopsy. I wouldn't doubt she had coke, if only enough to be sporting and if Brewer partied. She was in the service industry, and the customer is always right, lol. But I do not think she had that much coke, if any, nor do I think it explains how she got so far into a marsh.

I did learn something from your post: cocaine toxicity causes hyperthermia? Is that accurate? Because the usually explanation for the pants being removed by people (not me!) who lean towards accidental death is hypothermia.

I do think it's possible she was given what she thought was coke and it was really a sedative. For some reason, the only drug they tested for was coke.

MOO
Thanks for the reply! And according to research articles published by the NIH, BMJ, Annemermed and Science Direct so far it is believed that cocaine toxicity can cause hyperthermia




Your point about sedatives is very good though and it does lead me down another train of thought about their possible effects and does cause me to want to learn and research more.
 
Slightly off-topic, but a reminder how every thing in the world is connected.

Shannan Gilbert disappears one day in May, and while searching for her, other bodies are discovered. This leads eventually to the arrest of RH. With the arrest of RH, there is a huge upswing and renewed interest in Shannan's case. Which I believe is great news.

As someone who has been following and posting on this site for years, I have renewed confidence in the SCPD, and that there will be justice for Shannan.

IMO
 
Thanks for the reply! And according to research articles published by the NIH, BMJ, Annemermed and Science Direct so far it is believed that cocaine toxicity can cause hyperthermia




Your point about sedatives is very good though and it does lead me down another train of thought about their possible effects and does cause me to want to learn and research more.
Just keep a balanced point of view as to what the drugs she may have voluntarily or involuntarily consumed can tell us.

They can't explain why Brewer and Pak were behaving the way they were, cajoling her to leave with them rather than just kicking her out/abandoning her. What substances were in her body can't explain why she called 911, why she didn't know where she was, why nobody denied or seemed offended at being accused of trying to kill her, or how she managed to end up face up by the highway. Substances in Shannan don't explain all the lies told by Oak Beach witnesses.

There is limited value in chasing that down. But, yes. According to Pak, who lied often, Shannan was a fan of alcohol and ecstasy. It's possible these were among the few true words he uttered. They are somewhat reasonable choices to medicate mania and depression.

(I'd recommend medicating under the supervision of a doctor, of course.)

MOO
 
Slightly off-topic, but a reminder how every thing in the world is connected.

Shannan Gilbert disappears one day in May, and while searching for her, other bodies are discovered. This leads eventually to the arrest of RH. With the arrest of RH, there is a huge upswing and renewed interest in Shannan's case. Which I believe is great news.

As someone who has been following and posting on this site for years, I have renewed confidence in the SCPD, and that there will be justice for Shannan.

IMO
That couldn't be more on topic, Windsor. Nor could it be more uplifting.

Thanks.

MOO
 
It's relevant, and on topic. It's also a persistently offered theory.

It's not my theory. Cocaine was not found in the autopsy. I wouldn't doubt she had coke, if only enough to be sporting and if Brewer partied. She was in the service industry, and the customer is always right, lol. But I do not think she had that much coke, if any, nor do I think it explains how she got so far into a marsh.

I did learn something from your post: cocaine toxicity causes hyperthermia? Is that accurate? Because the usually explanation for the pants being removed by people (not me!) who lean towards accidental death is hypothermia.

I do think it's possible she was given what she thought was coke and it was really a sedative. For some reason, the only drug they tested for was coke.

MOO
Slightly off-topic, but a reminder how every thing in the world is connected.

Shannan Gilbert disappears one day in May, and while searching for her, other bodies are discovered. This leads eventually to the arrest of RH. With the arrest of RH, there is a huge upswing and renewed interest in Shannan's case. Which I believe is great news.

As someone who has been following and posting on this site for years, I have renewed confidence in the SCPD, and that there will be justice for Shannan.

IMO
I am not sure if SG was murdered but what I find so alarming is that you often don’t hear of someone claiming on a 911 call that people are trying to kill them and they are scared for their life and then no one every hears from them again. Than you have a neighbor in a gated community ( a doctor no less that worked with the local police) just insert himself into this story and call the victims mother claiming he runs a home for wayward girls and he had Shannon but she ran away. Then while searching for this missing girl they find all these dead bodies of SW and a year after that they find her body and on top of all of this you find out the police who are supposed to be investigating this are corrupt and also had relationships with sex workers. They also found another killer during these last 13 years which one of his victims had ties to RH’s victim. I mean come on Hollywood couldn’t make this up .. I don’t think that RH is involved with Shannan’s death but their is definitely something going on on that island with sexworkers being killed and it is starting to feel that Shannan’s death could be a homicide and their are multiple killers. Too many coincidences for me.
 
