Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[gitana1]

Well then. I really want to know what the probable cause was in that search warrant now.

I’m guessing it was a tip.

 

[Strangeworld]

Wow, I don't know what to say about the last 12 hours. Great that the door footage is now out there, but if this massive LE response in the last few hours was a knee jerk reaction to one tip, I'm conflicted (obviously just what was said in the interview with the the detained man's mother in law, so not sure if this is actually the case).

On the one hand, you'd want LE to do anything to bring Nancy home. But on the other hand, I'm sure we don't want them steamrolling around Arizona detaining innocent people either.

 

[gitana1]

Has anyone in here who was set on a theory changed their opinion on this case because of these new developments i.e. the man captured at Nancy's door?

I've been on the fence because there were pros and cons for either scenario i.e. family did it - stranger did it but now I just don't see a valid reason that family was involved - at least at this point.

That man does not look anything like TC to me.

Yes. The twists and turns have made me veer in different directions.

 

[touchlove]

In this post, it says an investigator from Adult Protective Services left a card on the door of Nancy’s house.

https://twitter.com/x/status/2021355815106719928

This is the video from the new station with the card on the window.

https://twitter.com/x/status/2018800434371284998

 

[gitana1]

Didn’t ask him a single question?!? What the…

That is insane. I am at a loss.

 

[shonyakay]

This is utterly bizarre. Pretty much every component of this case to date. Just bonkers.

JMO.

Like Tricia stated this is pretty much unprecedented here.

 

[avalonisland]

Would you pay ransom without "proof of life"?

Nope. The only real proof of life released to public imo would be the 5:32pm Uber driver pick up at NG house

 

[JoeFromLB]

Well, so much for the case being solved...
Frustrating doesn't even begin to describe it.

 

[avalonisland]

Like Tricia stated this is pretty much unprecedented here.

And this Carlos POI...if it's him putting bushes in front camera...I think it was an assignment to disable camera footage. I believe based on all reported to media that a tragic incident happened to NG which NG was with intimate family members.

 

[auburnmomof2]

In this post, it says an investigator from Adult Protective Services left a card on the door of Nancy’s house.

https://twitter.com/x/status/2021355815106719928

This is the video from the new station with the card on the window.

https://twitter.com/x/status/2018800434371284998

One thing I did notice..the pic of the perp without the backpack...if it's the same guy, there's zero blood on his pants, which gives me a little hope and I don't think the inside of the house was a horrific crime scene.
My opinion only

 

[CrimeDawg123]

They did process his house and car so it may not be the last we hear of him. The fact they didn’t ask him anything did they just want him detained while the search warrant was executed? I hope for his sake he didn’t have any involvement however something must have lead them to him and to search his house.

Someone could have called in a bogus tip to the FBI

 

[Strangeworld]

In this post, it says an investigator from Adult Protective Services left a card on the door of Nancy’s house.

https://twitter.com/x/status/2021355815106719928

This is the video from the new station with the card on the window.

https://twitter.com/x/status/2018800434371284998

I wonder when that card was left in the timeline, must be after Nancy went missing as she would have seen it otherwise?

 

[avalonisland]

Full interview from ABC15 out from CPjr.

WATCH: Man detained by police in Nancy Guthrie search speaks to ABC15

A man who says he was detained by Pima County Sheriff's deputies for "kidnapping" Nancy Guthrie spoke first to ABC15 immediately following his release.

www.abc15.com

The answer lies within where Uber driver dropped NG off. No solid proof of evidence that NG returned home after Uber driver assignment at around 5:30pm 1/31/26. I think the "suspects" at the home early morning 2/1/26 had family ties in some sort of way. Not random and the activity on 2/1/26 to me seems like a coverup to what happened that could have been tragic to NC night of 1/31/26

 

[avalonisland]

I disagree. No reason for these potential weirdos to abduct an elderly woman with health issues.

 

[washysmum]

A few points of note (without me injecting my conclusions)

Crypto ransoms take a high degree of skill to pull off. POI would need to understand how to cold store BTC. Not on a hot wallet like Ledger. True cold storage takes sophistication and years of planning (storing keys and sleepy wallets with NO prior transactions). After the ransom is paid, POI would then need to use a crypto mixer like Monero or similar to breakdown the BTC, send it to hundreds of wallets, wash the hashes in thousands of transactions and then recollect the BTC once its been washed. After all that, they’d need a laundering scheme to convert the cleaned crypto into fiat. This person(s) would NOT send notes to the media. They understand anonymity and would avoid hot contact (I.e internet contact)

If you’re confused, you’re not the culprit. That gives a sense for the kind of person or persons skilled enough to pull off a crypto ransom. And that says nothing of the skill to kidnap someone. Those are two very different skill sets that rarely occur in one person.

Appreciate this crypto breakdown as someone with no idea

 

[CrimeDawg123]

Has anyone in here who was set on a theory changed their opinion on this case because of these new developments i.e. the man captured at Nancy's door?

I've been on the fence because there were pros and cons for either scenario i.e. family did it - stranger did it but now I just don't see a valid reason that family was involved - at least at this point.

That man does not look anything like TC to me.

I've never thought the family was involved. Absolutely not. But seeing the perp come with a fully loaded backpack has changed my mind from a burglary to something else. I was convinced the perp and ransomer were 2 different people, now I don't know.

One thing for sure, a DoorDash driver living at the border doesn't fit and I'm surprised LE made such a dog and pony show about it.

 

[iamshadow21]

Has anyone in here who was set on a theory changed their opinion on this case because of these new developments i.e. the man captured at Nancy's door?

I've been on the fence because there were pros and cons for either scenario i.e. family did it - stranger did it but now I just don't see a valid reason that family was involved - at least at this point.

That man does not look anything like TC to me.

Not so much the latest developments, but until the information about the destruction of the cameras, I was leaning towards this being a medical event and she just hadn't been found yet.

I'm still not convinced the kidnapper and the ransom person are the same, but I'm not seeing everything they're seeing. We're only getting a fraction of a fraction of the picture.

MOO

 

[avalonisland]

This is utterly bizarre. Pretty much every component of this case to date. Just bonkers.

JMO.

Bonkers afterr NG was dropped off at Tucson daughter and SIL house.

 

[luc1fer12]

That is insane. I am at a loss.

In the interview C says they asked him questions. He says “they asked me where I was”. Nerves probably made him misspeak

 

[avalonisland]

It's been difficult to sleep throughout this case for me. Nancy reminds me of my mom who passed away in 2024. The doorbell footage really is eerie and makes me feel even more hurt for the G family

Sorry about your Mom passing away. I don't think NG ever saw the creepo who disabled front door nest ring doorbell. I cannot explain the blood droplets but I truly believe NG never came home from dinner and game night.