MA MA - Ana Walshe - Supposedly Left Home in Rideshare to Airport - Cohasset #2

[Ilex]

Can you tell us which court department etc. in order to find it, please? The link just goes to the main page.

I don't know why it won't let me link it! Sorry, it's under Superior Court, Suffolk Civil Court. Search under Brian Walshe

 

[Gardenista]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1612870176394854400

 

[di anna]

This guy sounds like a wheeler dealer, and his wife obviously was either oblivious
to his shortcomings or as the old saying goes, "Love is blind". I think often people sometimes have their own method of coping and over a period of time she found her own way of coping. Three children in rapid succession had to be difficult under the circumstances.

 

[Gardenista]

oh please share more interesting tidbits, I hit a paywall

Put it on reader view and it will come up.

 

[rkendmar]

But there was a case against Brian in 1999 from Austen Riggs. Was Brian admitted twice to the facility? https://www.masscourts.org/eservices/search.page.134?x=xaES8idUj9KYQ8hAMU9neA

What date was this case filed?
Was it civil court?

 

[Ilex]

Put it on reader view and it will come up.

I can't see it either. The Boston Globe thing comes up and says I have to subscribe.

 

[Gardenista]

Brian Walshe: Court docs reveal struggles with mental health, relationship between Ana & his mother

Brian Walshe was born into a Massachusetts family with “economic means” but his childhood was hardly considered “privileged,” according to more than a dozen character letters sent to a federal judge in September 2021.

www.boston25news.com

 

[mendicant]

Yes, re: the Globe -- to which I do subscribe -- article, "your experiences may vary" in being able to get the damned thing. For some reason, once again, the site's refusing to open for me. Ongoing issue, it was ever thus, etc.

Therefore, share all the good stuff, i.e. that first marriage factoid.

 

[Snoopster]

Husband of missing woman had business, personal ties to North Shore

MARBLEHEAD — Investigators searching for a missing Cohasset woman have spent several days searching and attempting to re-trace the movements of her husband, Brian R. Walshe, after he allegedly told

www.salemnews.com

In an affidavit filed in Quincy District Court Monday, Cohasset police say Walshe, 47, told them that hours after last seeing his wife Ana at around 6 a.m. on Jan. 1, he had traveled to Swampscott to see his mother, who recently underwent cataract surgery. Walshe, who had been on home confinement awaiting sentencing in a federal art fraud case, had been granted permission to leave his home from 3 to 9 p.m. on Jan. 1 to take his mother home to her apartment, telling the court that she would be staying with him until that date. However, Walshe told police that his mother had recovered more quickly and, he said, drove herself home earlier. He told investigators that he planned to run some errands for her and went to the CVS and the Whole Foods stores near her home.

So what is the true story??
If his mother was at his place after cataract surgery, then how could she drive herself home? How was her car there? Apparently the plan was that he would look after her and then drive her home. But miraculously she drove herself home and her car was at Brian's place. If the plan was that Brian was going to drive her home, her car wouldn't have been there. That doesn't jive.

Was his mother at his house or not? Curious minds want to know.

 

[shotgun09]

Lots of interesting info in this article

Ana Walshe’s husband has a history of chasing the good life — with other people’s money - The Boston Globe

What made Brian Walshe so believable? “His likability, communication, his reassurance,” prosecutors said. Walshe was a skilled con man.

www.bostonglobe.com

I am not feeling good about this statement from the article:

"In a letter to the judge, Diana Walshe described her son as “the ONLY reason I get up in the morning. He is the ONLY person to take care of me and he is always there for me.”

“Unfortunately, I do not have a good relationship with my daughter-in-law,” she wrote, “perhaps due to cultural differences.”

 

[Knox]

I don't know why it won't let me link it! Sorry, it's under Superior Court, Suffolk Civil Court. Search under Brian Walshe

Can you give the cliff notes? What was this case regarding?

 

[Ilex]

Can you give the cliff notes? What was this case regarding?

Let's see if I can copy and paste:

