GUILTY Australia - 3 dead after eating wild mushrooms, Leongatha, Victoria, Aug 2023 *Arrest* #19

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #1,121
10.34am

The pre-sentence hearing begins​

By​

Erin Patterson’s hair has grown long; today, she has it pulled back into a ponytail. She is wearing the same black pants and black sandals she wore during the murder trial in Morwell.

The simple paisley top she is wearing today is one she had on rotation during the trial, too.

She carried a bundle of manila folders into court and was seen chatting with her legal team.

Seated closest to her is Ali Rose Prior, Patterson’s power of attorney and her biggest supporter during the trial, attending the Morwell courthouse nearly every day.

The pre-sentence hearing has just started.

“Call the matter please,” Justice Christopher Beale said.

Patterson stood to confirm her date of birth, age, her occupation as an administrative clerk, and her last address.

What is a victim impact statement?​

By​

There will be seven victim impact statements read to the court during Erin Patterson’s pre-sentencing hearing. The first one from lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson who will read it out himself.

The statements are an opportunity for victims – which in this case could include lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson, Erin’s estranged husband Simon and any other family or friends of the Wilkinsons and Pattersons – to tell a judge what impact the crime has had on them.

The statements can be read out loud or handed up for the judge to read.

The Supreme Court has indicated that if any of Erin Patterson’s victims elect to have their statements handed to the judge, they will be kept private and the details not released.

Legislation provides limitations on what can be included in a victim impact statement

ople are allowed to include the impact of the offence on them and any injury, loss or damage suffered by them as a direct result of the crime.

They can include medical documents, photographs and poems but if they stray outside the rules, a judge can rule that parts of them will not be taken into account.

The purpose of an impact statement is to allow victims to tell the court the emotional toll an offence has had on them.

Victims of Crime Commissioner Elizabeth Langdon says they are an important mechanism for victims to have a voice in the justice process and feel like rightful participants in the justice process.

According to the OPP, a victim is a person who suffers any of the following things as a result of a crime: injury, loss or damage, grief, distress, trauma, or other significant adverse effects. This means that a victim can be a person directly affected by the crime, family, friends or even witnesses.

10.44am

Married for 44 years: Ian Wilkinson mourns the great love of his life​

By​

Courtroom four is hearing a moving victim impact statement read aloud from an emotional Ian Wilkinson, who is fighting back tears.

Before his wife was murdered, Ian and Heather Wilkinson were married for 44 years.

“I want to begin with a few words about my beautiful wife Heather,” Ian Wilkinson told the court. “She was a compassionate, intelligent, brave, witty, simply a delightful person who loved sharing life with others.“

She was a generous wife and mother, Wilkinson told the court. And she was funny, too.

“Heather had a great sense of humour, and it was a joy to be in her company.“

She had skills that made up for his own shortcomings, Wilkinson told the court.

They were in love, even after all those many years, they remained in love.

 
  • #1,122
2 minutes ago

Lunch survivor's voice breaks as he describes 'delightful' wife
Sole survivor of the mushroom lunch, Ian Wilkinson, is first up.
His voice broke as his began reading his statement.
He described his late wife Heather as “compassionate, intelligent, brave, witty, simply delightful person who loved sharing life with others”.
“Like everyone else she had faults but she actively sought to overcome them so she could live peacefully and constructively with all people,” he said.
“She was generous in her attitudes and with her resources.
“If she could help somebody, she would.
“Heather had a great sense of humour and it was a joy to be in her company.
“She loved learning and had a special interest in languages.”
Ian said they had been married for 44 years, starting to cry.
“She was also supportive and encouraging to me,”
“She was wise and had skills that made up for my shortcomings.
“Together, we faced life as a team and we delighted in each other’s company.”
Ian took a brief pause and wiped tears from his eyes.
His hand was shaking as he drank water from a glass

 
  • #1,123
Just now
Ian pays tribute to beloved friends Don and Gail
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

"The second heaviest impact on me has been the loss of Don and Gail," he says.

He described the couple as the closest people to him besides Heather.

"I would like to acknowledge their good character," he says, describing the families growing up together.

