Agreed. Can you get verified as an attorney? I like to hear as many professional opinions as possible, although I must say that many of the posters here have been so involved in these trials that they are practically as good as!!!
The state proved first degree murder, IMO. But I do think they make a mistake in not providing motive to a jury, even though that is not required. We have seen that repeatedly. In the Laci Peterson case, where there was really no blood or fiber evidence and frankly, much less circumstantial evidence that he murdered her than in cases where the defendant gets off, the state proved its case with motive via the taped calls with his mistress. scott peterson is on death row.
In the Caylee Anthony case, where there was a ton of forensic evidence linking casey to the murder of her daughter, I think the state did a poor job of establishing motive - nothing showing exactly how tied down and trapped she felt, nothing showing that her new boyfriend really didn't want the baby around and that her parents refused to babysit overnight so much. casey walks.
I do think evidence of her stalking and obsessive behavior should have been presented in the case in chief, if they could.
Thank you! Now I can see what I missed!
I;m on the fence. I think he could have survived a gun shot for awhile. Many people do. I mean, she came prepared with a gun and her statements about how she would have shot him over and over instead of stabbing him support that scenario. Also, the fact that in her ninja story, the shot came first sticks out to me, because I think she was then trying to match up what any potential witness, like a neighbor, may have heard: A shot, then screaming, then someone saying "shut up".
In the least picture of Travis, he was seated. She may have shot him, looming above and he may have screamed or held his head and asked for help. Frightened that he could get away, she may have run for a knife in his kitchen or in her purse and when she came back, he may have been able to stand up and was weaving on his feet. Then comes the stab to the lungs. Impossibly, he is still able to lurch toward the sink. She then begins stabbing him in the back. He falls to his knees and begins crawling and she continues to stab him in the back and head before, panicked that he could still somehow survive, straddling him, pulling back his head and practically cutting it off.
I think the ME allowed for some wiggle room for this to happen.
ETA: I think in the casey case, there were a few facets to motive. The others were her deep hatred for her mother and jealousy of Caylee and of being replaced as the princess of the family by Caylee. The state did a piss poor job of showing any of that.