AZ Nancy Guthrie, 84, (mother of TODAY Show host Savannah Guthrie) missing - last seen in the Catalina foothills area on Jan 31, 2026

[allboys]

I keep going to back to language of the video posted on SG's instagram on Saturday. She says "This is the only way we will have peace, this is very valuable to us - and we will pay." I just feel like the wording is so strange. I would think she would say "she is very valuable to us" if she were still alive. (I very much hope that she is). JMO

The more I listen to it, the more it sounds like SG believes (or knows) her mother is deceased. The big question if that’s the case, is how does she know that? So saddening to listen to her words.

 

[Nikynoo]

Just now, I took a photo of a televised CNN story on the Guthrie disappearance: This is my photo.

View attachment 642929
Please note that there is no mention of the “11:00 am phone call from church member”

It’s in the criminal complaint authored by the FBI against the hoaxer But it’s in the criminal complaint by the hoaxer. https://www.justice.gov/usao-az/media/1426976/dl?inline

 

[Nikynoo]

I must have missed something. Is it verified that AG and SIL made up a fake church call?

No. It’s in the criminal complaint authored by the FBI against the hoaxer. But it’s in the criminal complaint by the hoaxer. https://www.justice.gov/usao-az/media/1426976/dl?inline

 

[LAborn]

I thought people were trying to figure out if contractors visiting the house might have set up the kidnapping. Doesn't matter the race of contractor. Don't see race in any scenario where a worker may be involved.

"Cartel" "yard worker", come on now. Please.

 

[HoveringWombats]

But he explained that notification means movement was detected and it could have been an animal. I haven't seen any substantiation that NG has a pet currently. Meaning, IMO, the camera that sent notification about movement was outside.

MOO, this really neither confirms nor denies that the camera was outside. I think he was just speaking loosely (as he often has) and covering his bases. I don't think we should put too much weight into this either way.

 

[Nikynoo]

I’m sure yesterday there was an update from the Sheriffs office which stated there were NO suspects and NO POIs. If this is the case, the family are victims.

ETA - yes, it’s here

https://twitter.com/x/status/2020557653588726267

 

[SMK777]

I must have missed something. Is it verified that AG and SIL made up a fake church call?

No. But why was the call removed from the official timeline? It's a legitimate question, IMO.

 

[SeattleStew]

Agreed. $6M is not worth their time to get in the car.

And where does the figure $6 million come into play? Why $6 million? Why not 5 or 7 million? Six-Million Dollar Man enters my train of thought, even though it makes no sense, just creative thinking. IMO. So someone over the age of 50?

 

[UsernameRequired]

https://twitter.com/x/status/2020901445118079449

 

[turaj]

I thought people were trying to figure out if contractors visiting the house might have set up the kidnapping. Doesn't matter the race of contractor. Don't see race in any scenario where a worker may be involved.

I heard on one of the talk shows that a neighbor mentioned to LE how very white NG roof is and that it must be new work. I assume they followed up with that contractor. They spent some time on roof in the last few days and found another camera up there. Could a worker have planted that up there?

 

[Bodhi]

Is this what launched the bar thing? It's obvious conjecture. JMO

In this post, it is clearly understood as speculation. In other posts I read, which did not quote this one, the bar visit was cited as a fact.

 

[louvillian08]

Regarding the “church call”, what changed in approximately 17 hours between the filing of the complaint and the sheriffs presser? At approximately 6:02 PM on February 4th, LE had realized the ransom was a hoax by Callella. The last pressor from the Tucson sheriff was February 5th at approximately 11 AM. Lack of follow through from whoever filed the complaint? It just seems odd to me that the church call was added to the complaint but omitted from the timeline and pressor.

I said this yesterday and I don’t think many people agreed with me but I think the sheriff was only using 100% time stamped, black and white facts in the timeline and that’s the reason the call was omitted. There’s already so much back and forth and confusion already because he previously said the family got to her house “around 11” but then revealed it was actually 11:56am.