"My life is greatly impoverished without them."


 
  • #1,124
4m ago01.44 BST

Ian Wilkinson pays tribute to late wife Heather​

Wilkinson is delivering his victim impact statement in court.

He begins by describing his wife Heather who was murdered by Patterson. He says:

She was a compassionate, intelligent, brave, witty, simply a delightful person who loved sharing life with others …


She was generous in her attitudes and with her resources. If she could help somebody, she would.
Wilkinson says Heather had a great sense of humour and it was a “joy” to be her in company.

His voice begins to crack as he says the pair shared a close marriage relationship for 44 years.

Together we faced life as a team and we delighted in each other’s company.
Wilkinson says the pair’s six children were thrown into an unprecedented situation where they had to take medical responsibility for their parents.

He says the trauma they experienced over their mother’s death and his attempted murder has left “deep wounds.”

 
  • #1,125
Key Event
1m ago
Ian describes health battles following deadly lunch
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

Ian says he very nearly died following Erin's actions.

"It has taken me the best part of two years for my health and strength to recover," he says.

He says despite the recovery, his health has never recovered to the point it was before "the fateful lunch".

He says many aspects of his health, such as kidney and respiratory health, have not recovered.


 
  • #1,126
10.51am

A moment to remember Heather Wilkinson​

By​

Attention is showered on those who do evil and so little on those who do good, Ian Wilkinson tells courtroom four.

For years, the public gaze has rested on Erin Patterson - on her story, on her trial, and now on her pre-sentencing hearing.

But this moment is for Heather Wilkinson.

Her husband has paused to wipe tears from his eyes. Erin Patterson is sobbing in the dock, watching Wilkinson from behind. Wilkinson has chosen to face the judge - not the court - to read his statement.

“Together, we faced life as a team, and we delighted in each other’s company,” he told Judge Christopher Beale. “Tche hildren were thrown into an unprecedented situation where they suddenly had to take medical responsibility for the lives of their parents.“

“The trauma that they experienced at their mother’s death and at my near-death has left deep wounds. I am deeply grieved by their ongoing pain.“

“Family events are no longer the same. A very important member of our family is missing.“

Wilkinson pauses, holding back tears. “I could go on,T” he adds. “There’s so much more that deserves to be said about Heather. It’s one of the distressing short comes of our society that so much attention is showered on those who do evil and so little on those who do good. The greatest impact of Erin’s actions on me has been to deprive me of Heather’s company and Heather’s important place in our family, the silence in our home is a daily reminder. I continue to carry a heavy burden of grief over her untimely death.”


😥
 
  • #1,127
1m ago20.50 EDT
Wilkinson says a “very important member of our family is missing”.

He says:

The greatest impact on Erin’s actions on me has been to deprive me of Heather’s company and Heather’s important place in our family …


The silence in our home is a daily reminder.


I continue to carry a heavy burden of grief over her untimely grief. It’s a truly horrible thought to live with that somebody could decide to take her life.


I only feel half alive without her.
At this point, Wilkinson stops to wipe tears away from his eyes and is joined at the bar table where he is standing by his daughter, Ruth Dubois.

Wilkinson says his life is also “greatly impoverished” by the deaths of Don and Gail Patterson.

 
  • #1,128
Key Event
1m ago
Ian Wilkinson offers to forgive his attempted killer
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

Ian describes the grief he feels now in a life without Heather.

He then turns his attention to Erin Patterson, slamming her "callous and calculated disregard for my life and the life of those I love".

"What foolishness possess a person to think that murder is the solution?" he asks.

He tells the court he offers Erin Patterson forgiveness for the harm she caused him, but he has no right to forgive her for the other deaths she caused.

"I bear her no ill will, my prayer for her is that she will use her time in jail wisely to become a better person," he says.

"I am no longer Erin Patterson's victim, and she has become the victim of my kindness."



 
  • #1,129
2 minutes ago

'Family events are no longer the same'
Ian said his children have experienced “trauma” from having to take medical responsibility for their parents, which has left “deep wounds”.
“I’m grieved by their ongoing pain,” he said.
He said Heather was a “proud grandma” who loved each of their six grandchildren.
“Family events are no longer the same,” he said.
“A very important member of our family is missing.”

