Supreme Court Nominee #2

Welcome to Websleuths!
Click to learn how to make a missing person's thread

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think when considering a nominee the most important part is to review past cases and their demeanor and fairness toward both sides at the time. Plus their knowledge of the law and demeanor on the bench.

16 of his opinions in the WDC..appellate court was also adopted in the opinion of the SC as well. That is an amazing achievement.

Even defense attorneys have said JK is a fair judge. I haven't seen anyone who has appeared before him in the last 12 years say otherwise.

He is known for his calm temperament giving respect to both sides. Like he said...the one who has the law on their side will be the one who wins. That is how any judge should rule
Not one who interprets the law and how they want it be read but upholds the laws as they are written.

Even though he showed anger and emotional sadness in his latest testimony when he personally was being attacked and accused imo that has nothing to do with his temperance when he is in a courtroom.. He is well known to consistently have the demeanor needed to be a good judge that listens closely to each side of the argument.

Imo the worst thing for anyone would be if they felt they were being falsely accused of a sex crime they insist they did not do. So I found his anger justified and anyone accused of the same would be madder than heck if they knew those claims were false. It showed JJ..who is a human being who hurts and feels anger like everyone does during traumatic times in their lives.

The situation for him and Dr. Ford were totally different situations.. She was handled with kid gloves by both parties...rightly so.

He faced 10 crouching tigers ready to spring to attack him and they did just like he had seen them do in the media for many days before he was finally allowed to testify again.

No one seem to care that he and his family were also getting death threats during the time he had to wait to testify again.

Imo

Dr. Blasey met in person with the FBI in SF to report the death threats made on her & on her family. I have not read or heard that Judge K did likewise. I am not saying that if he didn't report them they didn't happen, but I am straightforwardly saying that it has become common place in virtually every forum, online or not, for folks to play politics & defense by accusing other folks of being reponsible for death threats, or to claim to have received death threats when none were ever made or were laughably exaggerated. See, for instance, the claims by Nurmi & Wilmott that they faced death threats when what was said to them amounted to - your client will pay, yada yada . Or Scott Pruitt, who claimed threats to his safety justified armrd guards and private planes and bullet proof desks because once or twice- literally only that- fellow air plane passengers told him he was killing the environment and shame on him. Boo. Hoo.
 
Excellent post oceanblueeyes. Thank You.

I think when considering a nominee the most important part is to review past cases and their demeanor and fairness toward both sides at the time. Plus their knowledge of the law and demeanor on the bench.

16 of his opinions in the WDC..appellate court was also adopted in the majority opinions of the SC as well. That is an amazing achievement.

Even defense attorneys have said JK is a fair judge. I haven't seen anyone who has appeared before him in the last 12 years say otherwise.

He is known for his calm temperament giving respect to both sides. Like he said...the one who has the law on their side will be the one who wins. That is how any judge should rule
Not one who interprets the law and how they want it read but upholds the laws as they are written.

Even though he showed anger and emotional sadness in his latest testimony when he personally was being attacked and accused imo that has nothing to do with his temperance when he is in a courtroom.. He is well known to consistently have the demeanor needed to be a good judge that listens closely to each side of the argument.

Imo the worst thing for anyone would be if they felt they were being falsely accused of a sex crime they insist they did not do. So I found his anger justified and anyone accused of the same would be madder than heck if they knew those claims were false. It showed JK.....as a human being who hurts and feels anger like everyone does during traumatic times in their lives.

The situation for him and Dr. Ford were totally different situations.. She was handled with kid gloves by both parties...rightly so.

He faced 10 crouching tigers ready to spring to attack him and they did just like he had seen them do in the media for many days before he was finally allowed to testify again.

No one seem to care that he and his family were also getting death threats during the time he had to wait to testify again.

Imo
 
“We have her yearbooks,” the anonymous staffer said. “She will not make a good witness.”

Christine Blasey Ford's Senate Judiciary Committee to reference Yearbooks | National Review

In one of the yearbooks, girls wrote about hiring male strippers for sweet sixteen parties and ruining “heirloom Persian rugs” with vomit.

“The tenth grade taught us how to party,” girls wrote in another section. “Loss of consciousness is often an integral part of the party scene.”


Yes, and ?

This may be true. Also, true is that he had references to parties and Renata Alumnus. They were teenagers with the privilege to have monies for substance use and abuse. These kinds of comments are common in yearbooks. The behaviors were also common when you have an adolescent with brains developing and the ability to be on their own with little accountability.
 
I wish young gals would have watched Dr. Ford on tv, it would go a long way to helping them avoid going to parties to have a "good time".
Seriously? More of the same old toxic masculinity rape culture. Don't hold men responsible for thier abhorrent behaviour, tell women they should not be out having a good time because our society owes them zero expectation of safety in a world where boys will be boys?
 
