State rests rebuttal case - thread #169

[SuperTmo]

Oh, he has to look at the context to determine if it's a lie or an exaggeration? ALV looked at a lot of context too!

 

[Mrs G Norris]

Ok I love Juan but dude, chill, just a little ..

 

[gloomy]

you know why I love this height question? JM has no problem with his height and it's a big FU to JA with her twitter!

 

[BrownRice]

I'm an MD---but a Pediatrician---but, Ive had a H--- of a lot more anatomy and pathology exerience than this PSYCHOLOGIST has ever had---and no way in HADES could I EVER testify in a court of law about bullet trajectories and whether someone would incapacitated by a bullet wound or not....DEFENSE you offend me and every rational person on this board!! Bring back the M.E.!!!

Yes, this is ridiculous! I loved how Juan asked him how many autopsies he had performed. Waits a second and then says it's ok if it's a high number, just guess. The jury realizes this as well.

 

[katydid23]

Juan has trapped this witness into ADMITTING that the killer exaggerated her stories. BAM.


Did she exaggerate when she talked about the 'abuse'?

 

[jellybeanz]

Where's he putting all this water?

Apart from all over the stand.

 

[wenwe4]

Borderline Personality doesn't exclude PTSD or Anxiety . . you have to justify why all these consistent results

bullets path of travel . . change direction . . .not his speciality . . what brain can do . . right hand side over the eyebrow and ended up in left cheek - thru his sinuses

deflected into what area . . . to right and left motor to incacatate . . speech . .what ever you say what that person could not do . . motor strips located

frontal parietal . . . in center and frontal on both sides . .

bullet entered from where lodged arrow straight not touch areas of incacity

duramater was intact . . it would have to have to be ....one thing has to be if damage inside there has to be entry from outside.

no more quesrtions

JM - pattern of consistenty in the test

take look element #631 elevated . . .F scale . .

validty scale elevated
yes 2 of them are elevated . . issue of malingering
can be issue of secondary gain . . .

lied on 2 tests isn't that pattern

lie vs. exaggerated symptom of severity

do you go to the ALV school of
objection

if tehy exaggerate they are still lying . .
when does exaggerate become a lie . . 10% or 20% or 30%
not a percent . . you have other things to look @ need to be cautious

this person display many symptoms
didnt you tell me

when exaggeration become a lie
not same thing
2 different dimensions you are asking - having hard time answering

if prosecutor said he was 6' tall . . is that exaggerating or lie
probably both

if he said 6'2" . .
don't know definitive cut off that i know about . .
anyone can exaggerate that becomes a lie
do you believe this prosecutor is 6' tall
no
prosector said 6'2"
could be either exaggeration or lie . . .no specific cut off . . @ 5'8" or 5'9"

i asked you about 6'2 remember
objection
approach please

 

[JustMeDeb]

The longer the DT decides to try and fight today, the less time they are going to have to prepare for closing. Go ahead, we have all night.

 

[ShadyLady]

Jodi has lied her way through life...and she does not like being called out.

 

[shiloh42]

An exaggeration becomes a lie when it's told to deceive someone else... like getting off on a murder charge.

 

[HarvestMoon]

Wild About Trial has been extremely reliable for me, today!

Not for me

 

[ljwf22]

Wow! I went to mow 2 hours ago and am surprised court is still in session. (Although I knew the judge said they'd go all night if needed.) Did they take a dinner break?

 

[Charterhouse]

With leading question by JW.

Doesn't mater to me what JW said. He said Dr Horn's report was wrong. Dr. Horn is in the building.

 

[TexMex]

If The Proeutor tells you he is 6'2"...is that an exaggeration or a lie?
Lol, Juan

 

[zoozoo]

Oh no, Dr. G just brought up the "context" word.

 

[Arishia]

I'm an MD---but a Pediatrician---but, Ive had a H--- of a lot more anatomy and pathology exerience than this PSYCHOLOGIST has ever had---and no way in HADES could I EVER testify in a court of law about bullet trajectories and whether someone would incapacitated by a bullet wound or not....DEFENSE you offend me and every rational person on this board!! Bring back the M.E.!!!

:goodpost: Thank you!

 

[EquallyDivided]

I love this! After watching Juan, I want to go run around a track....

AND I hate almost all forms of exercise!

 

[Curious Me]

It's easy to resent Willmott's objections and need to approach. She is so whiny.

Juan is the air we breathe in this case.

 

[seguek9]

Oh dear spirits....

 

[mobius99]

IMO, it was unnecessary for JM to bring up ALV. Someone on the jury might have liked her a little better than WS posters.

I doubt it. moo