 
  • #1,130
Erin Patterson arrives at Court……

View attachment 610781


View attachment 610783


View attachment 610784



She's lost some weight.
 
  • #1,131
Key Event
1m ago
Heather and Ian's daughter Ruth Dubois begins her statement
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

Ruth Dubois takes to the stand.

Erin Patterson is visibly upset following Ian's speech, screwing up a tissue in her hands and holding back her tears.

"Where do you start?" Ruth begins, the emotion heavy in her voice.

Ruth says four generations of a family have been traumatised by the events of the July 31 lunch at Erin Patterson's home.

She describes her mother Heather as one of her closest friends, and an example of a mother that she aspires to be like.



 
  • #1,132
1 minute ago

'I only feel half alive without her': Ian's heartbreak over wife's murder
Ian declared to the court that “so much attention is showered on those who do evil and so little on those who do good”.
“The greatest impact of Erin’s actions on me is to deprive me of Heather’s company and Heather’s … place in our family,” he said.
“The silence in our home is a daily reminder that … I continue to carry a heavy burden of grief at her untimely death.”
He said it was a “truly horribly thought” to think that somebody could decide to take a life.
“I only feel half alive without her,” he said.
After Ian finished reading his statement, Erin grabbed a tissue and wiped her nose.

 
  • #1,133
10.56am

A half live plagued with pain: Ian Wilkinson on life after the death of his wife​

By​

After 44 years in a loving marriage, Ian Wilkinson says he feels lost, only half alive without Heather Wilkinson.

Broken sleep, emptiness at work, even pottering about in the garden and house leave Wilkinson feeling alone.

“It’s a truly horrible thought to live with that somebody could decide to take her life,” he told the court. ” My consolation is that we will be reunited in the resurrection.“

The pastor has now turned to Don and Gail Patterson and their role in his life. He said they were the next closest thing to him after his wife. “We encouraged and supported each other for about 50 years. My life is greatly impoverished without them.“

Ian has thanked the medical staff who saved him from near death, saying they strove to save all four.

“Although I have made a good recovery, my health has never returned to the levels before the fateful lunch. I have had to face the many challenges of reestablishing life without Heather. I am suddenly single. The heartbreak of having to wind up her affairs, returning to pastoral work without her help and sage advice.

″⁣Unsettled sleep, no one to share in life’s daily tasks, which has taken much of the joy out of pottering around the house and garden. The impacts are so many and varied, some big and a myriad of small things that no list could even contain.”

 
  • #1,134
1m ago
Ruth says Patterson used her parents kindness against them
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

"Life feels less bright without her [Heather]," Ruth says.

She says her father has remained a pillar of strength during the ordeal he underwent.

Ruth says Erin Patterson used the kindness that came naturally to her parents against them, using it to lure them to the deadly lunch.

"The world seems colder and harsher knowing this," she says.

"For the offender to sit and watch over casual conversation, while these people who showed nothing but love and care for her, ate a meal that would kill."


 
  • #1,135
8 minutes ago
Pinned

'I only feel half-alive without her': Ian Wilkinson addresses his wife's killer​


Sole surviving lunch guest has begun delivering his victim impact statement by sharing words about his wife, Heather Wilkinson.

Ms Wilkinson died after eating the poisoned beef Wellington prepared by Erin Patterson at a lunch in late July, 2023.

A visibly emotional Mr Wilkinson told the court he had only felt “half-alive” since his wife was taken from him by Patterson.

“The biggest impact of Erin’s actions on me has to be to deprive me of Heather’s company and Heather’s important place in our family,” he said.


He told the court the silence in his home is a “daily reminder” of her death.

“I continue to carry a heavy burden of grief over her untimely death,” he said. “It’s a truly horrible thought to live knowing that somebody could choose to take her life.”

Mr Wilkinson described Ms Wilkinson as a “compassionate, intelligent, brave, witty, simply a delightful person who loved sharing life with others”.