What is the fact? She personally isn't responsible for what others were posing in yearbooks. Otherwise you judge everybody by the teenager with the worst behavior, but not all are the same.

The FACT is her yearbook is online. That’s what I said.

@jjenny, the discussion leading up to your question was not, in fact, whether the yearbook was or wasn't online. It was regarding the perceived value and source of reporting about Ford's yearbook.

Your questions are on point! I enjoy your posts.
 
What is the fact? She personally isn't responsible for what others were posing in yearbooks. Otherwise you judge everybody by the teenager with the worst behavior, but not all are the same.

Thanks for a segue into what I find quite amusing in this otherwise serious discussion. Why the focus on someone's high school yearbook? How significant is one's high school yearbook in the grand scheme of life?

I spent 12 years in a small parochial school. There were 72 students in my graduating class of 1968. I only purchased the yearbook my senior year because seniors were prominently featured in settings beyond sports or cheerleading. I was also recruited for the yearbook staff senior year, so the annual provided a sample of my writing. I didn't participate in sports or cheerleading, so the only photos of me in 9th, 10th, and 11th grade were thumbnails of annual school picture and a group photo of Future Teachers Club. I kept the yearbook for many years but finally tossed it when moving into current home. High school was a very long time ago and certainly didn't define my life. I don't understand the focus or significance of high school yearbooks of BK or CB-F.
 
I think that because Dr Ford's has no corroborating evidence of her assault some are now trying to make Judge Kavanaugh look like a horrible person who is unfit to be on the Supreme Court.

Time to shift gears I suppose. JMO

He has always been a bad candidate.

Feingold questioned Kavanaugh, who had played a critical role in advancing the Bush administration’s judicial nominations, about his handling of the controversial nomination of Charles Pickering Sr. to serve on the Fifth Circuit. Kavanaugh feigned ignorance, claiming that “This was not one of the judicial nominees that I was primarily handling.”

In fact, as Feingold notes in a Huffington Post essay, “newly released emails show that Kavanaugh appeared to be the primary person handling Pickering’s nomination, at least by 2003, and was heavily involved in pushing for his confirmation as early as March 2002.

Allegations Against Kavanaugh Must Be Investigated, as Must His Lies Under Oath
 
Thanks for a segue into what I find quite amusing in this otherwise serious discussion. Why the focus on someone's high school yearbook? How significant is one's high school yearbook in the grand scheme of life?

I spent 12 years in a small parochial school. There were 72 students in my graduating class of 1968. I only purchased the yearbook my senior year because seniors were prominently featured in settings beyond sports or cheerleading. I was also recruited for the yearbook staff senior year, so the annual provided a sample of my writing. I didn't participate in sports or cheerleading, so the only photos of me in 9th, 10th, and 11th grade were thumbnails of annual school picture and a group photo of Future Teachers Club. I kept the yearbook for many years but finally tossed it when moving into current home. High school was a very long time ago and certainly didn't define my life. I don't understand the focus or significance of high school yearbooks of BK or CB-F.

The focus on BK's yearbook became important because he LIED about what was in it. He lied about Renate Alumnus, Boof and Devils Triangle and everyone knows it. He is a compulsive liar and does not belong on the Supreme Court. Lying about a situation has gotten more polititians into trouble than what they were lying about. cough <Clinton> cough
 

I posted links to media reports about the Jesuit magazine yesterday. I've also read several reports about Yale reaction to Kavanaugh's nomination, as well as the American Bar Association.

Yale Law School dean says Brett Kavanaugh should be investigated over sexual assault allegations

American Bar Association Said FBI Investigation Should Come Before A Kavanaugh Vote
 
Last edited:
FBI investigation.

Even if the FBI can establish a specific date & time & place for the gathering at
which B says she was attacked, it will inevitably come to whether anyone was aware of/saw/knew/was told of the attack.

1. She says she didn't tell anyone about it at the time or for long after she was out of HS.

2. If her close girl friend who was there didn't know/wasn't aware of what happened, there is no reason to expect FBI prompting & investigation will result in other named party goers who were downstairs remembering more, especially if the sight of Judge & K drunk & laughing & bouncing off the walls was commonplace.

3. The one alleged witness in the room is Mark Judge, and imo it is fairly certain that he will continue to say he has no memory of that night, and more, that he has a reason for not remembering in any case, which is that by his own admission, he was a black out drunk at that time and for years beyond. No direct answers there.

Then what? I think the next logical avenue is for the FBI to pursue the possibility that K did assault her, but that he did not remember doing so, perhaps still doesn't, but also knows he is vulnerable to it being proven that he in fact often enough DID drink to excess, enough & often enough to make it plausible both he & she are telling the truth. He did, but he doesn't remember.

