Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[shonyakay]

[...]

Nancy Guthrie was supposed to go to a friend’s house where she and her pals would tune into a church service online on the day she was reported missing, a source close to the family has since claimed. [...]

And, the pal called Annie – Nancy’s other daughter – when the Guthrie matriarch failed to show up.

Nancy Guthrie was supposed to go to pal’s house to watch church service on day she was reported missing: family source

Nancy Guthrie was supposed to go to a friend’s house where she and her pals would tune into a church service online on the day she was reported missing, a source close to the family has since&#8230…

nypost.com

So it was a call. I am very curious as to when Annie received that call.

LE is not sharing it for some reason. LE might have an innocent reason for not sharing it or they are not sharing it because if they did, everyone would suspect the family's involvement. JMO.

 

[su5ie]

BIG APOLOGY PLEASE READ ​

I want to apologize for how I handled things yesterday.

There is a great deal that goes on behind the scenes that most of you never see. It can be incredibly frustrating to repeatedly post instructions, only to have them ignored, and then have to remove hundreds of posts because the rules were not followed. Many of you may not even see those posts due to how quickly the thread moves.
SHERIFF REFUSES TO RULE OUT SG'S BROTHER -IN-LAW, ACCORDING TO NYP.
Yesterday, when I posted the same message multiple times in a row, it came from a place of real frustration over the continued rule violations. That frustration got the better of me.

However, none of that is an excuse. I should have handled it differently, and I take responsibility for that.

I am working on finding a better way to make important moderator posts more visible and easier to follow so we can avoid this situation in the future.

And yes — I have been informed (by certain unnamed moderators who may or may not answer to “SillyBilly”) that if I throw another public hissy fit, I will be timed out. Fair is fair.

Thank you for your patience.
Tricia

Thank you @tricia to be human is to err and I admire your ability to admit that keep up your fantastic work and for the record I thought the repetitive post was an accident so paid no heed after the original post

 

[Kemug]

What did Nancy work as before she retired , was she still active in a role of administration in any community based programmes

Potential suspects for me would be , church goer or someone related to them , former Co worker , jilted former companion , stalker of SG or one of her siblings or nancy herself ( you don't have to be famous to have a stalker ) someone in the community with a mental illness or bearing a grudge

It's a wide net but to conceal a person tells me it's a person known . A murder that occurred during a burglary wouldn't really warrant a concealing of Nancy as the hassle of moving a body is hefty and wouldn't be in a burglars interests imo and would a person breaking and entering not have a gloves on and or a mask to conceal identify.

I think she will be eventually found within a 5km radius of her home

Don't statistics state that a person known to a victim will generally try to cover up their crime whereby a person with no connection ( beyond 6° ) will generally not conceal

We see in the idaho murders BK did not try conceal the bodies , ok maybe that's a bad example but you get my point .

Is there any chance whatsoever that Nancy had an onset episode of some sort and wandered off herself?

Jmo moo and speculating and me being inquisitive

You make some good points. Firstly, about Nancy having some sort of episode and wandering off in the middle of the night. Quite possible IMO, but surely she would have been found by now? And secondly, if one of the obvious suspects
killed/injured her, either accidentally or on purpose, what would be the point of removing her from her home? Especially as it is now looking less and less likely to be a proper kidnapping. But if it happened in a different home, there was every reason to move her.

 

[Kemug]

Well I learned the pacemaker continues to function after death so am thinking it (as a tiny machine) still syncs but device oughta have data to say when flatline occurred. I mean, many are programmed to send that data to connected clinic. I don't honestly know enough facts to give more than presumption.

All I know about pacemakers is that they are very expensive, but you can always get a secondhand one.

 

[Cassie P]

8 days of Search & Rescue; and the majority of LE now believe the kidnapping was another hoax. What's left? A missing woman, possible foul play involved... much like so many other cases that do not get solved

Does LE believe the kidnapping/ransom was a hoax by the perpetrator to cover up the crime and confuse LE and the public? Or was it someone not connected to the original crime who thought they would get a payday and attention off of a tragedy?

 

[Cassie P]

Well I learned the pacemaker continues to function after death so am thinking it (as a tiny machine) still syncs but device oughta have data to say when flatline occurred. I mean, many are programmed to send that data to connected clinic. I don't honestly know enough facts to give more than presumption.

Yes this is my understanding. A pacemaker is a little machine that keeps functioning whether the heart is still working or not.

 

[shonyakay]

DBM because I asked a stupid question.

 

[shonyakay]

All I know about pacemakers is that they are very expensive, but you can always get a secondhand one.

Wait... what?