It's relevant, and on topic. It's also a persistently offered theory.

It's not my theory. Cocaine was not found in the autopsy. I wouldn't doubt she had coke, if only enough to be sporting and if Brewer partied. She was in the service industry, and the customer is always right, lol. But I do not think she had that much coke, if any, nor do I think it explains how she got so far into a marsh.

I did learn something from your post: cocaine toxicity causes hyperthermia? Is that accurate? Because the usually explanation for the pants being removed by people (not me!) who lean towards accidental death is hypothermia.

I do think it's possible she was given what she thought was coke and it was really a sedative. For some reason, the only drug they tested for was coke.

MOO
much like MDMA and meth, cocaine can cause hyperthermia, which can cause people to disrobe trying to cool off.
 
Just keep a balanced point of view as to what the drugs she may have voluntarily or involuntarily consumed can tell us.

They can't explain why Brewer and Pak were behaving the way they were, cajoling her to leave with them rather than just kicking her out/abandoning her. What substances were in her body can't explain why she called 911, why she didn't know where she was, why nobody denied or seemed offended at being accused of trying to kill her, or how she managed to end up face up by the highway. Substances in Shannan don't explain all the lies told by Oak Beach witnesses.

There is limited value in chasing that down. But, yes. According to Pak, who lied often, Shannan was a fan of alcohol and ecstasy. It's possible these were among the few true words he uttered. They are somewhat reasonable choices to medicate mania and depression.

(I'd recommend medicating under the supervision of a doctor, of course.)

MOO
That is true and I will admit that I may be looking at this with a bias lens due to my medical background and seeing my family and friend’s background change drastically after experiencing toxicity from substance use. I have had friends who ran away from the rest of us, once in a moving taxi too, because they swore someone was after us and trying to kill us. It was a terrifying experience that I would happily not repeat. We did have someone leave our place of residence and reside in dark wooded area and almost succumb to hypothermia after using cocaine. I also experienced an acute manic state with a family member struggling with bipolar disorder. I didn’t abandon my loved ones in these instances either and some of these cases did require immediate hospitalization due to the ensuing physical and mental complications. So all-in-all I have to agree have been using a pretty narrow lens which I have to address and confront going forward.

Also, none of my friends or family members have ever called 911 on us nor have they accused me or our social group of being a threat, which is in an important distinction you pointed out.

If his statement to Mari Gilbert is true it also bothers that even though Dr. Brewer is a licensed medical doctor, I question how the appropriateness of him giving Shannan Gilbert any controlled prescription substances, even if they were sedatives. I feel like on the safe side one should be know medical, social and Rx history first in case their any crossed Rx reactions or adverse side effects to be aware of. A big part of me wishes he just called EMT services first so that they and nearby medical facility could monitor her appropriately. Again even in this instance my bias has made me focus a lot on the medications and I should widen my perspective a lot more.

Edit: I think my focus to was influenced on learning from ABC and LI news that short-term drug use wouldn’t be evident on the toxicology reports using SG’a hair and bone and may have been further compromised because of the state of decomposition of her remains unfortunately.
 
Last edited:
There are lots of medical conditions that can bring about hyperthermia and hypothermia and as there is zero evidence of drugs in either of her autopsies...
Right.

Besides, she had tight jeans on, and they can be hard to remove with balance impaired, if it was impaired. She sounds a little slurred in speech, and Coletti pretty much immediately described her as impaired. (But the speech slur could be a slowed down recording. She sounds more natural at 1.25 speed. And the content of her speech is coherent.) if intoxicated, pants removal is a project, not a quick moment while hidden. If she were safe removing her pants, why continue on?

I have not seen one scientist confirm that the conditions could cause hypothermia.

Still, I appreciate posters like apple. While intoxication can't explain all, it is nice to have someone the discuss it for what it's worth.