Unfortunately for K, there are plenty of folks who knew him in both HS and college who could tell the FBI he did indeed drink to excess.

K boxed himself in years ago by stating under oath that he never drank to excess (and would have had to lied about that to the FBI on background checks as well). He cornered himself still further by stating there was no possibility that her story could be true in any way because he had never had so much to drink that he would have acted that way or not remembered afterwards.

The FBI could thus theoretically present info to the Senate Judiciary Committe that Senators could interpret as evidence that K had perjured himself about his drinking.


Would that be enough to have his nomination withdrawn or voted down? Ummm. Imo, no matter the obvious unacceptablity of a SC nominee perjuring himself. ..I'd bet no.
 
Last edited:
That is an interesting idea. When people drink out of a bottle in a paper bag, they are considered loser scum.

If they drink the same anount at the country club, that is being sociable. And they may be enjoying their fine booze which makes them a sophisticate.. .

Many people who drink become what I call a pro. They drink all day yet never appear drunk. They are functional alcoholics.

I wonder if that is something that is examined

Alcoholism is a progressive disease. "Functional alcoholic" is only temporary. It may be a lengthy period of time that someone appears functiinal, but it always progresses. I don't know if BK is currently an alcoholic, but I have zero doubt in my mind that he hasn't come to terms with, nor is he being honest with himself, let alone anyone else, about his excessive drinking habits.
 
Who knows if it is? If this man is an alcoholic and has been a prominent high level judge, it is not working. The background checks started long ago, well before his nomination.

i think we are thinking all background checks are similar

i think there might be a different test for a lower level judge that the SC

etc etc

all behavior has meaning hiding 100 , 000 documents - they were not recipes

I think a lot of that ( like the affirmative action/ hawaiian)is gonna be about racist homophobic anti semitic immigration disgusting stuff

I do think we should be a little less surprised by this disgusting event

if no one cares if someone grabs things then why would think a failed rape is all that big a deal

i think the nation is just exhausted the past year

Folks IMO need to mindful of what might be ahead - and I am telling ya ll ( I cant do tucker or hannity) but it is very "cautionary" tales --but seriously you need to have Fox on in the background like once every 24 hours -- daypart shows are easier to handle- but I am very serious here

it is actually like a thermometer - you can tell the "temperature " -- this week very important to do so imo

its scary but needs to be endured -- if your not retired and can only do prime time that blond haired (pretty) Not that Ingram one -- later is sane

just once every 24 hours and you don't need to do it for long

pay attn for what they are doing in the first 15 minute segments at the top of any hour

all moo

like last week there some other big deal and they were doing (in C segment) if some simpson characters are gay!!!

if you cant endure listening keep a window open and just check out the title cards on the bottom from time to time

Trump supporters should be doing the same imo -- rachel maddow (msnbc)is the best imo

this viewpoint is obviously only my opinion --although scary it is also amazing!
 
High might mean ceiling climbing?

Or maybe the party crasher got confused between up and down and thought he was going to the basement to get another keg and accidently went up into the ceiling!

Rameriz will be part of this investigation

OT

Hahahahahahaaa! I appreciate the visual and your sense of humor, @CARIIS. This is a serious topic, and it can be good for us to share a fleeting moment of humor together.
Thanks for a segue into what I find quite amusing in this otherwise serious discussion. Why the focus on someone's high school yearbook? How significant is one's high school yearbook in the grand scheme of life?

I spent 12 years in a small parochial school. There were 72 students in my graduating class of 1968. I only purchased the yearbook my senior year because seniors were prominently featured in settings beyond sports or cheerleading. I was also recruited for the yearbook staff senior year, so the annual provided a sample of my writing. I didn't participate in sports or cheerleading, so the only photos of me in 9th, 10th, and 11th grade were thumbnails of annual school picture and a group photo of Future Teachers Club. I kept the yearbook for many years but finally tossed it when moving into current home. High school was a very long time ago and certainly didn't define my life. I don't understand the focus or significance of high school yearbooks of BK or CB-F.

You make some extremely valid points, BDE. Thank you for this thoughtful post.

Overall, I agree with you.

I think there’s more value placed on Kavanaugh’s yearbook in this instance (and, to a lesser degree, Ford’s and others’ they both went to school with), because it gives context to and “informs,” per se, the culture, attitudes and behaviors during the time in question.

Like Kavanaugh’s much maligned flip calendar from the period, it’s one of a very limited number of “documents” available from that period.

So both take on a seemingly inordinate amount of weight since they’re almost all we (meaning the public) have to quasi validate or invalidate the alleged victim’s testimony.

All MOO, of course.
 
