Australia - 3 dead after eating wild mushrooms, Leongatha, Victoria, Aug 2023 #10 *Arrest*

Could have been, maybe incorrectly reported, or maybe the prosecution just don't see it as worthwhile given she's admitted to picking the mushrooms
It should be very important to the prosecution, in my opinion, as it is evidence of her experience, knowledge and expertise which negates or reduces the defense argument that she pick the deadly ones by accident.

As it stands in the trial at the moment, her foraging has only been put forward as a once off.

MOO
 
Either way you won't know that they're not being called until the prosecution are done I guess. And if they're not called, you'll know either they weren't needed or the media got it wrong, as they frequently do.

especially if only one media outlet reported it
 
Could have been, maybe incorrectly reported, or maybe the prosecution just don't see it as worthwhile given she's admitted to picking the mushrooms
Yes, she's admitted to picking them. But I think it could be worthwhile to show the jury that she had experience foraging, had lots of books about proper identification, and knew what she was doing. And testimony from others that foraged with her or discussed it with her could be helpful?

I think they need to shut down the 'Oops, it was an accident' narrative if possible.
 
Here are today's updates from the Herald Sun


2 hours ago

'Fascinated by the world of fungi': Poisons specialist takes the stand​

Retired pharmacist Christine McKenzie has been called to give evidence after a short delay.
She said she worked for 17 years as a poisons information specialist at the Victorian Poisons Information Centre before retiring in 2023.
Ms McKenzie told the court she would answer calls from members of the public after the potential ingestion of fungi and give them advice.
But she said she “wanted to know more” about mushrooms beyond the knowledge required for her work, describing them as “beautiful”.
“I was fascinated by the world of fungi,” she said.
“I did a lot more extra reading myself and went on some forays with some experts … bushwalking because it became a bit of a personal interest.”
She added: “A lovely way to go for a bushwalk is with an expert.”
Ms McKenzie told the court she wanted to be able to identify “relatively quickly and easily” the most toxic fungi, including death cap mushrooms.
But she noted she was not a forager.
“I don’t go for a walk to find them to eat.”

2 hours ago
Highlight

Death caps spotted in another area near Leongatha: Witness​

Ms McKenzie told the court she had an account on the citizen science website iNaturalist where members of the public post sightings of plants, animals and fungi.
She confirmed she had contributed 70 posts, mainly identifying fungi.
The court heard she had made two observations of death cap mushrooms, including in Loch, near Leongatha, on April 18, 2023.
Ms McKenzie said she was on a walk with her grandson and the family dog when she observed the death caps under an oak tree near the recreation oval.
“I took photos first and then … we had a dog poo bag with us, so I removed all the death cap mushrooms I could find,” she said.
“Because of my training, I’m well aware of the toxicity of amanita phalloides (death cap mushrooms) and it was a popular area for people to take their dogs.”
She added that local children also attend “bush kinder” near the oval.
The court heard Ms McKenzie was concerned more death caps could grow in the area over the “subsequent weeks”.
The jury is now being shown a screenshot of her iNaturalist post.
When shown one of the photos she took on April 18, Ms McKenzie remarked: “If I say so myself, that’s quite a nice image of a mushroom”, prompting laughs from the courtroom.
She described the death cap as having a white cap with a yellow tinge and white gills.
She told the court the remnants of the veil could be seen in one of the photos.
The court heard iNaturalist allows users to zoom in on a map to see the exact location where a sighting has been made.
In its opening address to the jury, the prosecution alleged that phone data suggests Erin travelled to the Loch area 10 days later on April 28.

1747628677419.webp
1747628695283.webp
2 hours ago

Witness 'in the dark' on wider fungi kingdom​

Under cross-examination by defence barrister Sophie Stafford, Ms McKenzie agreed she looks out for toxic mushrooms because she does not want anyone to mistakenly forage and ingest them.
“I often suspected there would be death cap mushrooms under the oak tree near the oval,” she said, but confirmed that she had never seen them growing in that area before.
The court heard she was in Loch to visit her daughter in April 2023 and did not return to the tree to see whether more death caps had grown.
Ms McKenzie told the court she would consider herself a “novice” when it came to identifying non-toxic mushrooms and uses iNaturalist as an identification tool.
“The toxic mushrooms that I’m aware of in my work, I feel much more confident about,” she said.
“As far as the wider fungi kingdom, I’m as much in the dark as anybody else.”
She has completed her evidence and left the witness box.

1 hours ago
Highlight

Digital forensic expert takes the stand​

Digital forensics expert Dr Matthew Sorell has entered the witness box.
The court heard he has experience in more than 400 criminal matters and one of his areas of expertise was mobile phone network data.
He has started giving the jurors a lesson on base stations or the infrastructure that provides a radio connection between a mobile phone and the network through antennas.
He said base stations could be located on a telecommunications tower, a tall commercial building, a grain silo or even a large water tank.
“In an urban environment, these are spread out throughout the suburbs,” he said.
“In country areas, there are typically 1-2 base stations that cover a local town and then there will be base stations designed to cover … areas between towns.
“We end up with a relatively large number of base stations, placed carefully throughout that environment.”
The jury has been shown a map of several base stations in the Gippsland area, depicted by circles.
A base station can be seen at Korumburra, Loch South, Arawata, Kardella and Holmes Hill.
Dr Sorell is explaining that the antennas of a base station will point in different directions to provide coverage on all sides.
The court heard the circles did not indicate the area of coverage.
“In a country area, base stations are deliberately placed to provide coverage into a town or they’re placed at key locations … like major roads … or hilltops for the purpose of providing wide area coverage,” he said.
Dr Sorell will return to the witness box at 2.15pm.
 