10/18/1999	Transferred from Berkshire Superior Court (Case originally filed in Berkshire District Court, removed to Berkshire Superior Court then removed to US District Court and retransferred back to Berkshire Superior Court) (See P#31)
10/18/1999	Origin 91, Type B99, Track F.
10/18/1999	Complaint	1
10/18/1999	SERVC RETRND: DZ(Defendant) last & usual on 2/9/98	2
10/18/1999	SERVC RETRND: Brian Walshe (Defendant) last & usual on 2/9/98	3
10/18/1999	ANSWER & Third party complaint of deft Brian Walshe	4
10/18/1999	ANSWER, CROSSCLAIM, COUNTERCLAIM & Third Party Complaint of deft TW	5
10/18/1999	Docket entries received in Berkshire Superior Court from Berkshire District Court	6
10/18/1999	PLEADINGS FILED IN BERKSHIRE DISTRICT COURT
10/18/1999	PLEADINGS FILED IN BERKSHIRE SUPERIOR COURT
10/18/1999	Notice of limited appearance of counsel for deft DZ (Atty NB)	7
10/18/1999	SERVC RETRND (3rd pty summons): Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Ma in hand to person in charge on 3/19/98	8
10/18/1999	Notice of removal of third party deft to US District Court	9
10/18/1999	Docket entries received in US District Court from Berkshire Superior Court	10
10/18/1999	PLEADINGS FILED IN US DISTRICT COURT
10/18/1999	ANSWER of deft TW to third party complaint	11
10/18/1999	Motion of deft DZ to dismiss (w/opposition)	12
10/18/1999	Motion of deft DZ for leave to file reply to plff's opposition to her motion to dismiss complaint & Allowed (L J)	13
10/18/1999	Motion of third party deft for Judgment on the pleadings	14
10/18/1999	Motion of third party plffs T & Brian Walshe for additional time to respond to third party deft's motion for Judgment on the pleadings & Assented to & Allowed (, J)	15
10/18/1999	Motion of third party plffs T & Brian Walshe for additional time to respond to third party deft's motion for Judgment on the pleadings & Allowed (L, J)	16
10/18/1999	Motion of third party plffs T & Brian Walshe for additional time to respond to third party deft's motion for Judgment on the pleadings & Allowed but no further extentions will be permitted (L, J)	17
10/18/1999	MEMORANDUM AND ORDER on deft Z's motion to dismiss and third party deft's motion for Judgment on the pleadings - Denied without prejudice to renew if the court determines that it does have subject- matter jurisdiction. So ORDERED (Lindsay, J)	18
10/18/1999	Motion (P#12) Denied (Lindsay, J)
10/18/1999	Motion (P#14) denied (Lindsay, J)
10/18/1999	Motion of deft DZ for extension of time to file answer to complaint pending outcome of Court's Decison on retention of Jurisdiction & assented to & allowed (Lindsay, J)	19
10/18/1999	Motion of third party plffs to stay further proceedings pending OPM'S Administrative Review - allowed - (Lindsay, J)	20
10/18/1999	PROCEDURAL ORDER: This action having been stayed, the court enters the following administrative order: The captioned action is dismissed without prejudice to either party's moving to restore it to the docket upon completion of the administrative review by the Office of Personnel Management (Lindsay, J)	21
10/18/1999	CASE CLOSED
10/18/1999	Motion of plffs to restore case to docket	22
10/18/1999	Motion of plff for leave to file reply to defts' opposition to motion to restore case to docket	23
10/18/1999	Motion (P#22) Allowed because the previous closing of this case was ordered for administrative purposes only and the case shall be restored to the docket (Lindsay, J)
10/18/1999	Motion (P#23) Allowed (Lindsay, J)
10/18/1999	CASE REOPENED
10/18/1999	Stipulation of Dismissal as to Blue Cross and Blue Shield of MA Inc with prejudice without costs and with waiver of any right of appeal (filed in US Dist Ct not received in Suffolk Sup Ct)
10/18/1999	ANSWER & THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT of Deft DZ	24
10/18/1999	Motion of deft DZ to withdraw motion to dismiss	25
10/18/1999	Notice of voluntary dismissal (41a.l.i) as to third party deft C H M & C PC	26
10/18/1999	Joint Motion to remand case to Berkshire Superior Court & allowed (Lindsay, J)	27
10/18/1999	Motion (P#25) allowed (Lindsay, J)
10/18/1999	ORDER OF REMAND: In accordance with the Court's allowance of the joint motion to remand on August 27, 1999; it is hereby ORDERED: Case remanded to the Berkshire Superior Court (Lindsay, J)	28
10/18/1999	Attested copy of docket entries received in Berkshire Superior Ct from US District Ct	29
10/18/1999	Joint Motion to change venue to Suffolk Superior Court - Although the captioned motion read "Southern Berkshire District Court" I assume that this is a Superior Court case. Motion DENIED without prejudice and reviewed upon a statement of the reasons for the requested transfer (Curley, J)	30
10/18/1999	Renewed Joint Motion to change venue to Suffolk Superior Court and Allowed (Curley, J)	31
10/18/1999	Certified copy of docket entries received	32
10/18/1999	Civil action cover sheet re: Transfer	33
07/19/2000	Case status changed to 'Needs review for answers' at service deadline review
07/21/2000	Case status changed to 'Needs discovery' at answer deadline review
12/12/2000	Motion of defts T and Brian Walshe to continue trial & assented to (w/o opposition)	34
12/21/2000	Motion (P#34) Assented & Allowed (Maria I. Lopez, Justice) (Dated 12/19/00) Notices mailed 12/20/2000
03/08/2001	Assented to motion of DZ to Continue Trial Dated to and including 10/29/01 and ALLOWED (Giles J) notice sent 2/28/01 (dated 2/27/01)	35
10/22/2001	Motion of DZ to Continue Trial Dated to 2/1/02 and ALLOWED (Lopez J) notice sent 10/18/01(dated 10/17/01)	36
03/29/2002	Motion of deft DZ for emergency hearing or determination without a hearing on her motion to continue trial date - Allowed (Lopez,J)	37
03/11/2003	Stipulation of Dismissal (filed 3/10/03) as to plff vs defts crossclaims counterclaims and third parties with prejudice JUDGMENT entered on docket pursuant to Mass R Civ P 58(a) as amended and notice sent to parties pursuant to Mass R Civ P 77(d)	38

