Found Deceased TX - Sherin Mathews, 3, Richardson, 7 Oct 2017 #8 *Arrests*

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
As I said upthread, it is my opinion and speculation that SM is the "puppet master" and that she directs WS activities. I could be completely wrong, but I think he is taking the majority of the fall for her. With the little we know, I currently see her as the ringleader, head Perp. If there is sexual abuse discovered, that opinion will change.

All amateur opinion and speculation.

This is what I highly suspect, too. The exchange at the end of their court appearance was very telling. My suspicion is that WM has been covering for her from the get go. He is not as calculated as she because his stories make absolutely no common sense and never did. SM is now up *****'s creek because her "I was asleep the whole time" story has multiple holes.
I suspect that she is controlling and emotionally abusive. His attempt to catch her eye and exchange a smile seemed like approval seeking behaviour. She is trying to distance herself from him and punish him for screwing this up. I suspect this is going to go downhill fast. Someone earlier in this thread suggested that he is going to sing like a bird with the real story and I agree. It's coming...

(All speculation and IMOO)
 
I think there were control issues going on, but not sure who was in the driver's seat, so to speak. In dysfunctional families, there is often a ring leader and a follower. So my theorizing about how this could have happened, and who was controlling things, is stemming from that. I don't know that either adult was being abused by the other adult, but I believe that one of the adults was subservient in some way to the other. It doesn't absolve either one from responsibility--they are both murderers in my opinion.

So far neither WM or SM have been charged with murder yet. WM admitted to his part in causing Sherin's death. He has different charges than SM, who is currently only charged with child endangerment because LE were able to determine/prove that Sherin was left home alone by both of them for an hour and a half.
The abuse allegations by the doctor were obviously not enough to arrest & charge the Mathews couple, and as far as we know they did not cause Sherin's death, as bad as the knowledge of the multiple fractures are.
If and when COD/Autopsy reveals any further evidence we will have to wait and see. There is also another hearing coming up on the 5th. which is Tuesday with ? witnesses, so that could reveal further knowledge on the W's treatment of Sherin.
 
And i think in some of these cases with involvement of two people in a crime, if LE can't determine who is lying or perhaps covering for the other person the are inclined to charge both with the same charges. I have seen that happen in a couple of murder cases anyway.
Because SM could turn and say WM caused the fractures or he in turn could say she caused them, so i guess it can be difficult to prove exactly who caused what & when if people lie about their involvement.
 
My mother has 4 children, 7 grandchildren, and 8 great-grandchildren. Put them all together and Sherin had many more broken bones in her 3 little years of life than all of us put together over a span of 60 years! I think that paints the picture.

Not saying I believe the parents stories of how she got the injuries but malnutrition severely increases risk for fracture. Possibly why she had so many.

https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ije/2015/628740/


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Not saying I believe the parents stories of how she got the injuries but malnutrition severely increases risk for fracture. Possibly why she had so many.

https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ije/2015/628740/


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Or possibly not since the Dr testified she didn’t have any underlying medical condition affecting her bones and The American Academy of Pediatrics says:

Vitamin D insufficiency was not associated with multiple fractures, in particular rib fractures or CMLs, the high specificity indicators of abuse. Perez-Rossello et al studied radiographs of 40 healthy older infants and toddlers with vitamin D insufficiency and deficiency and concluded that radiographic rachitic changes were uncommon and very mild. In this population, the reported fracture prevalence was zero.72
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/133/2/e477.full.pdf
 
Finally got caught up on this thread. So glad to see that so many members are still posting and that the thread is still moving along at a good pace! I had been closely following a few other cases plus didn't feel I had anything of much worth to add since I know very little about broken bones etc. (I actually had always assumed a break and a fracture were not one in the same prior to this thread! :shame:

Like some of you have expressed, I am sure the defense will have their own experts to explain all those breaks :thinking: and that did worry me a little. Nothing is worse than someone doing something terribly wrong, but having a good defense attorney with good resources and a "scientific reason" to cause some doubt.....

but even if you take all of that away, the knowledge of those NUMEROUS and significant breaks, you still end up with two educated adult parents
with 5 cell phones
and 3 working vehicles
who had an adopted child die on their watch,
never called 911 for an ambulance,
or ran to a close neighbors house
or drove to a hospital.

Instead, they threw her away in a culvert, then hours later called the non-emergency number and said they had a missing child.

Just that information alone should be enough, no matter how any defense tries to spin it. They lack the ability to provide critical care when it's a life or death situation. They also happen to leave toddlers unattended while they dine out.
They are also both in jail. You can spin a story and throw in science and experts to explain those breaks, but you cannot explain the rest.

This is one case where I'm not too worried about undeserving parents getting a child back.

All JMO opinion of course.
 
So far neither WM or SM have been charged with murder yet. WM admitted to his part in causing Sherin's death. He has different charges than SM, who is currently only charged with child endangerment because LE were able to determine/prove that Sherin was left home alone by both of them for an hour and a half.
The abuse allegations by the doctor were obviously not enough to arrest & charge the Mathews couple, and as far as we know they did not cause Sherin's death, as bad as the knowledge of the multiple fractures are.
If and when COD/Autopsy reveals any further evidence we will have to wait and see. There is also another hearing coming up on the 5th. which is Tuesday with ? witnesses, so that could reveal further knowledge on the W's treatment of Sherin.

BBM.

If there is anyone that thinks they did not cause Sherin's death then I'm sorry but you are very mistaken. I don't need to wait for no COD to know that.
 
