Just pointing out I do not find it odd having a make up bag in the car. I know several women who bring one everywhere they go. I'm not one of them, lol, but seriously I know women who cart a full make up bag and touch things up, or change their look entirely, in the car. Personally, I believe that part of the story. It looks like Tamilka wears a lot of make up in the pics we have seen of her.
The trackpants sound absurd due to how baggy they would be, BUT that can be a style choice, and they may have been a desirable brand.
I'm very confused about when they supposedly realized money and jewelry was missing? I think Pheobe would have had motivation to steal given her expressed desire to never return. Not meant as a personal comment. I think ANYONE in that situation would have motivation. And likewise, if someone stole from you, that would be motivation for violence against them, if not intent to murder.
We already know there are some serious problems with anger and weapons here, so not a big leap at all.