- Joined
- Apr 24, 2025
- Messages
- 1,703
- Reaction score
- 21,868
The charges were dropped because the Judge ruled that they had to be a separate trial. The prosecution challenged it and took it to the High Court, but lost.I listened to the extra Mushroom Daily podcast today, and was interested to hear some of the detail they went into.
Specifically, they mentioned that the defence had an expert witness basically refuting all of Simon's poison claims and indicating that his symptoms didn't align with having ingested something. I don't think he could say 100% though.
Quite late in the game, the prosecution brought out the rat poison link based on searches but the expert wasn't there to possibly refute.
I suspect this had quite a lot to do with why the charges were dropped. Had the defence pulled apart those claims they might have feared it could have had a knock on effect on the more significant ones. It could've ended up looking like Simon had it in for Erin and was out to get her.
Instead, they let the main case play out and the much clearer evidence from that took her down. Once you realise she did those, then it becomes much more likely that she was simply very cunning with how she poisoned Simon.
It was always going to prejudice the main charges, so it's pretty understandable why it wasn't allowed.