AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[justwannahelp]

I am the one who said the Circle K is right next to AG’s house, it’s .5 miles, a 2 min drive or 10 min walk. However it is also one of the closest gas stations to NG’s house and is on the way to the highway from her house.

I live a few minutes from NG, I’m not a verified insider or anything but I do know people who know her/the family.

Hi SunChips. Thx for being here. I looked up circle K oracle rd, Tucson AZ and 5 come up near the Catalina hills. Have they confirmed which one it is?

Sorry everyone. Trying to catch up. This thread is big

 

[MCB1151]

Ill bet a biology teacher might have a lot of cool tools at their disposal.

I haven't actually seen the blood splatter but the trajectory, force, and "tool" will all affect how you'd plant that.

Strangely I learned a lot about blood splatter one Halloween with my kids. Whole science lesson on our sidewalk and their costumes and bodies lol

 

[Kemug]

Bbm but re her birthday I was thinking celebrate could be a reference to a family member’s birthday etc. They seemed more passive in the video imo. My interpretation was they recognized and showed respect for the power the sender/s have.
It’s almost impossible to interpret without more context unfortunately so just me throwing something out there.

Another birthday - but what if someone was thinking "All that money that I need, and she's never going to die, she'll probably live to be 100"

 

[Megnut]

My opinion is as soon as she was out of the car they likely took off. Time is money in gig work. But I could absolutely be wrong.

I was thinking about when she was picked up, possibly the driver would have had to wait a minute or two for her to make her way to the car. Wondering whether he remembered anything useful to LE.

 

[Cebavl]

I’m beginning to wonder if LE wasn’t at AG’s house just to distract us from something else. Where was the FBI? The sheriff’s in Chapel Hill, so who’s in charge? And just like that, I’m back to wondering if the ransom might actually be the real situation.

 

[cady]

has anyone checked on Pima County Jail?

 

[emigrate]

He could be on the run. SG may have been appealing to him in the video.

Either on the run or in the pokey.

 

[bajaflash]

I was thinking about when she was picked up, possibly the driver would have had to wait a minute or two for her to make her way to the car. Wondering whether he remembered anything useful to LE.

Oh im sure they gave anything they remembered to LE. Especially if they didnt have a busy night. They'd be more likely to remember.

 

[PacoElFlaco]

Where's Tomasso? Haven't seen him since he and Annie were trying to hide their faces while driving off in their car.

 

[Kemug]

Ill bet a biology teacher might have a lot of cool tools at their disposal.

Maybe someone had their hand over Nancy's mouth, to keep her quiet?

 

[Vaderman]

I’m beginning to wonder if LE wasn’t at AG’s house just to distract us from something else. Where was the FBI? The sheriff’s in Chapel Hill, so who’s in charge? And just like that, I’m back to wondering if the ransom might actually be the real situation.

I don't that "we" are the target audience JMO

 

[Fargo]

has anyone checked on Pima County Jail?

I check every hour or so. Nothing so far.

Pima County Sheriff Department

Pima County Sheriff's Department.

www.sheriff.pima.gov

 

[cathathorse]

No. Only that it didn't connect

Is NYPost allowed as a source here? Because here they are citing the Thursday press conference about a spike in heart rate at 2am:

NYPost Heart Rate Spike article

 

[whitelilac]

I’m beginning to wonder if LE wasn’t at AG’s house just to distract us from something else. Where was the FBI? The sheriff’s in Chapel Hill, so who’s in charge? And just like that, I’m back to wondering if the ransom might actually be the real situation.

It's making us all crosseyed. It's been a back and forth situation all week.

 

[TheDinks]

It seemed like NG cherished her grandchild (all of them, of course, but AG's seems to be the one she spent the most time with due to proximity). I really hope SIL wouldn't do that to him, and the rest of the family. I hope there's an innocuous reason LE's taking photos there, but I don’t know.

And if SIL was involved I really hope AG wasn’t… it’s possible she wasn’t if he planned it with a friend or something. IDK what to think anymore. Really hoped the family wasn’t involved.

I've hoped since the beginning there was no family involvement in the crime. It's horrific enough to lose a love one this way but then to have to deal with that aspect on top magnifies the trauma!

When AB revealed what her source told her I was annoyed with her, both for possibly hindering investigation but also for bringing SO much negative attention on someone who may not be guilty. Days later she was telling Megyn Kelly her source is still adamant with the tip, so...

I am 100% sure, following latest plea from Savannah, that Ms Guthrie has passed but I still hope that her family (despite what my theories comprise) are not involved.

 

[InspectGadget]

Is NYPost allowed as a source here? Because here they are citing the Thursday press conference about a spike in heart rate at 2am:

NYPost Heart Rate Spike article

The title of the article is how it could possibly show a spike
They only said disconnected at the presser.

 

[MCB1151]

Maybe I'm not understanding this. Don't they need probable cause to get a warrant? I'd be surprised if they went there last night, parked, and then suddenly realized that they didn't have a warrant. So maybe they were there last night for some slightly different reason?

JMO

I don't think they pulled up and "realized they didn't have a warrant", but sometimes just showing up and asking to check inside is enough to make some people panic and scramble. Remember too they started searching the area between the two houses today as well. Something could have popped up on a cell phone dump, they may have found something in between the houses, there may have been something suspicious in plain sight. There's really no telling what happened between last night and today that convinced a judge to sign off on a search warrant.

 

[Moonchime]

I find it hard to believe if SIL and AG are involved, that they would be able to send these ransom notes without it being figured out by LE before now. Especially since it involved the bitcoin account and IP encryption. I feel like her death may have been heat of the moment if it was SIL/AG, so it seems off that they could throw together an elaborate ransom situation that quickly. I don’t know. This case is really crazy. So now I’m leaning towards the ransom notes not being really connected.

Searching AG’s house could simply mean it’s the most important location for reconstructing the timeline and finding physical/digital evidence not because NG died there or anyone who lives there is guilty of her disappearance.

Detectives left with boxes and a folding table. They were inside for about two hours. Maybe the camera they removed yesterday held the identity of the person(s) responsible for NG's disappearance. Hopefully, an arrest will happen soon.

 

[TheDinks]

Is NYPost allowed as a source here? Because here they are citing the Thursday press conference about a spike in heart rate at 2am:

NYPost Heart Rate Spike article

Megyn Kelly and Ashleigh Banfield have discussed that 'spike at 2am' also... I did put link to MK's broadcast yesterday but tbh am not sure if she is an accepted source.

 

[priyaya]

Is NYPost allowed as a source here? Because here they are citing the Thursday press conference about a spike in heart rate at 2am:

NYPost Heart Rate Spike article

They also said stopped synching