AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[Maybe?]

I

I tend to believe that she was assaulted (or sadly possibly killed) in the home and carried to the car.

agree

 

[Starkville]

Has LE come out to confirm or deny anything in Banfield's report? I saw some comments on her video from people saying that LE said that the SIL's vehicle was not impounded and that he is not a suspect.

I haven’t seen anything addressing AB’s claims directly.

Those comments aren’t exactly 100% accurate.

The Sheriff’s post said they haven’t identified any suspect or person of interest. Somehow people have translated that to “The BIL has been cleared”.

the Sheriff also said they would not confirm the rumor that a car was impounded and they didn’t know the source for that rumor. That is not a flat-out denial.

Personally, I’m annoyed that the Sheriff said “she’s alive”. They won’t confirm whether a car was impounded, but he states a WILD “fact” that is the absolute central point of this mystery. JMO.

 

[Sessiebo]

well... many of us are writing out relative's names. That is one problem.
And using some pretty sketchy sources as well.

Can i ask, is pagesix considered a sketchy source or a legitimate one?

 

[jepop]

Dbm

 

[Jade]

They got her out the door, then one stayed with her while another moved the car as close to the door as possible.

It isn't likely the car was parked where it could be seen by the camera. Once the camera was removed, then the car was brought as close as possible in order to get NG inside.

The blood drops accumulated while they waited for the car to be move

Oh my, that seems to be a likely scenario for two. Also for a lone attacker to leave her weakened and helpless to get back in the door by herself to go pull up the car.




all imo

 

[swanniee11]

Normally we don't allow random TikTok accounts we will allow this TikTok video. Not all of their videos but this one is fine.

I wish she would have said the blood splatter appears to be going into the house or leaving the house, I'm not sure if that was confirmed yet or not. IMO

 

[vereb]

Typically those receive deletes not an entire thread shut down

Yep, but if there is a lot to delete, the mods may close the thread for the duration of the clean-up.

 

[MarciB]

well... many of us are writing out relative's names. That is one problem.
And using some pretty sketchy sources as well.

adult family names are public information, aren't they? Savannah's sister and bil names have been used for the timeline - when the sister (or maybe it was the bil?) dropped Nancy Guthrie off, for example

 

[MarciB]

Yep, but if there is a lot to delete, the mods may close the thread for the duration of the clean-up.

I hope the thread doesn't get closed - it is an important current case

 

[Pharmasgirl]

Sorry to butt in, but please agree to disagree and don't get into a fight, this thread is probably on thin ice as is already.

Please let's not bring ICE into this LOL

 

[MarciB]

I

agree

the getaway car might have been in the driveway close to the house and that's why the blood trail stopped

 

[Sadi]

I'm trying to catch up.

So,
it seems the dinner was at daughter's home??

Oh,
I thought it was a celebratory Birthday dinner at the restaurant.

Hmmm.....

JMO

Yes daughter’s home for dinner and then played a game, can’t remember the name of it though, but it’s pretty popular right now.

 

[academyrd]

Guys we can't sleuth the SIL unless Law Enforcement publicly label him a suspect.

Sorry for my ignorance. Is SIL sibling in law not sister in law? Thanks in advance

 

[Stormy415]

I will wait to make my opinion when LE makes their arrest. No naming anyone until the arrest.

 

[swanniee11]

Wasn't it the daughter and BIL who gave an account as to where Nancy was Saturday evening? If they are suspect then everything they said would need to be taken into account that it could be false. IMO

 

[investigatoroffacts]

Hello- a bit late to this forum and so many pages to catch up but has anyone checked this out to see if this could be something? This is on realtor.com (is the source) and shows a permit for electrical work at NG address. I have searched high and low for the work permit but running into road blocks.

https://apps.realtor.com/mUAZ/efg9lq50 (Very clearly listed on the house info on realtor.com)

 

[Maybe?]

They got her out the door, then one stayed with her while another moved the car as close to the door as possible.

It isn't likely the car was parked where it could be seen by the camera. Once the camera was removed, then the car was brought as close as possible in order to get NG inside.

The blood drops accumulated while they waited for the car to be moved.

This makes sense. Also thinking imo that they came in the back door, and when they walked out the front door, they we’re able to remove the camera from behind and without being seen.

 

[tricia]

Good Morning/Afternoon Everyone.
Please DO NOT make horrible accusations about people without a mainstream media link.
You can't say "I heard so and so is an ax murderer living under a pile of wood" without a link. Believe that line is not far off from some of the things I have read.
You can't post "I can't confirm in, but this guy has been a drug addict for years."
I am on my laptop. When I scroll down and look to the right, I see "Community Rules." Not sure how it shows up on your device. Please review those rules and help us keep Websleuths free of wild accusations.
Thanks.

 

[Baba O'Riley]

Do we know for sure if Annie and SIL are actually legally married? Because if they aren't AND let's say SIL is an undocumented immigrant, would he really take the chance of kidnapping NG? Unless he killed her on the spur of the moment in anger because she refused to give him money. Sorry for this stream-of-consciousness post!

 

[K9Enzo]

Sorry for my ignorance. Is SIL sibling in law not sister in law? Thanks in advance

I was confused also. I believe for this conversation son-in-law. IMO