The call to the family is absolutely meaningful. But it doesn’t actually confirm anything with the timeframe of when she went missing. The timing of the call also doesn’t mean that’s when someone noticed her absence. It means that’s when someone became so alarmed, they contacted her family. If you include the time of the call in your official timeline, people are going to ask what time the church service was, what time the friend texted or called NG, etc.

Like another user stated, the church phone call has never been debunked. The sheriff himself said it and now it’s referenced in an FBI document.

 

[tlcya]

This is important because this contradicts the ‘official timeline’. The FBI must release an updated ‘official timeline’. Unbelievably we have a representative from the FBI giving swore testimony in an Arizona Federal Court that destroy’s the ‘official timeline’.

This stretches the credibility of this investigation. It does not instill confidence in the veracity of the information released by the FBI. I would categorize it as sloppy.

The FBI needs to clarify this but I won’t hold my breath.

View attachment 642939

could you elaborate on how this federal complaint destroys the official timeline? The official timeline contains exact, to the minute, times of key events. While that timeline doesn't mention the call or communication from church friend, this complaint, which only contains broad approximation of times, supports that a communication from such an individual did indeed occur.

How does complaint destroy timeline? In my mind both timeline and complaint can be true?

 

[AZLocal]

June 20, 2025. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Tucson Sector and Mexican authorities located and raided a cartel safe-house which stored military-grade machine-guns, ammunition, heavy ordinance, stolen vehicles, and drugs.

Are you aware that the Tucson BP Sector covers 262 miles of border between Yuma County to the Arizona/New Mexico state line?

Are you somehow implying that this unsourced statement indicates that Tucson is controlled by cartels? If that is the case, why do you think the cartel allowed this to happen

 

[HoveringWombats]

Also on the VPN topic, maybe this is stating the obvious, but just to make my personal opinion clear:

While I do think that it's not as hard as people believe to hide your origin, I also am not confident that's happening here. It's entirely possible that LE does know where those messages came from, but just hasn't released that information publicly. There's obviously a lot about this investigation that they're not telling us, and this could be one of those things.

 

[Chimera]

Would like to know what if anything significant was discussed at the dinner and game night before ?
Also if there was anyone else at the mahjong game outside of family ?

Afaik, the Uber driver was the very last person to see Nancy outside of family.
Did she return home that night for 100 % certainty.

Is it possible there was a crime scene that happened elsewhere and the blood drops were placed at Nancy's house.
All it would take is to extract a bit of blood via syringe from a living person and let it drip at her doorstep thus making LE think Nancy was standing alive outside her home that night.
Jmo.

 

[sony12]

I'm honestly beginning to think that she has been gone for awhile now. Hard to say if the actual kidnappers are the ones communicating with them but I'm beginning to think the family is just being toyed with at this point.

 

[turaj]

Does someone have to be in debt to motivate them to commit a violent crime for money? Could it just be envious of other's lifestyle? Anxiety over future financial resources? Or even someone hating their job and seeing no other career path?

or frustrated that caregiving and managing NG's home fell on them due to proximity? Did not get enough help from siblings? This can happen in families.

 

[ab01]

Interesting! I am guessing it could depend on the app and pacemaker involved? The way some WSers described it sure did seem to be saying there was daily communication to DL data only. If the disconnect message showed up every time the devices were out of range, that could add up to many disconnects during the day if one does not keep the phone close.

Here's a Link to more information for those that are curious.

https://www.medtronic.com/content/dam/medtronic-wide/public/united-states/products/cardiac-vascular/cardiac-rhythm/cardiac-monitoring/mycarelink-heart-app-patient-user-guide.pdf

 

[Sarahlou]

I'm honestly beginning to think that she has been gone for awhile now. Hard to say if the actual kidnappers are the ones communicating with them but I'm beginning to think the family is just being toyed with at this point.

I'd be surprised if she was alive after the day she was taken.