1m ago

Phone serial numbers explained​


The jury is back after a well-earned lunch and has been provided their second glossary for the trial (earlier they got one containing medical terms).

This one contains mobile phone-related terms like "Base station", "Antenna", "MSISDN" (phone number), "IMEI" (phone serial number), and "IMSI" (subscription) and "SIM card" (information about your subscription).

Dr Sorell is asked about International Mobile Equipment Identity or IMEI numbers, a unique serial number that each mobile phone has.

From an IMEI number, Dr Sorell says he can identify a specific mobile phone.

He is then asked to explain the International Mobile Subscriber Identity or IMSI number, a unique number that identifies each subscriber on a mobile phone network, similar to a fingerprint for mobile users.

He also explains the UTC (Coordinated Universal Time) time zone.

 
2m ago

Timeline of communication records shown to court​


An incredibly-detailed table of more than 30 rows is flashed up on the court screen, titled "Summary of communication records".

The court hears that Dr Sorell has constructed a timeline which he will talk about soon.

The rows on the table detail things such as the time of each call, the location where it was made, and the IMEI and IMSI numbers as mentioned earlier.

 
It should be very important to the prosecution, in my opinion, as it is evidence of her experience, knowledge and expertise which negates or reduces the defense argument that she pick the deadly ones by accident.

As it stands in the trial at the moment, her foraging has only been put forward as a once off.

MOO
As I posted earlier, as a child I knew not to pick the mushrooms that were white underneath...
 
less than a minute ago

How often your phone 'pings' off towers​

Dr Sorell has re-entered the witness box after the lunch break.
He said communication records or “call charge records” (CCR) provide basic detail relating to calls, texts and data usage.
He told the court there was another type of record called “event-based monitoring” (EBM), which provides “more high-level detail” related to signalling.
“It’s your phone communicating with the network,” he said of EBM.
The court heard a mobile phone may make one communication record every 15 minutes, but it may make five to 10 EBM records every minute, especially in a metropolitan area, as the phone connects with several base stations.

 
2m ago

'Processed' phone records shown to court​


By Kristian Silva​

The court is shown what is described as a "processed" record. This appears to be a record of Erin Patterson’s phone usage.

The record resembles a phone bill, just way more complicated and in font so small you’d need a magnifying glass to read.

The prosecution points out the number ending in 783. Earlier in the trial, the prosecution alleged that Erin Patterson had connected a SIM card with a number ending in 783.

Dr Sorell points out that if a SIM card is moved to a different device, the IMEI number will change while the phone number remains the same.

 
4m ago

Expert asked to analyse four years of phone records​


"Now I want to turn to the records you've analysed for this case," prosecutor Jane Warren says.

With a grin, Dr Sorell confirms he's been given more than four years of records to analyse for this case.

"It's unusual that I'd cover four years of records," he says.

"Normally I'd be given a targeted period of about a month, or a few weeks or a few days."

Ms Warren says Erin Patterson was the registered used for the 783 phone number being used.

She notes the IMEI number changed several times during the period.

 
5m ago

Search for phone activity near death cap sightings​


Dr Sorell confirms he was asked to analyse the records for any movements near the towns of Loch or Outtrim.

Earlier in the trial, we heard internet posts stating death cap mushrooms were found near both towns in early 2023.

Before turning to the specific phone evidence relating to Erin Patterson, Dr Sorell fires off a disclaimer.

"This evidence has quite significant limitations in terms of both time and place," he says.

"The best that can be said is that a phone is in a general area … or that the phone is not in a particular area."
He says, for instance, the records won’t give much away if a person leaves their phone on airplane mode or if the battery has gone flat.

 
2 minutes ago

Erin's phone records analysed​

Dr Sorell confirmed he had been provided four-and-a-half years of call charge records, from January 2019 to August 2023, relating to a phone belonging to Erin.
The court also heard he was provided “targeted dates” of event-based monitoring records.
He confirmed he analysed records relating to the Loch and Outtrim areas.
The jury has previously heard observations of death cap mushrooms in Loch and Outtrim were posted to the citizen science website iNaturalist in April and May 2023.
“In the first instance of those four-and-a-half years of records, (we were) asked to identify periods where the phone could have been in the Outtrim area,” he said.
 
1m ago

The search for Erin Patterson's phone in Outtrim​


A map of base stations near Outtrim is shown to the court. In the middle of the map is the Outtrim base station.

A highlighted area shows the Outtrim postcode area and three nearby base stations - "Outtrim", "KONGWAKCMTS", and "Leongatha".

Dr Sorell says he was asked to identify periods of when Erin Patterson’s phone could have been in the Outtrim area.

He tells the court it is possible to connect to the Outtrim base station from outside the Outtrim postcode if at high elevation.

But Dr Sorell says if you were in and around Outtrim for some period of time, he would expect a phone would connect to "Outtrim" or "KONGWAKCMTS", or both.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
100
Guests online
6,618
Total visitors
6,718

Forum statistics

Threads
623,771
Messages
18,472,063
Members
240,525
Latest member
Gphedil19
Back
Top