ETA the case was Austen Riggs Center Inc. v Walshe et al and to remove names. https://www.masscourts.org/

 

[Kemug]

I am not a psychiatrist, but I would assume that a long stint under psychiatric care (whether inpatient or outpatient) might involve a person being taught such things as self-awareness, how to avoid damaging behaviors, that actions have consequences, etc etc. However, it seems to have been water off a duck's back.

 

[Ilex]

and:

• Case Type:
• Torts
• Case Status:
• Closed
• File Date
• 10/18/1999
• DCM Track:
• F - Fast Track

• Initiating Action:
• Other Tortious Action
• Status Date:
• 03/11/2003
• Case Judge:
• 
  
• Next Event:
• 
  

https://www.masscourts.org/

 

[PNW]

This guy sounds like a wheeler dealer, and his wife obviously was either oblivious
to his shortcomings or as the old saying goes, "Love is blind". I think often people sometimes have their own method of coping and over a period of time she found her own way of coping. Three children in rapid succession had to be difficult under the circumstances.

What’s that old saying? None so blind as those who will not see.

 

[WingsOverTX]

Brian Walshe: Court docs reveal struggles with mental health, relationship between Ana & his mother

Brian Walshe was born into a Massachusetts family with “economic means” but his childhood was hardly considered “privileged,” according to more than a dozen character letters sent to a federal judge in September 2021.

www.boston25news.com

Re: previous Austin Riggs stay in 1999

From linked article:
"According to Walshe’s treating psychiatrist, Dr. Tittmann, “Brian felt neglected, unloved, and emotionally damaged from being used as a pawn by his parents in their acrimonious marital relationship.”

Walshe was sent to boarding school in Rhode Island and then enrolled at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburg, PA. However, in sophomore year Brian’s mental health continued to deteriorate so he dropped out of school and checked himself into the Austin Riggs Center, a psychiatric in-patient treatment facility that specializes in psychiatric patients who have failed at least one prior treatment.

“His depression, anxiety, and anger left him unable to function, according to Dr. Tittmann. “There he started his long battle to overcome his mental illness.”

Emphasis mine

 

[Lexiintoronto]

Re: previous Austin Riggs stay in 1999

From linked article:
"According to Walshe’s treating psychiatrist, Dr. Tittmann, “Brian felt neglected, unloved, and emotionally damaged from being used as a pawn by his parents in their acrimonious marital relationship.”

Walshe was sent to boarding school in Rhode Island and then enrolled at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburg, PA. However, in sophomore year Brian’s mental health continued to deteriorate so he dropped out of school and checked himself into the Austin Riggs Center, a psychiatric in-patient treatment facility that specializes in psychiatric patients who have failed at least one prior treatment.

“His depression, anxiety, and anger left him unable to function, according to Dr. Tittmann. “There he started his long battle to overcome his mental illness.”

Emphasis mine

““His depression, anxiety, and anger left him unable to function, according to Dr. Tittmann. “There he started his long battle to overcome his mental illness.”

As Brian’s wife, Ana Walshe wrote to the judge back in 2021, “Brian has been deeply affected by his childhood and relationship with his parents. He was taught to lie and hide. He was told that he was a loser, that his parents should not have had him, that he had no chances of making anything of himself in life, and that he was a lost cause.””

Brian Walshe: Court docs reveal struggles with mental health, relationship between Ana & his mother

Brian Walshe was born into a Massachusetts family with “economic means” but his childhood was hardly considered “privileged,” according to more than a dozen character letters sent to a federal judge in September 2021.

news.yahoo.com

 

[annpats]

“Unfortunately, I do not have a good relationship with my daughter-in-law,” she wrote, “perhaps due to cultural differences.”

Sounds like baloney. I can't see what cultural difference she's on about. Ana is European and has been in the U.S. for nearly 2 decades! <modsnip> That fits in with upper-class Massachusetts.

I think 'cultural differences' was a euphemism for his Mom saying she didn't like Ana as she wasn't good enough for her precious son so made life difficult for her.

MOO.

 

[Knox]

Thanks @Ilex - I read the case details. Was the case filed because BC/BS didn't pay for his stay at the facility?

 

[mainemom376]

WT actual F?? WHY on earth was Ana ever with this guy? Come on. JMO