“Like everyone else she had faults but she actively sought to overcome them so she could live peacefully and constructively with all people,” he said.

 
  • #1,136
Key Event
1m ago
Personal tragedy turned into public entertainment, Ruth says
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

Ruth says the entire community, from medical staff to witnesses to investigators, has been impacted by the high-profile trial.

She says she is horrified her family has become embroiled in the case, and that her life will never be the same.

"It has changed the way I interact with people," Ruth says.

"It is particularly revolting to experience our family's tragedy to be turned into entertainment for the masses."


Key Event
1m ago
Ruth questions Erin's choices as a mother
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

Ruth turns her thoughts to Erin Patterson's children, and expresses bewilderment as to how Patterson would choose to go through with the murders.

"As a mother, I will never understand how you could willingly choose this for your children," Ruth says.

This concludes her statement.


 
  • #1,137
10.59am

With an offer of forgiveness, a pastor makes a murderer the victim​

By​

Just like a sermon, the pastor offers grace in his own victim impact statement, ending his words with kindness instead of hate.

Turning to Erin Patterson’s offending, Ian Wilkinson offered to forgive Erin Patterson despite what she had done.
“I’m distressed that Erin has acted with callous and calculated disregard for my life and the life of those I love. Erin has brought deep sorrow and grief into my life and the lives of many others.

“In regard to the many harms done to me, I make an offer of forgiveness to Erin. I say harms done to me advisedly, I have no power or responsibility to forgive harms done to others. In regards to the murder of Heather, Gail and Don I am compelled to seek justice. However, I encourage Erin to receive my offer of forgiveness for those harms done to me with full confession and repentance. I bear her no ill will.

“My prayer for her is that she will use her time in jail wisely to become a better person. Now I am no longer Erin Paterson’s victim, and she has become the victim of my kindness.”


 
  • #1,138
3 minutes ago

'I praise God for my miraculous healing'
Ian said his life is also “greatly impoverished” without Don and Gail.
He then turned to the impacts Erin’s crime has had on his health, physically and mentally.
“I very nearly died and it has taken me the best part of two years … for my health and strength to recover,” he said.
“I praise God for my miraculous healing.”
He said he has also had to grapple with the challenge of vastly different social circumstances.
“I’m suddenly single,” he said.
He told the court it had to deal with the heartbreak of having to wind up Heather’s affairs and returning to pastoral care without her help and “sage advice”.
After Ian finished reading his statement, Erin grabbed a tissue and wiped her nose.

 
  • #1,139
Key Event
1m ago
Heather and Ian's daughter Ruth Dubois begins her statement
Judd Boaz profile image
By Judd Boaz

Ruth Dubois takes to the stand.

Erin Patterson is visibly upset following Ian's speech, screwing up a tissue in her hands and holding back her tears.

"Where do you start?" Ruth begins, the emotion heavy in her voice.

Ruth says four generations of a family have been traumatised by the events of the July 31 lunch at Erin Patterson's home.

She describes her mother Heather as one of her closest friends, and an example of a mother that she aspires to be like.



Erin Patterson is good at holding back tears...
 
  • #1,140
1m ago02.02 BST
Wilkinson: ‘I am no longer Erin Patterson’s victim’

Wilkinson says he is “compelled to seek justice” for the deaths of Heather, Don and Gail.

But he says for his attempted murder, he offers Patterson forgiveness. He says:

I encourage Erin to receive my offer of forgiveness for those harms done to me …


I bear her no ill will.
He says his prayer for Patterson is that she will use her time in jail “wisely”. He says:

Now I am no longer Erin Patterson’s victim and she has become the victim of my kindness.”

Patterson was in tears during Wilkinson’s statement, watching on quietly throughout. Her hands sat in her lap, the fingers turning over constantly towards the end of his statement. When Wilkinson finished, she reached for tissues from a box in front of her in the dock, and dabbed at her eyes and nose.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
99
Guests online
2,386
Total visitors
2,485

Forum statistics

Threads
633,154
Messages
18,636,518
Members
243,415
Latest member
n_ibbles
Back
Top