UK UK - Claudia Lawrence, 35, Chef, York University, 18 March 2009 #17

[Pricklykitty]

They might have suspicions but that is all !

hi Popejohn3, I knew you wouldn't really agree with me But that's a good thing as if we all thought the same then no progress or discussion would ever happen and then there would be no chance of Claudia, or anyone, getting justice.

 

[cortina]

the problem we ordinary punters here have is that. we've got pope john, who seems. to know most. of the principal players and he seems to believe them.....I hate to be disloyal to friends, but there are very. few people I would say were incapable of murder under the right circumstances...probably including myself....history. has. thrown up so many. unlikely perps.

I think vixeys theory is plausible,, in the sense that it could. well have happened, but I just dont think. it. did...at least not. just as a result of one woman's jealousy....I probably like life to. be complicated

 

[Popejohn3]

the problem we ordinary punters here have is that. we've got pope john, who seems. to know most. of the principal players and he seems to believe them.....I hate to be disloyal to friends, but there are very. few people I would say were incapable of murder under the right circumstances...probably including myself....history. has. thrown up so many. unlikely perps.

I think vixeys theory is plausible,, in the sense that it could. well have happened, but I just dont think. it. did...at least not. just as a result of one woman's jealousy....I probably like life to. be complicated

I hope I am making myself clear when I say I’ve never been to York nor do I know any of Claudia’s friends okay !

 

[Popejohn3]

Go back to Vixey post on #9 and read from there, some interesting and detailed observations. 1 poster trying to halt the discussion as they know it’s getting near the truth. (In my opinion)

Hi if you are referring to me ( trying to halt discussions) I can assure you I do not want these discussions to stop!
I just think people keep barking at the wrong tree or trees even . I mean most of these ‘trees’ have not even been arrested !

 

[cortina]

I hope I am making myself clear when I say I’ve never been to York nor do I know any of Claudia’s friends okay !

oh, ok, pope....you just seem very sure of what you believe...how can you be. so sure...am I right in thinking you dont believe any of the rogues were involved...maybe they weren't, but. how. can you really know

 

[Kiranerys]

Hi if you are referring to me ( trying to halt discussions) I can assure you I do not want these discussions to stop!
I just think people keep barking at the wrong tree or trees even . I mean most of these ‘trees’ have not even been arrested !

Which tree do you think we should be barking up?. You must have an opinion that you can share?.

 

[cortina]

Which tree do you think we should be barking up?. You must have an opinion that you can share?.

I thought he'd been hinting at one of the cubans....or. is that just an example of. people who haven't been looked into

 

[Blonderabbit]

It’s simple isn’t it Pope - 1 man did the deed, 2 helped him cover up and 1 was unfortunately in the wrong place at the wrong time. Premeditated, organised killing. (In my opinion)

 

[Popejohn3]

It’s simple isn’t it Pope - 1 man did the deed, 2 helped him cover up and 1 was unfortunately in the wrong place at the wrong time. Premeditated, organised killing. (In my opinion)

You say premeditated . But can you shed any light as to why ? ( she was killed )

 

[Blonderabbit]

You say premeditated . But can you shed any light as to why ? ( she was killed )

I’ve got a damn good idea, tho as it’s based on speculation I’m not going to further comment. All I will say is there was a build up which hit home on Friday 13th.

 

[cortina]

I take it you have two people in mind ? And then possibly up to three others helped them !
I take it also you have these three (?) in mind and you have a name for each and every one ?
I cannot disagree with you more !
I think just one person is involved and he / she has never been mentioned so far !

why do you think it is just one person who has never been mentioned before...you may well be right but. I. want to know how you came to this conclusion....is this person someone within. the groups of people we know about or is it someone unknown to most of us

 

[cortina]

I’ve got a damn good idea, tho as it’s based on speculation I’m not going to further comment. All I will say is there was a build up which hit home on Friday 13th.

there's not just pope. John on this thread....please keep posting...I find. your posts very interesting....do you think the perp or perps acted because of one. woman's jealousy or do you think there were more serious reasons

 

[Blonderabbit]

there's not just pope. John on this thread....please keep posting...I find. your posts very interesting....do you think the perp or perps acted because of one. woman's jealousy or do you think there were more serious reasons

It’s nothing to do with a jealous woman. I’ve been back over majorlangs blog - it’s good as a source of facts. Think most sleuths think alleywayman is AC. Tho let’s imagine you can 100% rule him out. I’d think a previous boyfriend might well have a rear door key.

 

[susie sixpence]

Whilst concentrating on alley man we seem to have forgotten the two witnesses who saw the man in combat trousers and black hoodie, smoking with his left hand.

 

[Blonderabbit]

Whilst concentrating on alley man we seem to have forgotten the two witnesses who saw the man in combat trousers and black hoodie, smoking with his left hand.

Rabbit hole

 

[curiosity2]

Did the Police ever discover who the 2 Asian men were who were spotted trying Claudias door?

 

[susie sixpence]

Rabbit hole

Why publicise it on Crimewatch then?

 

[Blonderabbit]

Why publicise it on Crimewatch then?

It was one of a number of lines of enquiry at that time - all the rabbit holes coming out now. Serious Sleuths - the key is alleyway man - if it’s not cooper - think of who it is and put the pieces together

 

[Popejohn3]

It was one of a number of lines of enquiry at that time - all the rabbit holes coming out now. Serious Sleuths - the key is alleyway man - if it’s not cooper - think of who it is and put the pieces together

Yes I was going to ask a similar question! If alleyway man is AC and he is innocent, then why wouldn’t he say it’s him. ?

 

[Vixey]

Whilst concentrating on alley man we seem to have forgotten the two witnesses who saw the man in combat trousers and black hoodie, smoking with his left hand.

Was that sighting not confirmed and corrected to the Wednesday morning. And Claudia seen on the uni CCTV clocking in at 5.30 am? x