Shannan was in the middle of a drug, prostitution, money laundering sting. It is reasonable to think drugs were an issue, and possibly a tool to try to harm her. (And it's unreasonable that cocaine, not reported to be her drug of choice, be the sole focus.)

MOO
 
Right.

Besides, she had tight jeans on, and they can be hard to remove with balance impaired, if it was impaired. She sounds a little slurred in speech, and Coletti pretty much immediately described her as impaired. (But the speech slur could be a slowed down recording. She sounds more natural at 1.25 speed. And the content of her speech is coherent.) if intoxicated, pants removal is a project, not a quick moment while hidden. If she were safe removing her pants, why continue on?

I have not seen one scientist confirm that the conditions could cause hypothermia.

Still, I appreciate posters like apple. While intoxication can't explain all, it is nice to have someone the discuss it for what it's worth.

Shannan was in the middle of a drug, prostitution, money laundering sting. It is reasonable to think drugs were an issue, and possibly a tool to try to harm her. (And it's unreasonable that cocaine, not reported to be her drug of choice, be the sole focus.)

MOO
to be fair, MSM has reported her to be a known cocaine user, though she apparently was not using it the night of death. That is known to be her drug of choice. However it doesn't need to be a focus, like you said. She was clean that night.
 
to be fair, MSM has reported her to be a known cocaine user, though she apparently was not using it the night of death. That is known to be her drug of choice. However it doesn't need to be a focus, like you said. She was clean that night.
She very well could have snorted up something she thought was cocaine.

It was a professional must do, it seems. Her employer was a cocaine dealer, among other things. Just like one learns to coat the stomach with fatty foods as well as spill alcohol out clandestinely at times, to appear to be keeping up drinking, I bet she knew very well how to appear to consume as much coke as her client to be congenial, if the client consumed more than she wanted.

MOO
 
Right.

Besides, she had tight jeans on, and they can be hard to remove with balance impaired, if it was impaired. She sounds a little slurred in speech, and Coletti pretty much immediately described her as impaired. (But the speech slur could be a slowed down recording. She sounds more natural at 1.25 speed. And the content of her speech is coherent.) if intoxicated, pants removal is a project, not a quick moment while hidden. If she were safe removing her pants, why continue on?

I have not seen one scientist confirm that the conditions could cause hypothermia.

Still, I appreciate posters like apple. While intoxication can't explain all, it is nice to have someone the discuss it for what it's worth.

Shannan was in the middle of a drug, prostitution, money laundering sting. It is reasonable to think drugs were an issue, and possibly a tool to try to harm her. (And it's unreasonable that cocaine, not reported to be her drug of choice, be the sole focus.)

MOO
Though I am not stating that Shannan Gilbert died of hypothermia, because do not factually know her cause of death, I found online that the marshes on Oak Beach would have temperatures between 52 and 55 degrees Fahrenheit and than found just a couple of articles so far that support that hypothermia could occur at those temperatures. Factors such as age, exhaustion, being in windy or in this case wet (which I believe the marsh was) environments could increase that risk.




 
Right.

Besides, she had tight jeans on, and they can be hard to remove with balance impaired, if it was impaired. She sounds a little slurred in speech, and Coletti pretty much immediately described her as impaired. (But the speech slur could be a slowed down recording. She sounds more natural at 1.25 speed. And the content of her speech is coherent.) if intoxicated, pants removal is a project, not a quick moment while hidden. If she were safe removing her pants, why continue on?

I have not seen one scientist confirm that the conditions could cause hypothermia.

Still, I appreciate posters like apple. While intoxication can't explain all, it is nice to have someone the discuss it for what it's worth.

Shannan was in the middle of a drug, prostitution, money laundering sting. It is reasonable to think drugs were an issue, and possibly a tool to try to harm her. (And it's unreasonable that cocaine, not reported to be her drug of choice, be the sole focus.)

MOO
The question here is, not what her drug was, because no apparent drug was in her autopsy. Now I've studied autopsies on bones, hair etc just trying to figger out accuracy likelihood.
(sad life, I know)

I'm more interested in the nature of the drug of choice in the place that she entered..
shannan was, in effect, staff , that night. A paid worker. That was her role.

What were the roles of everyone else there, particularly in relation to cocaine which is a drug that carried high stakes and penalties at that time..
how high exactly were those stakes for people present in that house that particular night and everyone else that had any dealings with Shannan after she commenced her job, that night.