Alcoholism is a progressive disease. "Functional alcoholic" is only temporary. It may be a lengthy period of time that someone appears functiinal, but it always progresses. I don't know if BK is currently an alcoholic, but I have zero doubt in my mind that he hasn't come to terms with, nor is he being honest with himself, let alone anyone else, about his excessive drinking habits.

The 4 Stages Of Alcoholism For The Functioning Alcoholic



The term “functioning alcoholic” is generally used to avoid labeling someone as a stereotypical alcoholic. Alcohol is one of the most commonly abused substances and often has specific stereotypes linked to abuse of it.

When picturing someone struggling with alcohol addiction, it is common to imagine a disheveled, homeless person, or someone who has lost their home, family and other possessions due to their alcohol abuse. These stereotypes are only the end result of a much longer process, and they can mislead functioning alcoholics because their lives have yet to fit these stereotypes.

Someone who uses the term “functioning alcoholic” to define themselves may be in denial about the extent of their problem. The reality is that a functioning alcoholic can still be controlled by their alcohol abuse.

Ready to make a change?
Call to speak to a treatment specialist.

1-888-816-8415
Signs Of A Functioning Alcoholic
If alcohol abuse is suspected, there are a few signs that can indicate there is a problem.

Possible signs of a functioning alcoholic may include:

  • if a person drinks alcohol to replace eating food.
  • angry or defensive reactions when someone brings up the possibility of alcoholism.
  • not being able to remember what happened while under the influence of alcohol.
  • setting drinking limits and failing to stick to them.
  • participating in “pre-drinking” before an evening out.
  • attempting to hide drinking from others.
  • drinking in the morning, throughout the day or while alone.
  • joking about the possibility of being an alcoholic.
Alcoholism is a disease that slowly develops over time, not all at once. While everyone may experience this progression differently, there are four common stages people go through when becoming a functional alcoholic.

Stage #1: Occasional Alcohol Abuse And Binge Drinking
The first stage of alcoholism is a general experimentation with the substance. Individuals in this stage may not be familiar with different types of alcohol, so they are more likely to test their limits.

This stage of alcoholism is often defined by the goal of “drinking to get drunk.” People who abuse alcohol often use it to self-medicate and escape negative thoughts and feelings. This is how problem drinking starts.

addictioncampuses.com-The-4-Stages-of-Alcoholism-for-the-Functioning-Alcoholic-Stage-1.png


Usually, people in the first stage of alcoholism are not drinking every day, and they are still able to perform daily activities. Although drinking may not consume their thoughts, they may need to drink more to reach the desired level of intoxication.

During this stage, someone may believe they are still functioning because they have a job and they are successfully maintaining relationships. In reality, this isn’t true, because after they consume their first alcoholic drink, they usually struggle to control their drinking.

Stage #2: Increased Drinking As A Coping Mechanism
The second stage of alcoholism is defined by the mental obsession with the next drink. Many people consume alcohol in order to relax and unwind. But, those struggling with alcohol abuse may see drinking as the only way to relieve stress.

Over time, other coping skills will fade away and all negative thoughts and feelings will be addressed by drinking alcohol. At this point, people may not be physically addicted to alcohol, but they may be psychologically dependent on it.

addictioncampuses.com-The-4-Stages-of-Alcoholism-for-the-Functioning-Alcoholic-Stage-2.png


During this stage, outward appearances don’t change much, but individuals may be routinely hungover. This is often justified by saying they just like to “cut loose and party.”

Stage #3: The Consequences Of Problem Drinking Start To Show
The third stage of alcoholism is usually identified when others begin to show concern for someone’s drinking habits. For those struggling with alcohol abuse, stage three is all about managing the consequences of their drinking.

Individuals in this stage of alcoholism may try to set boundaries for themselves, but they will be unable to stick to them. Possible boundaries can include telling themselves, or someone else, they will only have a certain number of drinks and then stop, or they will drink only beer instead of hard liquor.

addictioncampuses.com-The-4-Stages-of-Alcoholism-for-the-Functioning-Alcoholic-Stage-3.png


During this stage, individuals may feel like they are a “functioning alcoholic,” despite all the changes alcohol has caused them to make in their lives. These changes may include a new group of friends or frequently changing jobs.

At this point, an individual’s life is centered around managing the consequences of their alcohol abuse. People may continue to compare themselves to the stereotypical alcoholics who have lost it all and assure themselves that is not who they are.

This is scientific stuff there is not a 10% thing -- its out there in the addiction literature

Disease-of-Alcoholism-rev-e1494725600371.jpg


The 4 Stages of Alcoholism for the Functioning Alcoholic
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
73
Guests online
1,621
Total visitors
1,694

Forum statistics

Threads
606,175
Messages
18,199,991
Members
233,765
Latest member
Jasonax3
Back
Top