 

[Cipher Vale]

I appreciate the differing angles posted here. I have not been shy about my own theory. However, some of you are planting some seeds in my mind that I want to water:

(I'm mostly using other's ideas and adding my own color)

Random-ish crime: Could still be someone close, like someone who works around/at the house. The destruction of cameras is not some sophicated act by someone with intimate knowledge of NG lack of cloud services, but someone seeing a camera and destroying it. Entry made, something happens, NG is deceased shortly after.

My questions are:
1) LE has never said the crime scene was "disturbing" or that they suspect she is deceased based on the crime scene. The family seems to believe she was/is alive and the FBI/LE have been entertaining the ransom situation. Is there any reason to believe NG was deceased vs kidnapped?

2) a robbery gone wrong, involving a random(ish) person rarely involves complete removal of the body. The perps simply don't plan to transport and dispose of a body. Clearly NG was removed. What are theories behind removing NG after a botched robbery?

3) Lack of suspect evidence in the house. How did a random-ish person(s) keep sterile during a robbery gone wrong? My opinion has been that the lack of foreign DNA is because the perp is someone expected to be in the house. So how did a random person avoid any DNA evidence?
**you would expect worker DNA in some parts of the house, but not in a bedroom for example

 

[TheDinks]

Does LE believe the kidnapping/ransom was a hoax by the perpetrator to cover up the crime and confuse LE and the public? Or was it someone not connected to the original crime who thought they would get a payday and attention off of a tragedy?

We don't know what they believe... we just know that the 2 options you pose have been the top theories among commentators on the situation.

 

[fr0stbyte]

I'm most concerned with the fact she hasn't had her hearing aid all week. Can she even hear anything?

 

[Kemug]

Wait... what?

Well, a perfectly good and expensive pacemaker isn't going to be buried with its owner.

 

[su5ie]

Wait a minute. Is her pacemaker synched to an app on her watch or an app on her phone?

Was that specified?

It's been mentioned in this thread by people who have them fitted that a pacemaker connects to an app once a day usually during the night for sync of data . It does not sync 24/ 7 continuously.


Once a certain distance is over stepped between pacemaker and phone or watch it will give a reading of unable to sync .

It does not mean the person is dead just that they are out of range for a reading .

That was my understanding of it anyways . Open to correction

 

[shonyakay]

Does LE believe the kidnapping/ransom was a hoax by the perpetrator to cover up the crime and confuse LE and the public? Or was it someone not connected to the original crime who thought they would get a payday and attention off of a tragedy?

I am not sure because of Harvey Levin's description that in the note it mentioned where Nancy's watch was and it was not in a place that you would think.

Sidenote: Harvey didn't say where the note said the watch was.

 

[Cipher Vale]

Great points.

Ah, And the garage opening for a measly 2 minutes. Maybe they were putting the Apple watch in her vehicle. Then went in another door .
Now I'm just reaching. For some reason the sheriff didn't want to tell us if there was forced entry, I've heard there was, then he stated "I never said there was forced entry or there wasn't. I can see why they would keep that from the public, rightfully so.

Two minutes is quite a long time. I tested it. You can park your car and walk in the house in less than 2 minutes. You can enter slowly thru the garage and leave thru the front door in 2 minutes.

Did anyone see a ramp in the garage? As if she enters the garage because there is a ramp to assist getting in the house vs the front door. Scenario being that someone drops her off at the drive way, garage door opened, she slowly walks thru garage, up ramp, in house, and then closes the garage?

 

[CrimeDawg123]

I'm most concerned with the fact she hasn't had her hearing aid all week. Can she even hear anything?

I wear them and can hear some things but other things not at all. Depends on what your particular hearing loss is. Everyone is different.

 

[Cipher Vale]

Yes this is my understanding. A pacemaker is a little machine that keeps functioning whether the heart is still working or not.

So then what data is synced to the phone/watch? If her heart stopped, wouldnt the pacemaker show it was repeatedly trying to get a rhythm?

 

[Kemug]

All I know about pacemakers is that they are very expensive, but you can always get a secondhand one.

My cardiologist tells me that I might need one some day, so I'll get back to you!

 

[Cassie P]

You make some good points. Firstly, about Nancy having some sort of episode and wandering off in the middle of the night. Quite possible IMO, but surely she would have been found by now? And secondly, if one of the obvious suspects
killed/injured her, either accidentally or on purpose, what would be the point of removing her from her home? Especially as it is now looking less and less likely to be a proper kidnapping. But if it happened in a different home, there is every reason to move her.

A domestic/personal/acquaintance murder committed in the home may result in crime scene staging to make the death look like an accident, suicide, robbery gone wrong, kidnapping, etc. So you may see a suicide or ransom note, fake break in etc.

In the case of a fake kidnapping, the body has to be removed from the home.

 

[su5ie]

I feel the solution lies in the questions
Who ?
When?
Where?
What ? ( motive)
How ?

Investigations take time and I believe LE are well on there way on answering 3 or 4 of those questions and it's a case then of where imo