Let's face it, there is every possibility in the world and zero to disprove it. that Shannan did not remove her own jeans or footwear or anything at all that night or any night before she died

Whose exactly grail was served by killing her when they did, if they did and at the time they did?

She's the victim.
 
2016
''MILLER PLACE, New York – An independent autopsy commissioned by the family of Craigslist escort Shannan Gilbert revealed that a hole may have been drilled in the hyoid bone near her throat, according to lawyer John Ray.

“The autopsy findings are consistent with homicidal strangulation,” said Ray, “just like the other women.”

Baden noted:

“Almost all of the skeletal bones were recovered and appeared normal. There was no evidence of trauma. However, the larynx was missing and only the body of the hyoid bone was found; the two greater horns of that neck bone were missing. These structures, the larynx and the hyoid bone, are often fractured during homicidal manual strangulation. My examination of the recovered body of the hyoid bone, after it had been anthropologically de-fleshed, showed a roughness at the margins where the separated bones had been attached.”


Baden found no evidence to support the theory that drugs might have caused her to fall into the water.

Baden concluded, “There is insufficient information to determine a definite cause of death, but the autopsy findings are consistent with strangulation.”
2016
''MILLER PLACE, New York – An independent autopsy commissioned by the family of Craigslist escort Shannan Gilbert revealed that a hole may have been drilled in the hyoid bone near her throat, according to lawyer John Ray.

“The autopsy findings are consistent with homicidal strangulation,” said Ray, “just like the other women.”

Baden noted:

“Almost all of the skeletal bones were recovered and appeared normal. There was no evidence of trauma. However, the larynx was missing and only the body of the hyoid bone was found; the two greater horns of that neck bone were missing. These structures, the larynx and the hyoid bone, are often fractured during homicidal manual strangulation. My examination of the recovered body of the hyoid bone, after it had been anthropologically de-fleshed, showed a roughness at the margins where the separated bones had been attached.”


Baden found no evidence to support the theory that drugs might have caused her to fall into the water.

Baden concluded, “There is insufficient information to determine a definite cause of death, but the autopsy findings are consistent with strangulation.”
Wow this just doesn’t sit right for me I’m sorry .. maybe if Peter Hackett didn’t insert himself in this case with calling Shannan’s mom with a wack story and then denying it and then all these dead bodies .. I would say yes definitely was an accident but these people are some shady characters.. i really think things are going to start to unravel now that RH was caught.. I don’t think he killed Shannan but something sinister happened to that poor girl.
 
Last edited:
That is true and I will admit that I may be looking at this with a bias lens due to my medical background and seeing my family and friend’s background change drastically after experiencing toxicity from substance use. I have had friends who ran away from the rest of us, once in a moving taxi too, because they swore someone was after us and trying to kill us. It was a terrifying experience that I would happily not repeat. We did have someone leave our place of residence and reside in dark wooded area and almost succumb to hypothermia after using cocaine. I also experienced an acute manic state with a family member struggling with bipolar disorder. I didn’t abandon my loved ones in these instances either and some of these cases did require immediate hospitalization due to the ensuing physical and mental complications. So all-in-all I have to agree have been using a pretty narrow lens which I have to address and confront going forward.

Also, none of my friends or family members have ever called 911 on us nor have they accused me or our social group of being a threat, which is in an important distinction you pointed out.

If his statement to Mari Gilbert is true it also bothers that even though Dr. Brewer is a licensed medical doctor, I question how the appropriateness of him giving Shannan Gilbert any controlled prescription substances, even if they were sedatives. I feel like on the safe side one should be know medical, social and Rx history first in case their any crossed Rx reactions or adverse side effects to be aware of. A big part of me wishes he just called EMT services first so that they and nearby medical facility could monitor her appropriately. Again even in this instance my bias has made me focus a lot on the medications and I should widen my perspective a lot more.

Edit: I think my focus to was influenced on learning from ABC and LI news that short-term drug use wouldn’t be evident on the toxicology reports using SG’a hair and bone and may have been further compromised because of the state of decomposition of her remains unfortunately.
I believe you are referring to Dr. Peter C. Hackett rather than Mr. Joseph Brewer.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
66
Guests online
160
Total visitors
226

Forum statistics

Threads
608,827
Messages
18,246,148
Members
234,460
Latest member
Mysterymind
Back
Top