So far neither WM or SM have been charged with murder yet. WM admitted to his part in causing Sherin's death. He has different charges than SM, who is currently only charged with child endangerment because LE were able to determine/prove that Sherin was left home alone by both of them for an hour and a half.
The abuse allegations by the doctor were obviously not enough to arrest & charge the Mathews couple, and as far as we know they did not cause Sherin's death, as bad as the knowledge of the multiple fractures are.
If and when COD/Autopsy reveals any further evidence we will have to wait and see. There is also another hearing coming up on the 5th. which is Tuesday with ? witnesses, so that could reveal further knowledge on the W's treatment of Sherin.

BBM

The specific charges against him actually do state that his actions led to her death. Back in the beginning we researched the charges and the amount of time he could get for them. That's why we are generally not up in arms over the lack of a murder charge.

There are charges outside of murder charges that do state someone has killed someone. YingYing's case is another. The perp may face the death penalty, yet it is not a murder charge. It is a charge of kidnapping and torture that led to her death.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/C...ial-Service-for-Sherin-Mathews-461531693.html

The community service for Sherin organized by Omair and the Omairettes with video

Thank you for sharing this Grouchymom. Two strong impressions from this video:

1. I think it is lovely how the community has come together to demand justice for this child, regardless of ethnicity, background, religion. Texas folk are good folk.

2. I am stunned by the *size of the culvert*. I didn't really grasp the size of the culvert until I saw it in comparison to the size of a woman leaving flowers. I don't know how far Sherin's remains were placed inside that culvert, but if it were more than a few inches in...there is NO WAY that a man the size of WS could have fit in there. NO WAY.

Seeing the culvert on that video gives me a whole new outlook on what happened that fateful early morning. Sini has some explaining to do, doesn't she?!

All amateur opinion and speculation.
 
Do doctors really tell parents with underweight children to wake them up in the middle of the night and make them drink milk?
 
Do doctors really tell parents with underweight children to wake them up in the middle of the night and make them drink milk?

I’ve only ever been told that until mine double their birthweight. Sleep is important for growth. If her failure to thrive was severe enough she might warrant a gtube or button. I’m no doctor but I have to wonder if Sherin suffered that much physical abuse that she may have also been deprived of adequate nutrition. Our pediatrician has always told us not to worry around the 1-3 range for picky eating as it’s normal and advised us to supplement with children’s vitamins. I can absolutely see pediatricians worrying about a sudden drop on the growth chart. My youngest is on the opposite end being very large for 2.5 and he sees specialists for a delay. Each specialist always remarks on his size and then checks his growth charts to see if his growth is steady or shows anomalies.
 
Do doctors really tell parents with underweight children to wake them up in the middle of the night and make them drink milk?
Newborns, yes. Children, highly unlikely. If the child was that underweight I'd imagine they'd be on a gtube. Jmo.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
Newborns, yes. Children, highly unlikely. If the child was that underweight I'd imagine they'd be on a gtube. Jmo.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk

It's pretty hard to muster up an appetite with all those broken bones. Pain has a way of suppressing appetite.

Monsters.
 
Seems highly improbable to me.
Sini, as an RN, possibly thought she knew better than doctors. Or maybe they are just lying about these regular middle of the night feedings, period.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
 
Finally got caught up on this thread. So glad to see that so many members are still posting and that the thread is still moving along at a good pace! I had been closely following a few other cases plus didn't feel I had anything of much worth to add since I know very little about broken bones etc. (I actually had always assumed a break and a fracture were not one in the same prior to this thread! :shame:

Like some of you have expressed, I am sure the defense will have their own experts to explain all those breaks :thinking: and that did worry me a little. Nothing is worse than someone doing something terribly wrong, but having a good defense attorney with good resources and a "scientific reason" to cause some doubt.....

but even if you take all of that away, the knowledge of those NUMEROUS and significant breaks, you still end up with two educated adult parents
with 5 cell phones
and 3 working vehicles
who had an adopted child die on their watch,
never called 911 for an ambulance,
or ran to a close neighbors house
or drove to a hospital.

Instead, they threw her away in a culvert, then hours later called the non-emergency number and said they had a missing child.

Just that information alone should be enough, no matter how any defense tries to spin it. They lack the ability to provide critical care when it's a life or death situation. They also happen to leave toddlers unattended while they dine out.
They are also both in jail. You can spin a story and throw in science and experts to explain those breaks, but you cannot explain the rest.

This is one case where I'm not too worried about undeserving parents getting a child back.

All JMO opinion of course.

I appreciate how you laid it all out in this post. Very clear and convincing when you see it all out like that....
 
Thank you for sharing this Grouchymom. Two strong impressions from this video:

1. I think it is lovely how the community has come together to demand justice for this child, regardless of ethnicity, background, religion. Texas folk are good folk.

2. I am stunned by the *size of the culvert*. I didn't really grasp the size of the culvert until I saw it in comparison to the size of a woman leaving flowers. I don't know how far Sherin's remains were placed inside that culvert, but if it were more than a few inches in...there is NO WAY that a man the size of WS could have fit in there. NO WAY.

Seeing the culvert on that video gives me a whole new outlook on what happened that fateful early morning. Sini has some explaining to do, doesn't she?!

All amateur opinion and speculation.
I agree with you on the size of the culvert. It makes their actions even more horrible. Imagine trying everything possible to push little Sherin's body in as far as possible. It speaks volumes on the way they saw Sherin.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
 
It's pretty hard to muster up an appetite with all those broken bones. Pain has a way of suppressing appetite.

Monsters.

Plus, you can imagine the traumatic stress of yelling and screaming that probably took place. No one could eat while in such pain and trauma.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
171
Guests online
1,065
Total visitors
1,236

Forum statistics

Threads
602,130
Messages
18,135,314
Members
231,247
Latest member
GonzoToxic
Back
Top